Nick did a great job buying my silver coin collection worth about $20K…read more Since there were so many coins he recommended me leaving the collection with him over the weekend so he could inventory it. I went back into his shop on Monday and he explained what the coins were worth (at market rate). He was also very upfront and transparent on his fees (which ended up being around 10%). Everything seemed reasonable so I proceeded forward. He wrote me a check and kept the silver and the transaction was complete. It couldn't have been any easier. His shop was modern, clean and well organized. He was professional and polite through the entire process. In all a very positive experience and I recommend his service. Thank you Nick for making it easy and painless!

Nick was incredibly helpful and went above and beyond to give me the best value for my silver coins!read more

This is my second time to Mayfield Jewelry & Coin Exchange. I was treated with the same respect and…read moreattention as I was the first time. Kenyon even remembered me from our first transaction and it was a few years ago. The experience this time was just as pleasurable this time as the first. I highly recommend this place of business because of its professionalism and open dealings. Nothing is hidden and everything is explained throughout the transaction.

I was at lost of where to go for my old coins I had. I found this place nearby my home in mayfield…read more Kenyon gave me a run down of the value of my coins. He explained it well in a way that I can understand. I didn't know my coins worth until today. Def recommend!

This business has top quality customer service. They went above and beyond for me, with a…read moreprofessionalism and ethic many business are lacking. I'd definitely do business again with them! Thank you Aaron!

Nice people. They guy with the beard is funny. They pay pretty good for the gold I sold. The…read moreonly thing is they don't have anything out for sale.

Great selection and great prices! I will definitely be back! My mother was also very impressed with…read morethe selection and quality!

From the owner: Established in 1993, Mentor Jewelry and Loan is a specialty pawnshop, and specialized only in…read morejewelry and coins. We make loans and purchase jewelry, gold, silver diamonds, watches, coins, currency. We also have retail jewelry & Coins, and offer jewelry repair.

Criminal sold my 95 year old, mother's platinum wedding ring from the 1940s to this place…read more Should've been a RED ALERT IMMEDIATELY. That a junkie that sold it to them - that it was stolen. He wrote on the ticket to the criminal it was gold. which means he lied on the ticket. Because any shop checks to see what type of metal a piece of jewelry is. It is platinum & a one of a kind wedding ring. With perfect diamonds with no imperfections, He's claiming he sold it to someone else to have it meltdown and the diamonds taken out. These are very unique diamonds, and it was a platinum band. He lied on the ticket to the criminal Whatelse would u lie about? Now he's claiming he cannot locate since my 95 yr old mother's wedding ring has been meltdown and the diamonds taken out. Thrown in a bag. WRONG ANSWER - these diamonds r ONE OF A KIND. Are u part of the crime? Prove me wrong.

Give fair prices for items. My go to store for turning old jewelry to cash. Honest and fair.read more

Always trusted this place for selling my gold. They use to…read morebe near downtown Willoughby. They have some nice jewelry for sale. Like a little boutique. Check em out. Go to Malley's then next door and have ice cream or candy.

Great service with fast delivery. They have good prices and are my go to place for coins, rounds…read moreand bullion. Always honest

I made a purchase via the phone after seeing an item on the website. Evan was extremely helpful…read moreand answered all my questions. The item was shipped the same day I made the purchase and arrived carefully packaged with a lovely note and a velvet storage pouch. The bracelet is unique and the highest quality. It was delight to do business with Dewitt from beginnIng to end and I would not hesitate to purchase from them again.

Tucked away in the arcade and worth the walk. Evan is knowledgeable and very helpful. I wanted…read moresomething special to celebrate a life event and Evan knew exactly what I wanted. Other stores had similar items that were significantly smaller for a much higher price. The selection was wide and I came out with the perfect item. Thanks again for many years of beautiful jewelry.

I walked in, looked at a few cases, and then Ken approached me. He was very friendly and able to…read morehelp me with everything I needed. I would recommend seeing Ken if you are in need of jewelry.

Warning long rant... I have been in on several occasions due…read moreto a piece of jewelry that I had issues with, between diamonds falling out days after I received it to a link just coming apart (I was told that was just because of how the piece was made) luckily I felt it fall off, had it fixed for the 5th time and 2 weeks later the clasp became loose and fell off yet again... when I took it back AGAIN I was told at this time we should look into trading it in... (ya don't say) well it was a certified piece and after a year the value was to be increased on the trade in value, because we were short of a year by a month sales person A said that could not be honored because it wasn't quite a year... fair enough we will wait... at this point we were done dealing with sales person A and moved on to Sales person B who did make things right I believe... I went in today again explained what I was looking for showed sales person C what I already wore everyday... because I'm tired and don't want to bore you with this long rant I will leave you with Sales person C had terrible customer service as well. We will be looking for another jewelry store with hopefully better customer service.