I've made a few trips to this thrift store and have to say it is a gem! Prices are very reasonable…read moreand merchandise is always nicely presented. I am growing tired of the "chain" aspect of some of the larger resale shops and the willy-nilly way they price donations. The staff here is helpful and happy to have you as a customer. The clerk who checked me out was more than happy to tell me about about Heritage House & the mission behind the store. I found a few gems @ Second Thought, and i'm sure you will too!

what a wonderful place to shop! Its a charity type store that sells things at great prices. The…read moreladies that work there are a blessing!

This is a great place with some great stuff for everybody of every age. Loved the verity from…read moreclothes to records and even antiques. So much to look at and go through at very fair prices. Friendly staff and helpful. Highly recommend if your ever in the area.

From the owner: Newark Consignments Center showroom is the best place to buy & sell both new & used furniture,…read morehousehold items, apparel for men, women and children, appliances, home d cor and so much more in the greater Newark area. We tastefully display upscale furnishings that are worthy of a repeat performance. Our inventory is constantly changing & growing. There is something for everyone at our showroom!

This place is a gem. The clothes are priced low and often vintage. I get jewelry and coats every…read moretime I come to town. Love the staff- especially Paul. What a good time he is! I highly recommend a stop here before a sandwich or burger and a monkey beer at Pinkys

Every time I come to Geneva I come back here. I always find good stuff for a great price. It is…read moresmall and local, but the staff is always happy to sell you anything in the store.

love LOVED this place! A gem tucked away on main street, LOTS of goodies galore, SUPER nice quality…read moreitems/clothes and reasonable prices and the sweetest staff working there! I bought a shirt and a dress for FIVE bucks - cannot wait to wear my items to work this week. Also loved their stockpile of decorations and books!

From the owner: Nestled in the heart of Downtown Canandaigua, the Finger Lakes Treasure Trove is more than just a…read morethrift store – it’s a community hub that welcomes everyone with open arms. Since 2016, we’ve been dedicated to making a difference, offering a carefully curated collection of high-quality, pre-loved items at prices that won’t break the bank. Every purchase and donation directly supports our mission of giving back to those in need. Dedicated to serving our community, we extend assistance to families and individuals facing crises or in need through our new food pantry, complimentary clothing initiative, and by providing information on available local resources and programs. Shop sustainably, find unique treasures, and make a positive impact. Your next favorite find is waiting!

The thrift store in the small town has a clean store and the staff is very friendly and helpful. I…read morevisit Geneva every year and always try to stop by at least once. Today, I found some decent shirts. Remember, every Wednesday at 4 PM, certain colors are on sale, so don't forget! 5star store if you ask me Thanks again

One star because I couldn't select no stars. Tried to donate a couch and coffee table. Within the…read moredesignated hours, pre called and verified accepting drop offs/ donations . Got there within 10 limited and 2 ladies told me they were not taking donations. Asked why no one could given a reason. Sorry can't recommend this location due to inconsistencies. Major inconvenience. Had to drive to Canandaigua Goodwill.

I'm so sad that the only time I got to visit was on their last day open (1/24/26), but really glad…read morethat at least I got the chance to stop by before they closed! The setup is an array of clothing and accessories from many different local vendors. They had a huge selection of vintage items from 50s, 60s, 70s, etc up to y2k, and they were all labeled very clearly. Everything was reasonably priced for the vintage condition, including a very cool Gunne Sax top. Service was great too! The shop owner was very nice, and the community seemed to truly value this shop. Many people stopped by for one last chance to shop and to say hi.

Cute concept for vintage store. Located near ugly duck coffee on Charlotte Street... This old house…read morehouses quite a few independent vintage vendors on both the first and second floor of the house. Clothing and accessories as well as a few household items were available. Staff was friendly and helpful. The store was very busy on a Sunday afternoon.

New owner! Great prices on high-demand brands, plus shoes, handbags, and an outrageous selection…read moreof jewelry for every budget.

Decent store with a large selection! Went because I saw so many bad reviews. The female employee…read more(only person I interacted with) was incredibly nice and not overbearing with my very slow browsing! I ended up finding a few vinyl records that I was happy to see! Tons of items in this store. Only minus 1 star because it's dustier/"dirtier" than most other thrift/vintage/second hand stores than I've been to most anywhere. Great prices on items I was interested in. I personally volunteer to clean this store completely for them for $3k.

Very high prices for a thrift shop, its not very clean, or organized. Staff is rude. Im gonna pass,…read moreit's a no for me. I'll stick to goodwill.