1. Finger Lakes Getaways

0

Penn Yan, NY

Cancel

Open app

Search

Finger Lakes Getaways

1.0 (2 reviews)
Closed • 8:30 am - 6:00 pm

Finger Lakes Getaways Photos

You might also consider

More like Finger Lakes Getaways

Recommended Reviews - Finger Lakes Getaways

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Finger Lakes Getaways

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

The Cottages on Keuka - View from the porch of the cottage

The Cottages on Keuka

3.0(2 reviews)
3.3 mi

We have been renting the South cottage for a number of years. We were some of the first renters and…read morewe have always had an amazing time. We look forward to doing this every year and we usually book numerous times throughout the season. I am actually booked every month through October this year for one week.

Renter beware! We stayed here last year and loved it and this year was a completely different…read morestory. This year we rented both cottages. The day we were to arrive we were told not all beds were made up, linens were supposed to be provided as per the contract. We also found out the beach area we enjoyed last year was off limits, the beach access was actually on the other side that they owned and to access it you have to duck under a low hanging willow tree and it's muddy. I text them when I found this out and asked them to call me and got ignored. The week was fine and after we left we got an email about 3 days later completely nit picking everything about our stay. They ended up charging us $300 for going over the number of renters allowed. Contract states north cottage 6, south cottage 8. We had 5 in north and 7 in south, 12 TOTAL, 4 of which were small children. They claim he made me a deal because of the number of renters. I rented both cottages for the purpose of having extended family. Tried calling and texting and again got ignored. His wife emailed but wanted to talk to him because I set this rental up with him not her. We were also charged for a board on the dock because the boat I rented pulled out a screw on the mooring whip. There was a charge to clean the grill down below because there was grease and they claimed it took a half hour to clean. Cleaning charge for south cottage. I feel like we went over both cottages pretty well and the place was ready to rent. We cleaned, wiped everything down and are pretty fussy ourselves. Would not go back.

Photos
The Cottages on Keuka - Living room

Living room

The Cottages on Keuka - Outdoor shower

Outdoor shower

The Cottages on Keuka - Me exercising outside in the morning

See all

Me exercising outside in the morning

Camp Whitman

Camp Whitman

3.7(3 reviews)
6.7 mi

I wish I had taken some pictures but I didn't think to review them until I left. We had 4 cabins…read morebooked for our family for Mon-Thurs. All the cabins has been recently updated and felt very clean. Mattresses were pretty good especially for camping. The cabins come stocked with paper towel, coffee, mugs, coffee pot, dish and hand soap, tp, garbage bags, sponge and first aid kit. You do still have to bring basically all your stuff as if you were camping. The pool has 2 canopy areas with picnic tables underneath. The pool is only open when the lifeguard is on duty which is a bummer but understandable. There is a short walk to the water where the canoeing/boating/docks are. It is a walk back up a hill but it's not too horrible. The groundskeeper also keeps some livestock onsite which our 2 year loved. She got to hold some baby chicks and we saw sheep roaming free. Nearby places to check out include wineries (obviously) Shtayburn Dairy, FLX Weinery and climbing bines brewery. This place is very affordable and the amenities are a great deal for the price, where else can you stay this cheap on Seneca Lake?

I went here and it was terrible, the food was gross and I couldn't wait to get out of there. The…read moreshowers were moldy. When we went sailboating the wind died and We had to swim the sailboat to shore as they were watching, not safe at all. The partner I was paired up with refused to get in the water since she doesn't like swimming. I would not recommend this place.

Photos
Camp Whitman
Camp Whitman
Camp Whitman

See all

Hampton Inn Penn Yan - Guest room

Hampton Inn Penn Yan

4.2(39 reviews)
0.4 mi
•$$

Absolutely loved this hotel. I stayed here while attending a wedding- the room I choose was one of…read morethe exclusive rooms with a door that led directly out onto the balcony/patio from my room. It overlooked Keuka Lake and was just absolutely beautiful- the room was spacious, clean and very comfy. Funny story - just not at the time, I accidentally locked myself out of my room and couldn't get back in - can you see me smacking my forehead right now? Well, let me tell you that the gentleman that was standing at the front desk could see I was in a mad panic because I wasn't fully dressed ( no shoes , hair still up ) ran immediately to help me. Within minutes he had rescued me- omg! Talk about embarrassing myself- This gentleman was professional and polite and had a positive attitude towards me- and I was super grateful and soon I was on my way to the wedding rehearsal party and when I returned back to my room later that evening, to my surprise I was treated like a queen with a bottle of the local wine country wine and a charcuterie board- Thank you young man for making my weekend that much less stressful- XXOO

To be honest, this Hampton Inn was a disappointment. It relies too much on its beautiful waterfront…read morelocation, however, the rooms show wear and tear. There were only two bath towels in the room. In every other Hampton I've ever stayed in there have been four. Why is this important? If you are sharing a room with a woman who wants to wash her hair invariably she will dry her body with one towel and dry her hair with another. To put the nail in the coffin arriving at breakfast at 9 AM almost everything had run out and the kitchen had not timed things well with people waiting 10 to 15 minutes for replenishment. As a brand, I love Hampton Inn. It is my go to place when I travel for business, however, this experience was."less than"

Photos
Hampton Inn Penn Yan - Guest room

Guest room

Hampton Inn Penn Yan - Guest room amenity

Guest room amenity

Hampton Inn Penn Yan - Guest room

See all

Guest room

Connect-A-Service Properties

Connect-A-Service Properties

2.5(4 reviews)
2.2 mi

I arranged online in early October for a gutter cleanout on November 15. I received a text from the…read morecompany that the scheduled service was available for that date and time. On the morning of November 15, I received a text and an email from the company that reminded me that the appointment was scheduled. Of course, nobody showed up. When I contacted the company, I to see if there was a problem, they said I was not on their schedule. "Oh, that's just out website," I was told when I said I had a reminder from them. I still don't understand. Why would they allow scheduling online and then forget you?

These guys are amazing! I was renting my house in Penn Yan for several years. I struggled on my own…read moreat first, dealing with all kinds of problems as I live far from the property, in New Jersey. I nearly lost all hope this would ever work. Then I found Connect-A-Service; these guys were able to do just about anything from cleanups to plumbing, electrical, yard care and property management. I hardly ever had to make a trip over there anymore. They made it all possible, I could never have done it without them. Always, they quickly responded to any of my requests, and took care of any issues very fast. Connect-A-Service even took over the sale of the house once I decided to sell. My last tenant moved, they fixed the house, including a basement renovation and got it on the market super fast. It sold quickly. Once again, everything was taken care of and I never even had to make a trip to Penn Yan. Outstanding! Thank you a thousand times!

Finger Lakes Getaways - vacation_rentals - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...