I must say this is the creamiest ice cream I've ever had and I just love all the different kind of flavors they have and come up with

Nice that they sell the "Beast Feast" chain wide even though it was inspired by Kings Island originally. Also, thank you for being super transparent with allergens at this location. It really is helpful! read more

Ice cream is okays. Nothing special was ice cream. The service is good. Sometimes doing rush hour. They need more employees there in the ambiance. It's just in the middle of the mall so it doesn't have that ice cream parlor ambiance for me. It's overpriced ice cream. If you want to bring a family you going to spend $100 and it's not really worthy read more

See all

Great ice cream and service- even better if shared with someone you adore. We this place. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

There are several ice cream flavors I like here. The peach is great, the chocolate chocolate chip is good but my all time fav is the black cherry chip. The ice cream surrounding the cherries has a good cherry flavor and it has huge chocolate chips that Graeters is known for. I go to the Gahanna location and everyone is friendly. They all say ,Welcome to Graeters . They have an outside eating area and the inside is decorated nicely., It's hard to stay away . read more

Great ice-cream, I have had several different selections as of recent, but the only critique I would give is that in this economy the pricing is a bit more than I would prefer to pay for a quick ice-cream snack on a hot day, considering the size of the selections. All in all, still a great spot read more

Nice Graeter's stand in the heart of Easton mall. They've got all the menu options of standalone locations and it's just as delicious. I enjoyed a single scoop of the classic Black Raspberry chip in a sugar cone placed in a cup. Pleasant, prompt service to top it off. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - a hand holding a cup of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I was walking towards the place close to closing, which I didn't realize. I get there and the lady says they are closing and I couldn't order. I asked for other ice cream in the area and she said there wasn't any. Well she lied and it was poor customer service. Other places are around I found out. Try Jeni's it's great. Also, the Shake Shack is very close. read more

The mint cookies and cream was amazing! But did the scoop sizes become smaller?! It's been a while since I've been to a Graeter's so comparing to previous experiences. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Mint Cookies and Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Very good ice cream, tons of flavors to choose from!! The staff there was super friendly and they are very accommodating for peanut allergies. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Coffee Single Scoop Sugar Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Finally after years of wanting to try this place, I finally did! I really enjoyed it. While I should have tried the Black Raspberry Chip, I instead went for the Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough and Buckeye Blitz, both of which were great, premium ice creams. The ice cream texture was perfect and wasn't overly sweet. I loved the chocolate chip process of pouring it into the mixer so that you can get huge chunks of chocolate in some bites. If you're looking for old-fashioned ice cream, Graeter's is great! read more

Get the Dark Chocolate Truffle Gelato. It's soooo good. A small is really all you need since it's so rich. This location is a stand inside the main building at Easton. They let you sample the flavors before you choose. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Dark Chocolate Truffle Gelato - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

If you've had dinner somewhere at Easton and want to get a dessert, this is one of your best options. You're always offered the choice of cone (several different kinds) or cup when your ice cream is dished up. Some of my favorite flavors include toffee chip and chocolate chocolate chip. The chips are more chunky than chippy. read more

OMG....After living in Columbus for over 10 years, it is still my most haunting memory. I long for Graeter's Ice Cream, but unlike Oprah, I can't afford to have it shipped on dry ice. The seaonal flavors are freaking amazing. February is my Strawberry Chunk and October is the delicious Chocolate Almond. Never, never, never do I get near Columbus without visiting Graeter's. read more

Always love Graeters. Now that I can get pints at home in LA, I don't miss it as much. But nothing beats a freshly scooped double in a waffle cone and sitting outside on a bench with your best friend people watching. read more

The new design is really on point. I had the hazelnut truffle Gelato which was amazing, not too sweet and it had chocolate chunks in it. Also got a scoop of cookies and cream, can't go wrong with this choice! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Hazelnut truffle Gelato and cookies n cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Ice cream flavor on point but can't make a milk shake at all. Just paid $6.50 for a large cinnamon maple milk. Also, every single employee seemed as if they didn't want to be there. Took roughly five minutes for us at the counter before someone acknowledged us despite roughly six employees behind the counter. read more

