I stopped here for some salmon. I was amazed at this place. Inside they have bins of whole fresh…read morecaught fish. There are tongs and plastic bags for you to pick what you want. After picking, you can go around back and they will clean it for you. The salmon was delicious, nice, fresh and delicious. I've had their shrimp and flounder as well and they too were delicious. The staff is friendly and helpful. I love this place. This is now the fish market I go to.

I have come here for many years. Always fresh and delicious. Kevin is the best - always makes…read morerecommendations and tells me to remember my herbs for the best taste! Love their fish and always is fresh. From clams to tuna, flounder for holidays and shrimp to make multiple dishes it's my go to. Highly recommend!

We recently ordered 3 x 1.5lbs fresh lobsters stuffed with crabmeat. Our first time at this market…read more EXCELLENT! The guys were so friendly and helpful. We will definitely be returning.

Always fresh and delicious! They know their fish!! Try ordering hot meal...they're amazing!!!read more

Today's visit, to their Wantagh store, was just perfect. Mozzarella was creamy fresh, delightful…read more Semolina bread was right out of the oven, warm and tasty. While I have had issues with prepared foods at other locations, these fresh made two items were supurb, top notch. Nice employees, too. Have to give credit when credit is due.

It pains me to write this review but enough is enough, ordered two hero's and wings for the Super…read moreBowl and I should of not given them a second and third chance but this time was something you couldn't even make up. I completely get that the weather was extremely cold but to pick up the hero's and them to be completely frozen to the point of me having to not only try and thaw them by placing them close to the heater (which only made them worse) but having to cut them because of the lazy employees that work there just can't finish doing a simple task I also had to throw out all the tomatoes because they were frozen solid and the lettuce started to brown. I'm not the only person who this happened to and when I went to return the boards I was hoping to see the manager but they only had young people working there and they didn't deserve my anger. This place has become a joke of a once proud establishment, they now even outsource there bread because they can't meet the demand. Stay away and go to other places because this place is a disaster!!

Went here with a couple of my boys to get some nice seafood heard this place was very good so I…read moredecided to give it a try. For appetizers, we got the raw oysters which were a 10/10, the clams oreganata, and the fried calamari. Not to mention we all got a cup of their outstanding lobster bisque to add to the gluttony. Everything we had was phenomenal. As an entrée, I had the house special panko breaded flounder with pesto laid on top of buttered up mashed potatoes with mussels placed beautifully around the dish 10/10 I would eat this once a week if I could. Desserts were pretty basic so we decided to skip Can easily recommend this spot to anyone who likes seafood. Service was a little slow but our waitress was extremely nice, the place is pretty small but nice with a comfortable vibe.

Busy spot since we had to wait about 30 minutes on a weeknight to be seated. We were told we could…read morewait at the bar but that was just a countertop around which we could stand and wait. Service was somewhat slow although our server was very friendly and helpful. We ordered the stuffed lobster and fish & chips. The food was a bit too salty for our liking. The fish for the fish and chips was soaked in oil and soggy. The whole thing fell apart as soon as I touched it. I was craving the traditional, crispy golden crust so this was a massive disappointment.

The service is superb- they are very sweet and very friendly. They helped me choose my meal when I…read morecouldn't decide. The food itself was tasty but definitely a bit salty. Not the whole dish but certain dishes so there was a bit of inconsistency there. The seafood was fresh but those julienne veggies were the bomb!! I would give this place another try easily. Their $12 lunch specials are a good deal.

Service is friendly and fast. Food is delicious and fresh. We love ordering their seafood salad…read more It's delicious. Store is always clean.

This place is huge! This place has every food item you can think of! I came here for the first time…read moremonths ago and tried the chicken noodle soup. I was absolutely in love! Since then I have returned back twice and no longer seem to find that soup. Which is unfortunate. I did try to branch out and try out the different items by the deli counter. They were good but I need more seasoning than what was given and I'm not talking about spicy lol overall service was great. I will try again to see if they bring the noodle soup & open to trying other items!

Today I made the mistake of purchasing $29.00 a pound of what was supposed to be Dry Day Boat…read morescallops. I am no Gordon Ramsey but I can tell when I have been duped. The scallops were small which should have been my first clue. I made sure the were dry and my Ramsey meter went off an it said these at best are thawed and not the Dry Boat I paid for . The scallops were spitting while being cooked and i knew they were crap. attached is a picture of this garbage . Along with this I bought the last slice of Icelandic Flounder I was told it was not frozen, I think they mean now that horrible fish was 24.00 a pound, my suggestion is avoid the fish at this place. As I was cleaning the stove from the mess these wet scallops made a song jumped into my head. Instead of Amore I have edited it to say no Amore for fish .

Very awesome place great seafood huge selection amazing great things that I want to eat and cook…read morealways

I go in a few months ago and buy $24 worth of tuna. The owner said minimum credit card charge is…read more$25 so I had him charge me $25. Fast forward to today, I go in and try and purchase the same amount and he tells me he can't take credit cards for this purchase as he looses money. There is a sign right in front of me saying he charges 3% for credit card so I pointed that out. He replied that he still takes a loss and I'm getting all this Tuna for $24 and cash only. It's clear he doesn't want to report it and pay taxes on it. Horrible business practices and he lost a customer. Just a tiny little dump with an owner who isn't too bright. AVOID AT ALL COSTS

Fruits and vegetables are great. Just like when i was younger , growing up in Brooklyn. Chicken…read morebreasts are great! Their bread............. THE BEST AROUND!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Buy 3 loaves of semolina, one to munch on walking around and 2 to take home when youre done.

I am not usually someone who writes negative reviews but while this supermarket chain is fabulous…read moreand this location is a delight to shop in, I unfortunately have had the experience of being sold expired food from this location on three separate occasions over the past year or two. And I have been going here for well over 10 years, and not once has something like this happened until very recently. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy shopping at North Shore Farms and appreciate how the store has a variety of products I can't find anywhere else. The store is also always well-stocked and clean, and it's easy to find things. The bakery and hot food sections are also stellar; though the variety of hot food has decreased somewhat over the years they do still updated with new offerings so there is something for everyone. However, I am baffled and disappointed by the fact that this location has put out and sold customers, such as myself, expired items in the refrigerated section in the middle of the store. Just yesterday, June 13th, I bought a ricotta cheese which was in this section and had a "sell before" date of July 8th; upon taking it home it tasted spoiled and we immediately had to discard it. I'm not sure when the item was packed, but I have a gut feeling that the sell by date listed on the box was inaccurate. The other two times I experienced this were also with cheese, as well as with cold cuts. I highly recommend that this location look into ways in which they can prevent spoilage of items from the refrigerated section and ensure that their customers are getting food that is fresh and well-maintained. UPDATE (6/15/2026): Make that *four* times. I bought fresh fish from the seafood counter and was about to cook it last night however, when I unwrapped it from the parchment paper that it had been stored in, I was hit with a significantly rancid smell and I think I was sold fish that was not fresh either. I'm not sure what's wrong, maybe the temperature of the refrigerators in the store aren't high enough, but I really hope that it can be corrected soon because otherwise this location is risking losing a customer in me. Which is a shame because this has been a mainstay store that I have been going to for years and I don't want to risk my health being in danger due to buying spoiled food that is being marketed as "fresh."