Love finding gluten free pastries! Converted home. Small interior but plenty adequate for the…read morepurpose. Owner is the server. Very engaging. Limited hours of operations. Peanut butter cheesecake had forward PB taste, nice texture. Hershey cupcake was a rich, dense but moist dark chocolate cake with a creamy milk chocolate frosting. Very good! Her signature dessert is a blackberry swirl cheesecake. So light and creamy, great blackberry flavor and delicious compote on top. This is a John Hancock signature dessert. Try this place!!

My wife and I went to Fernandina to celebrate our 38 year wedding anniversary. After dinner my wife…read moresaid "hey there's a bakery shop down the road we must stop at"! So glad we did! This is very nice bakery with a lot of great options to choose from. The owner is very friendly and pleasant to talk with. I ordered the Banana Fosters Cheesecake and it was very good!!!!! My wife ordered the Almond Raspberry Cake and it was also delicious! Definitely recommend Thirteen for all your bakery needs!

After seeing a TikTok video of this place, we had to come out and try the pastries. Quite…read moreenjoyable, friendly service, and clean dining area.

Simply delicious! I stopped in for a last minute birthday cake and couldn't have been happier with…read morethe cake! They keep small cakes on hand if you don't order ahead. They recommended about a week in advance for a custom cake. This one was on the smaller size but perfect for 4 people and we finished it! I went with a pink velvet flavor. It was amazing! Amaretto flavored cake with a buttercream frosting. The cake was super moist and delicious. The buttercream was the perfect compliment. Not overly sweet and didn't taste like butter. I know that sounds ridiculous but some buttercreams are so firm and taste like I'm eating a stick of butter, this was well done. I definitely still recommend leaving the cake out of the fridge for at least 20 minutes prior to serving so it's not as firm. Not to mention it's beautifully decorated and blew my family away! Can't wait to return to try some other goodies!

Great place! Eager to return and partake of Espresso Martinis. Yummy…read more Lovely setting!

We went on a very lowkey day but i've heard this place gets busy! It was very cute on the inside…read moreand staff was very nice!

Standout bakery and incredible food. So great we came two days in a row and took bakery items to…read morego. Kinda glad it's not in our neighborhood as that would be so dangerous.

Excellent food and service! We bought two loafs of sliced bread to bring home and we wish we lived…read morecloser to go their often

Solid 4 stars. Very friendly and efficient service. Kiki was engaging, friendly and helpful for us…read morefirst timers. Definitely local diners who lingered and chatted with other diners and staff. Large portions. Next time we will split an entree. Cakes looked amazing. Will definitely return and try more lunch items.

We had a great experience at Ms Carolyn's. The food was fresh made to order. The fishgush puppies,…read morecole slaw were excellent! My favorite end to this meal was the desseet! Every pie and cake that you can imagine made fresh that day because they sell out as fast as they make them! Order ahead before the locals geab them all. Our waitress was kind, informative and attentive. We willve back the next time we are visiting Fernandina/Amelia Island.

Great food and service! The wait staff are very attentive and the owner makes sure that everything…read moreis right! The ambiance is casual but has a great vibe. that's cool with interesting art and artifacts everywhere! One side that I highly recommend is the Gouda Grits which are absolutely divine! Cheers!

Wow, just wow! Looks inviting from the outside, the patio…read moreis seemingly pleasant. I ordered the seafood platter ($30) and a beer but never got a chance to eat. Before my beer was half finished my blood pressure was sky high because of the undue stress that the owner caused. The patio was 1/3 to 1/2 full. While Aubrey was my waitress- very kind, pleasant and prompt- the owner walked around the patio 90 to nothing, stomping his feet while walking, sliding chairs here and there (fast, furious and noisy) and just ran all over the place NONSTOP making quite the commotion. He asked me why I am leaving and he told me "I'm the owner, it's my job to take care of everyone"... No sir, it's your waitresses job to take care of everyone- you make this a very unpleasant environment. Sit down, trust your employees, go in the kitchen or something sir. That was ridiculous.

Authentic Spanish and Portuguese cuisine.Unfortunately my husband wasn't too hungry so we didn't…read moredo the paella I wanted. I opted to do Tapas and he ordered a salad that they added 7 shrimp to, which wasn't on the menu. My tapas was also shrimp done in a Mozambique style with coconut milk. Delicious! Also I had the cold octopus tapas which was spicy. It came with 4 spears of Belgian endive to use to scoop it up. I could have used at least 2 more because I ended up eating it straight and it was a bit spicy for me. Service was stellar and the restaurant was clean and nicely decorated. A solid choice for tapas!

Came here on Thursday evening dinner for a dinner. We made a reservation and clearly stated that we…read morewill be bringing a toddler. However when we came in hostess gave us altitude that we brought a child. Maybe she should have read a reservation better. She kept telling us that we should put a child on a reservation (which we did), but anyways, there were plenty of empty tables in the restaurant, so not sure what a big deal was. Our server was pretty decent, he explained the menu and was relatively attentive. We ordered many different appetizers and a big seafood paella. I also had non alcoholic sangria which was great. Grilled calamari were amazing, we also loved the shrimp, salad and burrata. Seafood paella was amazing as well. Ambience is more traditional with older people mostly around. They also have extensive outdoor seating area. So everything was good except the hostess.

You will not find a baker who is more caring and professional than Amanda. Her cakes are so tasty…read more This is probably my 10th cake from her. Not only are they so amazingly tasty! Thank you Amanda.

From the owner: Cottage Food Baker, not regulated by the FDA.read more