great pies and cookies and so many other foods. We love the owners, cooks and staff! we go there several times a week. read more

Amazing! Enjoyed brunch. A lot of items home made. Very satisfied with service and food. Definitely will come back!

I've never been disappointed plus the prices are very reasonable and the Baked goods and pies are delicious but hurry they don't last

Very good place to eat, food and service is outstanding . I would recommend Hartley inn .

My mom loves this place, and whenever I'm in town I always try to bring her. As a young girl she waitressed at the Hartley Inn, so for her there is a bit of Nostalgia held in its walls. For me, I love the place for people. The service is down to earth and fantastic, something which underscores the best part of Western P.A. Of course, Hartley Inn's charm is only surpassed by its down home cooking. Yup, I'm talking Grandma would be proud good. Although my mom hops around the menu, I always seem to settle on their delicious BLT. There is just something about this sandwich that I just can't shake; perhaps it semi-crisp bacon or that the tomato and mayo seem to merge with bacon and bread in a creamy, savory delight. Whatever the reason, I'm always down for a Hartley Inn BLT. I'm looking forward to our next visit to this iconic restaurant, a diner that has been serving up good drub since 1847!! read more

Hartley Inn Restaurant - Mom sporting her new Hartley Inn garb.. not too different from when she waitressed at the Hartley Inn so many years ago. - New American Near Me - Carmichaels, Pennsylvania

Happy to have found this place. Been quite awhile since I've had a real Hoagie and it was AWESOME. The zucchini fires were just the right mix of soft and crispy. Destiny and other staff are friendly and courteous. Love the look of the counter with the pedestal stools! Helpful with suggestions. Sadly we got there about 20 minutes before closing and would have loved to hang out longer. We were not rushed but wanted these folks to enjoy the day. Great Job, Hartley Inn!! read more

Everyone there is friendly and the food is always good! It's comfortable seating, always clean, and just an all around great place to eat!

The Hartley Inn is a staple of the area. We have been going here ever since I can remember. Even after moving away from the area, it's still a place I go to, even if it's not the best. Recently I've went and had two very different experiences. I went for lunch and hated it and then went for breakfast and loved it. The lunch sandwich I ordered looked like something I made at home. The bread was to be toasted but was still white and not warm. The breakfast I ordered on a separate meal was delicious. The eggs were fresh, the toast was great and the bacon was cooked exactly how I like it to be. The service is always a bit slow, even if business isn't booming. The wait staff is always nice though. The food needs to be more consistent though in order not to lose business. The price points, for the area are great. At the end of the day, even if it doesn't change I'll still come here because it's tradition, I just wish it would try to step it up a notch. read more

The food is delicious and the baked goods are even better! They have a buffet one Sunday out of the month.

Hartley Inn is another one of those places in Greene co. You grew up going to and you will always go back to! Nothing fancy, but your home town diner. Breakfast is always good. read more

Hartley Inn has been in this community for quite some time. I have not personally had any experiences at this location; but I hear nothing but praise. Definitely stopping in as soon as I can. Thank you for serving our community. read more

We were on a family trip and asked our hotel clerk for a good, non-franchise place to eat. She recommended the Hartley Inn, which we found to be hilarious because we are from the town of Hartly, Del. The place was not busy, and we got to chat with some of the staff (including our waitress, MacKenzie, who was soon to graduate from high school). They all were great. The food came quickly and was fine (the onion rings were fantastic). My wife took a homemade cheesecake back to the hotel. They also offered a military discount of 15% (which I forgot to ask them to include on the check). There's no sign out front, so be sure to look for the place on the town circle, next to the Fox pizza place. Give the place a try. read more

I grew up in Carmichaels , went to Hartley Inn throughout my childhood and the food was always great. My favorite to this day is the coconut cream pie. My mother and I used to share a piece when I was a child and I have such fond memories. I moved to Texas and when I had my daughter we visited the Carmichaels area and I was glad to see Hartley Inn was still open and I was able to have a piece of coconut cream pie with my daughter. It was the same amazing pie that I remembered . The hot Italian sausage with peppers sandwich is really great too !! read more

I called 22mins ago and they put me on hold! After 22mins I hang up to call back and have it BUSY! It's always something with this place!

Great small town diner type restaurant. Staff are wonderful and food is always good. Burgers and sandwiches are good

We loved their Sunday Brunch! This is definitely one of the best kept secrets in Greene County! Whatever you are hungry for, they have it on the buffet. Very impressed and will definitely come back! read more

We had a very nice diner style meal for my Mother-In-Laws birthday. I had not been here for a very long time - moved out of the county - and was very pleased to see that it was not only still here, but that there were several folks enjoying lunch. It was a bit slow, and could use a good cleaning, but my eggs were very good, my wife had a burger that was locally raised, and Grandma and Daughter had salads that were remarkably fresh for March in PA read more

Good family run place. Diner style offerings along with regional favorites. I'm not a liver and onions fan but my friends swear by them here. Their breakfasts are large and filling. My family loves their hot open faced sandwiches or their chicken fried steak. Their Pittsburgh style salads with French fries are delicious. Passing through and hungry for home comfort cooking, stop read more

This was the worst meal I've had in a long time. The meatloaf was dried out, the "crab" stuffed cod was disgusting and missing the side. When informed the server after the meal we were told "Sorry". That it. I'm not looking for a handout. I've eaten at this restaurant 100's of times. A trip to the bathrooms looked like a scene out of "Dirty Jobs". Disgusting. That is an understatement. Grossest dining experience on many years. Sad. Very sad. read more

Love going to the Hartley Inn. It is a staple of the community, and a place I look forward to going back and enjoying time with friends and family. Great food. Great prices. Small town environment and service -- I highly enjoy it and recommend it. read more

I love the history here. You feel it when you walk in. Home cooked meals that in my experience don't have a lot of consistency. I don't know if they have a high turnover with their cook staff but it seems like when I visit I'm always surprised at how different the same meal seems to be compared to when I had it 2 months prior. Nice little cozy place to sit and catch up with a friend though. read more

Have only eaten here once so far but all of the different foods that my family ordered were all really good.

I just wanted to make an update to my original review. The food still sucks and the portions are getting smaller. Once a great and storied business is still even after giving it some time and a second chance a place I once loved. read more

The Hartley Inn use to be THE place to go. Now it seems as though it's the place to go when nothing else is open or you don't want to drive far. The food use to taste like it was made from scratch, now most things just seem like pre packaged, heated food. Wait staff is friendly, but always very slow. Last time I was there I experienced an ant problem by the main window. I know things happen, the building is old and ants are one of those insects that are hard to get rid of. However it is a restaurant and should be kept insect free. I use to come here as a kid and drink hand made milk shakes and amazing blackberry shortcake when it was in season. I miss the old Hartley Inn. read more

Don't know what one reviewer means about bad wait staff we never had a bad experience and we dine there a lot...but anyone can have a bad day maybe even the reviewer. Food usually always good but there ARE certain cooks better than others as is anywhere. I feel we are lucky to have such a hometown restaurant that lasted generations not many left anymore enjoy them while you can,we will soon only have only fast food and chain restaurants left. read more