As an avid record collector, I make this Goodwill one of my stops whenever I'm visiting a client in the Webster Area. For those who aren't into vinyl, suffice it to say that the various thrift stores in the Monroe County area differ widely in the way that they price records. VOA & AmVets routinely price records @ 99 cents each. In the Webster Goodwill, prices are usually $1.99 per record, with a few 99 cent slabs peppered in the mix. Oddly enough, the prices for records at the various Goodwills range from 99 cents each in Macedon to $2.99 each in Henrietta & Victor. Which puts this Goodwill (and the one off Bay Road) smack dab in the middle. Now, as a collector, I *will* pay $2.99 for a mint record that I want. And so will any self-respecting buyer. The problem is that there are quite a few platters that won't move at that price... e.g. Jim Nabors, Roger Williams, Ed Ames, Herb Alpert, Dan Fogelberg and various junk records from the 60's and 70's. However, keep digging... for if you do you'll find some gem buried between Firestone Christmas albums and have something to brag about for years to come! read more

Goodwill - Webster - Thrift Stores Near Me - Webster, New York

See all

I store always smells like old clothes I had family work there and thry hated it No one that works there can give me good advise The only nice thing about it is the outside of the store Im done but that is it read more

Amazing customer service! The manager, (I think his name was Prince), was extra accommodating about holding our purchase, I truly can't thank him and his crew enough for saving, and loading this chair for us, IT BROUGHT US SO MUCH JOY. read more

Goodwill - Webster - Chair - Thrift Stores Near Me - Webster, New York

This place is not decent. The managers and most workers are just mean and not considerate. Prices are really high for items in horrible condition. :( read more

Best Eastside location! Set way back in a plaza (can't be seen from the busy road/sign easy to miss). Consistently better quality than other locations. Always clean, organized and staff is friendly vs the disgruntled court mandated "participants" at most local Goodwill's. Picked up a few toys for a dollar each that would go for 5x the amount at Saver's (practically across the street of you're on a thrifting bender) and triple at other GW locations. read more

Goodwill of the Finger Lakes ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ ⁩ Add a photo Goodwill of the Finger Lakes 4.2 (265) Thrift store in Monroe County, New YorkOpen OVERVIEW REVIEWS PHOTOS BY OWNER ABOUT Google review summary 5 4 3 2 1 4.2 (265) Reviews All donations13 color9 clothes8 price tag5 +6 Sort by Most relevant Newest Highest Lowest Prudence Billings 8 reviews 19 hours ago NEW We live out of state and come here to visit our son 3 or 4 times a year. We love to go to the thrift stores as well. But I will NEVER set foot in the Webster store again!! Two trips in a row I was not allowed to purchase an item because ... More Kathy and Paul Sleight Local Guide·87 reviews·91 photos 3 months ago Always find good stuff here. I donate alot as well. Great drive through to dump things off. The employees are always nice. Inside they could improve the stale scent in the store...use some fabreeze "air" spray. Good place to thrift shop tho. Deez Nuts 1 review 3 months ago The respect here it's absolutely horrible the manger practically locked me in the store was very rude and falsely accused me of stealing she would not let me put the store and she had the worst attitude I've ever seen. Very disappointed with this place will not be coming back EVER 2 Danorah Cox 2 reviews·1 photo 7 months ago I purchased a love seat, thinking I could get it home. When I realized it wouldn't fit I tried to return it but they refused, even though it had never left the building. Apparently they offer no returns for anything. Maybe that's the norm ... More 3 Prudence Billings 8 reviews 19 hours ago NEW We live out of state and come here to visit our son 3 or 4 times a year. We love to go to the thrift stores as well. But I will NEVER set foot in the Webster store again!! Two trips in a row I was not allowed to purchase an item because it HAD NOT BEEN PRICED!! Is that the customer's fault?? The same rude woman, claiming to be the manager, said there was nothing she could do. Then what good is she? There should always be someone available to correct such matters for the customer immediately. Obviously, I was not going to be there in 24 hours when the items were supposed to be priced. Poorest Customer's Service I've seen anywhere!! Don't waste your time. You'll just be disappointed , and treated rudely by the ineffectual "Manager!" NEVER AGAIN!! read more

Manager was a jerk! They would give me a dvd because it didn't have a price tag on it when all the dvds are the same price. The manager was very rude and dismissive . Horrible customer service! read more

