I placed an order. They got my order wrong. Then made me wait an additional 30 min for them to then serve me an uncooked pizza. When I returned to the restaurant to complain about the uncooked pizza, I was mistreated and subjected to racist innuendos DO NOT PATRONIZE read more

Pizza calzone and sub was all over cooked.. paid 45 $$$ and everything was way over done so disappointed read more

Fratelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, Georgia

See all

I like the musical aspects. The decor is minimal but showcases many musical artists such as Nirvana and Jimi Hendrix. The breadsticks were good but one couldn't really call them breadsticks. They were like a mixture between cheese sticks and bread sticks but somehow they worked. I also ordered the Sicilian pizza and the medium half pep half cheese. The medium half pep and half cheese had a nice cheese pull and crispy crust. You have to eat it fast, but not too fast as the toppings will fall off, but somewhere in the middle so the cheese doesn't congeal. The salad was also good, however it would have been better without the green peppers. The Sicilian I wanted to like but it was underwhelming. There was too much breading and not enough toppings to make it seem like you are not eating dough. After one slice I had to ask for sauce to make up for how dry the dough was which helped. The sauce is also free which was ahmazing. I feel as though maybe I ordered the wrong toppings because it had the potential to be great like a really good bread bowl. Overall the service was good but I don't see myself ordering the Sicilian again. read more

See all

Amazing food & even better service. Everyone was so friendly and kind. Only complaint is that several of the booth tables were broken to the point that we were afraid to sit there. read more

I ordered a buffalo chicken sandwich and frankly could not be more disappointed. Nearly $14 for a sub, and there's barely any chicken. It's mostly lettuce and sauce. Not to mention the sandwich came out burnt. All after having to wait almost 15-20 minutes for our food. Very disappointing read more

Fratelli's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, Georgia

Great!!! Love this pizza spot! Can't wait to come back!! The service was amazing and the music made it such a fun atmosphere. read more

See all

Anytime traveling thur Pelham is a must stop. The pizza is always great and reasonably priced. The service was good. The atmosphere is very clean with inside or outside seating. You stop once and your hooked. read more

In the Thomasville location. Have been here many times with my very well behaved dog sitting on the patio also other dogs around but now with no one else here was told my dog will have to be on the grass. Probably the last time we come here. read more

Fratelli's Pizza - a dog laying on the grass - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, Georgia

I hope the owner reads this! Rude Staff Good pizza They say they close at 10 or 11 but when you call and order 45-30 minutes before closing, they tell you that the manager won't allow them to make food that late. The staff are obviously trying to just go home instead of do their job. I've worked in the restaurant business for 12 years and we never and I mean never denied food before closing. My family and I have gone here on several occasions but after the last few visits and our encounter with the manager Josh, we won't be back. read more

Fratelli's is the best pizz... no, the best food in Pelham. Do not pass this place by if you are hungry and in the Pelham area. The pizza is always piping hot and if you pass by at food time you will see the place is packed. You may have difficulty parking. I keep it simple. I got a large pepperoni and some breadsticks. I believe they will charge you for water, too. I believe that is what the miscellaneous charge was I noticed. No worries, thought. The food is great. The staff is friendly. Give Fratelli's a try. read more

Fratelli's Pizza - Breadsticks (with mozzarella) - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, Georgia

See all

Really good pizza! I had a pepperoni pizza. The crust is a good consistency. Not tough, but has a good chewy texture like real bread. The sauce is tangy and there's enough on it to compliment the cheese and toppings. They use good ingredients to make a great pizza! read more

Food is always good! They have gluten free options too! Service is always great! Love the seating for outside.

We stopped in after passing so many times coming up from Florida and were quire surprised. We wanted a quick lunch and the first thing we noticed was the warm and personalized decor. Tie dye, karma, Beatles all you need is love and nice wooden tables. They have a very very menu and eight extremely personable and efficient staff. We tried an oven toasted italian sub with a little twist to it, by the addition of jalmango sauce, a side spinach salad and a delicious slice of cheese pizza. The guy tosses a darn good crust in their sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese was perfect. Will certainly stop there again. read more

I have eaten here twice now , the pizza is great , service is good and the ambiance is cool. The inside of this place is decorated with classic rock album covers and stuff like that. read more

Fun atmosphere!!! Music playing loudly, staff happy and singing along. Big outdoor seating if the weather cooperates. I had the Philly cheesesteak sandwich and it was delicious but small portions. Pizza at other tables looked good. For a tiny town with few options, this option is legit and very popular with the locals. read more

Fratelli's Pizza - Philly Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, Georgia

I am regular custom since opening in Thomasville. Normally the pizza is very good. Unfortunately today the the worst pizza ever. The pizza seemed to be old and reheated. Not acceptable, they have lost a long time customer. read more

This place has great pizza. Service was quick and very nice staff. Punic outside or draft beer on the inside either or.

So happy that there is a truly excellent pizza place out in the middle of nowhere. Big salads, awesome pizza and great sandwiches as well! I go here pretty much weekly! read more

Absolutely DELICIOUS! We had the Breadstix, a Sicilian Fratelli's Special, and a slice of Buffalo Chicken! Hands down, the best pizza in South Georgia/North Florida! Rumor has it, there's another one opening in Thomasville as well! We live in Monticello, Florida and that's only 25 mins away! Great atmosphere and service was great! Fresh hot food, prepared by Levi and Sampson, brought to the table after you order at the counter!!! read more

Fratelli's Pizza - Sicilian Fratelli's Special! - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, Georgia

I go to Fratelli's for their Margarita pizza. Fresh tomatoes and basil and the excellent crust. The large outdoor dining area is a plus.

