We have been working with Heritage Auctions for several months and have found their staff responsive, knowledgeable, and clear about what needs to be done to bring our items to auction successfully. At this stage, we are giving them four out of five stars, reserving the final star until all of our transactions have been completed. Based on our experience so far, however, I strongly suspect the final rating will be five out of five. From a buyer's perspective, Heritage also appears to have an excellent understanding of how to offer a broad and varied selection for both experienced collectors and those just beginning to explore the field. read more

Heritage Auctions - One of our three listing to date. - Auction Houses Near Me - Dallas, Texas

I've been buying/selling on this site for more than 20 years. Their customer service is exceptional and their auction site is easy to use & the site provides excellent photography which allows you to make a more informed decision on potential purchases. read more

Great assortment of comics in auctions. Like that they have a "live online auction" at the end of a week or more of general online auction. Let you wait for a few weeks to build up a number of comics to ship to save money. read more

Had a great experience consigning our coins to Heritage. Kyle K. was very professional as he guided us through the auction process. Highly recommended. read more

I discovered Heritage Auctions many years ago and have been buying art from them ever since. Like any prestige company, Heritage not only knows exactly ---and I mean exactly--- how to please its customers, they find ways of improving their service every year. The art they offer is extraordinary, their lot descriptions are accurate [and even poetic] and their support staff and delivery system are, by far, the best I've ever dealt with. Obviously, I'm a happy customer...and I have 100% confidence I always will be! read more

Risky business - a gamble with your personal data. Please think before you register to bid with this auction house. They request the following highly sensitive data that as a whole, leaves you open to great personal risk: Name, birth year, photo of driver's license or passport, last 4 digits of your social security number, bank name, and more. They will say it is for their protection, but should there be a data breach you will be screwed. This is a serious overreach by Heritage Auctions and my husband (who is an attorney) and I refuse to provide our sensitive personal data in bulk to this company. 1/26/26 response to Heritage Auction reply: While I appreciate that you don't sell your customer's private information (which is more than enough for anyone with bad intentions to hijack your good credit), you cannot guarantee protections from a data breech putting your customers at risk. It's well known that large companies with 'exceptional' protections in place are hacked and the data is leaked. The extensive combination of personal data you require is absolutely devastating should it be compromised. I am a registered bidder with many high end auction houses and NONE of them require such a depth of personal data. My advice to buyers is that there are many other quality auction houses to buy from where you are not put at risk. read more

Supreme quality service and attention to detail. They are shipping the items quickly and have been a solid reference source for my particular type of collecting. read more

Raiden Honaker was amazing during the auction process. We met a few times as I submitted different lots of graded US currency for auction. Mr. Honiker took care of everything and kept me informed throughout the process. He was always prompt in replying to any question I posed. I will certainly contact him again should I have further items to put up for auction. Leo Heinl, satisfied customer. read more

Cass Christenson was amazing. He took care of everything from the very beginning and kept me informed throughout the entire auction process. I can't imagine working with anyone but Heritage Auctions in the future - I was extremely satisified with the process and the results. Thank you Cass! read more

First rate professionals! Kyle Kavanaugh and his crew eased my worries and ultimately made this a very lucrative experience. I hope to use them again soon! read more

Heritage Auctions - Au revoir, 1 BTC - Auction Houses Near Me - Dallas, Texas

Kyle @ Heritage Auctions was very helpful and gave me all the information I needed to make a decision on my coins. He was prompt in getting back to me and made the entire experience very easy from beginning to end. I would highly recommend them to be above board with every detail! read more

Great company, fast shipping in Auctions maybe weeks here vs 2 months at propstore. The COA they send. are fantastic. Only complaint, they don't take amex express. Many use for the points. They charge a fee to use a credit card anyway so why not? read more

Had several pieces of sports memorabilia. Guess team was too busy for Brady signed Super Bowl 36 ball and similar pieces. Poor to no communication. Went elsewhere. read more

I contacted them regarding selling a very valuable painting. They said they would get back to me. When I contacted them again I was told they were still looking into it. When I contacted them again I received their stock reply that they would get back to me. I received their stock reply again and again. I have given up on them. Obviously they are not a quality auction house. read more

Extortionate Postage. Charged over $500AUD to have a single comic shipped from the USA to Australia. No option to organise your own freight. No way of knowing what you'll be charged until they take the money from your bank. If you're overseas and are buying comics etc, go to eBay. Postage is fairly priced. Heritage is double dipping on profit at the buyers expense. Not customer focused. Customer service refuses to show the quote from FedEx which states the postage cost. The lack of transparency only reinforces the notion that Heritage is extorting their customer base. If I was to send the same comic to Heritage, from Australia to Texas, USA, it would cost me $88USD. Door to Door. Their corporate discount would guarantee a better price. Yet I paid $300+. Don't trust, don't buy, find a better company to trust. read more

