My wife and I ate here for the second time and it was as fantastic as our first! First time was on a Friday just making happy hour and with a band playing. Packed at 530p! Great vibes, great menu, fantastic food and excellent service! Second time was on a Sunday just making happy hour. Quieter and different vibe but still great. Again food and service excellent. Their Sunday dinner special menu has great choices for an excellent price. Happy hour menu as well! we will now become a regular! Belmar Bruce! read more

I stopped in this restaurant for dinner. When I arrived I parked on the street nearby. I walked into a hometown bar and grill. I was sat and ordered: Jumbo Five Cheese Ravioli Ala Vodka Filet Mignon Dr. Chris with Jumbo Shrimp Mashed potatoes and Asparagus Chicken Cardinale with mushrooms and eggplant on linguini I loved the filet mignon! It was so flavorful! All in all a good experience. read more

See all

Fratello's Italian Kitchen is one of Sea Girt's best-kept secrets. The ambiance alone makes it worth visiting--live music, a cozy yet energetic bar area, and a fun, festive vibe that sets the mood for the entire evening. The bar is known around town for their martinis, and they definitely live up to the hype. We started with cocktails and appetizers, and everything exceeded expectations. The garlic shrimp cooked in Chardonnay wine and served over crostini was rich, buttery, and packed with flavor. The Blue Point oysters were fresh, briny, and beautifully served--simple, high-quality, and delicious. For entrées, the Norwegian grilled salmon was perfectly cooked and paired with a vibrant tomato basil sauce that complemented it beautifully. The chicken cardinale was hearty and comforting, with red sauce, mushrooms, eggplant, and toasted peppers all coming together in a classic Italian dish done right. Add in super friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere, and Fratello's becomes the kind of place you come back to--for the food, the drinks, and the vibe. Highly recommend if you're in the area. read more

See all

If you grew up on Jersey Italian food and you know you know. Fratello's is that place. We started with the stuffed mushrooms. Absolute classic. Then came the artichoke Francese and I'm not exaggerating when I say it might be the best I've ever had. Perfect amount of lemony buttery sauce and yes we asked for extra on the side because that bread deserved a dip situation. For mains we did the chicken marsala and the chicken special and both were exactly what you want from an old school Italian spot. Comforting. Rich. No notes. Also do not sleep on their surf and turf special on Monday and Tuesday for $28.99. This is true New Jersey Italian food. If you're down the shore get there. read more

Fratello's Restaurant - Chicken Marsala - Italian Near Me - Sea Girt, New Jersey

See all

had a wonderful dinner here tonight Gabby was our server. food was delicious i had the Fratello seafood special. just scrumptious read more

Fratello's Restaurant - kathleen and mary drinking martini - Italian Near Me - Sea Girt, New Jersey

Had a great dinner at Fratello's. Ordered off the early bird menu which is an awesome deal. They also have happy hour and other specials going on here. What I loved most about the food was how well it was seasoned. Everything was delicious! Just wish they left the shrimp tails off the shrimp parm, but otherwise no complaints! read more

This it was our first time. We ordered off the restaurant week menu. Octopus appetizer was delicious. I had the Osso Bucco My wife had a filet. Both wee excellent along with a carrot cake and tiramisu. read more

We enjoy the food and the service. My wife absolutely loves the rigatoni Bolognese. I've enjoyed every dish and the eggplant parm is a favorite. We like to go when they have live music. read more

Nice bar and restaurant. Staff was very nice and attentive. Had a few laughs there. My shrimp parm was very good. My husband said the chicken Murphy was ok. read more

Fratello's Restaurant - Chicken Murphy - Italian Near Me - Sea Girt, New Jersey

Maybe you thought you were some where else in life? No I'm very rational and I know exactly who I am. Look at your review- you could do better. Your steak sandwich was pathetic. I did get it from DoorDash and I've heard endless complaints about DoorDash. I'm a few blocks from you in Sea Girt. I was expecting a good meal from you guys and of course have been to your restaurant through the years. Your prices aren't fair which is why so many people are not going out for mediocre food. Maybe it was just a bad night, I'll come in again. Chris-If people aren't happy with the food/service then do something about it. I have many years of restaurant experience even opening a restaurant on Marta's Vineyard.You are always going to get the people you can't please! But when normal customers are throwing up their hands- do something! read more

