I stopped today for a late lunch after traveling since before 4am. I was glad to sit for a comfortable meal located in the iconic Little Italy section of Cleveland on historic Mayfield Street. I was greeted by the host just beside the bar who promptly seated meat my choice of to side or outside in on the patio/courtyard (I chose outside). I was greeted by my server, Faith, who took great care to price suggestions as I questioned her about the menu selections. I landed on a caprese salad, fried mozzarella and the 90 year old lasagna recipe! The service, food quality and taste and prices were all to my liking/satisfaction. This is my 2nd trip dining in Little Italy and the 2nd restaurant I've tried. Both have been fantastic choices! Great history for today's choice and I have included the story as an image in my photos. read more

See all

Based on one visit. This place is pretty famous and popular and probably worth trying at least once. It was OK but didn't impress us to the point we would go again as there are other choices. You can decide for yourself. Plus (+) *Nice old school environment inside and out. *Located in Little Italy Middle / OK *Food quality was not bad, but not exceptional. *Table Service wasn't bad, friendly and accommodating. But they were busy and a little more follow up may have helped get food faster. Negative (-) *Took a very long time to get our food. We were told there were many take out orders, it seemed the way it was explained after our order delaying our order. This may have not been the case and there were allot of take out orders before ours. However a couple that came after us received their food before us. *Parking: I drove by the lot and could not easily determine if it was pay park and amount or if there were spots available. We called to ask and was told almost rudely no way for them to know. read more

Really enjoyed our dinner here. Super cute and classy inside. We got the chicken parmigiana and spaghetti and meatballs. Both were delicious. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

From the very moment we were greeted by the parking attendant, to our entry greeted by the owner, Scott Phillips our visit was blessed. We were waiting on a few other members of our party and invited to relax at the bar with fabulous service and excellent excellent treatment. The warm environment of this family restaurant was like getting a warm hug on getting a cool rainy day. (It was!) Owner, Scott, took time in telling us a bit of the history while we enjoyed a couple drinks at the bar. A few minutes later, our friends joined us, and we were seated at our table. Our seasoned server, Mary Lou, answered any questions we had and gave us fabulous recommendations. She made sure she paid attention to us, but did not rush us in any step of the process. Our entrées included two orders of lasagna (made from a 60-year-old family recipe), an order of eggplant Parmesan, and an order of clam linguine with white sauce. All of us also ordered a side salad. Salad came out promptly and delicious! Followed by our entrées, beautiful, and looking so ready to be eaten. Every bite was fabulous, and the warmth of the environment made this meal truly seem like sitting around someone's family table at home. With hardly any room left, all four of us ordered dessert to go. This was a first for us, first time in the restaurant, first time in little Italy in Cleveland, Ohio! And finally, our first time to ever say this will not be our last time because we will be back, and will bring more friends!! read more

See all

I was told this was the oldest Italian restaurant in the area. The staff were really nice and the owner was very friendly as well as attentive to the customers. The service was pretty quick. I sat at the bar. The gnocchi was pretty delicious. It's a little salty but true pesto is always a little salty. The sangria was good for a mocktail. If I were gonna be in town longer I would go back. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Pesto gnocchi - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

Love the back patio, such a charming area. We really enjoyed the Italian wedding soup, lasagna, and chicken piccata. Service was great. We loved it so much that we are hoping to have a private event in the back patio this fall (just waiting to get in touch with them to reserve it!) Update -- we went back and forth trying to get in touch with someone about private event booking (email, phone, in person) and after weeks we decided to go with another restaurant. Don't recommend for private events. Very disorganized and poor communication for that. read more

See all

s a general rule, I don't bother reviewing restaurants with a lot of reviews, but this one is somehow getting underrated on Yelp. Yes, we had to wait 20 minutes. Yes, it's older inside. But the owner and staff are really nice and we had a great time. As for the food: yum. If you want traditional Italian food, head in. Standouts were eggplant Parmesan and fruita de mare pasta with red sauce. Bottle of wine was fairly priced and good. If you're visiting Cleveland, little Italy is a must-go and this restaurant is a great place to start. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Fruita de mare with linguini - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

We started with cocktails. I believe it was called the Isle of Capri and the other was a lemonade type drink with vodka. I had a glass of Montepulciano wine. We all were happy with our drinks. All three of us ordered the lasagna, which has a recipe that's been around for 60 years. My sister and friend really enjoyed theirs, while I thought it was okay but would have preferred a meat sauce instead of just marinara. That is why I took off a star. My sister and I shared the lemon cake for dessert, it was delicious with a capital D! We sat outside, which was wonderful; I loved seeing the trumpet flowers on the vines, that came from the "old country". The history of the place is fascinating, be sure to read it on the back of the menu. The free parking in their lot was a huge bonus. Our server was excellent--attentive without being intrusive. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Lasagna 60-year-old recipe - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

