Gus's New York Pizza is one of those places where you truly can't go wrong. I've ordered a variety of items over time, and I can honestly say I've never ordered anything I didn't like. The food is consistently fresh, flavorful, and satisfying every single time. The pizza is classic New York-style and absolutely delicious, but the wings are my favorite right after the pizza--crispy, saucy, and always cooked just right. Whether I'm in the mood for a quick slice, a full meal, or comfort food done right, Gus's always delivers. read more

Gus's New York Pizza is my home away from home. Being from New York - while visiting the area, I was craving some authentic New York pizza and landed in the right spot. Everything here is super fresh - and so tasty. I especially love their garlic cheese bread and salads. The wings are juicy and crispy and I love the mango habanero sauce for little kick. You must try one of the speciality pizzas - we really enjoyed the white pizza but also got a regular slice with pepperoni. The burgers are really juicy with the perfect amount of char and we really enjoyed the crispy fish wrap too - actually one of my favorite bites of the night. Aside from the food being really good. The owner is so super friendly as we all our servers - everyone went out of their way to make a time the extra special. We just love Gus's - I really wish we had one in our neck of the woods. read more

Overall, this restaurant had the most bland pasta ever. However, their boneless wings are pretty good. 3.5/10 read more

Great atmosphere and original brick oven pizza!! Service is fast and friendly. Salads and daily special are great prices!!

I actually think this is a solid 4.5. It's underrated on yelp, so I upped it. This pizza was super good! Vegetables were fresh, nicely cooked. The right amount of cheese. So many things done right. I ate two pieces before going out to deliver to the family. Because dayum: it smelled as good as it tasted. Bar service was friendly and efficient too. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Sports Bars Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

Great service,great food didn't wait too long and I love the decor. Euro and the burger was good. Good stop before the movies!

When chicken parmesan is a cut up chicken tender over pasta with mozzarella RUN! The pasta was over cooked. My husband had an Italian sub that was ok. He was charged for three beers and only had one. The first was flat. Then he asked for a bottle. Then he asked for a glass (for the bottle) and they gave him another glass of beer. He was charged for all 3. read more

This visit was a major let down. Normally the food is really good but this wasn't the normal quality of Gus's pizza. My mom and I went there yesterday I had gotten an individual pizza with mushrooms and she had gotten an individual pepperoni pizza. Once our food had arrived my order came as it should have been but my mom's order came out wrong. She had received a plan cheese pizza and it was sent back. When the pizza arrived it was obvious that all the cooks did was put pepperoni on the already made pizza instead of making a new one. It was sad that the best server working that night didn't take care of us because it would totally be a different experience. I love it how we weren't even offered dessert and the check came before we were even finished with our meal. I was a regular when I lived in the area but I don't think I will be back for awhile. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - 8" Individual 1-Topping Pizza Lunch - Sports Bars Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

I'm going to start off by saying I'm a regular and I'm not using my real name to avoid conflict. I went in a few times this week and sat at the bar like I always do. I noticed there's been some changes made behind the bar. The service is terrible. I came in last night (1/31) and sat at the bar. The bartender had a bad attitude and other people at the bar were also voicing the same opinion. It's unfortunate when you come to an establishment that has always had great bartenders and great service and then changes are made that disrupt the whole atmosphere. I was ignored and I felt like a burden to be there. I really don't want to go back. The 2 girls that were always behind the bar were a big reason I've come in for so long and it's the same for others as well. it's just a disappointment. I hope this puts things in perspective from a regulars point of view. I really don't know i'll be back. And lastly, I've never been to a restaurant that allows the employees to vape inside and behind the bar. read more

The pizza is delicious! Perfect size for a personal pizza. Be warned there isn't much sitting space though.

The hubs and I enjoy picking up pizza here when no one feels like cooking. They are also available on DoorDash and maybe ubereats. There's a small bar area with seating available upon entry in addition to a large family style table by the door for bigger parties. The times that we went in for a drink it was semi busy as there were 2-3 waitresses taking orders and bringing out the food. Locals come in for food and conversation. There is plenty of tasty options to choose from on the menu. Their wings are great, crispy, and fried fresh. Fish and chips were rock hard, and I'll be passing on that in the future. Bacon cheeseburger was ok, but the bacon was forgotten, and the cheese was more in the wrapper than the meat. Their slices of cake are awesome! It's a must order whichever one you choose. I've had the chocolate and banana slice, and it's just moist with amazing flavors. Onto the pizza. Some people like the crust thick and the hubs enjoys filling up on a little more bread so he definitely gravitates to Gus Pizza. I wouldn't say this is NY style pizza. It does have the large factor, but not the thin, and foldable edge crisp. The cheese is thick and chewy. There is an automatic 18% gratuity applied to your check regardless of how many is in your party when dining in. There is also another option below the automatic gratuity for adding additional tip. Service can sometimes be spotty, and it is frustrating because the tip is already secured without much effort and lots of waiting. Overall not bad. Fresh takeout pizza when time permits:) read more