When its good, its really good. The last few times we sat at the bar, the older guy was rude. Its cozy and has a good vibe. Chris, the owner is really nice. read more

Absolutely incredible, the food was spectacular. Love sitting outside and hearing live music. The service was great and very fast. The owner is awesome too. Highly recommend. This is a great summer spot, especially if you want to sit outside. The inside has a great local bars as well. Overall, one of the best restaurants I've been to New Jersey. read more

See all

Went Back to Fratellos! Saturday 6pm . Reserved a high top. Place was packed and happening. Totally different than my first time here. Everything, and I mean everything was awesome. Food , drinks, service. All great on this busy st Patrick's day weekend. Had the lasagna and meatballs. The best. Did a comparison of all the lasagnas I've had all over the shore area and this is clearly the best. The bread is even great, warm, crunchy. Wife had linguine with clams and said it was great, better than other places she has had it. You could smell it from 3 feet away. Great blend of flavors and they use the tiny clams that are better tasting and softer. Limoncello martini was awesome and strong and bonus, this time they fill the glass to overflowing and pour the remainder of the shaker in a separate glass, bonus!! Fratellos made me a believer and we are hoping to make this a regular place in the future. read more

Fratello's Restaurant - Standard size martini, you aren't getting anything big so don't let the menu fool you , tasted great though - Italian Near Me - Sea Girt, New Jersey

Surf and Turf Special Filet was butterfly without mentioning - was just okay. The salmon was acceptable. The bartender Kim was great! Food is not keeping pace with the other restaurants in the area. Frankly, it tastes like hospital food, unfortunately. read more

Great food, great vibes - pre-COVID pricing. (Surf and turf $40????) Get in here before management realizes they can charge twice the price!! read more

Horrible service, you can't get a drink. Unless, you are the the usual customers that go every week they don't even look at you. This is my third time there same experience, they are NOT the only game in town. I will not be going there again! read more

Burger was so good I was pissed I got it. Cause if they can do that with a burger, imagine the rest of the menu. Excited to come back!

I've been here many times, so I know the place to have good food and great ambience. We always sit at the bar and love it. Unfortunately, the bartender was awful and the service was so disappointing. She was only interested in getting our order in and not us. When we asked her to check about taking mushrooms out of the dish, she showed her annoyance with us. We ordered a bottle of wine which took her 10 minutes to bring and then she sat it in front of us without opening. We were confused and finally asked if she could open it. Our food came out from a waitress. Basically, threw it in front of us. The bartender never once asked how everything was or cared if we were enjoying anything and btw, we did enjoy everything. Delicious! Food is great! When we were finished, she never asked if we would like anything else. We would have liked coffee and dessert, but she obviously didn't like being at work, so we didn't want to bother her to ask. Very unfriendly person and really ruined the whole "sit at the bar and eat" experience that we always enjoy! It's really a big part of enjoying a nice dinner! read more

Real nice bar, with an old bar feel, you can tell the most of people are all regulars. We sat at a booth and had apps and dinner on a Friday night the place was full but not crowded. The food was good, not knock your socks off good, but certainly worth the price. They have a sheet of specials and the prices were extremely well priced. The bottle of wine we ordered was only 50% more than I pay in the store, so to me quite reasonable. I will return just to sit at the bar and hang with the locals. read more

My husband and I saw a promo for rest. week on news 12. While it's a great deal, I was more interested in the fact that it's a long running family business with a really nice menu. It's a charming location with a warm welcoming staff. Kim at the bar helped me choose from so many options. We have both worked in the rest. business for 40 plus years. A great, grown up staff, a really nice menu and sauces!!! make it great. The boss Mike was present assisting staff and making connections with all the guests. We can't wait to bring friends. read more