"Guarino's Restaurant" is a great place. It is a multigenerational establishment as I am part of a multigenerational family that enjoys patronizing them. I must first address the reason I almost gave them 4 rather than 5 stars. It has nothing to do with the quality of food... it is consistently excellent. It has nothing to do with the service... I always feel well taken care of by the entire staff. The reason may sound a bit silly but, 2 things bothered me. One is: I really miss the pavilion style roof that use to be in the garden patio. Two: I love the patio in almost any weather but the yellow jackets are everywhere. They will not leave me alone... nearly drove me inside today. Just sayin'... I know they're picky reasons but they bother me. However, that said. If you enjoy consistently good Italian food. In an establishment that has been there forever. With experienced, friendly staff. And MOST importantly, their own parking lot, continuously monitored; ya, a guy sits out front (that's like GOLD on the hill). "Guarino's is the place for you. Go, enjoy, mangia! read more

See all

Very reasonable prices and perfectly sized menu with plenty of food and drink options. Lovely cozy home like restaurant with its own parking lot next to it and free valet parking. Scrod with vegetables was the only low carb option in the menu save for salads but was good. Well oiled veggies and not dry cod in good portion for $20 is a good deal to me! The appetizer prosciutto olives were very flavorful. The joe lato cocktail was delicious. Creamy lemon flavor and sweet but not cloyingly so. read more

See all

Guarino's is so convenient it's becoming my favorite restaurant in the University Circle area. Why? They have a private parking lot just for patrons. No more trying to find parking and squeezing into a spot. Food is very good. I have stopped twice with out-of-town friends mid-afternoon for their Antipasto and fried mozzarella. Everyone says it hits the spot before heading home for dinner. Excellent staff at this family restaurant. Patio is nice tho we sat inside this old fashioned Italian decorated place. Full bar. Single restroom. I don't think this is wheelchair accessible. Call them to find out. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Antipasto and fried mozzarella with marinara. We ate the green olives!! Nice afternoon snack. - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

We stopped in for dinner because every other place packed. We walked right in behind a walk-in of 3 and both parties were sat immediately. Should have been a clue. Service was adequate but slow. Place didn't look so busy so unsure why. Wife enjoyed her drink, I had canned beer. The Marshall appetizer had a very thick hard crust, but was edible. The red sauce on the side was very tangy, like it was a day from being old or was left in a can too long. Wife ordered a pizza which was very subpar in general. Crust was thicken almost biscuit like? Round cut sausage versus crumbles, which we prefer. I had the brasciole. Tough, salty, but edible. Pasta it sat on was very watery. Relaxed environment with comfortable seating. Won't be back, expect more from "Little Italy " read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

I appreciated that we could dine earlier than our reservation, but the mairte d' forgot to assign a server to our table. We had to sit for a while. When we got ou server, things began to happen. We shared an eggplant and artichoke salad. When the bill came, I noticed we were charged $4.00 to divide the salad on to two dishes. I failed to ask that the blue cheese be left off. Fortunately for me, there was not a lot of the cheese. If I were a blue cheese lover, Ice.'d be disappointed. My wife's eggplant parm was tasty and accompanied by a generous portion of pasta. I had lasagna. It was a generous portion and had an excellent red sauce. The garlic bread was tasty as well. The room was dark and decorated with red brocade wall paper making for a pleasant ambience. Having their own parking lot is a big plus as well. read more

See all

The ambiance and service was great. Presentation of food was great. The lasagna was very tasty. I wasn't a very huge fan of what I ordered. I got the pasta primavera with "white sauce" in my opinion the noodles were not flavored well besides with just garlic, not much flavor to the chicken either so I was a bit disappointed. But the vegetables were good, other than that I can't complain about anything else. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Pasta Primavera - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

Excited to have lunch at this historic restaurant in Cleveland's little Italy. There were many special decorative touches that created an inviting atmosphere. We did not have a reservation and were seated quickly. Our server was friendly and helpful in explaining the different menu entrees. I enjoyed the cheesy garlic toast and chicken piccata. My family enjoyed their meals, too. I would recommend to anyone in the area. read more

