food is always amazing!! the ambiance is also very neat, i love the rustic vibe they have going on,…read moreit matches the menu completely. The service is usually pretty good too.

Great restaurant, like the ambiance. Service was Incredible. The Salad was great, the Pizza was out…read moreof this world good. I stumbled upon this place and promise you I will make the detour to go back. It was just that good! The Ezzo cupping pepperoni brought me right bake to the pizza I miss from Buffalo NY. Probably one of the best pizzas I have had! The homemade sauce, the Homemade dough and all the top tier ingredients you can't go wrong. Awesome experience.

I love this restaurant! I feel like I always have decent service. The food is delicious, and I feel…read morelike I get quality Italian relatively quick! It's a very authentic restaurant! You have to try the bruschetta, fried green tomatoes, and Alfredo!

We were traveling on Rt 60, and looking for something for lunch, when we found this place. It was…read morein an old strip mall, but the reviews were good. I am glad we tried it. It was clean, decorated pretty with friendly employees. My daughter had the spaghetti with meat Sauce. She got extra garlic bread, which she said was perfect. I ordered a delicious swiss burger without a bun. It was loaded with mushrooms and onions. I highly recommend this restaurant when in this area.

Cute spot tucked away in the shopping center…read more Finally stopped by here with my mom on a Saturday afternoon and LOVED IT. Server was very attentive and friendly. It's so hard to find good NY style pizza, and most of the pizza in this area is similar to Fred's/ Giovanni's/ Gino's and to have such a tasty example of NY style in Huntington was a rare find. We are definitely coming back.

The food was great ! I was welcomed with a smile and comfort. The owner came and checked and made…read moresure my order was up to par !

I can't believe I haven't posted a review about this place before today because this has become our…read morefavorite pizza place. We lived in Huntington before and would drive to this restaurant in Milton, passing other pizza places (some named Giovanni's also). The friendliness of this place is exceptional. I feel welcome and invited each time I visit. Today we ordered the Five meat treat pizza (I asked to have spicy pepperoni and spicy sausage today) which is my (Charley) favorite and my wife ordered the Turkey Bacon Club Sub. While we were waiting for our order, the owner brought a sample (okay it wasn't just a sample but a full order) of their new Party Bread. WOW!! Garlic, cheese topping, buttery deliciousness on fresh dough. You definitely will not be disappointed by adding this to your personal menu options next time you come here! By the way, now we live in Saint Albans and still drive back here to Milton. The wait staff are friendly and quick to help with whatever you need. You will not be upset by visiting Giovanni's of Milton!!

If you order Delivery, which is supposed to be FREE. 2 Miles from the store. That's a Laugh. I…read morewas charged for the Pizza and a $5. Del. Fee. And I Tipped the guy $8. NOT WORTH IT AT ALL. My last time.

Best garlic bread ever very good pizza very good service there is good a playground and pool table…read more are there people are very nice and the place is very nice 10/10 recommend

Never thought I would have good pizza during a trip AWAY from NY but here we are…read more Firstly, I was very grateful to be in a place with restaurants after spending a night in Sutton. This seemed like a fun place to have dinner and it is very hard to fuck up a big beer selection and pizza. Not far at all from where we were staying across the gorge in Lansing and it was nice to have another excuse to go back into the most adorable town, Fayetteville. We were seated immediately at 5 on a Friday (we are old now). There is both a very comfortable indoor area and a perfect-for-this-weather outdoor patio. Service was good, prices were very reasonable. The pizza menu is out of this world. I can't say I have ever seen such creative and unusual pizza ideas. We wanted to try a classic and their elotes pizza. I saw another Mexican-themed version with black beans (for the plumbing) but it was a compromise with GF to get the elotes (her choice) WITH black beans (for the plumbing). We also ordered something healthy (and for the plumbing): their house salad: spring mix (which I typically despise), grape tomatoes, huge croutons chunks, grated cheese, pepperoncini. Two dressing choices: I can't ever pass on a nice vinaigrette. I was not aware that grated cheese, frank grated cheese, in a salad could be so good. The dressing was fantastic. The greens were crisp. The croutons were very good but not plentiful enough, and again the cheese. The pizzas were incredible. The classic really couldn't have been better. The crust was PERFECT thickness and balance of chewy and crispy. Sauce had a flavorful tang. Cheese was, again, cheese. The elotes pizza was also sensational. Who knew that could be such a good flavor combo? So fucking good. The toppings (corn, black beans, jalapeños, think I saw a scallion or two) fell all over the place and made holding the pizza difficult (probably my fault due to addition of black beans...for the plumbing) but it was totally worth it. We did have to flag the server down but service was pretty good otherwise. Everything came out within a very reasonable amont of time. We finished the leftovers literally by the time we went to bed that night.

