Great little deli with the standard offerings. It's hidden from view so we happened across it by…read moreaccident. Glad we did, the bacon/egg/cheese breakfast sandwiches were absolutely delicious. They also have some outdoor seating which was perfect for us.

Dirty deli with a limited selection. Oddest thing about it is the business hours are unfathomable…read more Tried going here late afternoon mid-week a few years ago and place was closed. Tried again this weekend as needed hamburger buns (sealed products presumably safe) and despite the sign saying "we're open" door was locked with lights out within at about 5 p.m. on a Saturday. This is clearly a front for something, afraid to know for exactly what. Beware.

I absolutely love this place. Incredible tortas, sandwiches, and smoothies. If you have a banana…read moreallergy or hate banana, mention it, because they've added banana at times to smoothies that don't mention them in the ingredient list. Friendly service.

real good. Wasn't immediate but the sandwich was fresh and rolls were great. Authentic viberead more

Delicious, fresh bagels. We came in as a group of 11 and they got through us easily with no mess…read moreups. That can be hard to come by! They also got through us fast as well as the people behind us. No long waits for everyone!

A fantastic deli in East Hampton. Two lines, one for bagels only and the other for everything else…read more Limited space for eating there. So takeouts it is for me. On top of the deli meats, lox, salads, and, sweets that I take home; for years now, with breakfast, I choose their egg, bacon, and hash brown "Hobo" on an everything bagel; and for lunch, I choose their pastrami, turkey with slaw and Russian on rye specialty sandwich, "East Hampton"! (and, not to be missed on winter weather days, their amazing "Lentil" soup) CHEERS!

Great store for coffee, groceries or lunch. Has a little bit if everything in Springs…read more Reasonable prices and nice setup

Had a great experience in this local spot. Very friendly staff..has a little of everything. Saves…read moreyou from getting stuck in Montauk highway traffic. The hot food looks and tastes great. The owners are there making sure every patron is served promptly and is happy with their visit. Stop by next time you are in town.....

My husband and I stopped into this deli while we were in the area recently and really enjoyed our…read moreexperience. There is no sit down inside the restaurant, but we got our food sat at the picnic tables outside, which was very nice. Our food was very very tasty my husband had a meatball sub that he said was outstanding and he eats meatball subs often so I trust his opinion. I had a salad which was so big and that I had enough for the next day and then some and it was also very tasty. The service was friendly and preparation was relatively quick and it was overall very very good experience. Highly recommend when you're in the area.

Great sandwiches. Of course a bit on the pricey side, as everything in the Hamptons. The place…read moreitself is tiny, with limited seating outside (no indoor seating), so your best bet is to call ahead and take your food to go to the beach. Also recommend the bow tie pasta salad.

I'm a deli guy. Living in Texas for past 11 years I was thrilled to find this place for…read morebreakfast.... And for lunch. Breakfast sandwiches of course in the morning. The all American and hamptons classic were excellent sandwiches. My wife wouldn't let me eat here every day of vacation and the only reason I didn't is because I love her dearly.

I guess I've been coming here for 30 years now. Still reliable, fast service, I love the coffee…read moresince I like plain coffee that hasn't been roasted to death. Breakfast sandwiches are simple and uncomplicated and taste great. And you can get a full meal without having to mortgage your house.

Was on my way from Hampton bays to sag Harbor looking for a spot to get breakfast that wasn't going…read moreto cost an arm and a leg. Stumbled upon this gem. They made me a breakfast burrito that will put the best of us in a food coma. There were no shortage of choices at 9 am from fried chicken to a full hot food line and sandwiches. I'll be stopping back in here for sure.

What an amazing surprise to find a place in this area with amazing caldo de pollo and caldo de res,…read morenot to mention Salvadorean pupusas. Yum!! We are so grateful that we stopped by on our way home and will be back! A lot! AND, it says they deliver. Total score. Excited to taste everything on the menu.

Great fresh meats. Groceries of the highest quality. Service with a smile but can be pricey.read more

Just don't. Chaotic and not good. Fried chicken was inedible and vegetarian options non existent…read more This is our biggest regret on sag harbor and it was my choice to try it. I did order something vegetarian and it was an absolute tragedy. Husband will not let me live it down, that is how bad it was. He is teasing me as we speak and he will probably continue to do so for years to come -- the worst food we had in our 5+ year relationship. Yes, I deserve the teasing for suggesting this. Just don't. Don't listen to Reddit about the amazing sandwiches here. They don't live here. Infinitely better options nearby.

Solid 4 Stars for a quick convenient lunch while out on the East End for the day. I had the roasted…read moreturkey panini with herbed brie, tomato, and Barcelona vinaigrette on this rustic ciabatta bread. Oh mylanta and my stars! My insides sang such happy songs while I devoured my panini. So much so that after leaving the Cafe I said to myself that I still have my discount from post wedding registry I ordered a panini maker off of Williams Sonoma. That's how damn good the panini was. The coleslaw was meh but the standout was the panini. So much so I've already made a mental note depending what time I leave Montauk after my annual work trip I may stop in here. I don't care if I sit by myself because it was that good. Golden Pear you can count on me coming back for more!

Edit: from the owners response below, their lunch sandwiches are not buttered. I recommend that…read moreanyone who wants this sandwich to confirm this when you order because it appears some of his staff are unaware. This place serves mid food for insane prices and we only go there because there's few options nearby to grab lunch before hopping on the Jitney. Every pastry I've had there is mediocre. Every lunch I've had there is mediocre, but in this case it was a little less than mediocre. The sandwich was incredibly dry, needed sauce, dressing, mayo, something. Instead they buttered the bread??? Who butters a lunch sandwich. The lettuce and tomato at least provided some (albeit limited) moisture. Pasta salad was fine.