I've never actually eaten here, I do take out or delivery. Their gluten-free individual piecrust is my favorite. And their regular pizzas are also good. I do think that the dinner entrées are a little pricey. But I will always keep coming back for the pizza. read more

Likely the worst experience I've ever had with a restaurant. I ordered directly through Frankie Fed's website using its "Start Order" option, which directed me to the restaurant's own ordering app. I placed the order at 1:48 p.m., and the estimated delivery time was about one hour. As soon as my card was charged, however, the delivery estimate changed to 3:48 p.m.--a two-hour wait that was not disclosed until after payment. I immediately called the restaurant to cancel, but they told me I needed to deal with the app. The app first routed me through an AI chatbot that could not handle the issue, and it took several minutes to reach a live representative. That representative then told me I needed to contact the restaurant. When I explained that the restaurant had already directed me to the app, I was told this was a "self-delivery" order, meaning the restaurant itself was responsible for delivering it. I called the restaurant again and was told the order had already been prepared. Rather than wait nearly two hours, I drove there and picked it up myself--after already paying a 15% delivery tip. When I arrived, I explained how frustrated I was and asked them to do something to make the situation right. Their idea of compensation was to give me two small round cutouts from what appeared to be leftover cake--not even an item on the menu. Rather than making things right, it felt like insult added to injury. To make matters worse, the food was terrible. The pizza appeared to have been sitting for close to an hour by the time I received it. I used to enjoy Frankie Fed's, but after spending nearly $100, being sent back and forth between the restaurant and its own app, paying for delivery I never received, and seeing such a poor effort to resolve the situation, I will not patronize them again. There are better restaurants in the area that are more professionally run and value their customers. I strongly recommend taking your business elsewhere. Pathetic Check out the pics for further details. read more

Frankie Feds - Pathetic attempt at "making things right" - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

It's been a long time since I've been to this restaurant. My wife convinced me to go back and I will say I was very impressed. The pizza was very good and the Zappa di clams were delicious. I also know somebody eating a square tomato pie. Can't wait to order that I will be back. read more

Frankie Feds - Dinner Zuppa di Clams - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

I Had a craving for Feds Salad and that homemade dressing! I also had the personal size buffalo chicken pie. Outstanding - really hot fresh and delicious! Fast and Friendly service as always! Totally made my night. BYOB A PLUS! read more

Frankie Feds - Personal size buffalo chicken pie outstanding! - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

This 5 star rating is just for their one pie. The hot honey roni w/ sausage. That is the only pie you'll need to order. Everything else is eh. read more

Frankie Feds - Yum - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

Had an incredible experience tonight at Frankie Feds. The pizza was incredible along with the chicken parm I ordered. Our server Keely was great and I look forward to my next visit!! read more

Excellent meal, great service. Enjoyable experience. Portions were plentiful and into share!

Pizza was awesome thin crust. Salads were good. Antipasti hit the mark. Not coming here for the decor you're coming for the pizza. Had a simple house salad and it came with salami and cheese. Was nothing fancy in the lettuce but crispy and fresh. They have regulars now. We like the BYOB and adds to the family like atmosphere. Great place. read more

I went here last week with some friends. I haven't been here in a while. We got the vodka sauce pizza, and the plain pizza. Both pies were really good. I like the vodka sauce one better. The service was great. read more

Frankie Feds - Vodka Sauce Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Service was terrible. There was a party going on so anyone in the dining room was on their own. Pizza was good but I doubt we would come back. It was unacceptable read more

We loved this place in the past but the last few times we have had food from them it has not been great. Pizza is burnt and quality is just not there anymore. We won't be going back and giving it any more chances. Federicis in downtown Freehold is much much better. read more

Dropped into this unassuming place for an early dinner. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. My wife asked for some recommendations off the menu, but we decided to go with what we were familiar with this time. We ordered an eggplant parmigiana dinner with pasta and a shrimp fettuccine alfredo. My wife enjoyed the shrimp and my eggplant was equally good. Both dishes had plenty of food. For dessert we shared a tiramisu. We both could have used a little more coffee in the tiramisu, but that was our only fault with our entire experience. Their menu is loaded with pizza choices, which many around us were ordering and enjoying from what we could see. There were some pizza choices I would like to try on other visits. Overall a nice experience and somewhere we will return to. read more

