Stopped here for their Valentines Day dinner. It was a train wreck from the start…read more We had reservations for their Valentine's Day menu meal. Reservations for 7. We got their at 7. and they had to "clean off some tables." That woman disappeared for ten minutes, then sat a group in front of us. I had about had it but but my lip and we were sat. Then we had three waitresses wait on us and struggle with our drink order before we got our final waitress who was a nice younger girl. That was about the nicest part of the outing. My crown and diet was watered down by the time it got to me. Yikes. I ordered a French onion soup to start. It looked good with the bread and melted cheese - but it was basically just cooked onions with no broth at all. Yikes again. For my meal I got the New York strip with peppercorn sauce and baked potato with veg. Well... the steak WAS NOT a strip steak - it was more like a ribeye. It wasn't cooked medium as I asked - it was a medium rare then rare then purple finish. The broccoli I received must have previously been located next to power lines - bc the vegetation on the stalks were trimmed off, and the peppercorn sauce was more like yogurt and flavorless with pepper sprinkled on top. Oh and the baked potato? It was a HALF that was plated in a way to seem like that was by design. Yikes. I'm usually able to suck it up, but if I'm paying $80 you have to bat at least 2/4. They went 0/4 and the bay never got off their shoulders. Won't be back. Sorry.

The service was extremely slow, took over two hours for 4 adults to dine. Crab Au Gratin appetizer…read morewas just a half of a bagel cut up with melted cheese on it, we were unable to find crab. For $12 , 6 small pieces of bagel was a disappointment. Bloody Mary's were very good and flavorful. My steak that was ordered medium was tough and small. The group agreed that overall the wait time from beginning to end was way too long and the food was mediocre at best. We were served a free glass of champagne by characters from a play at a local theatre. It was confusing for customers that didn't know what was happening.

The steamed shrimp were huge and perfectly cooked. The service is always amazing and the owner is…read morevery welcoming and friendly. Lighting is warm and setting is cozy. Highly recommend this locally owned business!

If you are looking for a place to eat in the area, stop reading reviews, get in the car, and head…read morestraight to Crabby Maggie's! Five enthusiastic stars up for everything! We had to drop off some items in the area and wanted to get dinner before heading back, so we looked over the menu and reviews. It seemed like it would be perfect for seafood lovers, and we were able to snag one of the last tables available. From the time we walked in, the service was amazing. The staff made great recommendations, checked on us frequently without being intrusive, and made sure we were enjoying our first experience there. Even the other customers were super friendly and told us they had been coming back for years for the great food and service. We both loved our meals. The breading on my fish was really crispy (a recommendation from the server), and the hush puppies were delicious. The portions were very generous, and I really enjoyed my leftovers the next day! The decor there is also super cute. They have several old soda machines outside and adorable crab-themed items inside and outside. Even though it's a bit of a drive, we both agreed that it will be well worth another trip in the future!

When I was a child , 1957 to 1965, I lived next door to the Chat & Chew just down the bank in…read moreMcCoole. We were poor Appalachian family of ten children. The Chat & Chew workers gave me many a free meal. I'll always respect the for that.

Friendly service, nice portions and everything tasty! Very reasonable prices too! Will visit again.read more

We had crab legs and shrimp as part of a birthday celebration. These were by far the best crab legs…read morethat my husband and I have ever eaten. They were huge, had a ton of meat in them, and were cooked to perfection. We are seafood people and have eaten in several places along the eastern coast, and Captain Billy's far surpasses them all. The shrimp were great too - not over done, large, and had the perfect amount of seasoning. We will definitely be ordering from here!

Friendly service and the food is always top notch. Capt. Billys is our family favorite place to get…read moreseafood here in the valley.

This place was great with outside dining area. We had a soft carb sandwich which was super good!!!…read moreThe mozzarella sticks were just ok. They don't have crabs oysters during lunch time tho.

Cute little spot and good service. And I ordered the Shrimp Platter, described as 12 jumbo shrimp,…read moreI requested broiled. Very disappointed, they were not jumbo, not broiled and totally bland. They had no chicken wings on the menu as depicted in what are obviously old photos. Had good beer selection. It was just okay.

Oh gosh! Did someone say Fresh Amazingly Seasoned seafood?!…read more The Crab 99 is such a surprisingly good seafood boil restaurant. I would take it one step further and label it a mom pop boil restaurant. It may not look like much on the outside but where it lacks in outdoor decor it makes up with seasoning! I ordered the Monday. Crab legs, mussels, shrimp, corn, and potatoes. My friend and I shared one meal. So it's enough for two people but you won't want to share. Trust me!! The service was decent. They have a young staff and they're learning. But be sure to bring in a smile and leave a phat tip! This place is worth it. I'm looking forward to visiting tomorrow, and the day after, and the day after, .....

This place was great! Definitely does not look as awesome as it is when you pull up to the…read morerestaurant. Once you go in it's nice. Was very clean. Service and waitress were great. Very attentive. The boil bags were awesome. We went with "all juicy" and medium spicy and it was perfect. The flavors and all the butter to dip your seafood in was awesome. And the corn soaks up all the juices and was really good. My Daughter did sausage, snow crab, and Shrimp. I did Snow Crab, Lobster, and shrimp. All cooked well. The only reason I didn't 5 star is in my opinion the "market price" lobster tail with the amount of meat in the tail was over priced. Just my opinion.

First time in DCL and we wanted a dinner that was light and enjoyable. Thanks to Yelp I was able…read moreto survey the local food scene and this was one of the ones that I tagged. Well we are glad I did, first the location is a little off the main road but up atop a small rise. Outside tables and inside greet you at this great little restaurant. We had Calamari appetizer that was lightly breaded and served with sweet chili dipping sauce very good. Then main courses included Crab cake sandwich NO filler most crab, fish and onion rings (yep), cod sandwich and seared ahi tuna (seasoned with old Bay and Blackened seasoning). All members throughly enjoyed dinner and would go back. So if you are looking for a seafood restaurant in DCL here you go. Sorry no pictures as we were really hungry and ate the food immediately. Next time.

Had the blackened Mahi mahi tacos. Absolutely brilliant. Can't wait to try the dinner…read more Friendly and professional staff,

What a solid spot!!! Food was amazing. Got the crab legs and shrimp combo. First off, I've been…read moresearching for the best horseradish sauce since finding one in CT, but this place beats it. So good!! The crab was phenomenal too. Ordered alligator tail as an app, it was surprisingly great. Would grab it again. Friendly host and server. Place has that small town feel but a more homey vibe with how they welcomed us late in the night. Fun atmosphere and cool decor. Highly recommend!

Aside from being pro-nazi and pro-child rape, the food was pretty good. But you will be subjected…read moreto nazi propaganda and pro-child rape images all across the exterior and interior. Parking is kinda difficult.