El Bagelero checks all the boxes. Clean store, good music, with friendly and attentive staff. Bagels have a hard exterior with a plush and airy interior. Cream cheese is thick but easy to spread. Good variety of sandwiches but not too many options. If you come here and don't like anything about this place it's probably your fault. read more

Solid bagels. Delicious sandwiches. There's a new comer in the bagel scene in wicker. Bagelero is legit, with prices to match. Some note: -high level of craft -ample salmon on el Classico - coffee is hot and good read more

I frickin love this place! Chicago needs to step up their bagel game and this place is doing just that. The bagel sandwiches here are dang good. They're loaded, fresh, stacked, and poppin with flavor. I love their jalapeno cheddar bagel and their El Classico sandwich. Their doughnuts are only $3 and are truly delicious!!! I recommend the strawberry. Everything here is affordable too. The staff here is also friendly and personable, they truly scream that Midwest Nice. I love them. Just go here! You won't regret it. read more

See all

Amazing breakfast bagels and donuts!!! I shared an El Machismo (chorizo, egg, jalapeno) bagel sandwich (on an everything bagel), and WOW. I loved that the chorizo to egg ratio is heavier on the chorizo so you can appreciate the full savory flavor of the meat. The egg was fluffy, and the bagel was so fresh!! The bagel's texture was fluffy and a little crispy on the outside, with good everything seasoning. It came out hot and was the perfect texture, temperature, and flavor all around. I was very satisfied. I also shared an horchata glazed donut, and it was also very good! Fluffy texture and yummy glaze. The service was friendly and efficient! We didn't wait long and there was a steady line of people who came through. I'll definitely be back to try more! read more

See all

I had a great experience here! I ordered a sausage, egg, and cheese on an Asiago bagel along with an iced vanilla latte and both were absolutely amazing. Everything was fresh and flavorful. The line was pretty long but it was definitely worth the wait. The employees were friendly, welcoming and kept things moving as smoothly as possible. If you're looking for an awesome bagel spot in the Bucktown/Wicker Park area, I definitely recommend stopping by. I'll definitely be back to try one a donut! read more

El Bagelero - Sausage, egg and cheese on an Asiago bagel - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Came here right when it opened and it immediately filled up as we were ordering. I guess this is a pretty hot spot. They have a variety of bagels you can choose from when you pick a sandwich, including everything, egg, cheese, rosemary, poppy seed, and a few more. The sandwich is generous and very tasty. There's some seating but most people opted for takeout. Would definitely come here again for breakfast. read more

See all

Soggy bagels and a staff that either ignores you or gives you a wisecrack response when asking a simple question. I will not be back. read more

Good bagels! Order at the counter and take away or dine in, acres from Margis candies. I enjoyed the cold pressed OJ, looking forward to trying the breakfast sandwiches next time. read more

See all

Pretty small spot, ideal for a pick up order but there is seating if you want to eat it inside. The bagels get the job done but it's kinda crazy how much better the machismo bagel sandwich is than the other ones. I really highly recommend the machismo. The staff are really kind. They don't have sriracha here BUT they kindly gave me a salsa to have with my bagel and tried their best to make me happy hahaha. Honestly most of the bagel sandwiches I've had (like the BEC) are really plain and NEED sriracha or something to give it more flavor. But somehow the machismo doesn't need it. Like I said before, get the machismo lol. Fair prices. Seriously is amazing to have this bagel spot here now, it's definitely filled a niche that this neighborhood was missing. read more

See all

Tried 2 bagels and a burrito this weekend.. the prices and fillings are solid but disappointed in the bagels and tortilla as they were soggy / steamed texture. They should invest in a toaster and toast the bagels before loading them up, as soft steamed chewy bagel sandwiches aren't very appetizing. Same with the burrito, that outer shell needs more structure otherwise your burrito is falling apart. The everything bagel was pretty skimp on the everything topping but jalapeño cheddar was good. read more

El Bagelero - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Bagels have a weird aftertaste. I don't think I'll be back. It was an almost a dirt taste. Prices seemed ok. Space is pretty minimal. I wouldn't eat there. Felt a little grubby. People were nice enough. I didn't try the coffee but I'm guessing it's the same as the food. Pretty average. read more

See all

I was finally able to stop in before they close and tried: - Chocolate Donut - El Machismo The donut was pretty good, but the El Machismo was standout. I had it on the regular bagel and it came with chorizo, egg, jalapeños, and a mayo based sauce. I would definitely get it again. The staff was also super friendly, so wanted to shout that out. read more

See all

Amazingly friendly staff and a great addition to Bucktown as we were missing good bagels!!

