Ordered online said it would be 25 minutes. Arrived after 25 minutes. Sat there another 25 minutes waiting for my order to be ready. 50 minutes for a Togo order when I could have had it delivered in a hour. Then on my way home down the freeway checking my order I notice I was missing my seasoned sour cream for my appetizer waffle fries I ordered for 10 bucks that looked like there was about 15 fries in that order ( so not worth the 10 bucks) especially without season sour cream. I wasn't going to turn back and get my seasoned sour cream since the next exit is 4 miles down the road! I called the restaurant and and all I got was we cant guarantee how long your online order will take. I was more mad about me paying for my seasoned sour cream and didnt get it...needless to say, I did say a few words and hung up on the dude, next time...do better. Otherwise food id usually pretty good here. read more

Let me start with this - we were very happily greeted by a girl with a great smile. Our waitress was great. My Son ordered the chicken fingers ( he wasn't very hungry - he's a man) and said he was really disappointed. Said he has never had anything bad here until tonight. I ordered a build your own pizza. They forgot a couple of items but the waitress realized it and said "I have him making a new one, why not just start with this so you have something" Loved that. Here is my only note: The pizza although tasty had a crust that needed to be cooked longer. I had everyone try a piece and they all agreed. It's not that it wasn't cooked, just not long enough. I will say I loved the amount of cheese it had on it. I only gave it 3 stars because I personally wouldn't go back. Again wait staff was good. read more

The hand tossed pickle pizza was really good, the thin crust sausage and pepperoni not as much so, the chicken strips were tender and tasty, but I definitely would not recommend the French fries. The ambiance was very busy for dinner in a Friday night (kinda dive bar atmosphere). The service was just ok. I may go back to get that pickle pizza again but I think I would get it to go. read more

A hidden gem. This is the 2nd time we've gone. We live in Lakeville and always forget this place exists. When we stay at the Holiday Inn we venture here. It's SOOO yummy. Our server Zach was upbeat, friendly and attentive. We ordered waffle fries (yummy perfect crunch to it) and a 14in traditional crust pizza. We didn't want it to end. My only "complaint" is you pay .99c for a side of seasoned sour cream and you get get the smallest little cup. Could've definitely had more. We will be back! read more

Soooo disappointed tonight. Really almost embarrassed, as we picked up pizza to have with friends who had never had their pizza. We have been here many times in the last 6 years and have absolutely loved the pizza but the last 6 months the quality has gone way down. Ordered 2 pizzas and one had the crust hardly even cooked. This time and twice before we had requested the pizza be cut in squares and both times they ignored our request even though this time I reinerated how important this was and was promised they would do it. We paid over $50 and will never go back again. read more

The pizza, Hamburger and the Gyros salad is delicious. The service is also great, very friendly and welcoming. read more

The prices are on the high end but I can't stop thinking about the jalapeño popper pizza. It was phenomenal! The environment inside is half bar/half diner-ish. Pretty loud inside: Staff is super friendly and helpful. They make you feel like family. Parking lot is free. My boys loved their chicken wings and pepperoni pizza. We will be back! read more

See all

Food is 100 every time. Mac n cheese pizza is the best one yet! Good prices. Would recommend.

We order from Goodfellas frequently, calling in our order is a positive experience as everyone is always very friendly and helpful. The delivery is quick, accurate and the food is delicious! read more

In the area for a wedding. Came here for breakfast and was not disappointed. Waitress was super friendly and very attentive. The food was good and the Bloody Mary, too. We would definitely come back when in the area again. read more

Goodfellas - Veggie omelette - American Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

Service was horrible. Employee who was out smoking a cigarette yelled out "we are closed" at 10 when hours say open till 12. While we can see multiple people sitting at the bar. When asked what the hours are and when they close she states "whenever we want". We aren't from the area but wouldn't recommend to anyone and won't be giving it another shot. read more

forgot my pop. pizza tasted horrible nothing good about it dough was not cooked all the way

Great food! Large menu. Pizza is delish. Service is good. Ambiance is as expected for a local bar. It's busy and loud in the bar. The dining area is quieter and family friends. read more

Best Pizza in town!! Great service and bartenders. Cold Busch Latte on tap. Plenty of pull-tabs to pull as well.

I was really craving some pizza, and this hit the spot. I love the different unique pizza combinations. We ordered half gyro and half tator tot hot-dish on hand tossed crust. Tastes just like what it is supposed to be. It was $19.99 for a 14 inch pizza. It was worth the price and yummy. My husband and I both loved the gyro pizza. Our server was friendly and fast. They were out of the reuben bites, and most of the other apps sounded like something you could get any where else. I want to come back some other time to try their breakfast or fish fry because they both looked good. The menu offers pastas, burgers, sandwiches, and lots of other options. They have some good looking bloody mary's and a big bar area. read more

Goodfellas - Half tator tot hot-dish and half gyro hand tossed pizza - American Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

Hot Beef Commercial was one of the best ever! 50 years and the twist is it is on toast. That is a game changer. read more

Goodfellas - Hot Beef Commercial - American Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

Greatneighborhood bar vibe I'm from out of town people were very nice and inviting. Bar food was good and drinks were cold.