See all

Last month we visited Cleveland for very first time and decided to visit Cleveland's Little Italy. Guarino's restaurant was the absolute worst Italian restaurant our family has ever visited and I know because I'm Italian! This restaurant was a dark and dingy with one toilet and a tiny sink as the only bathroom for the entire restaurant. The decor was dated with rickety furniture. The barely functioning light sconces were very dusty with cobwebs. My Nonna triped once and almost triped twice on the old worn carpeting that had several large holes. It was a safety hazard and should be taped down. The food was also well below average. There was no bread offered to our table of five. The appetiters and drinks cost as much as the entrees. Although we all ordered entrees, on the check/bill they charged us an extra $4.00 per person share fee (adding an additional $20.00 onto the bill) because we took a bite of each other's food. I guess they watched us while we ate and then decided to price-gouge, taking advantage of us as we tried to support their business. This was creepy and weird. Eating there was a terrible experience for us and a bad memory of our first visit to Cleveland. Guarino's restaurant wasn't crowded, at all, and in hindsight that should have been a big clue but we stayed. We regret eating there. Upon leaving we saw so many other lively and crowded restaurants that had much better energy. read more

This place is so good and I went during the Feast I went to the stand and it was awesome and everything tasted awesome!

Old-world interior, good coffee, going back for the calamari again soon! They have their own parking lot which is a huge plus, be sure to tip the attendant! read more

It's been a while since I've been to Guarino's restaurant! We walked away, so happy that we ordered the Italian wedding soup and lasagna!! Out of all that we ordered, we've decided that those 2 were honestly the best and we will come back just to get those! read more

See all

The patio is really pretty, I was being swarmed by bees the whole time but that not their fault. The servers are incredibly nice and thoughtful. The food is always good and remind me of my family's Italian food. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Chicken Parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

Really cool old old restaurant and beautiful patio. I do think it's the best patio in Cleveland at least that I've seen. It was really hot and sunny but they got more umbrellas for us. The Joe-lato drink is my new favorite alcoholic drink, creamy and lemony. The Alfredo was great but I think I'd try something different next time. But I'd definitely come back!! Very very nice and professional workers too! read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Joe-lato - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

The maître d' graciously accommodated us at a very busy time, which immediately set the tone for a wonderful evening. One of the things that truly sets this restaurant apart in Little Italy is that they provide parking for their guests. They even allowed us to park well over an hour before our reservation, which gave us the gift of strolling through Little Italy and enjoying the neighborhood before dinner. What a treat. The food was exceptional. My husband ordered the lasagna, a 50-year-old family recipe, and it was spectacular. I had the chicken piccata, a dish I'm quite particular about since it's a favorite in our household, and I was genuinely blown away. I only wish I knew their secret. The calamari was another highlight. As someone who has lived on the West Coast and appreciates fresh seafood, I can be hard to impress. Their calamari rings were tender, never chewy, with a light, delicate breading that was perfectly done. We loved every minute of our experience and will absolutely be back. read more

This place os great and really authentic. The atmosphere is is fun and light. The Frutti de Mare in oil & garlic is amazing. Desserts great and wine list is well done. Also I met my doppelgänger read more

Guarino's Restaurant - My doppelgänger Frank - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

Came in for appetizers and a drink. Such a nice atmosphere! Food that we had-fried mozzarella and antipasto plate, were quite tasty. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Beer and appetizers - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

Great place to go Had Mary Lou she was great Drink were great , Apps awesome,and food was amazing Service was awesome Great Italian Restaurant Thanks Scott read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Italian Lemonade - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

Apparently this is the oldest restaurant in Ohio, established in the early 1900s. The ambience was classic Italian restaurant. We were fortunate to get seats out in the garden, which was amazing. The piano player was a nice touch, offering up some entertainment while we dined. We started with the calamari and the bruschetta, both of which were solid. The bruschetta was kind of so it yourself, with bread and the toppings provided together. My wife had the lasagna (60 year old recipe) and it was very good, solid mix of flavors. I had the Futti di mare, which was great. Mussels, shrimp and calamari. My daughter had the gnocchi and loved it. And my son had the pizza, which he thought was 'mid' thinking that it would be a regular pizza (with sauce and all) but it was tomato, cheese and basil. Only complaint was the variety in sizing of dishes: the gnocchi serving was considerably smaller than my Futti di mare while the lasagna was HUGE. The pizza was smaller than I would have expected. read more

See all

Classic Italian Restaurant in Little Italy. The evening started out right with Complimentary Valet parking. The restaurant was definitely old but the food, service and overall experience was second to none. Everything was amazing. Our party of six each ordered something different and from the Lasagna to the Veal or Chicken, everything was delicious. read more

Tasty antipasto, very authentic Italian food. Perfectly breaded veal. My husbands lasagna was great, al dente pasta. Maybe a little less sauce on the lasagna itself. Other than that, great food. We would come back without hesitation. Service was good, not busy at the time we were there. Ambiance was very old timey. Definitely speaks for the story behind the restaurant itself. Definitely try it! read more