7.5/10. Solid bagel spot but you can definitely find better spots throughout the city. Everything bagel with butter, could have used some more butter. I'll be back to try some of their sandwiches. read more

El Bagelero - Everything Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Can I get a hell yeah for finally finding a good bagel in Chicago? HELL YEAH! El Bagelero is a small shop offers a unique twist to your standard bagel shop that I didn't know I was missing. Order the Las Carnitas on a Jalapeño Cheddar bagel with Chive Cream cheese. Thank me later. read more

El Bagelero - Las Carnitas - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Really loved El Bagelero. I got a breakfast sandwich and it was honestly amazing -- super fresh, great flavor, and just really well done. They also had donuts, and I'm so glad I tried one. Perfect texture, perfect sweetness, and apparently they switch up the flavors, which is fun. Super chill spot, good service (you order at the counter, there's some seating as well), and just an easy, solid place for breakfast. I'll definitely be back. read more

El Bagelero is a new breakfast spot at Western & Armitage across from Margie's, which opened just after I moved from Logan Square so I only visit when I go to my old workout classes. It's a great spot for a quick breakfast. The vibe is very clean/new with a small amount of seating. They also offer pickup. Food: I've had the BEC on an everything bagel and I tried the Chorizo breakfast burrito and Steak & Egg breakfast taco. The BEC bagel was hot and fresh. However, I thought the bagel was pretty bland. Might be because it was toasted, but I didn't think it had much flavor. The breakfast burrito was amazing and the breakfast taco was solid. They load up on egg and potatoes for the burrito and the chorizo was solid. Salsa has decent flavor, wasn't overly spicy, and also a tad watered down. Being so close to Humboldt Park, I figured that the breakfast burrito and tacos would be better than the bagels and that is the case for me. I will have to try anlther bagel next time. Coffee is a tad watered down with not much flavor and it's $4 so on the pricey side when you can find better coffee in the neighborhood for that price. Prices are a tad high for breakfast at $10 for a breakfast sandwich and $10-15 for the breakfast burrito. But cheaper than Electric Mud/Cafe Tola and THRD's breakfast tacos and burrito. I pay ~$8 for a bacon and egg sandwich at Do Rite in the West Loop. Also, I thought Tilly Bagel Shop in the West Loop was slightly better quality. Do Rite and Tilly are both chains though. But El Bagelero does not skimp on the portion sizes. Portion sizes are big. Service is adequate. Overall, El Bagelero doesn't knock my socks off, but it is a great addition to the neighborhood! read more

See all

Breakfast burrito was quick, fresh, and delicious!! It also came as 2 smaller burritos rather than 1 giant one which I appreciate. Service was great too. Excited to go back and try the bagels! read more

Ordered through Uber Eats so I cannot comment on service or ambiance, but these bagel sandwiches are amazing! I got the chicken sausage egg and cheese with chive cream cheese. It was supposed to be on a sesame, but I received an Asiago which wasn't ideal but still great read more

El Bagelero - Sausage Egg & Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Incredible coffee, bagels, and Donas. Some of the best breakfast tacos I've ever had too read more

El Bagelero - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Love this twist on a breakfast bagel sandwich! Everything had great flavor and tasted freshly made. We will definitely be back when in Chicago. read more

El Bagelero - El Machismo Bagel Sandwich & Las Carnitas - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

In 2025 there is an article that came up that said this was "the year of the bagel" for Chicago. After many decades of mediocre bagel options in the city, this year, we've seen a true explosion of quality bagels, and delicious options at these locations. I've gotta say this is one of the best I've had so far in the Midwest. I got the bacon, egg and cheese, and El Machismo, which were both incredibly good. The actual restaurant itself clearly has a vibe of to-go, but does have some tables if you want to sit down. Everyone was incredibly nice. But I love most about the bagel is their ability to have a nice slightly crunchy outside with soft and just chewing enough inside. I cannot wait to return. read more

El Bagelero - Bacon egg and cheese bagel - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I was expecting this place to be overrated because of social media, but it was so good and lived up to the hype. El machismo bagel sandwich was so good I ate the entire thing even though it was a big serving. I haven't had a bagel sandwich like that anywhere, highly recommend. The chocolate donut was incredible--light and doughy, perfectly sweet. Unfortunately, the cafe con leche was really bad. The staff was nice. It was really busy, so be prepared to wait during peak morning times on the weekend. read more

El Bagelero - El machismo, chocolate donut, café con leche - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This place is TOP NOTCH! Delicious food, damn the burrito!!!! So good. Also thoughtful, efficient but chill, no fuss service. And kind people, good people. Highly recommend! Sry for the pic we ate everything lol but 4get the pic just go yourself homie read more