I've given them 3 tries. Pizza, pasta, appetizers. Horrible. Sausage pepperoni pizza. Horrible flavor and dry Fettucini Alfredo. Again, dry and horrible flaver. This, the owner boasted about. Potato skins. Very little cheese and bacon. Didn't matter, though. They were Rock hard. They would break my garbage disposal, no joke. Disappointing. They are so close to me. read more

Nice local place. Excellent Pretzels and Cheese !!! I usually don't like cheese sauce that comes with pretzels but this is good !! I've enjoyed a couple more visits; I tried the pizza, pretty good, I am very picky about my pizza sauce, I don't like it strong or too acidic....an Italian lady told me to mix a couple pinches of sugar in the sauce to remove the "burn." Most people wouldn't notice but It do. This was a little strong. Everything else was great. Don't get me wrong, it's good. But I'm very pizza sauce picky. I ordered Cobb salad last night...Over the Top !! Huge salad. Lots of quality meats, cheeses and boiled eggs. Very good but huge. 2 person salad. I really like this place. read more

The pizza is so so bad. Dry cardboard texture. Not much flavor. Couldn't even eat it. The sandwiches aren't too bad and the wings were pretty good. read more

I had to give them a 2 only because whenever we go there we have OK service. The wait staff is always really pleasant, but I always feel they are understaffed . Normally the pizza is great. Not overly greasy and an abundance of flavors to suit any one persons needs. Tonight the think crust was burnt and took well over an hour to get to us. The restaurant itself is well kept. Dark feeling, but fits the needs. Beer list is ok. Serves Pepsi Products. Overall just OK. Could easily be a 5 star with alittle bit of effort read more

Food is greasy, staff is not very friendly or helpful. This spot is local and convenient yet, not good products or staff.

Great food, great bar, best bartenders in town! Try the Goodfellas pasta, all great food,flatbreads and pizza!

They have added breakfast on Sunday from 9am to 2, it been very busy, food is very good. I recommend the French Connection with baby reds, best bacon around! read more

Goodfellas - The French Connection from breakfast menu on Sundays 9am to 2pm - American Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

good pizza and food and used to be my favorite spot but been away as I get older. I went there tonight and the new regulars think they own the joint making it a poor environment. Got scammed tonight to leave because we must have been too close to the regulars? Unfortunately, seems to have gone downhill from the the good times I remember. will not be back. makes me sad because this was MY place. but fortunately, there are many other places that are just as good or better. read more

My wife and I drove down to Lakeville to meet up with some friends. Goodfellas is off 35W in a small strip mall. We entered and it is a 6 tap bar/pizza place, but we took a left and entered the more dining area. I turned on the lights. The menu is pretty extensive. Lots of sandwiches, pizzas, salads, etc. I ordered the 10" pizza with light cheese, chicken, jalapeno, and tater tots. The crust came out nice and crispy with a solid melt on the cheese. Very tasty. I really enjoyed the sliced up tater tots. They seemed twice the girth of a regular tater tot and wonderfully crispy. Good stuff. The sauce was full tomato on. My friend's kid got the corn dog bites with fries. I had a fry, nothing special at all, but the corn dog bites were yummy. I know both were probably frozen, but the corn dog bites were fantastic. I had a Summit EPA and an a rare Anchor Steam Beer, nice touch on the Anchor. My wife got a no cheese pizza with basil and carrots. The sauce really came out. I think it may be real homemade. Not bad for a small pizza joint off the highway. read more

Stopped in for a quick bite to eat after a stressful day at work. Someone cranked the music so loud on a Monday evening at 7:30pm my husband and I couldn't even hear eachother. We asked the bartender if she could turn it down and she said she couldn't because the owner was the one that turned it up... ‍. Bottom line, 2 stars because the pizza was amazing, but the atmosphere wasn't enticing for a Monday evening. We had to box our pizza and leave. Not a very good representation for an owner of a small business with great employees and great potential. Not good when your bartenders/servers suffer because of this. read more

Goodfellas is a-ok. I'm not a fan of the chicken they use or the burgers, but the pizza is good. Not worth driving out of your way for, but worth it if you're in the area. There's usually a drink or app special every day. Service can be hit or miss. Great place to watch sports. At time of this review, they offer trivia on Tuesday nights. I'm not a huge fan of meat on my pizza. But the following are my favorites at Goodfellas: Momma's special Karen's veggie Gyro Fajita - beef only Cajun Pot roast read more

