Best place in town Hands down Try it You will not be…read moredisappointed Friendliest staff in Southampton

Family owned. Pulled Pork is to die for. Beef tenderloin…read more Same. Best secret in S Hampton. You can keep Citarella.

Village Prime Meat is THE BEST. I always buy my brisket there for the holidays and the quality is…read moresecond to none. Mike trims it for me and will vacuum pack it for me. The other meats are beautiful. Prepared foods look yummy.

Great selection. Expensive but worth it. A true throwback butcher shop and Italian specialty store.read more

I love writing reviews of every new place I visit... and today, I definitely couldn't wait until…read morethe end of the day to write about the tacos I just had for lunch--they had an authentic Mexican flavor. Not Texan, not Northern-style--no, simply and perfectly Mexican! The real deal, in every sense of the word. They also serve tortas, enchiladas, and other delights for breakfast or lunch! Recommended!!

I just ordered a simple turkey and cheese sandwich on a roll and it was just okay. They have a wide…read morevariety of specials and stuff that I wish I had tried because they sounded very good, next time I am in the area I will probably try it out. They also have a lot of chips and snacks that you can buy that are right next to the line area for your convenience.

Had seen this place on socials and I loved their vibe so we stopped in today. I knew they had…read moresandwiched but it was a little difficult to find a sandwich board or menu (I eventually did) the place is very clean. It's an old bank so it's a fun look too! I was helped right away. My sandwich came out fast and hot and it was delicious. I'll definitely be back.

What a nice store! Stopped in for a freshly made smashburger after hearing about them and we ended…read moreup getting the "signature burger" and "Justin's burger". Was very surprised when they came out so small literally like sliders. At $12 a piece, even though they came with some fries, I thought the price was high. I do understand we're paying a premium for a burger from a quality butcher but probably wouldn't order again. Although very tasty! Loved the chopped pickles. They have a nice selection of gluten free pasta products from Italy which I hadn't seen before. Got a few of those and some pickles, chips and sauces too. Nicely organized produce section, friendly staff and overall a very nice business to frequent!

Cute and convenient market in the heart of the Hamptons! They have a very convenient market that…read morecaters to your food, groceries and household items. They have a natural juice stand inside where you can also get fresh matcha green tea, and other natural juices. The variety of foods is incredible and they carry lots of delicious baked goods, and other prepared foods. FYI, bathrooms are upstairs. It took me a few minutes to find the bathroom until I asked and had to go up the stairs. The bathroom is not very clean but it is what it is. Not what you would expect from the area (Easy Hampton). The service is ok they are working very hard so they treat you like they don't have time for your questions..I was a brand new customer and even asking where the restroom was made me feel a bit unwelcome maybe they only cater to the "regulars"!

I went there to get some fried chicken, I've had it before and it was very good. Only this time I…read moregot just one fried chicken thigh. Well it was $6.00,, SIX DOLLARS!! for one thigh! seriously!!! I purchased it but was not pleased. It was very good as usual but not worth six dollars. It's not that I can't afford it, but at these prices I won't be back soon. And I'm telling everyone I know about this. They should be ashamed! They'll go out of business at this rate, especially in the winter when there's not enough people here to support them.

Read reviews that Herb's Market has the best fried chicken in town! And it absolutely was!…read more I was exploring Montauk Village Main St with my parents and we stumbled upon the market. Much to my surprise, the place was quite empty walking in maybe due to its huge space. My dad wanted deli meats, but I recommended the fried chicken. My parents sat down at these large picnic benches while I ordered a bunch of fried chicken by the piece! When I got to the counter, the guy informed me that there was only white meat left and that he would put in a new batch of dark meat now. I waited patiently for 15 minutes while the new batch was fried. Then, I ordered a bunch of wings, legs, and a thigh. I'm so happy we were able to order by piece because nobody likes white meat in my family even though it's the most meaty. I was also surprised that the white meat costs the most! The chicken was beautifully battered and flavored. Not too thick nor too salty! It was out of this world and it is what will bring me back to Montauk. The place also sells a bunch of pantry items, sandwiches, salads, and drinks. Once you order you pay at the cash register by the front door. Very friendly people!

Now that Montauk has morphed into a chi-chi destination, sourcing reasonably priced nutritious fare…read morehas become quite the challenge. Thank goodness Herb's Market is still around offering hearty deli sandwiches, freshly made fried chicken and ribs, beverages, salads and more. All served up by friendly young personnel with no sneering pretentious vibes in sight.

Schiavoni's Market is family-owned market. It is a hidden gem for all your grocery needs in Sag…read moreHarbor. They provide a fresh selection of meats in the butcher section. Additionally, they offer salads, lunch meats, vegetables, produce, cheeses, and much more. It is an excellent place to pick up something when heading to the beach or returning home.

So over priced and you ALWAYS need to check the dates on products. Spent $6 on a small kombucha for…read moreit to have expired in November 2024. Thank god I noticed it looked weird and checked the date before drinking. It's happened more times than I can remember that there has been expired food on the shelves. I've also found produce that has mold contaminating whatever fruits and veg that they are next to. It's ridiculous to have such expansive items that are already expired on the shelves. I've gotten sick from the hot plate food and everything is soaked in grease. Also rude workers.

Today I had lunch in Southhampton Village at Citarella's. The hot and cold buffet was a bargain at…read more$13.99. I purchased some fresh blueberries, ropa vieja, fried tilapia, and chicken with mushrooms. Gisele was my cashier, and I declined her offer to purchase a shopping bag because I was going to stay in the store and eat. I sat on a barstool by the window and people watched--no celebrity sightings though! WARNING: BAD INTERNET SERVICE! I had to check in AFTER I left the premises because I do not use public WiFi!!!

The prices have very recently (like within last 2 weeks) increased approximately 25% on just about…read moreeverything in the store - 3 bagels went from $6 to $7.50 - cheaper to buy fresh from bagel store. Then filet mignon went to $70 per lb and avocados almost $5 each. They were expensive before, but this is outrageous and customers in the store are talking about it as they walk around the store. Can't buy groceries there anymore..