We go here on a regular basis. They are usually pretty busy and the food is great! The servers are super nice and when it's nice they have a nice patio. read more

I love their spaghetti and meatballs and I like the people there and they are so sweet and kind and caring read more

Guarnieri Pizzeria - Canivore Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Marys, Ohio

People are rude. Act like they are better than you. Took family there we had to get up and leave no one would acknowledge us don't my money spend like everyone else read more

Amazing food!!! Fast service and beautiful location!!! Great employees! Definitely will be back!

Best pizza you can get around this area. It also has good drinks. The food menu also includes sandwiches. It can get pretty busy. This is a popular spot on weekends. In St. Mary's there's not much good to eat. It's right next to the lake, where it's mostly bars with fried stuff. While at the lake, be sure to take a visit into town. It doesn't have that much to see, but there's some better places to eat. This is probably the best, just by observing how busy this was. It's pretty nice looking inside. This however is just a casual bar and pizza place. I had an amaretto sour. It's about $5 for a glass. This has a buttery and sweet taste. I had the vegetable hoagie. It's about $7 for the sandwich. This is a good amount but it could have used more taste. It didn't have much spice beyond the Italian dressing. This is made using a choice of pick your own vegetables. It's one of the popular places for the locals. They like to gather here for sports events. This can get extremely crowded on weekends. read more

Guarnieri Pizzeria - Amaretto Sour And Vegetable Hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Saint Marys, Ohio

Had pizza here twice. Didn't care for it either time. Trying to be too fancy for my liking.

How can you serve food but barely are open? How are you even open with the hours you have and when it's to crowded to get your food, everyone's clustered together. Never again :) read more

The subs are terrible! The Philly Steak sub is an insult to Philly Steak subs everywhere! The other subs are all bread. Hardly any meat but if you like tomato lettuce and lots of mayo you will love them! The service is good but even our waitress could not tell which subs were which because you couldn't find the MEAT!!! Will never eat there again and neither will the other six people who were with us!!! read more

Matty & Garret provided excellent service and the pizza was delicious! It was my friend's first time there and she said she can't wait to bring her husband and family back. read more

They make REAL Italian food!!! I've always been very pleased by their food!! I fully recommend Guarnieri's!!

Great little place with great pizza and pasta dishes. Staff are friendly and very helpful.

Love the pizza! Enjoyed the salads when they first opened, they seem to have changed after the remodel. Not a fan. Subs are good. Pasta is decent. Don't love the dining room. Poorly laid out and too dark. Service isn't bad, but could always use improvement. Never blown away by the service. read more

The food is good. Service is always quick and friendly. Ambiance is cozy. In the summer they have outdoor dining and live music. Nice place

Amazing food! Chicken, bacon, ranch sub is my favorite!

Amazing! Pizza was great, sauce must be homemade! Great value! Very nice clean restaurant.

Best boneless wings around! I also recommend the whole menu but the wings are just the right heat.

BYOB. Pizza is EXCELLENT. Jenny is a premier host in the Industry. A must taste establishment. read more

Guarnieri Pizzeria - Lots of cheese. Meat is allll underneath. Slammin Sammy is #1 - Pizza Near Me - Saint Marys, Ohio

Absolutely the best pizza in the area. Great selection and very friendly staff. We have tried ALL the other pizza places and this is the best. I hope they don't change anything. read more

Food was ok and served on paper plates. We waited over an hour to get our food. Facade makes it seem like a cute little Italian restaurant but inside is very much a bar atmosphere. read more

Delish! We stopped in on a Sunday afternoon, and were one of the only tables. Out waitress was super helpful and sweet. The food came out super fast and hot, and was sooo good. We will definitely be back soon. read more

Excellent calzones and pretzel sticks with authentic beer cheese! Great service and friendly staff!

Wonderful pizza and apps, good beer and wine selection. Would come back and recommend to anyone!

Went here for the first time today. Atmosphere is cozy. Salads were excellent. Yelp address is wrong the street address is 220 East Spring Street. Going back to try the lasagna next time. read more

We love Guarnieri's. Since it opened up a larger restaurant it has really become a popular place. They have had a few issues with fast service but are getting better as they've been open longer. Great drink selection. Pizza and subs are fresh and delicious. Chicken bacon ranch and the buffalo chicken subs are my favorite. Definitely worth trying out. But beware of the crowded weekends. The place fills up quick. read more

We are in here eating and just watched new customers walk in the door, wait around then start cleaning off a dirty table so they could sit down with their kids. It's been almost 10 minutes and not a single employee has even acknowledged them. Because the server and bartender have been standing in the back talking most of the night. It took 15 minutes for anyone to acknowledge us, and our good took almost an hour... Very disappointed. read more

Terrible service, mediocre food. Arrived Friday at 6 pm ordered quickly but then waited 15 minutes to get my glass of wine, and 45 minutes to get our salad, one plate of lasagna and one plate of spaghetti and meatballs. Yes, the salad did not come out before the meal but with the meal. Water glass were never refilled. Totally ignored until leaving the bill, then we got a sorry for the wait after we paid. Would have been better to make it at home. Not worth the wait or bad service. Only saw two servers on the floor. Bad management it to blame. It is always worth it to pay more servers to handle the busy times then not to have enough servers to give good service. Service is key in this business. If you have okay food with great service people will come back. Great food with bad service-you just lost a customer. read more

Took a while to get our food, but the pizza is good and the wings, while small, were good. Gotta have the chocolate chip cookie!!! Very friendly folks as well. read more

This is far better pizza than one can ever expect in northwest Ohio. Tasty and kind of a NY style meets Chicago style and it comes out well. Wide variety of interesting and flavorful toppings. read more