Garden Catering - Mamaroneck

(1 review)

Very fresh homemade salads,,,,delicious eggplant cutlets,,tasty chicken cutlets & deli meats sliced…read moreto order,,Friendly owners & servers ---Have it YOUR way,, The Best sandwiches in the county ! We order lunch from SAGE as often as we can,,,,,and enjoy it every time !

Fiamma Pork Store

4.9

(27 reviews)

Great fresh sausages and other meat delights! Go! You won't…read morebe disappointed! In Harrison, NY.

Steaks, sausage, meatballs. Whatever you choose you won't be disappointed. Top quality meats!read more

Indulgence by Natasha

4.6

(11 reviews)

Natasha is the best! her for is truly special and reminds you why a home cooked meal is better than…read moreanything. she's also a lot of fun. highly recommend

Pros: We chose Natasha for a small family party to celebrate our wedding this spring. We went with…read moreher mainly because she was the first/only chef to begin our conversation by asking us what WE had in mind and letting that be the foundation for building the menu. She seemed eager to help us realize our vision rather than impose someone else's onto us. There are also four other people on the IBN team: the sous chef, whose name I forget; the bartender, for whom the same is true (maybe Aaron or Erin), and two servers: Mason and Spencer. These folks did an AMAZING job and we were both so grateful for their kindness and professionalism on the day of the event. Finally, I liked what I ate! I was happy with my day-of meal. Cons: Natasha was incredibly rude to both me and my husband in the weeks leading up to the post-wedding party. I had only spoken to her twice before the party: once when I hired her and again in February. She'd said in February that we could have a third and final call two weeks before the event. When I emailed her three weeks before the event to schedule this final call, she sounded irritated and said we'd spoken "a few days ago" (we had not; I even asked some relatives in case someone else had, but no) and she wanted to "stick to the plan" of having a call at a date a time to which we had not agreed--- only *five* days before the party. My husband reminded her that she'd said we could talk two weeks before and she eventually, reluctantly scheduled a call with us. When we call at the date and time she told us to, she does not pick up; instead, she texts us that she's in the middle of an event. All of these things are perfectly normal, human mistakes. We all get clients confused and talk to one as though they are another (like the "a few days ago" thing). We all overbook ourselves every once in a while and are unavailable after telling someone we would be. A professional would have simply apologized; instead, after I used *one sentence* of an email to express my disappointment about the missed call--- because my husband had taken off work to be available for it, so lost money for no reason--she used this as an excuse to threaten not to show up. Said she needed us to "confirm" in light of my "tone." In light of this, I decided not to speak to this person anymore unless absolutely necessary (i.e. at the party, for the sake of our guests). My husband took over talking to her, at which point we had a fun little role-reversal in which he was now the one reporting to me on a regular basis how rude Natasha was being to him. So at least I know it wasn't personal! Conclusion: If you just need to place a big food order and don't need to talk to the chef again after that, you can go with IBN and you'll probably be fine. If, however, you are planning an event of great importance to you--or just don't want to risk being treated like a burden for wanting to speak more than once with someone you're employing-- maybe look elsewhere.

Tastefully Yours Catering

4.4

(14 reviews)

Tastefully Yours catered my daughter's wedding at Monteverde. As a former caterer and private…read morechef; Very professional and very delicious food. David was willing to alter the menu to my specific requests and executed the event flawlessly! I have recommended him to others and they were also thrilled!

Chef David is kind and talented. We picked up our thanksgiving dinner order the day before and…read moreeverything was perfect. Will absolutely come back again.

Tentempié Madrid

4.4

(60 reviews)

If you can get a reservation you are in luck. It is in high demand for a reason! The ambience,…read morefood, and service are all 5/5.

Tentempié Madrid is a gem in Mamaroneck. It's cozy and intimate, with only about five or six…read moretables. The owner runs the front of house while his wife cooks in the kitchen, and together they create an experience that feels personal, warm, and authentically Spanish. The food was phenomenal. We shared a mixed cheese and meat board to start. Then came the ham croquetas (the flavor changes daily, and we lucked out with my favorite), mini albóndigas (tender beef meatballs in tomato sauce) and champiñones (mushrooms in a rich brandy sauce). Every dish was flavorful and felt homemade. For dessert, we had the Torta de Santiago (almond cake), which was the special of the day -- light, nutty, and the perfect finish. The service was amazing. If you're looking for authentic Spanish tapas, this place is a must-try.

