1. Goodwill Store

0

St. John, IN

Cancel

Open app

Search

Goodwill Store

2.1 (15 reviews)
InexpensiveThrift Stores

Goodwill Store Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Goodwill Store

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

If I could give zero stars I would. I am not a fan of goodwill anyway. They are way overpriced for donated items and a lot of their stuff is broke, stained, worn out, etc. I went in there looking for dress shoes for my daughters. I found 2 pairs. Brought them home and they didn't fit. Went to return them and they said they can't return shoes. Says right on the receipt, they DO NOT accept returns on furniture or electrical. Nothing in regards to shoes. I asked, where is this posted? They said on their sign. Well, I guess I've should have read the sign....SMH. It should be on the receipt like the other non-returnable items. I guess I'm just wondering why they won't return shoes? I guess I should have asked. They will take back clothing, hats, coats, toys, glassware, etc...but not shoes.

Goodwill. St John, IN
Scott M.

Expensive, unorganized, and out of touch. Used Walmart and target shirts for $6.99. You can beat that on the clearance rack at Walmart and Target. I am a huge thrift store shopper this is definitely the worst one I've been to. There is literally no brand recognition. Also very dirty, but I'm OK with that in the thrift store.

See all

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Scott M.
393
26
24

11 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 4
Oh no 1

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Abi G.
57
46
2

7 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Kelly B.
201
132
739

13 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Risa C.
38
43
5

12 years ago

Prices too high, expensive brand new items donated by Target can be found cheaper across the parking lot at Target.

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Goodwill Store

You might also consider

Last Chance Overstock - This is from their Facebook page, which is a great resource to see their new products that comes in weekly.

Last Chance Overstock

3.7(35 reviews)
4.6 mi
•$$

What an unusual store! Random isn't the word for the assortment of merchandise: some furniture,…read moresome clothing, lots of men's shoes, few women's shoes, area rugs, toilet paper, some decor, a larger appliance section, a few toys and games, small appliances, single cans of soda, sparkling water, Monster, even some pet items. And dozens of suitcases of all colors! If you need luggage you will love the variety here. I'm working in the area this week and happened to see this store which is near my hotel. The furniture is very nice and extremely reasonably priced. I found a couple of couches that I would have considered purchasing IF I wasn't 3 hours from home and IF I was driving a truck. There were men's Land's End shoes for $5 a pair. A great deal! In fact everything I saw was a very good deal. I've never seen a store like this before. A fun place to shop! If I lived nearer I would stop in frequently! We definitely don't have a store like this in Carmel where I live. I'll add that everything was well organized and prices were clearly marked. This store is very clean and tidy. I'll definitely stop in whenever I am working in this area.

What is this place?! It's filled with a random assortment of everything you can think of, but at a…read morediscount. Everything from name-brand clothing and shoes to patio furniture and bedroom furniture, individual rolls of toilet paper, laundry baskets, washing machines, luggage, margarita mix, mirrors, giant cans of tuna, dog beds, tiki torches and lots more. Last Chance Overstock sells the things that didn't sell at other stores. It's the Island of Misfit Merchandise, if you will. (Will you?) My children had a fun time sitting in all of the chairs and couches around the store. A big portion of the store is dedicated to furniture, and the store-people are 100% OK with you and your children sitting on every couch and lying on every bed. My kids wanted to find the most comfortable couch, and they chose the one with plush corduroy that had cup holders and a USB plug. They wanted to buy it, but we live many miles away, and also, there is no way I'm inviting a couch with cupholders and a USB plug into my home. Get bent, kids. You need to look at the products carefully, because some of the things are a little worse for the wear. But for the most part, most of the items I saw at Last Chance looked perfectly fine. I wouldn't come here to find something specific, because inventory changes frequently, but this is a good place to browse and find a treasure.

