I took my daughter here for lunch after the driving range...a fun morning!…read moreShe had the Pickletini and loved it...all the way down to the vodka-soaked pickle! She got a quesadilla and loved that, too. I had the Ahi Tuna Tacos with a side of hush puppies and was just as good as the first time I tried it. The atmosphere is always comfortable and inviting and the staff is SO friendly, helpful and all smiles. They made this another OUTSTANDING lunch for me and my daughter!

Came here on a whim while in town for weekend. Remember when they built this as a habit burger…read more Had the crab cake sandwich - yum. Kid had cheese burger - it was fine - huge - of course it's frozen per the other review - you're at a fish place. Burger was fine. Coleslaw here is good and creamy. Service here is great. Place is clean and was easy in and out. Skill games - outdoor seating - bar with high tops. They had brunch - we didn't try that. I would come here again in a heart beat. I would try the ahi tuna tacos next time. You can split a sandwich here for extra $2. If you see the low score reviews - they are just being hard to be hard - this place is great.

Great breakfast and service. Brunch champagne flights were large and tasty…read more Bar was nice, tables at bar was truly different. I do wish they would have the game sound on instead of music.

6/22/25 Ate List:…read moreChicken Cordon Bleu Wrap - 7.4 Grew up in Erie and I feel like this spot is a like "not so hidden" underdog sort of gem. Whenever I've been here, it's never packed. But each time when im leaving we say, "yeah that was the right move." It's a little further from the Bayfront but it's a lot better than some of the options that are closer. The vibe here is great. So glad that this place has withstood so much turnover nearby. Food is consistently great. Lunch, dinner, even brunch is SOLID. This time, I did the Chicken Cordon Bleu Wrap with tots. Could've just been a silly assumption, did not expect the wrap to be toasted. Now this was on a 100 degree day, so wouldve personally preferred it to be cold this day but all good. Tots are dependable and great too. Wish I received a larger potion though. Was kind of surprise it wasn't like filling the plate and was more a scattered handful. Love this spot though. Great experience, great staff, will absolutely stop back in.

Amazing food. Good atmosphere and great service. They also have a great selection of craft beers.read more

Bartender on Friday nights is weak at best. Spends more time sitting than waiting on patrons. Be…read morebetter.

We sat at the bar for a quick meal and were greeted right away! Their drinks selection menu is…read moregreat and so nice that it's all or most libations are made in house. The brunch menu also has some unique finds especially for Erie!

Good food, friendly service, respectable spirits. Would definitely return! We sat at the bar and…read moreshared an app and meal along with some drinks. We didn't buy any bottles but really enjoyed the food.

Very decent food. Fish was not crispy, but the breading was excellent. It reminded me of the fried…read morefish that was always made for wakes and other events 35 years ago when my family had ties to Fairfield. The tower with the warning horn was in our side yard on Pelham Rd. It's so good to see the fireball doing amazing things to generate financial stability. The food really was solid. I'm looking forward to stopping again when we are in Erie to try other menu items. We bought the membership for $40 just to support the firehall. Had the fish been crispy, this would've been 5 stars hands down when rated across other similar establishments.

Food was ok fish was dry and not to my liking !waited for a table for about 30 minutes and food…read moreeven longer they were really busy even though we didn't sit in front of the door very drafty and cold in the room they need a heated vestibule so people seated near the door don't freeze !waitress was very kind and accommodatin

Dive bar with amazing wings. They also have amazing pizza logs that you can get tossed in butter…read moregarlic and sprinkled in parm. Omg soooo good. Great staff and never a bad meal. Thick creamy ranch. Mmmm butter garlic Cajun wings. Good cheese burgers too.

Best buffalo chicken wings in town. I would give a 5 star rating but you have to swim through a…read moreblue fog of cigarette smoke to grab your order.

Great out of the way place. My hamburger was great and the fresh cut fries were delicious. Our…read morewaitress was very nice and answered all our questions easily. Good selection at the bar. Friendly clientele. Very clean. Nice outdoor seating as well. Fun place!! We will definitely make a return trip!

I love going out to Fatboys! Food is great and the staff is always attentive and friendly. Noel has…read moreseveral bartenders on duty and there is never a wait for a drink!

This review would have been a 5/5 if large wet wipes or cloth napkins would have been available…read moreduring dinner for all the sticky fingers. The paper towel roll was cumbersome. First, it is not our first time at Underdog. We found it several years ago at its old location. We were between hangry, famished, and slightly dehydrated when arrived. Seaglass hunting works up an appetite. The smoked deviled eggs were delicious. The huge fried provolone were outstanding. As someone who drinks unsweetened ice tea daily, it was terrible. My (picky eater) dinner date had concerns about the BBQ sauce selection. No worries BBQ sauce came to the table in a caddy to pick your own sauce. She had selected the pulled pork mac & cheese. I had the ribs with cornbread, cornbread (no baked beans for me), and coleslaw. The coleslaw would have been better with oil & vinegar. The meat just fell off the bones. We remembered the cornbread as being good ... warm with honey butter OH MY! We brought some back to the hotel. The live performance from Shari Dixon was nice addition to dinner. These Piitsburghers will be back!

I want to preface by saying that I got the food to go. But the actual bbq was very very mid. coming…read morefrom someone that grew up in the south and spent the majority of my life there. Just very bland. The sides were absolutely amazing and the desert. The banana pudding delicious. The critique to the banana pudding is I wish there was more banana slices.