Frankie & Fanucci's Wood Oven Pizzeria

3.7

(217 reviews)

It had been a long time since we were at this neighborhood Italian restaurant. We had decided to go…read morethere since it was convenient to the local theater. If you're looking for standard Italian dishes, or a variety of pizzas this is a good place to go. I had cavatelli with sausage, and my wife had a pizza. Check the photos for visual details.

Everything is well prepared and delicious. Staff very friendly. Highly recommend. They play nice…read moremusic too

Curated Creations

(3 reviews)

I had a really great experience with Michelle and Curated Creations a few months back. I was…read morehosting a team event in Stamford at Pinot's Palette and had asked Michelle to make us a charcuterie and veggie platter. I also had some special requests such as separating the meats and cheeses as much as possible (a few vegetarians in the group) and a specific delivery time. She was super responsive through text and adaptable to my requests. She arrived exactly on time! I would highly recommend her for any event. The platters were both beautiful and delicious!

I couldn't be more pleased with Curated Creations! I sent my family a charcuterie board as a gift…read moreand they absolutely loved it. I was so pleased with the excellent presentation, and the quality was top notch. It was super easy to place an order and the communication is quick, and they're great with updates! As a restaurant owner, our standards are pretty high and Curated Creations never disappoints. I highly recommend these boards as a gift, stress free gatherings, or as a treat-yourself gift. Life is short, so enjoy it!

Sandy's Flowers

(7 reviews)

I ordered flowers for an ill friend. The person who took…read morethe order was great. Helped me with selection and offered best time for delivery. The delivery driver was also great. He sent a picture of the address (home) to verify the recipient A wonderful experience.

Such a beautiful shop in a really nice area of Broadway. The shop is family owned. They had quite a…read morevariety of flowers and arrangements to pick from, all custom made by you! They had orchids, sunflowers, forget me note, sugarbushes, peonies, hydrangeas and so many more. It's a cute little shop, and we came in last minute to get an arrangement done and in less than 10 minutes it was done. Would come back again and love supporting a local family own business. The arrangement was $70 for getting an arrangement last minute and custom choosing flowers.

Larchmont Florist

(6 reviews)

This shop is the best place to get exceptional quality flowers, excellent customer service and…read moregreat prices! I highly recommend you to check it out! My experience was top quality! The owner treated me with respect and was very helpful in helping me choose a beautiful arrangement for Easter and my daughter was blown away by the flowers I brought to her home in Brooklyn! I will be buying & sending her flowers from this shop every time now!!!

Great local florist that creates designer arrangements. Whether you know exactly what you want or…read morejust have a price point, they will create memorable arrangements that will have the recipients asking where did you get them from.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Joe M.

2 years ago

Oh wow, let me tell you about the Apple Pie Churro Cones at Garden Catering in Mamaroneck, NY! They're like a party in your mouth, blending the classic taste of apple pie with the fun and crunchy texture of churros. Picture this: warm, cinnamon-sugar coated churro cones filled to the brim with luscious apple pie filling, topped with a dollop of creamy vanilla ice cream. It's a taste sensation that'll make your taste buds do a happy dance! Trust me, once you try these, you'll be craving them every day. They're a must-try for any dessert enthusiast! read more

L F.

3 years ago

They do not wash their hands often and use their bare hands to touch food that goes directly in Customer's mouth and the staff in Mamaroneck are racist against Black people read more

Melanie M.

4 years ago

Great chicken when its cooked well. Prices are getting steep though!

R C.

