After driving by one day I noticed their sign stating all day Pizza Buffet so a few days later I stopped in. I've been to dozens of Pizza Buffets over many, many years & to tell you the truth most of them are pretty unmemorable and/or downright bad but not Good Guys Pizza. I loved the fact that I stopped in on off hours ( 2:15 ) & the Buffet was fully stocked ( 5 Pizza choices, Salad Bar & a small Pasta section ) with everything being fresh which is extremely uncommon for Buffets in off hours. Everything was high quality & the best part was the unusually low cost of my meal ( Buffet w Beverage ) for $ 12.35. I strongly recommend giving Good Guys Pizza a try. You wont be disappointed. read more

We were there on a Sunday evening. Very few people when we got there and maybe 3 pieces of pizza on the buffet. There was a pretty nice salad. You can ask them what kind of pizza you would like them to make. We were a party of 5 adults one 6 year old and 2 toddlers. A large group came in, maybe 10 or 12 young people. There was never enough pizza on the buffet. The dessert pizza was blah. My advice is find somewhere else to eat. Anywhere else. read more

The service was terrible refused to put out fresh pizza food all over the floors the young kids didn't want to do anything and it was so so hot apparently they didn't have the air on I had my family with me this is the last time I'll eat here and that's a shame cause it used to be awsome read more

Pizza was delicious fresh great taste Restaurant very clean salad bar very well stocked and clean . Very friendly staff great service We will be back every chance we get. read more

Good Guys Pizza is in a strip mall and we past by it once but were luckily able to spot on our second pass! The buffet system is very efficient. The staff is friendly as they greet you as you walk in and pay for the buffet choice and beverage you prefer. Then you proceed directly to the buffet line. The line then leads you the beverage area and then into the dining room. The pizza selection was very good with cheese, pepperoni and supreme all being options available. I was particularly impressed with the salad bar and how well it kept everything chilled! While we were there, the pizzas were regularly replaced with fresh from the oven pies and the salad bar items were crisp, fresh and as mentioned earlier, chilled! The only thing that disappointed me was the chipped paint and spots that were obviously overlooked when cleaning. For instance the thermostat on the wall was black on the top from oily fingers touching it. It seemed there was a lack of attention to detail when it came to cleaning and upkeep. I do feel like the buffet area was clean as well as the tables and chairs. They also only have one single seater bathroom. As a former restaurant inspector, I do recommend Good Guys Pizza for dine in or takeout meals. read more

It's pizza. It's not my favorite but it's pizza, and pizza is good. Its salad bar is great. All you can eat pizza and salad. Overall worth it if you want dine in pizza. read more

Food: good Service: buffet Ambiance: ok My wife and I went for the buffet. For the price, which is less than $10, it was totally worth it. The salad was very fresh. You can eat all pizzas as you want. A lot of locals eat there. read more

Tasty, fresh food on the buffet and reasonably priced at $8.99. Enjoyed the dessert pizza.

Highly recommend! Pizza is amazing! Best pies in town. Great delivery. They are always friendly and Accurate on the order. Easy to order through website. read more

Great pizza and great price! Loved the buffet. Able to give requests. Staff was very friendly.

Love the buffet style and the salad bar was yummy. The service and staff was good as well.

We love this place as it is peaceful and the salad bar is good but if you have food allergies ask about everything as there may be hidden peppers that you never expected. They are very friendly and will give you a to go tea which is so considerate. read more

I was short on cash the other day and was big on hunger, so I thought I would try out Good Guys for lunch. At $6.99, it had to be better than CiCi's! At first I thought Good Guys was a chain because of the professional looking signage and design, but I think it's just a restaurant in Harrison. The staff was super friendly and quick to clear empty plates from customers. They had a really nice salad bar with nicely diced vegetables like onions and tomatoes. The pizzas were all thin crust, a bit thin in sauce cheese and toppings, but they tasted pretty good. The staff would ask customers if they wanted particular kinds of pizzas made to add to the buffet, which was nice. One of my favorites was the "White Hat" which I guess is a cowboy reference or reference to "Scandal" for the "good guys." It was covered with Alfredo sauce, cheese, Italian seasonings, onions, and bacon. They had garlic knots, along with some overcooked ziti with marinara and Alfredo sauce. I may come back to try something off the menu, but I won't be clamoring to hit the lunch buffet. read more

Had the buffet and they were putting new pizza out at the perfect pace with good variety of crust, toppings, and specialty pizzas. All of the pizza was good but the chocolate chip desert pizza is the best desert pizza I've ever had! read more

Not from the area but needed some carry out and the pizza was good. The price was even better. Will definitely stop by again when I'm on my way to the Buffalo River. read more

Good Guys is really an incredible pizza place. I love their variety and how affordable it is especially since my two young boys eat for free on the buffet. We did carry out tonight and it was fantastic. They have great customer service and consistently good pizza. The desert pizza is awesome and alone is worth the trip. Give them a try if you haven't. Their carry out is cheap and a nice change of pace during these times of isolation. I don't think you'll regret giving these guys a try. read more

It was pretty good. My husband likes the thin pizza. They had plenty and a good variety for an inexpensive buffet. It was a little loud in there! Be prepared to say, "Huh, what did u say?" Overall, it was good. read more

This place is great! The pizza is fresh and they'll cook to any pizza you want when you go in to eat the buffet. It's clean and the staff and super friendly. I only wish there was more room in the lobby. read more

Great pizza best we have had in years Unbelievably low price they even let you special order for the buffet which is 6.99 and they have a salad bar read more

Very good. Hot and fresh buffet. Thin crust and bread and cheese sticks very good. Locally owned by a great family too!

Best thin crust pizza in the area! Small location, good service. I didn't think Harrison needed another pizza joint. I was wrong. Welcome to the mix! read more

Love Good Guys! Salad bar is great, pizza is great, staff is great. The buffet is always fresh and it's very reasonably priced. You really do owe it to yourself to visit! read more

Really good pizza, excellent fresh taste, the crust was wonderful! The service was also really good. Making this our new place to go to for pizza! read more

A good change from the usual run of the mill pizza places. Toppings are good but the crust is mediocre. Tastes more like mass produced frozen crust. The cookie pizza however is really good. Staff is friendly and stays busy with purpose. read more

The buffet is good, jot and fresh. The twisty roll things are amazing! Love Good Guys!

Really greasy. It is cheap and a small buffet. We where there on a Friday night it was busy. The salad bar was smaller but way better for what they had. I really like pizza but this was just not good. read more