I challenge you to find me a better bagel than FA Nagle. Bagels were light and airy, you could uniquely taste all of the flavors of an everything, and the meats/cheese/egg were well balanced. This was everything a bagel breakfast sandwich is supposed to be. Can't wait to try the lunch sandwiches, but they looked great too. read more

Bagels were fresh but we prefer bagels to be entirely coated on both sides, not just the top as they do here. My everything bagel was scooped out and toasted well but the vegan cream cheese spread was minimal and tasted off. So my experience was mediocre. Pumpernickel breakfast bagel was Ok with decent amount of pork roll. Total of $12 for the two filled bagels, cash only. Clean interior and friendly staff. read more

See all

I don't get some of the reviews-I've been happy with the quality, service, and standard of the products they offer here. Great deli sandwiches on your bagel. read more

We Had some bagels and egg sandwiches, all of which were good. There is a big parking lot with other restaurants, so it is easy to park. ***cash only*** which, lucky I had some on me at that time. read more

Welcome to Ghetto Bagel. Absolutely appalling behavior by the staff. Literally arguing behind the counter. Using profanity and talking about sexual "body count", using racial profanity, and other ignorant terms. The ownership should know that their staff should be wiped clean and start over before it's too late. A disgusting experience for someone who never leaves a bad review anywhere. Food was ok. read more

Porkroll and cheese is staple for a Jersey girl. Especially for one who now lives in scrapple country. I come back to visit family and I rarely miss the opportunity to visit FaNagle the Bagel. I don't however write reviews very often, so im using yelp criteria. Food. Great! Bagels are fresh with just the perfect amount of porkroll and cheese. Service. Fast Friendly Efficient Ambiance. Plenty of space and seating. Its a beach bagel shop, not a fine dining restaurant. Its perfect. read more

Fa Nagle the Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

Came here on a Sunday morning which I understand is a busy time but the wait was frustrating. I got a croissant with ham, egg and cheese. It was delicious but not worth the wait. read more

$17 for a sausage bacon egg and cheese sandwich and a 12 oz Red Bull. Sandwich was ok but way too pricey read more

Nice bagel shop in a busy shopping center. Very busy on a Sunday morning with a line. 13 bagels for a dozen, bagels are fresh but I prefer them well done and crispy on the outside. These bagels are on the softer doughy side if you will. Veggie cream cheese was fine. Prices for bagels and sandwiches are reasonable. Plenty of parking and staff working the counter. read more

Fa Nagle the Bagel - Busy Sunday morning - Bagels Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

See all

I love their bagels. On weekends and lunch time there are often lines, but they move fairly fast. Plenty of parking.

I love Fanagle the Bagel's delicious, fresh bagels... From the cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese to the pork roll, egg and cheese with ketchup on a plain toasted bagel... #1 Bagel Deli in the area... 5 Stars... Everyone is polite and the place is clean... read more

Not a New York bagel at all, passable if you are at the beach and want a bagel. Satisfies your need for a Sunday morning bagel. Staff very nice read more

Rudest counter staff I've ever encountered. Super skimpy on the sandwiches. Bagels are doughy and can be hit or miss. 5 people behind the counter, two customers in the store, phone is ringing and they refuse to answer it while proceeding to say "I guess they don't get the hint." Well, I got the hint and will go literally anywhere else for a breakfast sammy and bagels. read more

Positive: everything bagel had a nice amount of topping. Bagels are not NY style, they are baked not boiled and baked. Zero crust, more like tasteless puffy rolls, which is NOT a real bagel. Service was expressionless. Person could careless about me being a paying customer. I ordered a dzn and 1/2 and seemed bothered when I asked how many I had left to choose. Sorry I didn't keep count in my head, and i bothered you to check. Just another bad shore bagel shop catering to the weekend crowd. No pride in their product. read more

Food workers with long beards not wearing masks or hairnets. Worker handling cash also handling food. Not good!