See all

This is my first time here I ordered the white pizza. The pizza was mostly crust and very thin and cold for an $18 pizza. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - White Pizza - Sports Bars Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

First off, I was impressed with our server's attentiveness despite our choosing to sit outside at the tail end of the lunch specials period. I'm sure she had plenty of inside prep duties to attend to yet still managed to return to us multiple times during our visit. Outside, we got to sit next to a mural of various New York cultural iconography but was bemused by the presence of Batman and Superman in the mural despite every nerd worth their weight knowing neither hero is a New Yorker. Lol. My food was great. The beef and lamb gyro was loaded and tasty. My potato salad was subtle in its flavor but really good... and a hearty sized portion. Wife Unit liked her sub but thought she preferred another locations slightly better. Overall, it was a great first visit and we want to try a few more items from the menu to see if it becomes a regular spot for us. read more

Pizza was cooked fresh, served hot and was good. Not my favorite but the best we've been able to find in this area so far. Order was for carry-out and was pretty quick service. No complaints. 1 medium supreme and 1 pepperoni and 1/2 cheese which came to roughly $43 tip not included. read more

See all

Food is awesome, the vibe is great and the staff makes it just a great experience and makes you wanna keep coming back or spend more time there every time you go. read more

I love Gus's, they are so nice and the food is fantastic! I've never ordered something from there and thought it was bad, that's just how wonderful it is there. read more

Don't get me wrong I really enjoy Gus's pizza. We have one near our house and order ALL the time. I went out this way and called in an order to go. The women said it would be about 15 minutes for the pizza. I arrive about 12 minutes later. I sent my daughter in to grab it with cash.. she walks out with just the pizza. I said where is the change? She said the cashier said that was all, just the pizza. I said no go back in to get the change. The lady gave the $5.25 change to my daughter. The pizza was $14.75... I would have had my daughter run in and give a tip BUT to just keep it? Well TRY to keep the $5.25? Yeah... no and this location has lost my business. The pizza was fine. Same as always. read more

4-13-22 @ 7:40pm. I called the Hampton location and was immediately put on hold and waited for 5 minutes until I hung up. I'm guessing this location is either understaffed or the employees forgetful. I WAS going to place a very LARGE order, but now I'll place my order somewhere else. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Waited to long on hold! - Sports Bars Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

For a neighborhood restaurant, it's not bad. The prices are reasonable and the food is not the best, but it also won't send you into an uncontrollable fit of rage . If you and your stoner friends want food for a low price, this is for you. Don't come here for your anniversary dinner, but it's worth a shot if you just want to eat and sit in comfort and not worry about the constant ticking of time that eventually will come for us all. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Calzone - Sports Bars Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

The service was awful. I went on yesterday to get my usual salad. I showed my military retired ID as always. The employee retrieved it from my hand, turned it over. I asked what was she looking for on the back and she stated the expiration. I told her the card was indefinite and it stated that on the front with my picture. She proceeds to tell me it expires July 2024. I told her that was for my medical. She says we need to make sure it is real, I am just doing what "He" told me. I asked to speak to "him" so I could show what to look for on the card. I am a 63 year old 100% disabled veteran just trying to get a salad. She then asked what I wanted to order I told her nothing. There were two others directly beside be at the bar. I am sure they heard the embarrassing conversation. Train your employees.****** Now I know why the staff act the way they do. spoke to the Manager today. He just didn't get it. One customer down. I love Vinny's. read more

One of my friends told me to try this pizza place out. Well I'm going to tell you not to. The quality of pizza you get is just above a papa John's or domino's. The toppings aren't fresh. There's not enough sauce. The dough isn't crispy, but rather chewy and tough. But if that wasn't enough it's expensive for pizza. If you want good pizza go to Vinnys. read more

The Pepperoni Pizza is exceptional and the staff was friendly. It like a low key popular spot for a beer and pizza. Everything I've tried from their menu got no complaints from me. read more

When this location first open they wear not good with pizza at all, but now I guess they been practicing. WOW! This is really good pizza! Wife and I ordered a large supreme pizza from these guus for take out and it was GREAT! Served hot with an abundance of fresh toppings. A nice pipping hot crust that was crunchy on the outside and soft like a pretzel on the in. And luckly for me, this location is within walking distance of my house! GREAT JOB GUS'S read more

See all

If you're looking for a good place with excellent pizza, great drinks, and family type of vibe, this is it! Every time I've gone in, the vibes were always positive and the food is always a hit. read more

I was at a friend's house for the weekend and order the veggie pizza minus tomato's and OMG it was delicious. We all loved the veggie. I haven't had meat in months I can't speak on how the other pizzas tasted. read more