3 years ago

Probably the best chicken nuggets I have ever had

Garden Catering - Mamaroneck - catering - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Garden Catering - Mamaroneck also viewed

Venuti's Deli

3.9

(14 reviews)

I just walked in there to order and I'm not sure what was going on with the guy behind the counter…read morebut he just looked at me. He didn't smile he didn't say how can I help you he just looked at me begrudgingly so I looked at him I waited for him to say how can I assist he never did so I left. Currently at Panera waiting on my $85 order. Greeting customers warmly or even at all, it's important

Great food and service! Will be going back regularly!!!! I…read morelove the menu selection they offer, always something different to eat.

Fradeli's

3.2

(25 reviews)

There is a new owner- Mike. He is incredibly friendly and there is great customer service! The food…read moreis incredible. I love their hot food and all their homemade foods.

I was charged for lettuce and tomato! Never in my life have…read moreI been charged to put lettuce and tomato on a sandwic. I can understand extra Lettuce or tomato you w have to pay for. I paid $11.50 when the price sign says $9 they don't even tell you lettuce and tomato or whatever other condiments you want are extra money till it's time to pay.

Mickey's Oasis Grill & BBQ

4.2

(25 reviews)

Terrible, anyone who thinks this is good has no idea what smoke is. These ribs taste like lighter…read morefluid. FYI, they don't smoke with wood they use charcoal. Talk about cancer on the bone! Enough said!

Ordered a chorizo sausage "hero". Came on a club roll…read more Definitely not a hero/wedge bread. One piece of sausage , butterflied and cut in half. Dont get me wrong it was good but definitely not worth the price. More like an appetizer. The "ribeye" was more like the steak ums you'd get back in the day at school. Onions and melted cheese were very good. The food is good and would've given it more stars if the portion was bigger.

Pat's Deli

4.0

(34 reviews)

First time here. I'm not sure if I was overcharged or if this is typical. I ordered a peppercorn…read moreturkey sandwich on a roll with lettuce and mayonnaise. Nothing else. The woman behind the register repeated what I said and then proceeded to load the round sandwich in the bag. I was charged $11.91! I thought OK, maybe the sandwiches are really large??? When I got home, I unwrapped the sandwich. If anything it was smaller than most deli sandwiches. Lots of bread and very little meat. definitely not an overstuffed sandwich! Usually you can get a wedge for less money. Hmmmm... maybe this is a typical sandwich here? I'm not sure.

Food is very good. Service is good. It's REALLY OVERPRICED! There are a lot of good deli's in the…read morearea that don't charge near as much for the same thing.

Nicky B's Deli & Catering

3.8

(4 reviews)

I cannot believe nobody has written about this place! I moved to Harrison over the summer and found…read morethis gem of a deli a block away from my house. I have never had bad service or bad food here. Nicky makes a fresh grilled chicken sandwich to die for, and his homemade banana pudding is out of this world. I tried his pasta fazool once. Never had it before so I don't know what it is supposed to taste like, but it tasted awesome! The service is great. I don't know the lady behind the counter but, man, can she handle a rush with ease and grace. Always smiling, always nice. When Nicky is not behind the grill, he comes out and talks to the customers. This place is a real "Cheers" type establishment. Unfortunately, the seating is very limited. But that doesn't stop people. They will stand and eat because it's that good.

We recently needed catering for our Office Holiday Party...for about 22 people and were referred to…read moreNicky B's Deli & Catering in Harrison NY. I was assisted by both Donna & Nick to make sure I had plenty of food and the right selection. We had several individuals who had health/food issues so we had to be extra careful. Donna & Nick put together an amazing menu selection including Chicken Francese, Penne ala Vodka, Sausage Peppers & Onions, Mixed Veggies, Buffalo Wings, two (2) 3ft Heros (American & Italian). When I say we had a tremendous amount of food for what I felt was super affordable...is an understatement! And the food was amazing! Delicious in every way! Set up was quick and easy and everyone was satisfied! We had enough for several lunches the next day too! Thank you Donna & Nick for doing a great job for our office party catering!!!

New York Bagels Deli & Catering

3.6

(138 reviews)

Tons of bagels, and they even have hot foods (eg pancakes). In addition to many of your standard…read morebagels, they also had egg (less common where we live) and everything egg bagels, both of which were delicious. I got the lox sandwich, topped with lox cream cheese, onion, and tomato. It was delicious and a solid sized portion of lox. Too bad we don't live around here because we would definitely be regulars!