See all

Outdoor patio was beautiful and spacious. Wine -- very weak poor for $14 a glass. Go with the bottle. Food -- good deal on lasagna! Caprese could have had much fresher tomatos. Eggplant parm feels like it came from a buffet. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Eggplant Parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

Service was excellent. Patio was beautiful with enough shade on a hot day! Indoors hasn't changed in years, very old school and traditional. Got the Caprese salad. Pesto on it was excellent. Ordered the Santino style personal pizza to go. Husband said it was good. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Caprese Salad - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

I'm giving it an extra star for the super friendly waitstaff and I absolutely loved this old ambiance! It is worth visiting just for that...and the very nice patio. The worst dish was the caprese salad -- the tomatoes were orange and hard and this was in July. The lasagna was very good. Hard to beat my mom's but it was good and worth a try. Our other pasta dishes were pretty average-- sauce was a little too strong tasting.. But all in all a very nice meal. read more

I have only ever had the pleasure of coming here one time. I had reservations a couple years but had to cancel, and we tried to come on Valentine's Day but it was closed on Mondays. The one time I was here was a few summers ago and I cannot speak highly enough of the atmosphere, the food, the company, and the staff. The restaurant itself is very comfortable with lots of ambience, but the patio outback is amazing. On a beautiful day it is breezy, secluded, and the perfect romantic atmosphere. The food was amazing. We shared mussels and bruschetta and i believe a parm meal but that part i do not remember. The wait staff is well versed in their wines and their menu. I truly hope to return at some point. read more

My wife and I had a fantastic meal at this beautiful patio/restaurant, Since we're both vegetarians, we started with a caprese salad with vine ripe tomatoes, followed by truly excellent cheese ravioli and an unbelievable pasta primavera with perfectly cooked al-dente vegetables in a well-balanced yummy marinara sauce. Solid Italian wines by the glass completed the meal. A wonderful and sweet waitress, nice piano player and cordial and attentive manager made this a great night! We'll be back! read more

Went for lunch today after celebrating a Browns win last night. We were quoted 30-40 minute wait, but at most it was 10-15 minutes. The ambiance made me feel welcomed and at home. We were greeted by what I believe was the owner and got a little bit of history about the location, great touch! Service was friendly, accurate and quick. The food was perfect. Some of the best lasagna I've had and the sauce took me back to some that my grandfather used to make. We got the lasagna, chicken marsala, cheesy garlic bread and meatballs. We left full and in agreement that we would be back on our next Cleveland trip. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

Service was excellent and personable. Sta at the bar while waiting for a table and order some drinks and appetizers. The mozzarella appetizer had stretchy cheese and the bruschetta tomatoes were fresh. Then for dinner we sat in the Patiño area during the winter and it was cozy and intimate. They had space heaters as well. They food was very good. I got the lasagna and that 60 year old recipe is no joke. Overall, best experience I've had at an Italian restaurant in a while! read more

Smelled amazing like fresh garlic knots coming out the the oven the cannoli was great and they had a live music and over all the service was good and 5/5 starts I would recommend. read more

Guarino's Restaurant - Good quality cannoli and recommend after a good day. - Italian Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

We REALLY liked this place. Completely unpretentious...a good thing. Even though we were in ASTROS gear, lol, we were greeted well and the service was super friendly. Really enjoyed the Food...my son-in-law especially liked the Lasagna and the Veal Parmigiana I got was great. The pasta was nicely cooked. Honestly, it felt very home-like (my wife and I are both Italian, so we feel we have some knowledge of the cuisine). Overall, we definitely will come back when we come back to Cleveland! read more

We stopped in here for a light dinner during the Feast so we could sit and get some drinks. We sat outside on the patio. The caesar salad was awesome and a huge portion. I share the lasagna with my mom and it was really good. The flavors were great. The kids had some calamari and it was nicely fried and not chewy. Others had the fettuccine alfredo which is something I never order and it was heavy but still really good. We tried the limoncello cocktail and my mom liked it so much that she bought a bottle. The owner stopped by our table and he was very friendly. And I have to give a shoutout because one of our party realized the next day that she lost her wedding ring and she thought it was at Guarino's. She called and they were able to find it so thank you so much for that! read more

Always good food and accommodating owners. Free parking lot next store. Great area to sit out in almost any type of weather.

Back again for the lasagna today. Yum. Great server. Frank in parking lot always nice& accommodating. Loved walking afterwards to Presti's for a few treats for my morning coffee. Thank you Guarino's. read more