This place rocks. Always good food and drinks. Pizza from the wood fired oven is great. Worth the…read moreride to Hilbert.

This restaurant was great! A hidden gem in a tiny town! I was so surprise this even existed yet…read morealone that the food was really good. Would recommend!

The place is great if you want to have a couple drinks. Great bar atmosphere! Bartender is friendly…read moreand attentive. The food was a little disappointing. We did go in the middle of the day so it could have been just timing. The mozzarella sticks could have cooked a little longer. The pizza was good, however, the sausage was spicy. It did not mention that on the menu.

Pizza is a bit different than we remember but was still good (pizza is nearly impossible to mess…read morecompletely up). Service was good for our drinks and food to go. It's a bar with what I remember high top tables but we got ours to go. They accept credit cards but add a small fee.

Beware of price gouging! If you order a split pizza, you…read morewill pay double for toppings. A $15.99 large pizza quickly becomes $25.59 if you add two toppings. The menu says $2.40 per topping, but if you split the pizza it's $4.80 per topping. The menu and the waitress will not tell you this until you are presented with the bill. If you ask to have it fixed, they say you must talk to the manager who is not there. It's sad that they need to nickel, dime, and dollar their customers like this.

I can't believe that I haven't written a review for this place. Every time we go up to our cottage…read morein nearby Cascade, more often than not, we end up here! It's a great family friendly atmosphere, with options for everyone. I LOVE their pizza. I'm originally from Chicago, so I'm pretty picky about pizza. I can't tell you what else is on the menu because I always get the same thing!!! ;) Sometimes they have a salad bar which is a fave with my boyfriend and his siblings. The only reason I don't partake is because I want to save room for the pizza! The service is fast and friendly. Everyone who works here is so nice. One night we came in just before they were about to close. They didn't kick us out like I had feared! They were happy to serve our hungry bunch. Made me like this place even more!!! We will definitely be back!

Nice traditional counter service pizza joint in charming little Kiel. Pizza was pretty good, with a…read moregood selection of toppings. Service was good and the pizza came out pretty quickly. 3.5/5 if I could.

Ordered a 12inch make your own pizza. Thick crust Pros…read moreWas ready on time. Had a decent amount of toppings except for the extra cheese. Dining room was modern looking, clean, good natural light but absolutely empty Cons Very average quality Im not positive if it was a pre-made crust but signs pointed toward it being so. Tomato sauce tasted uninspired. I ordered the pizza with extra cheese. It certainly did not exhibit signs of extra of it. I mean come on its Wisconsin extra doesn't mean an extra 1/2 cup especially when your paying extra for extra. The cashier was a young high-school girl who radiated signs of wanting to be elsewhere. Very poor customer interaction. No visible manager on duty it seemed. Then again the place was empty so... Conclusion. Buy a Take and Bake at Kwik Trip for less money and better quality

It was so insane and super good with pizza! I love it so much I rated 5 stars! ! It so tasty!read more

The new owner has run this place into the ground. Gone are the days when Jon and Anne owned it. He…read moretreats his employees like garbage and works them to death. The quality of the food has gone down so far that it no longer tastes like it used to. They seem to be using premade crusts and are using cheaper ingredients. It has lost most of the flavors.When the owner works, he's clueless and just gets in the way of the employees who are trying to do their jobs. They shouldn't have to be training HIM in his own restaurant. If it closed down one day, it would be no surprise.

Great place for Pizza in the Green Bay Area. Service was prompt and attentive and the food was…read moregreat.

We just had Rustique Pizzeria catering our post-elopement reception, and could not have been…read morehappier! Everything was so easy to coordinate! They went above and beyond to make sure we had options for all our guest despite having allergies. They had amazing communication and on the day of, hardly needed a thing so we could have a great time! Afterwards had so many people compliment the food! So grateful we found them and would highly recommend them for your event! Much love from the new Theado's!

Best darn wings around. I love them so much, my wife even…read moresurprised me with them for my birthday dinner. I was VERY happy and hungry

The ambiance was nice the woman at the counter was very friendly and accommodating…read more I had a calzone which was fine but nothing to write about. My friend had the buffet that looked dried out and lukewarm when I arrived at noon. We stayed an hour, there were maybe five other patrons, and no one else ate from the buffet. Zero fresh food was replaced, it just became drier, colder and nastier.

We enjoy stopping at Capones for their unique pizzas. Some pizzas are difficult to reheat like the…read moretaco pizza because everything gets soggy, but they're delicious. We have only done take out and the service was good. Always get our orders correct.

Great pizza, fast service, friendly staff. This standard Wisconsin bar scene has a pool table, dart…read moreboard, multiple TVs to watch sports, and a full and large wrap around bar. During sturgeon spearing season, expect to see sturgeon in the bar on display. Come for the pizza with it's thin crust and ample toppings, stay for the people watching!

My absolute favorite restaurant in Neenah. I ordered custom pie with goat cheese, fresh mushrooms,…read moregarlic and spinach, my husband had the Roasted Goat, also amazing cannot get flavor like that from a delivery box! The atmosphere is warm and inviting and so is the staff. Our waitress was the kind of lovely person who engaged because she is engaging, not just working for tips. I can't wait to go back next time.

A fantastic spot in downtown Neenah for a great wood fire pizza. The Haley's Comet (added…read moremushrooms) has great flavor combinations. The chicken, bacon, artichokes and onions all play well together. Adding the mushrooms brought a nice umami/earthy flavor to already solid flavor profile. My only small criticism, the pizza could've used another 20-30 seconds. It would've given more crisp to the middle of the pie, and a touch more char would've been . I would recommend swinging in and giving Broken Tree Pizza a try, I will when back in the area.