Some of these one star reviews are weird. Why would a vintage toy store "bargain" with you for…read moreexample? And--Don't touch things if you're going to place them back anywhere other than where they belong. This is a vintage toy store. Think of it like a museum of sorts, but one where you actually have the privilege to own the pieces. Be respectful. All of those bad reviews sound like people who don't understand that... Anyway...I ordered online so I'm reviewing the online experience--which was great. Packaging must have been good because my dad got his G.I. Joe in perfect condition. The owner, or the owner's son, emailed me personally immediately after I ordered to simply check to make sure the address was correct because my address and the shipping address were different--so they obviously genuinely care about their items and offering quality service to customers. And my dad, as a child, actually had the exact G.I. Joe I bought for him. He said when he opened the package it immediately unlocked childhood memories he'd forgotten about. He said it was the best birthday gift he'd gotten. And nothing beats getting your dad a good birthday gift. (Except maybe buying your parents a house, but, I'm not quite there yet.) You can't trust buying a G.I. Joe from just anyone/anywhere. This place has a G.I. Joe specialist who inspects the figures before they're available for sale. That means you're not getting some counterfeit replica pieces sold to you like you might elsewhere. I would absolutely order again from this place, and hope I have the opportunity to. I'll be checking back every now and then for future G.I. Joes that my dad doesn't have yet.

The last time I visited Toys Time Forgot in Canal Fulton, I literally had to buy more memory for my…read morephone--I took that many pictures. It's just one of those places where the nostalgia hits you like a wave. Every aisle is filled with treasures from your childhood: toys you had, toys you wanted but couldn't afford, and even some you totally forgot existed until they were right there in front of you. I told a friend recently that if I had a million dollars to spend only on toys, I'd still leave that store with a wishlist. It's that packed with incredible finds. They have toys dating all the way back to the 1920s, through the golden eras of the '50s, '60s, '70s, and into the '80s and '90s--the stuff we now lovingly call "vintage" or "retro." From Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and Star Wars to Marvel Comics, classic board games, and massive collectible statues, the selection is wild. I'm doing a couple of photo dumps just to show people how deep the nostalgia runs there. It's more than a store--it's an experience. If you're within driving distance, I highly recommend making a day of it. Explore the beautiful town of Canal Fulton, grab some food, and then spend time walking through this amazing shop. You won't regret it. And if you're not local--good news--they ship nationwide (possibly even worldwide). Right now they've got a spring sale: 20% off most items, and even 10% off statues and busts. Plus, they're gearing up for a huge Free Comic Book Day event, with a block party, vendors, and performers. Definitely worth checking out. Keep an eye out for flyers about NEO Con while you're there, and block out some time--you're going to need it!

Melissa and Dave (owners) are incredibly creative, friendly, and awesome! They have their store…read morestocked up with antique trinkets and clothes, home decor, records, Ohio gear (tees and hats), and so much more! Best time to visit is on the First Friday of the month!

Interesting building in an old industrial area, but use your GPS. We drove right past and to the…read moreend of the street. Three floors of mid-century, heavy on furniture. Main floor is for the ready-to-go, cleaned up items. Basement and 3rd floors are for the rougher, unrestored MCM pieces, basement is a bit damp. They offer upholstery services. The sign above their desk saying to respect their prices was odd, but that is their policy. Selection is great... but this is really retail. If you want a deal, you need to put in the time doing the hard work of finding this stuff, in the wild, yourself. They do offer selection and worth checking out for comparisons if nothing else... you might find the perfect item here for your modern self.

If you're obsessed with mid-century design, Main Street Modern is that rare gem you keep coming…read moreback to. I literally have a "MSM wish list" on my phone because their finds are that good--thoughtful curation, iconic pieces alongside sleeper hits, and everything photographed so cleanly you can picture it in your space instantly. This is a great store! - Kashew team

What a wonderful bookshop. I started to call it little, but it is quite deep and full of an…read moreamazing collection of books. The owners will also tell you that they have thousands of books downstairs, so you should ask if you're looking for something. They probably have it and are willing to hunt it down for you. I always find a treasure when I'm at Snowball.

I stopped in last week and immediately noticed the shop looking brighter and cleaner and less…read morecluttered. Apparently it's under new management. They've closed the basement level and are sorting through the large inventory, curating what's on the shelves, and selling most of the used books for only $1-2 apiece. There's no longer a cat there, which is a little sad, but it does feel like a healthier environment and no longer a deterrent for folks with a cat allergy. I'm excited to see what's ahead for this friendly local business.

Friendly staff, great inventory and reasonable prices.read more

Pleasant staff, but not knowledgeable to tell the difference between a natural and synthetic stone.read more

Couldn't agree more that this is one of Hartville's hidden gems!…read more As soon as you walk through the door you'll be met with countless treasures to browse. The checkout counter is lit up with soft white lights and each little corner has something to see. Every time I come here there are new items; some that I haven't noticed before and some that have been newly set out. The staff is incredibly friendly and ready to answer any questions you may have -- if the owner is in, you might even hear a little bit of history about the building! Stop in for furniture, jewelry, antique items, household decorations, and so much more!

I broke an antique glass bowl that my wife had received from her grandma many years back. We…read morelooked everywhere and could not find the bowl, but we were able to find the exact bowl online, and in this little shop in Ohio. I am in Georgia. I reached out to the owners to see if they would be able to ship the bowl and they said they do indeed ship. They packaged it up nicely, kept in constant communication about when it would be mailed out, and provided the tracking number in a timely manner. In no time at all grandma's bowl was back in it's spot on the kitchen table...like it never even happened! Thanks! Great people to do business with!

Love this place! Great, already sorted thrifting. They have a drop off option similar to a Plato's…read morecloset, but you get paid once an item sells. It's more expensive than a normal thrift store, but already sorted through with is lovely. Would 10/10 recommend stopping in!

My family loves this place, we always stop by when we are in Orrville. I've gone there many times…read morewhen I forgot to pack something, and always find what I need (the most recent case - I forgot to pack a white tank top, so I walked in to New Orr Not and found what I needed in about five minutes). My husband got an amazing Indians jersey there one year that fit him perfectly. I like that it is smaller than many other thrift stores, because I usually get totally overwhelmed in places like Goodwill. However, some people might wish it was bigger. They always have such cute displays in the windows!

I'm in love with this store! They have a little bit of everything at reasonable prices…read more I had been on the hunt for a 1900s steam trunk. I searched local stores to no avail. The Bomb Shelter has a fair selection of trunks. I found exactly what I had in mind. I took a chance and asked for a discount. 10 or 15% was given and they loaded the trunk into my vehicle. Can't beat that. I'm in love with the selection of vintage couches, chairs, and dining sets. Definitely check this place out!

If you want to take a step back in time and see items, furniture, or other household objects, this…read moreplace has it all. It's all here...cameras, furniture, clothing, jewelry, and even cars! Looking for a unique decorative item for your house? This place has it! A must visit for anyone into vintage anything!