The sky was dark, the air was cold, and my family was hungry after driving a few hours to visit me in Chicago over the holidays. After hearing whispers of Gretel's excellence amongst my peers, I decided it was the perfect time to share an intimate, culinary experience with those whom I love. Gretel provided us with an upscale and unique twist on traditional American cuisine. Our experience consisted of plenty of smiles, laughs , and a well needed sense of satiation. As an Eastern European food connoisseur new to the Chicago area, I have carefully constructed a rating system that reflects my personal thoughts, feelings, and experience.
Food: 9/10
Six of us attended this dinner so we were able were able to test a good portion of this menu. I'm glad we had a large party because we were able to share a variety of dishes, and it was clear that each dish was well thought out by the folks at Gretel.
Ramen - The broth was savory and smooth. The additives were what you would expect of ramen, but all the ingredients came together in harmony. Just a few sips soothed the small amount of nasal congestion that I was experiencing.
Wedge and Chopped Salad - both were great, but what I would expect from each salad. These salads both came with A TON of dressing which is great for most people, but my family typically goes much lighter on the dressing. The wedge salad had a great blue cheese dressing, and it was easy to remove the excess off each wedge, making it our favorite salad. The Chopped salad also came with an excessive amount of dressing which was much harder to set aside based on the structure of the salad. Both were great, but it was probably the least favorite thing we ordered.
Burger (medium rare) - This entrée is up there with one of the best burgers in Chicago and can easily be shared upon request. I usually like my burgers done medium, but the recommended medium rare worked perfect in the flavor profile. The burger was rich and savory, but not something that would make you feel like you had to lay down and take a nap afterward. The burger came with a side of fries which tasted great but were missing the crisp that I usually enjoy. I would highly recommend ordering this.
French Dip - My parents ordered this to share, but I unfortunately was not offered a bite. In their words it was "The best French dip we have ever had".
Mac and Cheese - We ordered this side for the table to share. It looked stunning, yet small. The dish was an absolute delicacy and probably the best mac and cheese I have ever had. You only need a bite or two of this rich dish to feel completely satisfied.
Drinks 10/10
While the food was incredible, they have a beer selection that is top-notch compared to other Chicago area restaurants. The draft selection left a little smile on my face as I went down the list. I was happy to see their local selections and some pretty elite, out of state breweries such as Surly (out of Minnesota) which have perfected their craft in the beer industry.
They seemed that they had many great cocktails and an extensive offering of wines as well.
Atmosphere: 9/10
The upstairs was a high end and classy bar aesthetic, but we dined down in the basement. The basement had cool brick walls with dim lighting. The dim lighting was complimented by some rather unique lamps that they had on display. The basement had a very comforting and modern speakeasy vibe to it.
Likelihood of Return 10/10
The food was amazing and will bring us back here again. The beer selection they offer is amazing and not something commonly found in the Chicago area. They do an amazing job, and I think this will become a new date spot for my fiancé and I. read more