I go the finagle 2 to 3 times a month for breakfast. This morning I waited 35 min for a pork rolled egg and cheese and a tuna on a croissant. I asked for let Tom and mayo I got 2 small slices of tomato no lettuce and no mayo. This is now the second time this has happened. 35 min and the order wasn't even right. It will be the last time I spend my money in there read more

I have been going here for years . It is delicious every time . there can be a wait but it's always fresh

Been going here for a very long time. Bagels are always fresh day of and you can see they make bagels through out the day. I have had everything from a pec, seg, to turkey clubs to the tuna fish. I won't eat tuna anywhere else but there. Staff is fast and efficient. It's a comfortable place to sit at the counter and eat! And the hot chocolate is spot on! read more

I'll jump in here with the terrible service and meh bagels. I've had much better bagel sandwiches at..well, just about anywhere. The staff is always uncaring. I don't want to say outright rude, but they definitely don't give a crap about the customer. An added annoyance is the fact that they don't take credit cards. That blatant tax avoidance always gets on my nerves. For those of you who don't care, you can get cash from their in house ATM which they probably own. For a $3 dollar charge you can take out $5 to buy a bagel sandwich. Enjoy that $8 bagel! read more

Anyone that does not give these bagels 5 stars, is not a connoisseur of good bagels. I would venture to say that the everything bagel I had this afternoon was the BEST I have ever had and I grew up in NY - home of the bagel! The everything part of the bagel was plentiful (I hate when it's mostly bald) and delicious! And the texture (very important) had just the right amount of chew! On this delightful bagel, I had egg and cheese - cooked perfectly and quickly. I only wish this place was closer to home as I don't get down that way very often. Why oh why didn't I bring home a dozen? read more

Great place to visit if you in need of some quick food, fast service, with friendly employees, really cant go wrong with anything on the menu, from the bagels to the sandwiches everything is just right ! been going there for years and its not going to stop now !!! read more

Great fresh bagels. A must if you are in the area Call ahead since there is usually a line out the door read more

Undercooked, under toasted, underwhelming. I use to go here when my mother lived nearby. Now I recall why I stayed away so long. Nice staff - bagels ehhhh read more

What was once my favorite breakfast sandwich place is now just another pricey moody ass hole spot for New Yorkers to bombard before slamming the NJ beaches and double parking. All the prices have gone up, which economy I get it, but wow I mean my god a bacon egg and cheese should not be this expensive. And the funniest part of it the most ironic to me, is they've never allowed card. still don't take card, fucking stupid and lazy. So now all the shit is even more expensive u need even more cash hahah normally if shit becomes more expensive, that's normally a good time to add other payment options. I'm sure y'all feel indignant, the vibe from the staff is normally not pleasant...maybe it's like you wake up real early so you think of yourself as a martyr of breakfast like that's a sacrifice or something. Nah it's just a job, and it's early, u don't have to work there. U don't have to be a cold robot to get through the day. Also the bagels are better literally everywhere else, fanagle just makes good sandwiches, the bagels are eh. I knew a kid who used to show up at Fanagle with a bagel from hot bagel bakery in Oakurst and tell them to make his sandwich on that. That's maybe the move, if ur risking it at all. read more

I love the bagels here they are always fresh and taste delicious. My personal favorite is the egg bagel. Only downside is that it is cash only but for a quick easy breakfast - worth it! read more

Okay so I use to love this place when I lived in long branch. It was well worth the drive. Now, I can't say that I'll be stopping here ever again. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a roll, very simple. But for almost $6 it was a waste. I ended up finding another place an extra mile down the road and got a power house sandwich for the same price. read more

Fa Nagle the Bagel - Bacon egg and cheese. Mostly bread. - Bagels Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

Surprisingly empty on a Saturday morning. Staff seemed a little slower paced than you might expect, but bagels were top quality (doughy inside, crisp outside). read more

Disgusting. I'm eating my bagel & I had to pull a long black hair out of my mouth. I called & the idiot girl tells me sometimes stuff happens. That's the answer I get. I wouldn't eat a crumb from there. They are rude & gross. Plus their bagels aren't good at all. I come from NY so I know real good Bagels & this isn't one of them. this place deserves ZERO stars!!!!! read more

Having spent my whole life in and around NYC, I'd like to think I know good bagels...and these are the best bagels I've ever had. Go here now. read more

Now called "Bagels Deli", this is the best everything bagel that I have found in the area. The bagel was generously sized, and the top was loaded with seeds, just how I like it. read more

Fa Nagle the Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

Weak. Five people working, very little line (when I arrived), and it took over 15 minutes to get a bagel with two eggs and bacon. Yesterday I ordered an omlette on an bagel and the cook didn't know how to make an omlette (he put a pile of scrambled eggs on a bagel). I watched them today screw up multiple orders. They are bad. read more

in my opinion, the flour used to make the bagels is now a lower quality, and the lady at the counter was nasty, go elsewhere !