Love the small town feel in this place! Friendly staff that TrueType love their jobs. Singing in the kitchen while flipping the dough!! Quality pizza at a reasonable price. read more

Great food and our friends were glad we brought them. Friendly service. Great value for the money

We stop in at least once a month! Never had a bad meal eat in or take out! Friendly staff and great service every time!

Great Pizza and wonderful service!! Loved being able to sit outside and enjoy our meal.

Talk about an involved owner! He wants to make sure you had a great italian experience. I would be handily giving out a 5 here but they brought our table a burnt cookie. We got both the white pizza and a meat lovers pizza. Excellent food, beautiful and relaxed atmosphere. Come in and enjoy great italian pies. read more

Pizza and other food is very good. Wonderful environment. Service is outstanding and food is always hot and beer is cold . Highly recommended read more

Outstanding food. Great environment. Professional staff. We will definitely return!!!

The food was good. The server looked stoned. Beware! They charge a fee when you use your credit card. Looked everywhere to see where they might mention that but the only place is on your receipt after you pay. read more

Was pleasantly surprised. The Mitchell County area has a nasty habit of getting new family owned businesses started up, but by the end of the year they usually die off and shut down. Happy to say that I do not believe Fratelli's will be one of those. The pizza was good, as was the service, and the atmosphere is really nice too. If more places like this open up, Pelham will be booming. Very happy with my experience at Fratelli's, I will be back for more. read more

First time here. Friendly staff, quick service! Like from order time to pizza at the table was maybe 10 minutes. Perfect crust! Let's face it: you can love or hate atmosphere or service, but the pizza is what makes or breaks a place. And the pizza here DEFINITELY makes this place an incredible dive. Hand. Tossed. Like old school. We travel nationwide over 200 days a year, and this is one of my top 10 pizza places ever. I ordered the white pizza and made it a meat lovers. Amazing. Great job guys! read more

Fratelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, Georgia

I have not once had anything from this restaurant that was not fantastic. To say that the staff is kind is a massive understatement. You walk in and you automatically feel at home. The ambiance is entertaining and wildly fun. read more

Pizza was amazing, and I was very impressed with the amount of beer choices on the menu. Also, the beer was super cold. Always a good thing. One very appealing thing is that you can order pizza by the slice and customize it any way you want! I had a standard pepperoni and extra cheese, and it was perfect. My husband got like 6 toppings on his slice and enjoyed it, and he's not a big fan of pizza. The two things keeping them from getting 5 stars had nothing to do with the quality of the food or the coldness of the beer.. First, it was soooo so hot inside due to the pizza oven. This is to be expected in a pizza joint, and, granted, it is south Georgia in June, but whew. Very uncomfortable. Second, they wouldn't allow dogs on their outside patio. This might have something to do with city of Pelham not being really dog friendly. Not sure. We were on our way back from out of town and had our pups with us, but just left them in the vehicle with the AC on. To sum up, they'll still get our pizza business, but we'll probably be ordering take out from now on. :) read more

Basically the best pizza in the local area by far. This pizza shop would do well in any place in the state actually... large or small population! Very cool rock 'n' roll atmosphere. read more

We just stopped in for lunch on our way to Steinhatchee, fl. We had a large group of folks and we were driving RVs and pulling boats. There was plenty of parking available. We were able to order right away and food came out quickly for large group. Everything was hot and delicious and as ordered. There is outdoor seating if desired but also enough space inside. Added benefit, the guy cooking pizza was a pretty good singer... they played good current county music. I recommend this as a good place to stop and eat when passing through. read more

Outstanding Pizza Restaurant! My wife and I often travel to Thomasville from our hometown of Athens GA and we pass Fratelli's each time. They always have a nice crowd at the restaurant and we promised ourselves that we would try it whenever possible. We attended a Pelham High School football playoff game tonight and decided to check out Fratelli's. Anyone who knows the pizza restaurants in Athens will tell you that you cannot get better pizza anywhere. Well, that's no longer the case because Fratelli's in tiny Pelham is as good, if not better, than any pizza you can get in Athens. I will also state that their pizza even tops Fellini's in Atlanta. The atmosphere is very lively, funky, and fun. Not what we expected, at all! The next time you're on US 19 heading towards the Florida panhandle, do yourself a favor and try Fratelli's in Pelham. They sell whole pies and slices. We got the hand-tossed pizza; half-vegetarian, half-meat lovers, because that's how we roll. Excellent! read more

Pizza here is very fresh. I liked the choices of toppings but it wasn't anything I couldn't get at any pizza joint. I'd like to see some more creative pies here. The decor is neat but the table top is very unstable because of the decor. You do have to order at the counter, get your own drinks, and then they bring you your food- that's fine but my husband was confused as he thought you were served not serve yourself. read more

Nice place. Pizza and the Service was great! Plus, we had great lunch companions in Myles' Tennis Teammates . Dinning area is small, but they have an outside patio as well. Recommend it to anyone in the area. read more

Great pizza, great vibes, and sweet waitresses. I will definately be back! The owners are very kind and you can tell a lot of heart and hard work went into the business. read more

Went there for lunch, all I can is WOW it was delicious. Had the cheese steak pizza and it was so good. The wings were so good. Nice friendly staff will go back next time we are in the area. read more

Outstanding service, food, and atmosphere. A rockin' place with people who appreciate your business. Best calzone I've had in a long time. Highly recommend. read more