As always; excellent service. Came in for the Monday surf and turf (only one dollar more from last year!). Unfortunately something went wrong in the kitchen.. we each got lobster tail and one with filet mignon and one with sirloin. Both lobster tails were mush and ammonia. The filet was supposed to be medium but came out raw inside. Didn't want to send that back after sending back both tails..It's a class operation so we'll be back but hopefully just a bad night in the kitchen... read more

Was surprised to see this place had only 3.5 stars. Dont trust the haters. We had wonderful service and I thought the food was great! I loved the bolognese. and the chicken parm was an absolute BEAST. Would definitely recommend this place if your visiting or if you live near by and havent tried yet. read more

Fratello's Restaurant - chicken parm - Italian Near Me - Sea Girt, New Jersey

See all

Food was great! I had classic shrimp parm. Waiter Matt was very helpful and nice. Owner even came over and chatted with us. Menu has so much to pick from. And great martini list! Also they have a wonderful early menu and drinks before 5pm. read more

Fratello's is a little gem just outside the gate from New Jersey National Guard's Sea Girt training post and beach. It's the perfect summertime spot for alfresco dining. Hostess seated me without a reservation, and the outdoor dining area was busy close to the summer sunset on a Monday night. Recommend the escarole sautéed with red wine vinegar, garlic, red bell pepper strips, and capers. Rare that I find this item, and moreover well prepared, however this is a true Italian style side, suitable for sharing. Caesar Salad is fresh, well prepared. Ask for fresh cracked pepper! My server tried to mill the pepper with some difficulty. Finally she left the pepper mill at the table, which required only an adjustment to the screw for the pepper to flow nicely. Tonight I had crab stuffed scallops in a delicately seasoned cream sauce, with a potato croquette. Definitely will return to Fratello's on another trip to the beach. read more

I loved everything about this restaurant. The atmosphere is great and the food even better! I had oysters the were so fresh and delicious. Then I had their seafood pasta special, it was so delicious! Loaded with scallops, shrimp and calamari, sun dried tomatoes in a pink sauce and pasta. My husband had the fried calamari and a veal dish, also top notch. We then shared a Tiramisu, it was light and not overly sweet, soooo good. Our waitress was as sweet as could be. Had plenty of leftover for tomorrow and a nice walk on the boardwalk to walk it off! Definitely will be going back! read more

See all

My go to for eggplant, can't get it thin and decadent like this anywhere else! Best sauce! Homemade desserts, specialty martinis, homemade soups perfect for a date night! And a hopping bar that is great to eat by yourself or with friends anytime read more

Fratello's Restaurant - Worlds best Eggplant Parm.... Garlic Shrimp - Italian Near Me - Sea Girt, New Jersey

Food was tasty and well prepared. Service was attentive. Note the front is a bar with live music on Fridays and the back has a small area for fine dining. At first, I thought it was an odd mix, but it actually ended up being nice because you can only hear the people at the table that you were with. That means the music is loud enough to drown out the other conversations but not so loud that you can't hear each other. I consider that a plus. read more

Great appetizers friendly staff Great neighborhood place for hood good and a drink I love Fratellos read more

This is the 2nd time we waited over an hour and a half for our food. The second time they said they weren't expecting this crowd, it was 4th of July weekend, don't you think they should be prepared. Owner came over to apologize, did not offer a free drink or appetizer. Just left us sitting there. So dissappointed. read more

Kim was our waitress and bartender. Mixes a stellar Key Lime specialty drink, very personal and outstanding service! Went for drinks, returned for a meal. Wow! 5 star service and food in a relaxed atmosphere with al fresco dining. Loved it. Thank you. Gwen & Adam read more

We would go here 3-4 times a year Last time we went was for restaurant week. I always get the Seafood Della Casa. Sautéed 4 oz brazilian lobster tail, sea scallops, shrimp, crabmeat, sun dried tomatoes, prosciutto, shiitake mushrooms, green peas, tossed with paccheri pasta with cognac pink cream sauce (paccheri pasta ~ tubular rigatoni pasta). Well, it came with a SINGLE shrimp and no scallops. I mentioned this to the waitress, and she mentioned it to Joe the bartender. Everyone loves Joe. Since we already paid he said come back this week and he would take care of us. I wasn't looking for a comp, I just wanted what was advertised. We came back I ordered the same thing and again it came with a single shrimp and bay scallops this time. I complained. The waitress said there's nothing they can do. The owner or manger, whoever the prick was sitting by the door , told us oh well that's the way the chef prepared it. A seafood dish with one shrimp? Unbelievable. read more