Been coming here on and off for years. Never truly satisfied and usually only because it's close to home. But enough is enough. This place is chaos behind the counter and unless you're just picking up a bag of bagels, you can flip a coin if your cooked order will be handled properly. First of all the bagels plain and simply are undercooked. I've had a few bagel aficionados test them. They are so doughy inside that you can gut them and then have a can of play dough for your kids. Seriously. Then if you dare to order a cooked sandwich, it depends. Is the person taking your order new? If so you will be overcharged and underserved. The training system for new employees is not good. I've seen so much turnover over the years they either don't pay enough or don't train enough or both. Over the years I've been overcharged, given the wrong sandwich, the wrong bagels, not the proper amount of bagels, etc etc. management needs to step up BIGTIME. If not for the location, and the proximity to the next nearest bagel shop, this place would simply not make it. Sorry not sorry. read more

Was in long branch and needed a bagel seen fa Nagle bagel but now they are called bagel deli I ordered a everything bagel with cream cheese and grape jelly omg I love it very fresh warm just how I like my bagels the place is very clean not a long wait at all only down fall is bring cash if not they do have a atm they don't accept cards will be going there again read more

Fa Nagle the Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

I've eaten many bagels in my lifetime and can confidently say I've had the worse one ever from this hole in the wall. I will give them credit for consistency because I've consistently had horrible bagels from this place. I keep trying to give them a chance because it's close to my home, but today was officially the last time. The bagels are always stale, ALWAYS. Fun tip: When you use the name bagel in your name it might be a good idea not to have stale ones waiting for customers. The restaurant decor is deplorable and unwelcoming. The staff always seems under the influence of something and takes a good minute to mentally process my relatively simple order. Clean up your act because the location should command better bagels. read more

The worst bagel place every staff is nearly brain dead. Heaven forbid you decide to order for pick up, you will pay way more than you should for help small portioned food. And when you complain they'll tell you "I didn't take your order." I could go on, but I've already wasted time and money with these clowns. Steer Clear! read more

Good and fast bagels and if you eat in there's 5 TVs you can enjoy watching while you eat. read more

Fa Nagle the Bagel - Mmmm - Bagels Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

BEST PLACE HANDS DOWN. A pork roll egg & cheese on an egg bagel is your best bet. The bagels are so fresh and soft. I live in Monmouth County however go to school in Union County & I will purposely drive down just to get fanagle! No other bagel place compares. read more

I've been coming here for years, and I hate to write a negative review like this, but if any place deserves it its Fa Nagle. I work nearby at a restaurant, and the camaraderie that should exist between restaurant industry workers who deal with annoying tourists is nonexistent here. The staff never smiles, they never act like they're happy to see you, or that they're even happy you're giving them your business. Each time I go I swear it will be my last, but it's convenience always wins out and I find myself back there again, angry with myself and the miserable employees and owners. They have a phone for phone orders but never pick it up. I've called ten times in a row only to be finally answered and told they're not accepting phone orders today. I get it, you're kind of busy, but find a way to deal with it more efficiently. Ignoring the phone is not efficient. The saddest part about them is that the bagels used to be fantastic, and more than made up for the abysmal customer service. These days the bagels are gummy and chewy, but not that good kind of chewy you want in a bagel. They taste like uncooked flour. Bad bagels coupled with wretched employees makes this a most unhappy bagel place by the beach. It's a shame, I want to like the place and it's employees, because I live locally and understand their frustrations with a majority of their customer base. But they're are unfortunately terrible at being nice. This will truly be the last time I ever get Fa Nagle. Check out the Brothers Bagel Deli in West End Long Branch instead. read more

Every part of the Fa Nagle experience is the worst it could possibly be. The pretentious, snippy staff is inconvenienced by your business, and painfully crafts the most underwhelming bagel sandwich you could possibly have. Doughy bagels that stick to your teeth, undercooked pork roll, no napkins for a to go order. Your soul sucking experience starts at the register. God for bid you insult her by asking spinach, prepare for the judgy looks while she forces herself to scribble down your order and has to find the strength in her cold heart to take your money - cash only of course like it's 1931 and you shouldn't assume technology has caught up. The cooks begrudgingly prepares your order when they find the time to dig deep into the prison chef cookbook and slop together your order, dumped into a white bag and left right in front of you. When another cold soul who makes eye contact with you by mistake wanders by and lifelessly calls out your name, you take the bag and run for daylight. This place makes me sad. read more