All of the workers were professional and friendly. There was a manager there not only overseeing the employees but helping them ring up customers and informing us of the new app that's coming out. The price was good for a three large scoop platter. I got all sorbets and I was so happy to see they had a few delicious non dairy options . read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Watermelon, mango and raspberry sorbet - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I came to Easton Town Center while driving through. The service was pretty good here! I had a single scoop of mint chocolate. It was heavenly after driving for 4 hours. Although it was pricey, it was worth every penny. The chocolate pieces in the ice cream complemented the mint really well. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream has been in existence since 1870. I discovered it in 2006. I am so sorry for my delay. You can only find this stuff in Ohio and Kentucky, which is a good reason to visit Ohio and Kentucky. They use something called "the french pot process", which means nothing to me. Except totally awesome ice cream. They are famous for their flavors and black raspberry chip is legendary. Try it and I promise that you will fall in love..... read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I'm not normally a huge ice cream fan but Graeters serves some exceptional treats! Have been here 3 times and always get the coconut chocolate chip waffle cone. Last night I went for the 2 scooper- my favorite coconut chocolate chip plus the chocolate almond coconut chocolate chip. Granted 2 scoops was a bit much, but other than feeling stuffed, each creamy, sweet but not too sweet bite was delicious. Plenty of coconut, almonds and large chunks of chocolate. Very friendly "scoopers" And a great way to end Valentines date night! read more

See all

Yum!! Everyone was raving over this ice cream and they always seem to have a line waiting so I decided to give it a try. They have several selections of cones, including pretzel cones. They also have several ice cream flavors. I decided to go with the Coconut Chocolate flavor with the chocolate dipped pretzel cone. Yummy Yum! The ice cream had large chunks of chocolate and was nice and creamy. A must try! read more

YUMMMMM!!!!! What more does a review for an ice cream place need to say??? OK... here's some more... The best Mint Chocolate Chip ever.... and the chips are CHUNKS, not just little chips.... YUMMM. The best Black Raspberry Chip ever.... and the chips are CHUNKS, not just litle chips.... YUMMM. The best Buckeye ice cream ever.... Are you noting a trend here..... Like I said.... YUMMMMM!!!!! What more does a review for an ice cream place need to say??? read more

This is based on my last experience at Graeter's in Easton Town Center. I have had Graeter's before and remember it being better. I had the most famous flavor this time--the black raspberry chip. I didn't really care for the flavor that much. In the past, I've had more traditional flavors like chocolate and vanilla and enjoyed it much more. Still, I didn't really care for the texture. It was a little like taffy and not smooth, light, and creamy. The texture kind of reminded me of the Thrifty ice cream from Rite-Aid (which people rave about). So, maybe it is just a matter of preferences. read more

Amazing service, even better icecream! I am a Vermonter, but I liked this icecream way better then Ben and jerrys... I can't believe it! Seriously, worth your time to stop by and grab some of your visiting Ohio. Also, for the locals, they have a rewards card! read more

Amazing ice cream! Usually has giant chunks of chocolate in it-which is fantastic! My favorite is the double chocolate chip ice cream on a waffle cone! Their flavors are rich and delicious! This is probably one of my favorite places to get ice cream!! It always tastes amazing! read more

They have the BEST mint chocolate chip ever! I'm a fan of the flavor but don't usually eat it that often. When I do, I'm used to places or store bought brands where the chocolate comes as either chocolate shavings/pieces or as actual chocolate chips like in cookies. But the chocolate here comes as chocolate chunks! They are huge bits of chocolate! and not just any chocolate- really delicious, soft chocolate! They also have a frequency card where you get points for every dollar you spend and after a certain number of points you can choose something from a list. read more