See all

Great pizza!!! So many great ones it's hard to choose. The Tony Soprano is a must. Best Buffalo Chicken pizza. The new Hot Honey Roni is a great addition to the menu. Tonight was peppers and onions. Loved it read more

Frankie Feds - Peppers and Onions Pie - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

At minimum, you always get the pizza, and you always order the small one, and you order multiple kinds. I strongly recommend you get an eggplant Parmesan pizza. They're all meat. Pizza is incredible as well. It's BYOB, you can go with one person or you can go with 20 people, they are happy to accommodate you. I brought a family of 12 the other night, and they were super attentive, and the weight staff are extremely friendly. If you drive too fast, you'll miss it. But I definitely recommend it. read more

Good food but service could be a lot better. Wish there was starters with bread and salads coming out, but there was none of this. Did not feel very cared for in the sense of efficiency. Appetizer came out with dinner which was disappointing considering it was a Saturday night. Ambiance was family oriented and people were nice, just wish that the service was a lot better. read more

It has been quite a while since we frequented Frankie Feds but we were very happy that we chose to come here on this Wednesday night. The place offers hearty portions and delicious food It's very casual and great for an easy night when there is no time to prepare at home. The prices are very fair even with all the increases we've endured recently. I had the veal Bolognese special which was yum. I can't believe I ate the whole thing. I just couldn't stop; it was so good. My husband had the lasagna which he loved and we do have lunch for today. This is a free-standing building with its own parking lot. It's very handicapped accessible being on one level. It was not busy at 7:30pm on this Wednesday, but I'm sure it's packed on the weekends. Our food was hot and delivered very quickly which was epic! Very reliable establishment which I would recommend for casual dining and great pizza. read more

See all

Been living in Freehold for 33 years and never tried this place until then. I'm not sure what the hype is about. I'll get to the good and/or okay.... 1) Our server was friendly 2) the 'Super Garlic Bread' was different and delicious. 3) The Garlic and Olive Oil pasta and the Lasagna was good but typical.. nothing special. 4) The bread pudding and the Toll House cookie cake were very good! The major downside and the reason why this place is getting 3 stars... first of all, the managers and servers were all chatting out in the open (and loudly!) They were talking about the weather, their sisters, other customers! I just wanted to enjoy my meal in peace and not have to hear the whole conversation for over an hour. Also, I paid with a credit card and noticed they put "cash" for tip. I didn't bring cash... that's why I'm paying with a card! I didn't see a sign or anything anywhere about leaving tips in cash. Therefore, I just wrote out what I wanted to charge to the card (with tip). I apologize if they didn't get a tip, but that's just crazy. In 2021, you should be able to leave a tip with a card or at least get told about it! This place was overall okay. I wouldn't recommend or come back. I'd had much cheaper and much quieter dinners. read more

Now I remember why I don't come to this place. The food here is awful. If I could give it zero stars I would. Entrees are in the $25 range. No salad. No bread. I ordered eggplant parm. It tasted like it had been in the freezer for a long time. Horrible. My husband ordered a seafood dish. It was just ok. My kids had pizza they didn't rave about it. Just ok. All in all terrible meal. Won't be coming back again. read more

Always excellent thin crust pizza. Their sausage is delicious. Pie is perfectly cooked. We regularly crave the pizza and have to go to Frankie Feds asap. Matt and the long-time servers are always friendly and attentive. We always say we'll try their dinners, but once we're seated we just want the pizza! Looking forward to the next time ... Hopefully soon!! read more

I do Uber eats from here regularly, and usually Uber eats screws up the food. Honestly it's the only way I can get it to my house. This place even if the food is cold it's absolutely bomb every time. We have 3 kids so dinner out is hard but my husband and I would love to go dine here sometime to try the food at its best potential. Definitely recommend this place! read more