Photos
Last Chance Overstock
Last Chance Overstock
Last Chance Overstock

See all

A Resale Shop

A Resale Shop

2.3(4 reviews)
3.9 mi

It's not bad, it's not good. This store is clean and well organized, prices are clearly marked on…read moresigns and boards, larger items such as furniture are marked individually. For the younger thrifters, the clothing available will most likely not appeal to you, unless you're into reconstruction and are merely shopping for fabric/print. The children's clothes are plentiful, most are dated, all are clean. I never buy second hand shoes, so I cannot opine on that. They sell BETA tapes, a few CDs, some vinyl that nobody would want. There is a good selection of books, I got a hard cover Harry Potter with no dust jacket for a buck. Beware when buying clothing, they sell "boutique" items which are priced differently and not marked all that clearly. This store benefits Highland Christian School,it is cliquey (I know, right?? See below.) and Christian music is piped in through the loudspeakers. Cliquey, while checking out, the owner/manager was picking through my purchases telling the woman behind me who donated this, and "oh, little Madison wore this to her birthday party." It was a bit creepy.

Be careful. If you want a display item and they tell you they can't sell it until the following…read moreMonday. I wanted to purchase a display item on a Tuesday and they told me they could not sell it until the following Monday at 10:00 AM. I said I really wanted it, it was a 1-of-a-kind item I had been looking for for years. Still NO. So being a Christian store I trusted that they would not sell it if that is their policy. I waited outside the door Monday before 10:00 AM and it wasn't in the store. The same lady who told me I could not buy it checked in the back and said someone had "accidentally" sold it before they were supposed to. Very bad business. I was waiting almost a whole week and took the morning off from work to be there at 10:00 AM Monday.

Chicago Estate Advisors - Chicago Estate Advisors 2021 West Division Chicago, IL 60622

Chicago Estate Advisors

3.7(41 reviews)
34.0 mi•West Town, Ukrainian Village
Women-owned & operated
Offers customized solutions

My experience with Chicago Estate Advisors Was more than I…read moreanticipated. They are very helpful and made my whole experience so smooth every went well and if you are looking for a Company that knows what they are doing, Call Chicago Estate Advisors. You will not regret it. Very professional, kind and knowledgeable.

Absolutely HORRIBLE experience. I went to their storefront a couple years ago and everything was…read moreextremely expensive but this past weekend I went to an estate sale. On Friday I asked about some items and just for a pottery bowl they wanted $65. I asked about some artwork it was $500 for 2. That same artwork did not sell over the entire weekend. I saw one worker being a bit rude to another worker which isn't ok in front of people but I assumed it was stress. Then they posted a video in a beautiful MCM living room saying "the house is jam packed" and "bring a semi." I went a bit early since it was confusing "11-1" for the sale but "9-1" online. I saw people asked questions but no comments back until right before the time. They were giving 9-11am the last chance for people to buy "lower than retail" probably since so much was so expensive for an estate sale and even after 3 days they still didn't want to even try going down. They tried to sell a Frank Lloyd wright PRINT (not an original at allll) for $300. They tried to sell a woman a nightgown dress from like JC Penny for $30!!! But thankfully they said they could for $25 just for today (before the $25 deal at 11). After MULTIPLE people expressed their frustration and anger with the misleading marketing they created a generic response in person AND online, I decided to express my disappointment and let others know there wasn't actually anything they advertised. I was highly respectful regarding providing feedback and how to provide better customer experience so people can avoid driving 2-3 hours for some binders and scraps (which yes some people can score but none of what was left was worth a 2 hour drive since you could find it closer to your home probably). When I commented, I noticed someone else was mentioning they are deleting comments regarding feedback. I since then started to screenshot my comments to ensure I had proof of what they were and weren't saying. I mentioned how they were moving furniture out and they commented back they were deliveries from "the couple that purchased them" but I was talking about artwork that I was eyeing on the first day but it barely went down in price.... And they were taking it to their store front which they said out loud too! So it's not like they sold everything. Then I quickly found out from someone else that they blocked me. I didn't get photos of all my comments but needless to say I won't be supporting them. They only care about numbers and marketing even if it's at the expense of customers. Is that a company you really was to support when there are other people that yes they need to make a living but haven't lost their humanity for people? Unless you are willing to overpay a company that is has a lot of false advertising then I wouldn't support them. Hopefully they won't remove this comment. It's sad to see them doubling down and instead of correcting themselves or expressing that their sorry.... they delete and continue to do what their doing.

Photos
Chicago Estate Advisors - Staging is our specialty!

Staging is our specialty!

Chicago Estate Advisors - Modern and antiques beautifully blended.

Modern and antiques beautifully blended.

Chicago Estate Advisors - Estate sales for hoarding situation's.

See all

Estate sales for hoarding situation's.

Goodwill Store - thrift_stores - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...