I have come back here over and over! I like the service, menu and coziness. You rule! Subway isn't…read morefor me anymore. Yesterday I tried a lunch special. I was licking my lips! Yow! I will bring my buddy here nxt month. The hours are very convenient as is the location - has a city bus stop out front.

Bagels were great. Breakfast sandwiches were delicious and fresh made to order! Would go againread more

This place is absolutely adorable first of all. They staff were super friendly and helpful making…read morerecommendations and letting me take my sweet time making a decision between all the amazing options. The bagels were delicious! Personally, I would have liked a heavier hand on the cream cheese... but that's my only complaint. My coffee was also excellent. Got half a dozen to go as well so I could try more flavors!

The Blue House Bagel Co. was another business I had unreasonably gargantuan expectations for. I…read morehave wanted to visit for a very long time, and heard extremely positive things about it. Never mind its awards. So when I finally went this morning, I was afraid the bar was set at a level it couldn't possibly live up to. Somehow, it still blew me away. It's an adorable building (yes, it is a blue house). The side door main entrance was open and clearly marked, and then the layout inside was so well thought out and it couldn't have been easier to navigate as a first time customer. I had a pretty good idea of wanted I wanted ahead of time, and was just hoping that even though it was a weekday, they weren't already sold out of anything (I know they get extremely busy and have a very devoted following). They had been posting a lot about their Egyptian dukkah bagels. I love dukkah (they use cardamom, sesame seed, clove, paprika, fennel & E.V.O.O.), so I ordered that as my bagel choice for their Blue House sandwich. They have many brilliant sandwich options as well as the option to build your own. They also have many house made schmears, pastries and other goodies. They even do stuffed bagels. I believe they are a completely, if not predominantly, sourdough based bakery. So my sandwich, the Blue House, had egg, white cheddar, heirloom tomato, greens, and herb aioli. Watching them make the sandwich was incredible and a treat in itself. The level of care and craftsmanship they put into each sandwich is rare. I could tell which one was mine and just had a blast watching! Very happy foodie. The bagel was toasted just enough, but the chewy sourdough texture wasn't lost. It was a remarkable bagel. One of the best I have ever had. I hesitate to call it the best after just one visit, but it was good enough to entertain that thought. The sourdough recipe also made it extremely light and it agreed with my finicky health/dietary needs better than any other bagel I've had in years. The topping ratios were just perfect. Rarely do bagel sandwiches with an aioli have enough, and they put plenty without making it overly saucy. Just brilliant sandwich construction, which really is not taken seriously enough. I brought a French toast bagel to my mom with a tub of their apple & honey cream cheese, which I tasted of course. Whipped and super light. Flavor unlike any other schmear I've had before. It was an incredible flavor. My mind really was blown. Everyone working was cheerful, warm, and friendly. It was a wonderful environment, and from what I had seen on social media it seems like it's always that way and I great place to be with passionate people behind it. I honestly see it being very hard to go to another bagel shop any time soon. This was just an overall fabulous experience. Every aspect. I cannot wait to go back. I will say it had very steady business around 8:45 on a Wednesday, so be prepared for them to be busy.

Craving a bagel breakfast sandwich and Google sent me here. They did not disappoint. The bagel was…read moreso good. The chocolate chip cookies 4/$3.00 were a winner. Freshly baked that morning and you could tell. FYI. They use real eggs for the sandwiches. This minor detail is very important to me when it comes to breakfast sandwiches. I cannot do premade egg. The guy was super nice Cute little place for a quick bite or take it to go. French vanilla coffee was also on point. Nice and fresh.

I have been wanting to stop and finally did with an EVERYTHING appetite. Nice small place, rather…read morequiet inside with one older gentleman who seemed like a regular. The Bagel shop is in a newer developed space along Route 4 (aka busy Farmington Avenue). The odd thing I couldn't get through my head was how the site was designed. The back of the shops face out to Farmington Ave and the store fronts and parking are in the rear? Usually it's the other way around. Terrible advertising for the businesses. Just the same, I managed to stop, ordered two Everything bagels with White Fish spread and a large dark roast coffee. I was met with "...white what...". I repeated and added, "...its Jewish thing, which is delicious on a bagel. " Sorry we don't have that." Hmmm . Well I'll have a thin smear of creamed cheese, which they had plenty, on my two toasted Everything bagels. I prepped my coffee and in a flash the bagels were packaged and bagged. I was given a "have a nice day". Get in my car, unwrapped the First bagel, ahh an Everything. Later the second was unwrapped back a my home office and a Toasted Sesame Seed jumped out at me. No offense Sesame lovers, I was hugely disappointed my simple order got twisted. And to top off my dissatisfaction NO WHITE FISH SPREAD!