"Heritage" charged my wife the SAME amount of a "service" fee as they did for the buyers fee ! ! $2000 for our $9000 sold price. Then we get our check about 6 weeks late ! ! Aaron, does NOT return calls. Hardly responds to emails. He is ALWAYS busy. We are BOTH disabled seniors and cannot keep taking these surprise HITS like the deal from Heritage We were led to believe that the fees were reasonable, HAH! I needed to have my attorney look at this 'contract,' I guess. Tried to list the same item a few yrs ago w / them. The previous dept head was rude and obnoxious. And HE is gone now too. What the . . . . This complaint is going viral to keep away from these "honorable" people as well as a complaint to the F T C. Heritage took advantage of our good faith in what we thought is a 'reputable' outfit. I got an email from them to resolve this "issue." Yesterday. Just send a check for $1700 and we are OK then. At this point, Heritage is disreputable and will go viral on this activity of theirs. You should think long and hard before dealing with this outfit if you have an item appraised by them for less than $10k. Do business, but, bring your lawyer before signing ANYTHING. better yet, go elsewhere. And Yelp took down my initial posting. What ? read more

My grandfather, once an editor at the New York Sun, started collecting game used bats in the 1930s. He brought me into this collecting universe when I was a child, and I inherited his collection and have added to it since he passed. I have quietly amassed a large of bats and other memorabilia over the years, and along the way have dealt with every single auction in the hobby. Heritage is by far the best of them all, and that is a tribute to Chris Ivy. Along with Dan Imler and Joe Orlando I have the utmost faith in Chris and his Heritage crew. Margaret and I have listed Heritage in our Trust as the auction to handle the sale of my collection when we are gone. You can't go wrong here, whether buying or selling. read more

Two months later and Robert Fornesi continues to hit it out of the park! He is always ready with excellent advice for maximizing our profit margin - while also being a delight to work with! He is friendly and incredibly knowledgeable about the world of vintage comics. We would be lost without him. We are a starting business ourselves. Robert Fornesi has been the perfect guide and teacher for us. Both my partner and I can not praise his work highly enough. Thank you, Robert! You're amazing! read more

Excellent placement of items in auctions; top dollar received due to large audience of interested buyers. Highly recommend read more

Kyle Kavanaugh has been very helpful and professional in handling our transactions with Heritage Auctions. He was personable and answered questions well. We felt we were in safe hands and HA was prompt with our dealings, both purchasing and selling. It's been a pleasure to work with Kyle and this business. We would choose Heritage again. Gratefully, James S. read more

Our experience was completely satisfactory. Through our transactions, HA has been consistently responsive, accommodating to all of our requests and needs, and has always operated in a sensitive, above board, and transparent manner. I feel like their fees have been reasonable and we received no surprises. We are really happy that we chose HA to facilitate the sale of our items and would choose to use them again in a heartbeat. read more

Michael worked very hard in a very professional way to make the most out of my Wine collection. Couldn't be more happy with the results and service . Thank you, Oren Bitman read more

After a disagreement about the combined shipping from the USA to Australia common sense prevailed and a satisfactory arrangement was reached. I am heartened by the fact that as a customer I was treated with the respect and consideration I deserved. Old Greek adage "customer always right even where he is wrong". Items not cheap but what is a good nights sleep worth knowing they are legit. read more

I found their evaluation deceptive and too far below market value to call them legitimate. Pawn shop value offers more. read more

I had a wonderful experience selling through Heritage. Todd is extremely knowledgable and helped me in so many ways. I highly recommend Heritage Auctions! read more

It's no surprise Heritage Auctions is the leader in the collectibles marketplace. Working with Robert Fornesi has been a great experience -- he knows what it takes to sell collector comic books and made the whole process easy from day one. If you're looking for the best in the business, reach out to Heritage. read more

Cass, was great to work with! Very honest and easy guy to talk with and he answered all my questions!Highly recommended Heritage Auctions

Heritage is a completely trustworthy place to do business! There's no fear of not getting what you paid for, or not being paid for items sold. Also, their staff is great. I recommend Xavier Chavez! read more

Selling with Heritage Auctions has been an absolute game changer in selling my collectibles, especially because of my assigned expert Oscar who has gone above and beyond to support me every step of the process. The top notch customer service I've received through him and his associates has made the process not only informative and smooth, but fun and exciting as well, something that's a breath of fresh air from the normal stress of selling high value items to customers. The returns on my auctions have consistently gone above and beyond my wildest expectations and I'm truly thankful for having such incredible access to their sales platform, looking forward to many years of continued business through HA! read more