USED to be a great thrift store. But since opening, they've not only done away with weekly 50% discounts, they've also started sorting pants / shorts / skirts by "small/medium/large" instead of actual sizes. I'm just waiting for them to follow the lead of other thrift stores and sort everything by color. Not sure what on earth possessed them to take two massive steps backwards, but this has gone from a good thrift store to one with few bargains and a poorly organized selection. read more

Amazing store! -CLEAN -AFFORDABLE -MANAGED VERY WELL -EMPLOYEES: The employees are knowledgeable about the items on the sales floor,& when the back room door is open you can hear the employees having a wonderful time ENJOYING THEIR WORK EVERY DAY TO SERVE THE COMMUNITY AND RECYCLE, HELPING OUR EARTH! **Unlike many thrift stores in the Rochester area, There are no pills, rips, or stains on any clothing on the sales floor. They are the best in making sure **only the best items go out onto the sales floor. ** They also have a GREAT SELECTION of AFFORDABLE: -furniture -books - records -accessories -clothing for infants,children,women, and men -goods for your kitchen, den, bathroom, and any other room in your home that needs sprucing up. *-------GOODWILL GIVES BACK 100% TO THE ASSOCIATION FOR THE BLIND AND THE ROCHESTER COMMUNITY AS A WHOLE, unlike another thrift store that has come into this area recently. ---------* GOODWILL RECYCLES EVERYTHING!!! : -All items are RECYCLED if they cannot be sold. This includes housewares as well as clothing items. -They even Recycle the cardboard boxes and plastic bags that donations arrive in!! -Come here to * Properly Dispose of American Flags *, as they have a special program for that. -Come here to properly recycle chemicals you don't know what else to do with. -Come here to recycle ANY Electronics that aren't working including but not limited to old typewriters, computers, cellphones, house phones, old appliances, power tools, etc. NO OTHER THRIFT STORE OFFERS THIS AMOUNT OF RECYCLING. OTHER THRIFT STORES SAY THEY RECYCLE BUT END UP TOSSING ABOUT 80% of what cannot sell or does not sell. All electronics are tossed if not working and all plastic donation bags and cardboard boxes find their way to the dumpster in these other thrift stores. BOTTOM LINE: DONATE & SHOP at GOODWILL STORES to -help your community -get everything recycled properly -shop in a store that has quality items at a great price -purchase gently used items to give them a new life with you! read more

I've shopped this location a few times before. I usually come in looking for random household items and I peruse the women's clothing. I haven't bought anything here in a while, but this week I made a donation at this location. It was quick and easy with their drive up donation door! read more

It takes a bit time to drive up here but I'm glad that I have finally come to check it out. Compared to Henrietta and South Wedge, they seem to have a nicer selection of clothing: more up-to-date styles and brands and more in size small. I got a black-and-white-patterned maxi dress. read more

I never normally have a bad experience at goodwill. However, when I went to go purchase a used tv the other day I asked an employee about their return policy Incase it didn't work. I was told that as long as I returned it within 7 days with all of the tags attached, I would get a refund. So when I went to return, due to the fact that it just wasn't what I had thought, I was told that I would only receive store credit back. Never once in the 5 minutes of me talking to the employee did the point come up that all purchases are refunded with store credit. So now I have $70 lost. If the employee had explained the return policy correctly then I wouldn't have had any issues. But, here we are -$70 later so for future sales on big purchases, I recommend explaining that to the customer before they purchase the item. read more

Def a couple good finds here. A steelers Troy Polamalu jersey 5 bucks. Glad to be a steelers fan. Some great records on hand as well. 3 for 5. read more

Ladies, go through the racks of clothes. A lot of my purchases are banana republic, Calvin Klein, express, ny&co, Ann Taylor, j.crew. For a fraction price of new but like new. So worth it build up your wardrobe. Plus the housewares that you can find. You gotta try it! read more

So to me Goodwill has always represented THRIFT meaning cheap and since its a "Not for profit" they should be pricing DONATED goods as such, instead they are thieves. I Like to search for old video games there and since everything is donated they should be pricing them fairly. YOU are not a video game store, they got a large donation of Wii games some of are more desired instead of giving you a deal they are locked up in a case charging pretty much what video game stores charge used. GIVE ME A BREAK! You can keep them for those prices. The only time the deals are actually a deal is when they have the 50% off a certain color price sticker week then its worth buying otherwise prepare to pay full price. I was told the money goes to support their call center. Wow why do I care about that? Give me a deal since you got the stuff for free. I buy Wii and other games all day long at garage sales for $1-$2 at most. read more