Was nice to get a good pie so far from home. I had one with plantains and it was interesting, but tasty! I substituted mushrooms for the beef, and it was still very good. Medium pie was like a large at home. Fluffy crust perfectly done. The place is really really loud, though and tiny. The servers were nice, but we had to ask for soda three times. Pizza a bit pricey. read more

Heather's Pizza - Boricua pizza with mushrooms instead of beef. Very good. Great garlic flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico

Walked in to Heathers because as we walked by it smelled delicious and they had pastas available and we weren't disappointed!!!!! (Like someone mentioned, my review is based on island food ratings) Best food we've had on the island. If you're in Culebra this is a MUST! Plus the customer service was amazing, thanks Kevin :) read more

Heather's Pizza - Chicken Alfredo was delish! - Pizza Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico

I don't have a picture of my pizza because we were so hungry and ate it so fast, but it is amazing! My family and I shared a Boricua and an Oasis pizza. The boricua had red sauce,cheese, plantains, ground beef, and cilantro on it; it was my favorite. So flavorful and the perfect amount of sweet from the plantains. The Oasis had lots of cheese, garlic sauce, spinach, and tomato and it was very good too; lots of garlic favorite. The crust is perfectly cooked and nicely crispy. I got a passion fruit daiquiri that was delicious and very flavorful with passion fruit. I also got a bushwhacker which seems to be the island drunk, and it was one of the best and sweetest ones I've had on the island. My mom got a mojito and it was not very good at all. She had it remade and asked for it to be a little sweeter and the second time it was basically all sugar. So would not recommend a mojito here. The reason I'm giving four instead of five stars is because the waiter does not really check on you at all; I've noticed this is typical at some restaurant on the island though. Definitely would recommend coming for some good pizza! read more

what's better than pizza? plantains on your pizza, that's what. my only regret is that i got so full so fast--the boricua pizza will change your life!! after a day of beaching and relaxing in the ocean, it was the absolute perfect end to the day while waiting for our ferry back. make sure to stop by here if you're in Culebra. read more

Heather's Pizza - boricua pizza - Pizza Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico

Don't miss this pizza place if you are on Culebra! We ordered 2 special pies (Oasis and Vegetable) for takeout at 2:30pm when it was empty. Both were ready in 20 min exactly as promised and turned out to be so delicious that next day all my folks were begging to do it again !:) Unfortunately we did have time to repeat. Thank you Heathers for the great pizza and fast service! Well done! (Visited in Feb 2017) read more

Great pizza with crispy base ....have a big slice of cheese pizza for $2.50 Super chicken wings done the way you want... read more

Heather's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico

Delicious food, fresh and really fun place to relax. The service is excellent. Highly recommend! read more

Heather's Pizza - Oasis pizza - Pizza Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico

See all

Man this pizza was the best thing I've eaten on the island. We ordered two pizzas for 3 adults, 2 teenage boys and an 8 year old. We still had 4 large slices left. It was delicious and hot. They were very big pizzas. All they needed was Parmesan cheese and pepper flakes! 22.00 for a large pie tho. read more

We got cheese pizza and a specialty calzone. We agreed that the pizza was three-star pizza but the calzone was five-star. I am used to thin-crust pizza so that is what I prefer and this was a little thick. read more

I can recommend the spicy Hawaiian pizza (jalapenos, bacon, and pineapple)! The crust was awesome. I was impressed! We went on a Saturday night at 6pm, and the place was slammed. We were sat at a small table in the far left, essentially in a hall that leads to the freezers and restrooms, but it was a table and we were hungry! They apologized for the cramped space, but it is what it is. There was barely enough room on our table for our pizza, plates, and drinks, but we made it work! We saved our leftovers and had them for breakfast (pizza is an anytime food in our book). If you're in Culebra, give it a try! The service wasn't out of this world, but I would return if given the chance. read more

Heather's Pizza - Here it is! - Pizza Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico

We saw the lady with awesome looking fish sandwich. We ordered the same. Fresh, delicate, tasty! Very recommended! read more

attention vegetarians visiting Culebra- very good pizza here with really friendly service!!!

Fantastic pizza! Sourdough crust is soooooo good! And a nice selection of beers. Totally exceeded our expectations. Nice surprise on the island! read more

Lovely staff, fun place to get a taste of Air Conditioning and a little decent pizza! I'm rating this based on "island" food which is a different scale. Island food faces challenges. Ingredients can be inconsistent, and you just need to go with the flow. The love is always in the food as people do their best with what's available. This is the only place to get "non seafood" type meal so it's a welcome variety. One of the few places where tourists and locals seem to mix it up. read more

To say that this is the best pizza on Culebra isn't saying much but saying that this is some of the best pizza I've ever had? YES! It was delish. It's more of a locals bar than a fancy tourist place, but the AC is pumping and the Medallas are ice-cold. Win-win. read more

Arrived mid-afternoon on a Monday and there were two-three other tables of people in the restaurant. Ordered a large pizza and a Spicy Italian sandwich, the pizza was OK and the sandwich was Ok. The service was subpar, the waitress was sooo slow and didn't seem to care that I might have been dying of thirst. Having worked in the service industry I'm usually pretty understanding but meh still gave it three stars. I'd probably check it out again and hope for a new waitress. read more

Had the boricua pizza while waiting for the ferry back to fajardo. It was delicious but took a long time. We were told 20 minutes but it took over 30 minutes to come out. read more

Heather's Pizza - Boricua pizza - Pizza Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico

Incredible!! I recommend the calzone that I cannot pronounce. call in your order for 5:30 that way you won't miss the sunset at melones beach down the road read more

I'm sure very many tasty things are served here. Passion fruit mojitos served frozen are a must try and the boricuan pizza. Sweet plantains on a pizza? Yum. It sounds a little weird, but once upon a time people thought pineapple on pizza was weird. Cilantro, ground beef, and sweet plantains. We also tried the jalapeño poppers, which the world over, are way too hot (temp) to eat. A couple next to us seemed to enjoy us biting, and desperately attempting not spit them out. We came around 6 and the place was filling up, but not jammed full yet. I suspect its a great place order to go and enjoy a mojito while you wait. read more

I recommend the Oasis pizza! Best pizza I've had in a long time. That crust! Amazing service. Close to Ferry.