Side of bread: fresh, ok Caesar salad: Good but not like the traditional Caesar salad recipe (you'll be disappointed if you're expecting that) Cheese pizza: Sauce & cheese tasted yummy. For the crust, you have to make sure that you know that, although this is described as "thin-crust pizza", it's the kind of thin crust that's cracker-like (unlike other thin crust styles). I like both styles & was in the mood for this. Service / staff: Very good. Atmosphere: Very casual , informal. I liked it. read more

Everything on the menu is very good. Chicken, veal and, eggplant parm along with the thin crust pizza are stand outs. Rigatoni with vodka sauce is great. Service is good. Ambiance is old school Italian. read more

I had to try this pizza again since my last review. After trying it again I have to bump it up to a 4 star place. I ordered the large cheese pizza and although it is a little salty this pizza is addicting. The style is very unique since it is very thin and almost has a cracker crust. I can never eat just one slice. I get some extra house dressing on the side and sometimes dip the pizza. If you havent tried that you are missing out. We also tried the fried ravioli with tomato sauce. The kicker was that tomato sauce. It was chunky and delicious. Very underrated. Frankie fed's is a solid spot. The pizza is unique and probably divides opinion but that doesnt mean it isn't good. 4 stars! read more

Frankie Feds - Fried ravioli's - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

Absolutely a great local restaurant serving pizza and the usual Italian Specialties well made and a fair price.

Have not been there in years and remember why Staff is nasty, food is not great , except for the Pizza Brought a cake for a guest birthday, which I paid for them to serve,thern the staff quickly decided to cut theselves up the remainder and eat in the back RUDE!!!! Poor service!! The pizza is great, but that's all read more

Good food! We normally order for delivery. Thin crust pizza and many other dishes. Great service. Would recommend

Frankie feds is a good option for thin crust pizza in the Freehold area. I recommend it, and their pizza is comparable to Fedaricis in downtown freehold, but Frankie Feds offers more options in a different environment. Nice staff and quick service. read more

This place is a gem. It never fails my family and I after ordering their platters 'catering style'. The eggplant parm is amazing and flavorful. The fried calamari was also good being crispy and breaded to perfection. Tons of other stuff we tried as well and it has not disappoint yet. Keep doing the great job guys! read more

Hands down the best thin crust pizza in NJ Couldn't have a nicer staff. Especially teresa Matt is an amazing person and fantastic chef!! read more

Yes, this is my fifth time here. But, my first time to review, and the first time that I'm dining here alone. The nice smells that emanate from the kitchen heighten my olfactory sensors and it put me right in the mood for their luscious pizza. But first I asked my server, Heather, for a small portion of cold ante-pasto and Italian bread with oil and wine vinegar. It tasted great even though IMO raw carrots should never be in any ante pasto. After devouring my first course, including the carrots, I ordered a medium mushroom pizza, oven-cooked to perfection with a glass of seltzer and lemon. Great meal and it hit the spot. They have a complete Italian menu, which I forgot the pic. BYO Yelpers, be aware of the 15% coupon, to help defray the cost. This is a great Italian restaurant that I believe is associated with Federici's in the town of Freehold. read more

See all

Let's call it like it is - charming location & atmosphere with excellent customer service & friendliness, serving highly priced, average at best thin crust pizza. I was really excited about finally making it to this local favorite eatery. I was expecting to give it rave reviews and have a delicious pizza experience. On the plus side this place is really unique and a fun place to take the family. Also their customer service, speed of bringing our food, and friendliness is the best I've seen in the area. At least three people asked me if I enjoyed my meal on my way out for example. Very impressed with the customer service here. But darn it their pizza just didn't offer the excitement I was hoping for. The flavor was just average at best. It is thin crust though, so if you like that style you may want to try this place. We ordered a plain, vodka sauce, and pasta & vodka sauce pizzas. The plain and vodka sauce pizzas were average. The pasta and vodka sauce pizza was two stars. The excellent customer service and charming location gives this place a solid 3-star rating. read more