We were headed to a movie, needed to kill time and decided to stop by... I am glad we did!! The lunch menu was phenomenal, we each chose a mini pizza and a drink, for $6.99 per person! They also have a lunch special rewards program... Back to the food: It was some of the best New York pizza I've had since NY itself, perfectly crispy, nummy flavors and it was NOT burnt! The service was great, there were not many customers while we were there but it's nice to know they don't slack when it's slow. Only slight complaint was the music was a little annoying for my mom, but I tuned it out, and we did not ask for them to turn it down. They had football on but it was muted with subtitles (football is a plus for me). The store was clean with no weird smells, just pizza! read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Before the meal... - Sports Bars Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

See all

I was on the way to a play nearby on a busy Friday evening, and just needed a quick bite to eat somewhere nearby. Of coarse I hopped on Yelp to see what was good nearby, and was very pleased with the slice of pizza and pop received. The place was bigger and nicer then I imagined it would be, and prices better then I expected as well...now tell me the last time that happened to you?! My teen loved the jukebox photo booth thing as well! They seem to have specials on foods and drinks daily, so don't miss out and make sure to give this place a try sometime soon! They don't fall short on pizza sauce or cheese topping like some other local places where you feel they decided to give as minimally to their pizza prep as possible. Our party of two was very pleased with this in and out eat in experience, and my waitress provided great service to boot! read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Sports Bars Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

See all

Amazing service and food. Had slices of pizza with my boys before a movie and loved the jukebox music They had playing. My boys loved looking at the pictures of NY city on the walls. Visited frequently. Must go. read more

For one it doesn't taste like New York pizza and, not a lot of options, second of all way too over priced for so called New York pizza and, lastly Gus's should be Gus', proper grammar. However the inside the restaurant is really nice but doesn't look like a pizzeria. The people were polite and really helpful. read more

Amazing pizza where you can taste all the ingredients! Love the chewy but soft bite of their crust! Just like NYC! Cheese is perfect!

Thumbs up for the drink variety and the reasonable prices. They have a nice variety of lunch specials as well. But what matters is the pizza. the best thing I can say it it's chewy on the inside and crispy on the outside. But the bottom of the rust is flaky, it basically cracks apart. Also, there was too much cheese added. The flavor of the sauce is okay, but needed some more seasoning. I had to add quite a bit of garlic, parmesan, and oregano to make it taste better. I've had authentic NY pizza many times and while it's an okay attempt, it's not close enough. read more

My favorite place for my favorite sub; however. 8 inch sub, bag of chips and a drink and tip = $20.00 I can get a 12" sub, bag of chips and a soda with no tip at Subway! I'm not cheap but I am frugal. Didn't enjoy the cackling of drunkies at the bar for the everyday happy hourssss either. Afraid the climate and prices has excluded this long time customer from future visits. read more

I I ordered gyro lamb ang beefI and when I get home the meat is not lamb or beef, it was a steak uuum the one in the frozen box , instead of using tsatziki, they used mayonnaise . What a rip off! !!! I understand about the prices going up but this is way too bad and ripping off the costumers. They raise the prices plus they do not used the ingredient that was written in the menu. I do not recommend this place in Hampton on the big bethel road.. read more

The FOH staff was amazing, but my party all agreed the pizza was a little undercooked

Sad pizza, no better than domino's....I guess if you have never had a real NY/NJ pizza made in a gas/coal/brick oven, then pizza made in a rolling electric oven will do....tombstone pizza is better. read more

Great food, smoking section outside with heaters and the pizza and fried cod are delicious. My boyfriend smokes so we are here often! Been coming here for a while now, friendly staff, drink is cheap.... Ultra $1 and other drink specials! Worth the visit, just off Big Bethal in Hampton read more

Smh... truly disappointing. I was born and raised in Jersey, so this would never fly there let alone New York. They fixed the slice up quickly, but their speed was over-shadowed by the poor presentation and lack of flavor. Save yourself the annoyance and buy a frozen pizza for less. At least then you know the disappointment is warranted. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Cheese pizza with vegetables thrown on top = vegetarian. Subpar no resemblance to NY style in taste, size, or presentation. Won't try again. - Sports Bars Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

Pizza is bomb I personally like going to dine in customer services is nice and fast and pizza is fresh out the oven

Great place for a quick lunch, great service and inexpensive. If you are looking a place that is friendly and good food I suggest you try Gus's!!! read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Sports Bars Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

I have been going to this Gus's location since they opened several years ago. Today I went for lunch and the service and food was awful. Initially I noticed a new menu with increased prices and when the check came, there was a surcharge if you wanted to pay by credit card. I ordered an individual cheese pizza with banana peppers and onions. The waitress brought me the wrong pizza and said she sent the wrong order to the kitchen, understandable. However when the second pizza came out it was burned. Our waitress hardly had any interaction with us after that however the one time she spoke to me and asked how my pizza was, I told her it was burnt. She just said she was sorry and walked away. It was the worst experience I've ever had at Gus's and I won't be returning. In the future I'll go to Brickhouse Tavern in Port Warwick. They are less expensive and the food is just as good if not better. read more