Best pizza we've ever had and we are from California! The Alfredo pasta was also amazing! Great service & friendly staff. Just a note, the slices are HUGE, we ordered a large pizza and it lasted us two days +. We had a great time and would def recommend this place! read more

Quaint little pizza joint right near the ferry. Lots of locals in there so that's always a good sign. We had a pizza, fries and a chicken parm sandwich and all were very good. They have beer as well. Our waitress kept our leftover pizza there while we spent the day at Flamenco beach and we scarfed it down on our way back to the ferry. read more

Boricua pizza with ground beef and plantains with added bacon was super delicious. Eating each ingredient off the pizza was also very flavorful. The portion size of one slice of pizza was huge! Staff was friendly and the restaurant and restroom were clean! read more

Heather's Pizza - Boricua pizza with ground bees, plantains and added bacon...pure deliciousness! - Pizza Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico

Great place to get pizza for hungry kids on Culebra when so many other restaurants are closed on the island during the pandemic. They sometimes close a little early so I recommend ordering before 6 p.m. So nice to have a pizza option on the island! read more

I've been visiting from NYC and I have tried lots of different pizzas all over US but this one it the best. Very relaxing atmosphere as well. Highly recommend if you go to Culebra. Thank you! read more

The best pizza that I've had!!! Delicious! The best one is Boricua - perfect!! It comes with plantain and ground beef, but the Hawaiian is delicious too...take the chance to eat something different with a ton of flavor. You really have to go here. :) read more

Great pizza on a very small GORGEOUS island , we had a large pineapple pizza that was just delicious. They were very friendly as most are in PR and the prices were good for what you get, definitely the better choice over Williams pizza down the street. read more

Horrible. Absolutely extremely over salted food. Not just one item but everything that came out. The calzone was made with breakfast sausage that just didn't sit well because it didn't cook. Waited an hour for a slice of pizza, However the bartenders were great. Way over priced. read more

Looking something to order by phone, sent a message thru its Facebook page and responded promptly, saving us time for dinner plans. Without a doubt, great food and service. Gladly agreed to warm leftovers, with warm hospitality and consideration! read more

This place was a life saver! My husband & I, showed to Island late at night 9:30-10pm on a Thursday night and it was still open. I was so hungry I didn't care what I ate! But I was pleasantly surprised with their Buracai Calazone. It was HUGE, enough for two to eat! So, glad we went straight there after 22 hours of traveling! read more

When I tell you that the BORICUA pizza is out of this world I truly mean it! You would think that this is not an island you should have pizza on, except when it comes to that pizza! Trust me!! read more

It's on OK spot but since there not many food places around, this is probably your best shot in terms of opening hours!

Pizza was amazing, waitress was absolutely amazing and sweet (she makes fantastic drinks), but the owner was rude. We spent a lot of money over $150 and she was pretty rude to is even after that. Wouldnt let us eat in the air conditioning and made us sit outside where there were a ton of flies because a few of our family members had a dish from another restaurant. read more

I'm a Brooklyn boy, a pizza snob by birth, that expects to be dissapointed by pizza even at most NYC joints. It counts for alot that this place got two 4 star reviews from Brooklynites. First, the crust was great: fresh, wheaty, yeasty, homemade taste; deftly stretched out nice and thinly; and cooked crisply just right. I was not looking for a NY-style Neopolitan or Sicilian pie. I wanted local flavor and got just what I wanted from the Boricua pie, a flavorful comination of plantains, ground beef, garlic, and mozzarella. If i could spend another week in Culebra the only places I'd bother eating would be Heather's, Zaoc's Tacos, and the Flamenco Beach kiosks (I never got to try Susie's). read more

We had a great service; they kept the beer flowing. Pizza was just about as good as it gets anywhere. They use fresh jalapeños so expect some great heat on the spicy Hawaiian. The wait for pizza can be a little while on a busy night, but order some grouper fingers and beer and relax; no need to be in a hurry. We came in starving after a day of snorkeling and kayaking, we left 100% satisfied. read more

I was told that Heathers was good, and that was from a New Yorker. They have nightly specials and the night I visited it was Gnochi with a blue cheese sauce. It was excellent. The pizza looked great. If you're on Culebra give it a try. read more

Very good pizza!! Great service and the staff was excellent also!!! Definitely would recommend eating here!

The best pizza ever. We ordered hot pizza wit pineapple and ham. It was so so delicious! We came back there to order again same pizza! The waitress was very cool. Price ok! I recommend! read more

All I can say is yes. The service, the food, the everything here is great. I understand vacation can add a rose tint to the glasses, but this is the best place for dinner and drinks on Culebra as far as I can tell. read more

Boricua pizza with plantains cilantro and ground beef was deeeeelish!!!