The service was horrible at this place. We put in an order of three bales and a hero a latte and a…read morecappuccino and the person taking our order didn't write it down. She gave us our bagels and forgot out drinks and hero. Then I had to stand there to make sure she made the drinks. And then she forgot the hero again. Then gave attitude about the drinks. She made two cappuccinos instead and filled them to the brim so that when we opened the flap it spilled on my husband and burned him. I was polite and said thank you despite all this and the response was a mmhm. Don't get upset if you get the order wrong three times and the customer isn't happy about it. We were there for 34 minutes waiting. Just waiting. Not going back there ever again. Don't go there if you want any type of service. When we got home the bagel orders were wrong as well. The only thing they got right was the Babit since the cook in back made that and my bagel with strawberry cream cheese. That's it.

Yonkers Miasarnia

4.6

(32 reviews)

I found this place by serendipitous accident because I was a little lost…read more This place is amazing; there are all sorts of imported Eastern European "goodies". For some you'll need the translator on the iPhone. But, it's the meat case that is fascinating. There's more types of made on the premises sausages and cold cuts. The proprietors are more than happy to explain the various Kielbasa. They make their own pierogies in several different combinations. Try some of theirs, and you'll never go back to those you find frozen in a box at the supermarket. They explained that the sausages are fully cooked and smoked; so you don't need refrigeration even if you have a long trip back home.

I live upstate NY and I drive down to Yonkers on every Holiday to get my Kielbasy, perogies, babka,…read moreand horseradish. It's the most authentic Polish food in th area if you ask me. Reminds me very much of growing up and the food we ate!

Over the Moon

4.5

(4 reviews)

First time here for lunch and i loved it... its a cute little cafe in cute little Bronxville!…read more They have everything from pastries to wraps to salads. Its an AWESOME lunch spot! The wrap i had was a Turkey, Cranberry Sauce, and Sweet Potatoe wrap... omg Thanksgiving festivities in my mouth! What a creative wrap and so delish! It comes with a side (my meal, i only got half a wrap, plus a bottle of water, came out to $5.50 NOT BAD!).... they first gave me a pesto pasta salad, but then offered that i could instead have a beet salad so i went with that. All their wraps looked really delish... kinda creative too, not just the usual grilled chicken wraps. They also have daily specials such as meatloaf, fried chicken, steak, and FRESH FISH FRIDAYS! Can't wait to go back and try something else... and of course the pastries!

Adorable little place across the street from the Bronxville MetroNorth station. Bronxville itself…read moreis very upscale, but Over the Moon is a more down-to-earth place where you can get a nice lunch. This place is tiny but well-kept. Grab one of the (small) tables near the front window so that you can people-watch, or simply watch the trains roll on by if that's more of your thing. They make a very good hot chocolate, although the coffee/espresso machine that they have is minuscule, so it will take awhile to get your drink. They also have really good wraps and side dishes. I'm not usually a big wrap person, but I bought the shrimp wrap here and it was great. It came with a side of tomatoes and mozzarella and a side of green beans - all quite good, and the food inspired jealousy when I brought it with me to my grad school class. Eben T. is right in that this place is a tad on the expensive side, but I think it's worth it. It's a low-key hangout operated by some very nice people in hipper-than-thou Bronxville, and my only sorrow is that I'm not in Bronxville often enough anymore to take advantage of this charming little establishment.

Country Markets

3.1

(30 reviews)

Love the Deli and fresh cooked items - Joe runs this department…read more Also butchers and filet Mignon is excellent and value Best daily made sushi by Mr Kim who will make personal requests.

Country Market has the best sushi maker around! For years, we've refused to buy sushi from anywhere…read moreelse when we need a quick bite and can't make it to a restaurant. The gentleman behind the sushi counter is always polite, and you can tell he puts real care into every roll. His sushi is fresh, flavorful, and has a unique touch you just don't find at other supermarkets. Highly recommend!!!

Whole Hog Cafe