Goodfellas - Half pot roast pizza and half tater tot pizza. - American Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

See all

Try it they have some great twists on a classic pizza.... Pot Roast any one? I would say the staff makes this place but it is also great take out. Come and see this could become your go to pizza joint but they have a lot more than just pizza! read more

Service was slow. My group ordered a personal pizza and two sandwiches to go. It took over 50 minutes to get our food. We were told the kitchen was "slammed", but the establishment was clearly not that busy. read more

Waited over twenty minutes to place an order and another twenty for food. Would not recommend if you are in any kind of hurry. The bar seems to take precedence over everything else. read more

We used to like this place. They can't seem to get it together. A simple order or three burgers, no substitutions. Called it in, told 25 min. With groceries and children melting down in the backseat, 55 minutes later, still sitting in their parking lot waiting for them to get it right. Brought 2 burgers to the car. Took them back inside to get cold. 15 min later the third showed up. Annoying. Really wanted to support this place. read more

I frequent here on a regular basis and it isn't because I love the closest! I used to work across the street so it was convenient for me but found that that isn't the only reason I enjoy coming here! The pizza is amazing and they have so many specialty pizzas it really shows creativity, like they have a tatertot hotdish pizza, a pot roast pizza and a gyro pizza! The crust is my favorite. I also love the fried cauliflower! But hands down my favorite item on the menu is the French dip! The staff is also very friendly and it's nice to see the owners there on a regular basis too! Happy hour is a good idea, some may say the prices can tend to be high but I think it is well worth it! Will continue to come here! read more

Goodfellas - Goodfellas French dip and crinkle fries - American Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

Great food, staff ,and clientele. Owners couldn't be any nicer. It's our "Cheers" just down the block. Love it!!! read more

We stopped into Goodfellas today to grab some lunch before we hit the lake. The food was outstanding. I had the chicken Parmesan sandwich the marinara was fresh the chicken was crispy and the provolone was perfectly melted. If you're in Lakeville near 30 5W I recommend stopping in a trying Goodfellas. The food is really good the atmosphere was fun and the drinks for cold. read more

As far back as I can remember, I always wanted to be a gangster. Whatever I expected going to Goodfellas on a Friday night, Goodfellas did not deliver. Literally. When we walked in, it kind of felt like the bar scene in the movie when Henry walks in and everyone stopped talking... No one died during my visit, but you get the point. We stopped in to case the joint and I decided it would be smart to order a pizza off of their extensive pizza menu. The Wild game was on but I was so distracted by all of the drama going on with the staff, I couldn't even focus on the tv. It seemed as though all of the women working hated each other. At one point, one of them even took off through a door in the bar with another on her heels yelling for her to come back. They were picking at each other for washing the glasses wrong and putting dirty dishes in the wrong place. It was just weird. Also, it just kind of felt like an armpit to me. The walls are bright red (chipping away in some places) and there was a martini/ wine glass rack directly in front of us full of dusty glasses. To the right of where we were sitting, there is a six tier shelf full of crap. Dishes, utensils, menus. It was unsightly and very odd. We were only in the bar area so I'm not sure what the restaurant area looked like. The pizza was fine, had lots of cheese and toppings but wasn't stand out by any means. Frankly, I would have been ahead staying home, eating a Jack's pizza and watching the movie Goodfellas. read more

It's a local place, and the food is fine. Pizza is okay, good selection of choices, and relatively fresh. The ambiance of thte place is in the lower half of the lower third of the spectrum...I prefer to carry out and reheat it at home over eating it there. It's loud, and doesn't have a clean feel to it. The service is below second rate. the staff appears untrained, uneducated, competitive, and act like somebody is "making" them work there - like work release or something. There are enough places that want my business that I will patronize before I put myself through going back to this place. read more

Very medium. We used a living social certificate so the total bill incl tax and tip came to $13 for a medium pizza, 1 beer and an order of fried mushrooms. Don't order that by the way. Pizza was all right but I wouldn't drive more than 10 min for it. We live more like 20 min away. Decent place for local folks. Service was good. read more

Had the bacon cheese burger along with fries which were very good. Sat & Sun $10 buckets of beer...Awesome deal. My girlfriend and I will be back for some beer drinkin' to watch the Cowboys game. read more

Goodfellas - Outside Goodfellas - American Near Me - Lakeville, Minnesota

Caliber of pizza has declined. We picked up one last week and though we ordered four toppings, it was difficult to taste or see the hamburger or mushrooms. And we paid $23 for this pizza. Sorry, until you return your quality I will not ordering from Goodfellows. read more