See all

I am VERY disappointed. After MANY years of being a devoted fan of Feds and Frankie Feds, I have to say that they do not meet up with what they once were. Earlier today, I called in an order for a pie with onions and another with a double order of sausage and garlic. While the onion pizza was good, the "Extra" sausage pizza had only 8 pieces of sausage. To take it to a higher level, this pie did NOT have any garlic. This is NOT the same Federici's that I once purchased pizzas from. I have been a loyal Federicis customer since the 1970's. During the last few years, they have let me down in many ways. Farwell Feds. read more

Had not been for awhile heard good things with new owner/management - not so much. Appetizers were delicious the rest not so much. Very salty and food tasted old. Gut feeling says jar sauce- Kind of creepy with the Santa set up when you walk inside and a real turn off to be greeted by a table of 2 people taking phone orders the minute you walk in the door. Maybe invest in some office space in another part of the restaurant- most people go to enjoy a nice dinner not hear management yapping on the phone to other customers saying how much their catering pricing is per tray. Not going back lol still laughing at how ridiculous and sad the experience was. The stars were for the soup and other apps. read more

Ordered 3 pies it was 74$ went to pick them up and my order was not put in for some reason treated terrible will never go back ever!!

First time we ever ate here. Let me start off by saying the employees were friendly but the service was a little slow! From when we got seated to our server, everyone was friendly and attentive. However, it took two hours for the entire dinner with one app (coconut shrimp-which was decent), and dessert. We sat outside in the covered area, which had outdoor heaters. It was a nice little area that was comfortably warm for a cooler night and had nice ambiance with the clear Edison and string lights. As for the food, we ordered a pizza; which came thin and crispy. It was pretty decent but not on par with a thin pizza from that place in Neptune ...I got chicken piccata with wheat pasta. Let me begin by saying I was a little disappointed that a salad DID NOT come with the dinner. I did get one but was banged 5.99 for it ‍. As for the portions, they were average at best with three and half VERY thin sliced pieces of chicken. It tasted very good, but I must say it left me hungry for more even after eating the wheat pasta. The pasta was also good, which was in a tasty red gravy which tasted home made. Also had dessert, the toasted almond tiramisu. I have to say the tiramisu was very good. Overall, the food was good, and the service was so-so. When a chicken dinner costs 23.99 I'd expect a little bit larger portion and/or a side salad ‍. read more

Frankie Feds - Looking forward to trying Frankie Feds! - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

I enjoyed good pizza from Frankies since moving to Freehold a few years ago. I've even had a few good meals as well. All takeout. No issue with the food and since I've never dined in the resturant I can't talk service or decor. However, on Thursday while waiting for my takeout pizza at the resturant rear near the kitchen, I witnessed something gross. A staff member was preparing multiple dinner salads and while dishing out ingredients with gloved hands decided to cough covering his mouth with his hand and then proceeded to grab for more ingredients. All salads were now contaminated. You can decide for yourself how you feel about this. I know enough to make up my mind. Ps. I'm sure that stuff goes on behind the scenes at many restaurants that we don't want to know about. But once its known i just can't continue to be a patron any longer. read more

We've lived in the area for over 20 years and often passed Frankie Feds but never stopped in. I can say that after today I won't go back for another 20 years. Stopped in for lunch and I ordered a meatball parmigiana hero, my son got spaghetti in a meat sauce (no meatballs) and we each got a soda. The bill was $40 + tip! My "hero" was 2 - TWO meatballs cut in half! The spaghetti didn't even have meatballs! Complete rip-off for mediocre meals (I'm being kind). read more

Went there with some friends for lunch we ordered three large pizzas and some appetizers when the pizzas came out they were not large pizzas they were like a bar pie if you want to say medium maybe medium. I know things have gone up in price but it wasn't worth the price of the pizzas and I certainly would never go back there again. later that night myself and my friends had a severe case of heartburn we figured it was from the tomato sauce and our server name was Jax, she was great very friendly very accommodating but we will never ever go back there again. read more

Frankie Feds - Patsy's Pizza Large. It's not a large you get from other pizzerias, pictures do no Justice - Pizza Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Very good thin crust pizza. They make a nice salad too. The pasta dishes are just average. I go for the pizza and salad and nothing else. It's byob so that is a plus and nice atmosphere and good friendly service. read more

The food is great. Your delivery guy is the best. He is the epitome of great customer service.