I've been a Heritage customer for 24 years, primarily as a numismatic buyer. Over time I have seen their service evolve and improve into the massive collector resource it is today. Particularly for collectors of U.S. material, the Heritage database is invaluable. Their auctions are simple to navigate online, the photography is accurate, and delivery is efficient. read more

I have been a long time buyer through Heritage Auctions, and have never had an issue until recently. The measure of a company's worth is not how little they make mistakes, but rather how they react when mistakes happen. Heritage Auctions did an incredible and very fair job in making the error right. I worked specifically with Stephanie Bowen and Robert Fornesi, and both were incredibly communicative, honest in their assessment and absolute willingness to ensure me I would be taken care of. They nailed it on every front, and have strengthened my fortitude to work with Heritage Auctions as the premiere Auction House in the collectibles world! Great job! read more

Professional Perfection! It has been a rewarding experience working with Heritage from the very beginning. For years, I have trusted Heritage Auctions to sell art and collectibles that I owned. Every aspect of the process has been stellar from start to finish. The sensitivity and respect they've shown me as their client have always been consistent and unquestionable. As an Art Advisor, I trust their world-class specialists to collaborate with me and my clients. I especially thank Atlee Phillips, Aviva Lehmann, and Ricky Sosa. I continue to look forward to our future dealings. Sincerely, Walter Baker Art Appraisal Austin read more

They're closing down and never sent email per their phone call. Too, bad large collection of stamp to sell. But on the bright side did find a buyer for my collection. read more

If I could give them a zero I would. After over a decade of customer loyalty I was SUSPENDED by Heritage with no explanation why? I must have done something or they think I did something but I will never know. Oh, Did I mention I won over $14,000.00 worth of currency , bid on 5 posters and was canned without notice. How about taking my purchase back, refund my accounts, and make me whole? Apparently their CUSTOMER DIS_SERVICE IS NUMBER ONE IN THE COUNTRY. There are much better auction venues than Heritage. Over the years the quality of service has turned over with the turn over of employees. The newbees are not qualified to wash dishes let alone the phones. I have been dissed but its not the 1st time and I am sure it will not be the last time. BTY they blocked my phones from calling in to any and all offices owned and operated by Heritage. I had someone verify this at VERIZON and again locally. I will be filing a slew of complaints. This is not the end but the beginning. Long story short................NO CUSTOMER SERVICE. read more

I am a budget buyer, so I often get outbid on items. But every time I buy something, the payment and shipping process is fantastic. Well packed, clear invoicing, and items exactly as described and pictured. I will say my favorite thing about the website as well: great archived information. Both my purchases and auction histories. A great resource. read more

My experience with Heritage Auctions was excellent. My family needed to sell an extensive coin collection of a deceased family member and from start to finish we received expert guidance. My first point of contact was Bob Marino. He was compassionate, professional, and knowledgeable as we navigated the selling options and next steps. Next, I worked with Kyle Kavanagh and Jason Friedman. They came to my location, inventoried, packaged, and shipped (fully insured) the entire collection to Dallas. They were friendly, professional, and knowledgeable. Once the collection was received in Dallas all the items were assigned to specific auctions or sent off to be graded to help achieve the highest bid. My point person at this stage and moving forward through the months of auctions was Kyle Kavanagh (and to a lesser extent Bob Marino). Kyle is the ultimate professional. He answered my many questions promptly and researched those he couldn't answer. I never felt like I was dealing with a huge company and always received individual attention. The auctions themselves (with large audiences of interested buyers) and payments afterwards went very smoothly. I highly recommend Heritage Auctions. read more

I have been doing business with Heritage Auctions for over 35 years. They are extremely knowledgeable and easy to work with. This is true for both buying and selling. They have specialists in nearly every category of Collectibles imaginable. Their specialty is Rare Coins but they are highly respected in many other areas and have achieved world record prices for quite a number of high end Collectibles. If you are considering selling or auctioning any of these types of items, you owe it to yourself to contact Heritage. read more

See all

Very good place to deal with - I was a bit apprehensive with the concept of selling comics, but they made it absolutely quick, easy and painless. read more

Over 20 years a customer and still going. So far I've had great experiences with them and everything I've purchased even though some ill advised purchases of stuff I just got too jumpy buying. I've purchased - Comics, Animation Cels and Sketches, Currency, Coins and other various items from their auctions. Fun and engaging can be costly but if you enjoy collecting they are a real auction house unlike Ebay which is more of a marketplace nowadays..... read more

Great customer service unlike many of the other auction houses. From beginning to end nobody you can trust as much as Heritage.