Okay, I've eaten here about 15 times and have read all the reviews so here are my two cents:
This place IS authentic. If you just want to eat a big awesome burrito in hamburg, you're probably better off at places like Jim and Q (don't want to be too specific in my naming of the competition - if you love mexican food and live in hamburg, these two names should be clear as to what i am referring to). Pikosito is not Tex-Mex, it really has an authentic flare.
**There are a ton of new additions to the menu as of around March 2014 - so go try them out!!**
The one thing I will say about the place to start off my review is that there is really a lot of inconsistency here. It isn't always BAD inconsistency, but things are not always the same there as they were during the previous visit
Drinks: Awesome mojitos and, in general, the margaritas are awesome too. last time we went though, the margs were SO salty that my boyfriend could barely finish his. ... so, in general, delicious, but also a bit of a gamble... inconsistency.
Appetizers:
the nachos ARE delicious. But, the cheese is definitely out of a can. The beans and jalapenos on top make it to die for, and it TASTES GOOD. Yes, it is cheese from can, but if you accept that for what it is, you will definitely enjoy them.
As mentioned above, there are a ton of new menu additions and we recently tried the Chilaquiles as an appetizer. There are no eggs or chicken on them... it is basically like nachos but BETTER and at least in the dish, you're not getting cheese sauce but rather real melted cheese. Then there is a mix of green and red salsa on the chips. it was SPICY but everyone in our party enjoyed it. but... SPICY!
we also once had the chili cheese fries.... they were also really yummy but also with this cheese sauce from a can. so if you are totally against the canned sauce, then I wouldn't recommend.
main dishes:
Entomatadas: I love! definitely not spicy, so if you are lookin for spicy, look somehwere else. but the sauce has such an awesome flavor and teh big plate of three entomatadas, big salad, and plenty of mexican-style rice will DEF have you feeling full.
Enchiladas: I've had these three times... here is where the inconsistency comes in again. I thought there were delicious every time, but the flavor of the sauce definitely changes. also, I've read in past reviews that some visitors found the sauce to be way to spicy... i love spicy food so maybe im not susceptible but i know a good friend who ate there following my RAVING reviews, and he LOVES spicy food and said the enchiladas were so spicy that they were not edible. i guess this is a sign to me that they really have changed the sauce recipe a lot. so my recommendation here is: stick with what works! stop changing the recipe!
Quesadillas: I've never ordered this. it looks insanely boring to me. BUT my german friends always order it when we go and they LOVE it, so I guess I can recommend that too.
Service: inconsistent and depends on the day and the server. if you have the guy behind the bar serving you at all (he wears glasses) , you'll have an awesome time. other than that, it is a gamble. there are always new faces there and the people i used to see don't work there anymore. really high fluctuation. generally that is a bad sign.... but if you ask me, especially in germany, I'd really rather have GREAT food with so-so service, than the other way around!
All in all I would say it is definitely worth trying out!! I know I will definitely be back a ton. :-) read more