We travel to this area a couple of times a year and look forward to pizza here. This place is…read morestupid good!! The food is incredible. The beer is amazing! Always had solid service. If you're looking for great food and great drinks this is it. Highly, highly recommended. I wish I could leave 6 stars!!

Great atmosphere, but serious seafood safety concerns…read more I really wanted to love this spot the vibe is fun, the service was decent, and the menu looked promising. But unfortunately, I had a serious issue with the mussel dish I was served. When the bowl arrived, most of the mussels were completely closed, which is a huge red flag for anyone familiar with seafood. As a general food safety rule: if a mussel doesn't open during cooking, it was likely dead before being cooked and it's unsafe to eat. I flagged it right away to avoid getting sick, and while the server acknowledged it and took off $4, that felt like a very minimal gesture for a dish that could have caused food poisoning. I'm grateful I caught it before taking a bite, but serving unopened shellfish isn't just a minor mistake it's a health hazard. The cream sauce itself was tasty, and the bread was good, but the overall experience left me cautious. If you're ordering seafood here, I recommend checking your plate carefully or maybe just skipping it altogether until kitchen safety improves. Hoping they step it up. Food safety isn't negotiable

Good locally owned small town pizza place that has been around for years which the locals loveread more

This is not my week. Just got yelled at by the manager who yelled & screamed at me because they…read moremessed up my food. They gave me the wrong pizzas. Person that picked them up got home & I looked at them & said this isn't what I ordered. Called the store & she blamed me for her mistake when questioned about why my food was wrong. Stating we'll then you should've picked them up yourself. Asked for the owner & the manager said, " She doesn't come in to the store & she'll side with me". I was also told she didn't care if we came back or not. 5 years of dedication & a lot of money later this is how I was treated. PLEASE, PLEASE PAY ATTENTION TO THE SERVICE YOU RECEIVE FOR YOUR HARD EARNED MONEY. As for me, I will NOT go back since there are plenty of other businesses in town that would appreciate the business.

Slow Daddy's is more appropriate. The place was half full. Plenty of serving staff in the front of…read morethe house. Sunday brunch order of waffles and scrambled eggs took 45 minutes from the kitchen. The best part is that it was cold. Perhaps the kitchen manager is under the impression that most patrons to brunch will be 2-3 mimosas deep and not notice the timing or the lack of any real flavor to the meal. I've had better brunch at any given roadside motel with "breakfast included". Slow Daddy's has better dinner food to be sure. What will prove to be the undoing is 45 minutes for a brunch order and a two hour wait for a dinner order from the kitchen.

Listen . They are busy . Always . But for good reason . If the parking lot isn't full . Stop and…read moreget some food , if it is full . Stop and get some food . I've non stopped raved about this place for weeks . The inside is busy , lots of stuff going on . But when the food comes out it all disappears. The only thing I would change especially for new comers is to put directions on how to order ect on a little sign in the front . Other than that . Just go get some pizza , not sponsored. Real talk

Excellent food, wonderful service, fantastic place to eat. The atmosphere is great! I highly…read morerecommend it.

Just ordered a grilled chicken salad that comes with Bacon cheese and tomato I also added and was…read morecharged for bell pepper and onion! All I got was a box of lettuce sum cheese and bought 5 strips of chicken? No bacon no onion no bell pepper and no tomato! Sad very sad! Threw it in trash! Will never darken their door again! If you don't want my money? So be it ! Horrible place!

I have only ate here about 3 times but their pizza and hot dogs are fantastic and the staff is…read morealways been nice.