I lived at Evander Square for 4 years, almost since the complex opened. There are a handful tenants who've lived there longer than I have (and they seem to be fleeing rapidly), but not too many, so I know it pretty well. For most of my time I was a fairly happy tenant -- I probably would have rated it at 3 or even 4 stars. But a very frustrating experience has really soured me, and so it seemed like time for a review...
Pros:
The complex is very pretty and the apartments are nicely finished. Not luxurious exactly, but there is a nice modern style and some quality touches (stainless, granite, etc). There are plenty of great amenities -- pools, gyms, outdoor kitchen facilities, a little playground and a teeny tiny dog park. The location is pretty good -- you're officially in Celebration but quite close to I4 and 417. The pest situation is also manageable though there is a serious ant problem. I've been attacked a few times by fire ants and when I asked the front office about it they said "oh, we spray every week!" At this point, I think the ants like it....
Cons:
The mix of tenants here is kind of odd, and I think that your experience will depend on your luck (or lack thereof) with your immediate neighbors. Thankfully the folks in my building have always been really lovely (and the one weird guy who was always muttering under his breath kept to himself), but there are some real assholes who live here, and I'm sure living below them or next to them is no treat. And even if you don't live near them, you will still suffer from their asshole-ry because they treat the complex like garbage. Almost no one cleans up after their dog and people are routinely damaging the pools, the fire pit, the trash compactors, etc. We lost our recycling privileges because people would just dump piles of putrid garbage on the ground. Unfortunately, little is done about any of this -- every other week an email comes out from the leasing office (usually with the subject "dog feces"-- charming) reminding people to clean up after their pets, but it doesn't change anything and the piles just sit there for weeks and months. It's gross.
Parking is incredibly difficult lately -- show up after 8pm and you may have trouble finding a convenient spot. Landscaping has also gone downhill. They used to have a weekly service visit that lasted all day -- it was noisy but the grounds looked great. Now it seems very half-hearted and there are weeds and unruly patches of grass everywhere.
Lack of closet space is incredibly annoying (I hope you don't have a vacuum cleaner, or a Christmas tree, or a coat), and the cable and internet providers are limited and disappointing.
Also, the complex does not feel particularly connected to the Celebration community. We're far from downtown, and when I moved in I didn't get any information about amenities that are available to Celebration residents like resident IDs, the town intranet, or parking permits. Evander doesn't participate in any of the local events (like the porch and yard sale).
Staff used to be FANTASTIC, truly the best I've ever experienced -- so helpful, kind, thoughtful (leasing office and maintenance). In my last few months there was a lot of turnover and suddenly it all went downhill. I'd walk into the leasing office and see every desk empty, not a staff person to be found. Got a random call from an office "temp" about my renter's insurance but had all the wrong info. Maintenance requests taking forever to get fulfilled. Then they announced a change in building ownership, and it all made sense. No idea how it will be going forward, but I suspect things will continue to be rough.
Finally, my particular grievance: they decided they didn't want people to be month-to-month anymore (a very normal rental situation, particularly in this area) and instead of charging people an extra $100 for that "convenience", they DOUBLED the rent. Usurious and just insane. They were completely non-negotiable, wouldn't even consider my incredibly reasonable request.
Given the increase in housing options in Celebration (new buildings go up nearly every day), I'd strongly consider just about any of the other apartment and townhouse communities. read more