I really, really love ice cream; ask anyone that knows me, I love ice cream so much, I can eat it for breakfast! On one, hot summer day couple of weeks ago, I stopped by Graeter's inside Easton Town Center and after some much given thought, I went for one of their signature flaors: Black Raspberry Chip. I got a waffle cone with just one scoop of this magnificence. Ice cream was very rich and creamy and had a strong raspberry flavor with silky dark chocolate chip bits nestled all over. Each bite was super rich, by the time I was almost done with it, it was almost overwhelming. I'm glad I only got one scoop, I had to hold myself back. It's summer and it's hot, perfect weather for ice cream so why do I need to hold back, right? Maybe because I'm lactose Intolerant... *sigh*... but who cares? You eat some, you lose some, right? =__= (k, that was kinda gross... sorry, guys)... *clearing throat*.... anyways, Graeter's Ice Cream is wonderful; it's super rich and creamy and the waffle cone I had was fresh. I might go back and try a different flavor once I work up the bravery to face the consequences once again.... Even though for the price my one scoop of Black Raspberry Chip on a waffle cone may have bought me a half gallon tub of ice cream at your local grocery store, I think everyone should at least try one time ^___^ All this talk about ice cream has me craving for some more! If you'll excuse me, I'm going to scurry over to my freezer and get me some "fake ice cream" - for those of you wondering what they are, it's just "flavored" ice T^T;;;; read more

If I had only know to try their black raspberry chip ice cream I would have! Next time definitely. I had a single scoop of mint chocolate chip on a sugar cone. I have to comment that this is one of the few times i've had mint choc chip that was white and not green colored hah! It was a big scoop of ice cream, large enough that they had to give me a cup to keep the ice cream from overflowing onto my hand. I tried their chocolate coconut almond and fell in love with as well. This location was found inside the Easton Town Centre and there seemed to be a continuous small line forming. Who can resist ice cream :) read more

I had gotten greaters on a previous trip to Columbus and had been impressed. When I saw them at Easton town center I was excited and went over to see what flavors they currently have. The employees were all very nice and immediately said to let them know if I want to sample anything. I asked to sample buckeye, peanut butter chocolate chip and Elenas blueberry pie. I was blown away by how delicious all three flavors were and by how generous the size of the samples were. I hate nothing more than when I get an ice cream sample and it's so microscopic I can't taste the flavor. They also had no attitude about asking for multiple samples. I debated between one scoop and two scoops. Of course I wanted two scoops but I'm always on a diet and have to be careful. It was so delicious I said screw my diet and I ordered a medium for $1 more. The scoops were pretty generous. I got one scoop of buckeye and one scoop of blueberry pie. I enjoyed them both but the blueberry pie was very unique and the flavor stood out more. The graham crust was to die for. I recommend blueberry pie flavor to anyone, just make sure you don't look at the calories and fat or you'll be as horrified as I was. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Medium. Blueberry pie. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We like Graeter's but this locations customer service is ridiculously bad. Staffed by teenagers who could care less, when you ask them for something explicitly simple, they look at you with apathetic eyes and then do the complete opposite. Eat Graeter's, just someplace else. read more

Unbeatable classic ice cream. No insane flavors - what keeps bringing you back is how they make the stuff. The French Pot method results in two things that really make this ice cream stand out from all others - the "mouth feel" of the product, which because it has a low air content means that it is incredibly rich and creamy, and the chocolate chips, which are formed by pouring melted chocolate into the French pot while it is spinning, then creating the chunks by breaking up the now-frozen chocolate with a paddle. You can end up with massive chunks of chocolate in your ice cream! read more

Yay! This is fabulousness! Had the Mint Chocolate Chip waffle cone. Pleasant find while on a conference. Life is beautiful! Definitely recommend stopping by if you're in the area. read more

Can't provide a glass water when ordering other items? Shame on you! Seriously, Jeni's is around the corner. Better service (terrible, terrible,terrible) and quality elsewhere. Definitely avoid. read more

Great options and prices. Love going and trying something different! Best Ice Cream EVER!

Ordered an 1870 tower and it looked/tasted like trash and the cherry fell onto to the workers hand and he tried to put it back in my cup. Ice cream melted before I could even eat it, sticking with Westerville location. Workers were all sitting around on crates and on phones read more

This is an Ohio institution. When I tell people I have to travel to Ohio for work, they ask me to bring this stuff back. (Sadly, it doesn't survive plane travel very well.) The Buckeye ice cream is a great local treat. Portions are fairly large and the ice cream is quite rich, so go with a small size. read more