El Bagelero - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

So far I have had a bacon egg and cheese, and a everything bagel with cream cheese and the bagels are very good. The everything bagel comes with a lot of seeds but I'd like them to add more garlic to the mix. My boyfriend tried the breakfast burrito which was huge and delicious. So excited to have a local bagel spot now! read more

El Bagelero - Bacon egg and cheese on a jalapeno cheddar bagel - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Solid bagels. Decent bagel options, decent quality, good selection of spreads, good menu of more complex offerings. No gluten-free options, which is unfortunate but obviously won't matter for most. Service is usually friendly and timely, though it can get a little crowded at peak times which increases wait. Not a tier of bagel place I'd brag to New Yorkers about or insist visitors try, but a safe option if you're a local in need of a relatively fast and solid breakfast or lunch. read more

This has been on my list to stop by for a while - so glad I did! Very friendly service immediately upon walking through the door. Ordered an everything bagel with sausage, egg, and cheese. The sandwich was ready in no time! I took it to go, and the bagel was still hot when I got a chance to eat! My new favorite bagel shop in Chicago, perfect size, tasty sausage, fresh eggs, and the chipotle mayo really added a nice kick. Looking forward to trying more of the sandwiches or tacos! read more

El Bagelero - Sausage Egg & Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

The carnitas bagel sandwich was okay. Plain bagels were good but nothing special. Service was great, it's a smaller place but there's tables to sit. read more

This place has pushed its way to the top of my favorite local breakfast spots! We really needed a good bagel place, and El Bagelero is it. The bagel sandwiches are great! But the real best menu item is the breakfast burrito--perfect for splitting between two people (because it's wrapped in two halves!). Everybody is really friendly, and the food comes fast. Great ambience too! read more

El Bagelero - Pickup counter and order station - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Really solid bagel sandwich - el machismo! Good breakfast taco too. Nice service as well. read more

El Bagelero - El Machismo Bagel Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Delicious donuts; Horchata donut hits it out of the park every time! The strawberry sprinkle is a taste of nostalgia for me. Their cake donuts are an also pleasant delight. The changes in flavors adds a little excitement to showing up too. Let's just say I go nuts for their donuts :3 Always a pleasure grabbing a breakfast burrito too. They are juicy yet not messy, and have a good balance of flavors. Their salsa on the side is excellent for dipping! Also a newer development of bagel dogs! I enjoy the poppy seed one. Try El Bagelero! Especially if you're close, it's worth a visit :) read more

"Chicago isn't know for bagels", said everyone before they tried El Bagelero. absolutely delicious bagel sandwiches and great service. got to interact with the manger Austin and he is top notch. highly recommend! read more

We came in and ordered a bacon egg and cheese and the classic (bagel lox). Both were amazing. The staff working there are also very nice and friendly. Service was great, we messed up our order but they still fixed it for us even though it was our fault. Forgot to take pictures sadly :(( next time I'll remember read more

Cute new place for a quick bite. The bagels are tasty, the donuts are fresh and the breakfast burrito was GREAT. Salsa for the burrito was also yummy. Portions are good for the price and will definitely be adding this into the breakfast rotation. read more

I was in the area, walking around, desperate for a bagel. Lo and behold, I turn the corner and I see this establishment. "Wonderful", I think to myself "exactly what I wanted". Well, usually I'm met with disappointment in these situations but I walked in happy and left even happier. Asiago bagel was soft, toasty and delicious. Latte was soft, toasty, and delicious. Service is incredible, really cool atmosphere too. Keep it up!! read more

Best breakfast sando I've had in YEARS! I got a bacon, egg, and cheese on sesame and my husband got "the classic" on rosemary -- 10/10 cannot recommend more!! read more

Went to the soft open today. Rosemary bagels were great as were the tacos. The bagel sandwiches were good but just a standard bagel sandwich. Waiting for the donas to start being served! read more

So glad to have this place in the neighborhood! I got an egg & cheese on a jalapeño cheddar bagel and it was delish. Super busy on a Saturday morning, but service was still fairly quick and staff was very nice. Didn't get a donut this time, but some of the flavors looked very interesting and yummy (apple cider, churro, horchata) read more

First sip of coffee was not favorable but that's on me because I was vaguely about it since it said cafe con leche normally they make this pre sweetened. A quick redemption when I bit into the B.E.C corn tortilla taco. That is the best taco I've ever had. I eat good food, and cook good food so I have high standards. I only wish I had gotten another. You got a loyal customer from me. Hats off to the chef. read more

Great find near the Western Blue Line stop. Big variety of bagels. I had the Cuban, was delicious and filling. Friend had the breakfast burrito, divided into two tortillas for easy eating. Friendly staff too! read more