A great local Italian restaurant, with a great wine selection. If your taste tends towards a little bit on the Irish side, they got that too friendly bartenders and a great bar great waitresses that I've been there for years know the place well. read more

The food was seriously terrible. Ordered the "special" stuffed mushrooms and they came out in a pool of water and oil. Absolutely disgusting and inedible. One of the waiters took them away and grabbed my dinner order (after being virtually ignored for 15 minutes). Stupidly, I got the chicken francaise thinking "you really cannot mess this up." Came out soggy and soaked in a watery butter liquid. I mean look at the pool of literal water it was served in. I offered to pay for the "chicken" but the male waiter offered to at least take the mushrooms off. What a waste of $40. Cannot URGE YOU TO EAT ANYWHERE ELSE. read more

Fratello's Restaurant - Chicken francaise - Italian Near Me - Sea Girt, New Jersey

See all

Had dinner here last night. I'm happy to say that our experience last nite was so much better than the last time we tried. Though it wasn't crowded, which may be why this time our reservation was honored. We reserved a table. But we like to sit at the bar, and being there were bar seats available, we sat there. Bartenders were a bit slow, but we weren't in a hurry, so no biggie. The food was VERY good. Oysters were a bit small, but the breading and lemon butter sauce tasted good. My veal Caruso was nice. And the Rigatoni Barisi was tasty. A guitarist was playing on stage which was a pleasant soft addition at the perfect sound level- not loud. I'm glad we gave it another try. We'll try it again on slower nights. read more

Wonderful, classic Italian food. Plentiful portions, friendly service and comfortable surroundings. It feels like Nonna is doing the cooking because you can just taste the love! read more

To be honest this was more than disappointing. I ordered the ceasar with steak and my steak was overcooked, but my friend ordered the STEAK period and hers was even more overdone and had to be taken back it was so well done. They didn't even take a dollar off of her $40 entree for the extra wait that she had to make while all her friends ate so their food didn't get cold. On top of that, there was a stray spaghetti noodle in my friends penne which leads me to believe that this kitchen is just as disorganized as it seems . The only positive was how nice the staff is read more

Tried this restaurant for the first time and was not impressed. The food was flavorless and took an hour and a half. Would not recommend the linguini and clams. It was somehow very watery and had a ton of dried oregano and raw garlic. read more

The food, service, entertainment & ambiance is A+. The bartenders (Jim, Carolyn, etc) are the best.

Great ambiance good food for a fair price. Fun to sit at the bar, catch great live music!

I really wanted to like this place, it looked very promising when we walked in. There is plenty of street parking, a small outdoor patio, a nice size bar when you enter, lots of nice wood paneling everywhere and overall a lively atmosphere. But after our initial impression everything else fell flat. We made a reservation and really glad we did because it was extremely busy on a Friday night. We walked up to the hostess and let her know we had a reservation and she looked a little frazzled. She said she had to get our table ready and disappeared into the back for probably ten minutes. While we were standing around we noticed the majority of other patrons there were probably 70 years old and older. Eh, no big deal it was only 7:30pm so didn't think much of it. We were seated in the back area away from the bar. The wood paneling we admired was only in the front area. The back area had lots of photos and artwork on the walls and was small but cozy. Our waitress was friendly enough but clearly spread thin. Food was nothing to write home about. The dessert menu is a tray of all of their offerings. Definitely my favorite part of dinner. When it was time to pay the bill I checked in on Yelp to get the discount. This got the managers attention and he came over to talk to us. As we were walking out an older gentleman walked by looking for his waitress to get a coffee. She gave him such a nasty attitude although he was really being nice. This really left a bad taste in my mouth. Overall not a bad meal but I honestly thought we were eating in the middle of a retirement community. I actually made my husband drive around the area. Not sure if it was just the night/time we went or what. I wouldn't recommend or go back. read more

See all