We ordered take out. Pizza, onion rings, cheese sticks and breadsticks. Everything was delicious…read more The onion rings were especially yummy. Restaurant looks cute. Bowling alley in the back.

It was a bit of a disappointment. We ordered and wanted to eat in but the restaurant was freezing…read more When we got home our order was wrong. The pizza was average. We won't be back!

The food is wonderful and even when not in store, you can tell that the food is homemade. The guys…read morein the back are so kind and seem to truly care about what they're making and the service they are providing to their customers. The wait time is a little long but it doesn't really affect you when you know that the outcome is going to be 50x better than the wait. Great things take time. I love the feel of the shop when you go in to eat. Even with little space, it gets you closer to the action. Love Coffaro's! They are vegetarian friendly and welcoming to all eaters alike :)

Pepperoni Pizza was excellent. I didn't care much for the…read more"hot" wings. I was in the mood for wings & they were disappointing .. not hot or much flavor to them. I look forward to getting other items on the menu next time. The menu looks amazing. We will visit again.

Great employees and owners! Friendly and supportive of the local community…read more The food is always good and exactly what we've ordered, so have not had an experience dealing with mistakes. Carside pickup via the app is excellent.

very nice man was biking around my campus yesterday gave me a free voucher for the new pizza. He…read morewas super sweet about it. would def come there

I was staying across the street for the night and didn't expect much, I was pleasantly surprised…read moreat the thin crust and well balanced ingredients. I ordered a to go 'captain' pizza it was ready on time and the crust was perfect. This is a true pizza shop so don't expect to eat onsite. The counter guys were courteous and helpful.

I wish I could rate it higher because not only was the food good but the staff made our experience…read moresoar! We haven't had service like that in forever, they loved their jobs and wanted us to be happy with their product. They let my son watch them put the pizza together and in the oven and it meant a lot that they took the time to do that. The pizza is made from scratch start to finish in front of you so it's really fun to watch. The place has a couple tables inside and a chair to sit and wait for take out. We were so happy with our entire experience!

Consistent good pizza. Unique to our Western PA Eastern Ohio area…read more Staff is friendly and offers advice as requested. Family friendly seating.

If anyplace needs yelped it's this place. Pizza Joes in Portersville Pa…read more Stopped for first time and purchased their pizza slices. It was awful! Crust was so soggy and sauce not good. Had a funny taste to it. I love Pizza Joes but this location is not in line with their recipes Don't know WTH they are doing there

Mom and Pop country store. Pizza is amazing! The owner is super nice too! Try it, you won't be…read moresorry!

Quaint little gem that just pops up unexpectedly. Stopped in for some macaroni salad, ( dont want…read moreany grandma brand ) she has homemade mac salad and she had a wonderful broccoli salad. All made there. Gonna try her pizza next. She also has lottery, candy, you know, anything you need. You have to stop if your in the slippery rock, grove city area. Thanks Chef

This place sustained me throughout college and graduate school. It fed myself and all of the…read morevagabonds that I lived with for many years. Though the crew at this store is different, when I came back to eat lunch one day, I felt like I was coming home. It was nice to see real, genuine pride in the people who made the pizzas and the bountiful sides. The pizza was just as delightful as I remembered it, the perfect ratio of sauce to crust, the cheese as a gentle blanket. Very good!

Villa churns out some pretty good pizza for a fast paced environment at a mall. The cheese and…read moresauce are evenly distributed nicely and are tasty. The beauty is in the crust as its just perfect! Their gsrlic bread rolls are really delicious as well

A group of us went here for a post-work gathering. It's a cute spot tucked away in ellwood city. I…read moregot the gnocchi which was good though the meat portions were small for such a large plate.

Best Italian food in the area in my opinion! Very generous portions and good prices. The serving…read morestaff was great and knowledgeable about everything on the menu.

I've dined here a handful of times and the food is typically very good. On one occasion we were…read moredisappointed, but that was an anomaly. Our server today was Bobbie and she was very, very good. She was lighthearted, friendly, and patient. She was also on top of everything, including my "to go" order we asked to to hold back on for a few min before putting in the order (time to cruise the cute shops in Zelie ).

For a busy night during Miracle on Main, this place pushed out good food quickly! I had the Cajun…read morechicken sandwich and it was excellent. I loved the spice, and the bread was so fresh. I really enjoyed the flavors. My wife got a chicken salad. It was a large portion with lots of fixings. The pizza was good and hot! Just a heads up - they don't do call ahead, so expect a little bit of a wait. But a wait is a good thing - it must mean they're doing something right if people are willing to wait in Zeli... a place with multiple other great restaurants!