Great variety, service and convenient locations. Bagels are always fresh and delicious and a great…read morevariety of cream cheeses.

I have enjoyed Fancy Bagels for many years. Most recently I have been stopping by on the occasional…read moreWednesday to pickup for my work tradition of Bagel Wednesday. Service is always speedy. It is your trust bagel shop with few tables and chairs and the beautiful wafting smell of bacon on the griddle. They always have a good playlist going and the bagels are very good. A lot of flavor options with many cream cheeses. Sandwhiches, wraps etc, they have it all. I find the value to be pretty fair considering some prices in the area

Best bagel sandwiches in the area. It is definitely my favorite spot for a bagel and they are…read morepretty fast with their service even if it is pretty busy.

Visiting my Mom and was hungry. I looked up bagels and Yelp and found Isaac's. Glad I did. Place…read morewas bustling. They had cornmeal bagels which intrigued me. Got inebriated with cream cheese and it was great. Bought a dozen to bring home. The mozzarella bagel was unique and very yummy. If you're in the area stop by you will not be disappointed.

Bagels are always great! Service is fast and staff are always friendly and professional. Orders are…read morealways ready when promised. My go to breakfast spot!

My normal go to bagel place was randomly closed while I was visiting in town so I was super bummed…read more My friend found this place so we decided to try it and man am I glad we did. They had lots of bagels to choose from - regular and "fancy" ones too. I am pretty basic so I got a sesame seed bagel. They also have lots of options of what kind of sandwich you want. I got an egg and cheese and a hash-brown side. We also got coffees. I was bummed about the other place I like because they always have some kind of fun flavor coffee until I saw this selection!!! Holy moley - so many flavor choices! I got the Yankee Doodle flavor which is basically hazelnut and cinnamon. Yum!!! Our bagels were ready pretty quickly - we grabbed a seat and dug in. It was Delicious. The bagel was nice and toasted on the outside and so soft on the inside!

Nice clean place, good variety of bagels and pastries. I had breakfast sandwich with coffee which…read morewas great. Friendly staff

We stopped by for a quick bagel on a late Sunday morning. We did not realize this was a chain,…read morewhich were were trying to avoid. Just to order was a 10 min wait and another 10 to get a well done bagel with scallion cream cheese. Bagel...meh...very chewy but no bite or crunch. They said they were out of fresh brewed iced tea but we noticed while waiting for bagel it was available. Tables wobbly and not clean. Not impressed by the bagel or store and would pass in the future. Plenty of parking in very busy strip mall.

We got the jalapeño cheddar egg and cheese bagel from Cohen's Bagels in Madison and it was…read moreabsolutely phenomenal. The bagels are made in house and you can really taste the difference. The service is always great and it's such a cute little shop with delicious bagels. Definitely worth stopping by!

I popped into the Wesleyan Bookstore to grab a coffee and breakfast from Story & Soil, my favorite…read morecoffee shop in Middletown. I was startled to learn they'd been ousted by the University earlier this year for unknown reasons, and this new bagel shop took its place. I loved the previous cafe, so I was very hesitant to try the replacement but, hey, I'm open to new things. Unfortunately, it doesn't even come close to the quality and service of S&S. They always offered delicious and creative holiday beverages, and this new place didn't even know how to make a cortado (Starbucks even offers this now so it seems like it would be common knowledge). I tried to explain how to make it, although I probably explained it poorly, and instead of cortado, I got an overfoamed latte, which tasted weak even though they charged me for an extra shot of espresso for some reason. I returned it, which I almost never do, and the barista was very nice about it. I got a cold brew instead cause how could you mess up cold brew? Welp, it tasted like chilled hot brewed coffee (you know, the kind of coffee that tastes like cigarettes?) that just went through nitro infusion, not actually cold brewed coffee, which typically tastes smooth and not bitter. I also ordered an avocado toast, and it was very plain on seemingly store-bought bread, but the price was also pretty low so it matched the quality. The main saving grace is that it's in the most adorable bookstore and gift shop, so the ambience is very nice. Cohen's does have another location in Madison, so they are veteran cafe owners, but they are new to this area so maybe they just need to work out some kinks before things start running more smoothly.