I didn't know how awesome this place was until I started checking out the competition. Gamer's…read moreAnonymous - particularly this location - is fantastic and makes retro & modern game buying an enjoyable experience. They had a poster by the entrance that caught my eye on my most recent trip - they sell a SNES handheld console! It is fantastic. I was able to try it out because they had a used one for sale the day I was there. After playing on it for a few minutes, I knew I must have one and now I've fallen down the wormhole of classic SNES games. Pricing on the Supaboy S and the games I bought were all fantastic. I was not familiar with pricing, so I did a little peeking on eBay before making a big purchase and all of the games were very very good prices. I expected to pay a good bit more to buy local, but GA seems to price their cartridges for about the same as they're selling for on eBay give or take.The Supaboy system was also a good price - it was available a few bucks cheaper online, but I'm literally talking about less than a 10% difference and buying local means having a great store like this AND not having to wait. I have checked out the other Gamer's Anonymous on the westside and I liked this location more. The staff here is friendly, approachable, and knows their stuff. This location also has some fun games playing on retro systems to let you relive some fun memories for freeeeeee! I'll be back! Update: ended up swapping the handheld Supaboy for a genuine Nintendo console a few days later. The store was fair to me - I had opened and used the Supaboy, so they did deduct a percentage of what it was worth to trade it out - but the process was easy. I would continue to recommend them.

Friendly and helpful staff! Lots of affordable options to try - available for many different game…read moreconsoles - even outdated/retro titles and formats. Fun shop!

I stopped by this afternoon to ask for help with a game I'd purchased elsewhere. I was warmly…read moregreeted while I waited in line and was quickly helped. The gentleman behind the counter listened to my issues and had no problems helping me even though my game wasn't from his store. He was able to fix my game by cleaning it and even waited to see if I could play it properly before I left. I wasn't charged a dime even though I took up a good 5 minutes of his time. I'm not a huge gamer nor am I what would be considered the common target demographic for gaming, even so I wasn't ignored or treated badly. I really appreciate the time taken to help me with my problem and I think I've found my new gamer store. Thanks guys!!

Love this place. Dark guy with the braids is very knowledgeable and nice. I highly recommendread more

lady ripped me off, I pulled a latias sir from surging sparks which well sold for 175 last and it…read morewas in perfect condition and they gave me 104 dollars in cash. I also sold my Mega charizard X ex promo and they paid me a good 18 dollars when one sold last for 45, they be taxing the hell out of me when I'm just tryna get sum quick cash. if your reading this sell your cards anywhere else but here

Walked in, two youngish guys were chattering away barely interested in saying hello.They could have…read morebeen characters in a Kevin Smith movie. From what I saw the store has mostly newer collectables but I didn't stay long. The two guys were loudly playing a video game AND the way the store is configured they were literally standing in front of many comic book boxes and the shelf of Graphic novels that I wanted to see. Not a great customer experience

Wonderful toy store with amazing collectors items! Came for Star Wars toys for our 4 year old and…read moredid not leave disappointed. The owner was wonderful, helpful, & friendly! Will be back!

Cardboard Collectors is a hidden gem! My family and I have spent hours enjoying the different…read moregenres of cards. Pokémon and sports are our favorites, both classics and modern. We appreciate the knowledge, honesty and hospitality of the owners. Jordan's expertise of Pokémon and sports cards has helped us piece together an awesome collection in a short time. It's a must visit when you have time to enjoy the exciting world of cardboard collecting.

Place is really dirty and they don't know a lot about the cards they have. Very very small Pokemon…read moreselection and everything is covered in dust, piles of junk. They have potential but they need to up there game. I probably won't come back

We didn't know about this place until we pulled into the parking lot because we were going to the…read moreVietnamese restaurant. Nice spot and everything clean and organized. People were super friendly and not pushy at all. I collect X-Men Marvel Legends and I found some here that were decently priced, new and loose figures. They had some figures from older waves. I don't do comics, but they had what seemed like a good selection and had some graded ones as well. Lots of variety here of different things hotwheels and funko pops, we will come back if we're in the area. I came away with a figure and was satisfied. This was a nice find for us.

Asked them to save a rare chase Funko and said they would. Then they proceeded to sell it. Then…read moredidn't wanna give me a discount until I confronted them about it and only gave me 20% off

I can't say enough good things about this place. Awesome crowd to play with, great selection of…read moresingles especially for modern and commander , and straight up the best trade in value in town by a long shot. Chris and Easton are awesome guys and the Owner, Angelo is great. You can really tell he cares about cultivating a fun and relaxed environment and is just an all around nice guy. They are also the only place I know of that does pauper tournaments (every Sunday at 1pm). My only complaint is that that I can only give them 5 stars and not 6 hahaha.

Talk about garbage! Prices are terrible; they use some third rate pricing site for their cards in…read morelieu of more standard sites like tcg player or star city games. The owner is a foul human being with a bad case of little-man syndrome, who barely knows the rules of a game he's claimed to play for over 15 years. The knowledgeability of the staff is laughable; there is maybe one judge out of the entire employee ensemble. For a store that focuses on ONE card game, you'd think that they'd at least have a handle on the concept of it. Realistically, you're guaranteed a better atmosphere, a better community, and better prices at any other game shop in the area: Active Imagination, Twin Suns...hell, even Walmart gives these clowns a run for their money.

Good selection of most kinds of games... although not so much in TCG. Plenty of other TCG elsewhere…read morein town, though. Not much else in town for TTRPG. Appropriately friendly staff. Community events. A good number of tables on a Saturday night. Good number of people.

Great shop. Getting a bit high priced for NM but still the best gaming store in NM.read more