It is very limited in the local area to find made to order fresh pizza other than big chain stores,…read moreso I was delighted to find blind frog cafe, very nice looking inside with tvs and ice cream, nice atmosphere, I always try a business 2 or 3 times before making reviews, 1st time I went in they had a few people at tables 6 total customers, so not very busy,order 2 personal 10in pizza 1 cheese 1 meat lovers for takeout, very expensive at 9.99 & 14.00 compared to other pizzeria in proximity radius (I don't mind paying for good quality food if it's perfect) again it's a tourist spot so I guess they can charge higher prices, pretty quickly I got the pizzas hot and ready before I could finish my beverage, counter girl was very nice and polite (owner daughter I found out), finally got home look under pizza an was burnt charred like they had the oven way to hot, ok not a deal breaker but I would have not served it to a customer, pizza taste was ok for being burnt on bottom, nothing to rave about, I always give business benefit of doubt maybe they had a bad day or just not on point that day... So I figured a week later I would try again 2nd time, to see if was same or better or worse this time I went in, no customer whatsoever in business, ordered same, 2 10in personal 1 cheese & 1 meatlovers an 1 beverage came to $30.04. Best pizza in the area hands down

We heard that this recently opened and had to go check it out…read more I'm really glad that there's another restaurant in the area. It will be a great spot for the ATV'ers and tourists that are coming back from cabins and rides. The service was great with no issues in seating, ordering, or help - they were very nice! The food was cooked to order and was quite tasty too. The spicy dip was definitely my fave. Will definitely come back soon for a mid-Sunday lunch!

This place reminded me of our favorite pizza place back home. It was good and prices were…read morereasonable. The buffet comes with lasagna and spaghetti so make sure you ask your server to bring you out some since it's not on the buffet. We would have gone back but it's closed on Sundays and we had to head home.

The food is good, the service is typically good. Charlie's Specialty Pizza is tasty. We usually go…read morefor that and the lasagna. Their lasagna is hearty, nice flavor. Salad bar is typical. The wings were ok. It's a casual pizza place. Locals love it.

Great food and great service. I'm not usually a fan of pizza but this is great, perfect amount of…read moresauce and toppings and a unique crust. I loved the potato soup and chili.

The food is really good, but the service is very slow and the cleanliness is severally lacking. I…read moresuggest take out and add 20 minutes onto their quoted wait time, unless you want to hang out in an overly cluttered hole in the wall restaurant with with multiple staff's kids running around like crazy.

Great food! I think they have the best buffalo wings I have had. Nice and crispy. My husband loved…read morethe steak sandwich and I had the biggest cheeseburger ever. We didn't try the cakes but by the looks of them it's a must have.

Food is not bad, service is a slow. This is one of those places that has excellent reviews from…read morethe locals because it is the only game in town. Wife said fish sandwich was good, son said bacon cheeseburger was somewhere between ok and good. I waited 40 minutes for a 7 inch pizza that was a 7 out of ten flavor wise but was semi- warm when it finally made it to the table and all the sausage fell off when you picked it up due to no cheese over it to hold it down. Loaded Cheese fries were decent but could have stood additional toppings....should just call them cheese fries. We were going to split a piece of cake which was reviewed highly but we ordered it and nearly 10 minutes later still no cake soooo we cancelled the cake and paid the nearly 60 dollar bill and hit the door. If you have to be here I guess it beats McDonald's.

Great carry out pizza and very friendly owners. We ordered thin crust medium BBQ chicken and a…read moresupreme and it was plenty for two people. Definitely a gem in Oneida.

Some of the best pizza I've had! The dough, the sauce & even the sausage are all made in house and…read morethey are all gooooood! The crust is crispy on the outside and chewy inside, seriously can't rave more about this pizza! My husband had wings which were equally as delicious. The owner also has this homemade Alabama white BBQ sauce that is out of this world. I'll drive it off the way to come back here in the future. I hope this local, made with love small business continues to thrive!

We stopped in yesterday for lunch on our way to The Mint, this was some of the best pizza I've ever…read morehad. The crust is thin, has the perfect crunch, the cheese and sauce were both delicious! I wish I lived closer.

Delicious pizza & sandwiches! Great service. I suggest calling ahead to place your order as they…read morecan be busy & pizzas take about 20 mins to cook. I recommend!!

Quick good pizza that was cheap after we went hiking. Not the greatest ambiance but that's not…read morewhat we wanted. Good food to get us back on the trails. Good service as well.

The pizza and pasta are delicious!! Always clean, and customer service is always great.read more

Service was great. Food was good too! Leaving my first yelp review because this place deserves more…read morestars than it has.

We were welcomed like a good friend! We were explained the special! Very good food! Clean bathrooms…read morewere a plus!

Brooklyn Brothers is an absolute Italian food gem! The pizza is incredible, the pasta is fantastic,…read moreand those homemade rolls? I could honestly make a meal out of those alone! The atmosphere has that classic East Coast neighborhood pizzeria feel--casual, laid-back, and completely unpretentious. It's a comfortable sit-down spot with full table service, where everything comes out fresh and surprisingly quick. No frills, no fuss, just really good Italian food done right! The pizza crust deserves its own standing ovation--perfectly crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and absolutely delicious. The kids had a blast with the build-your-own pizza, which made the experience even better. Everything we tried was outstanding! And I'll say this--if Brooklyn Brothers were in Lexington, there would be a line out the door every single night! It's THAT good. Authentic, delicious Italian food that is absolutely worth coming back for. Don't sleep on this place!

I am a pizza snob, even though I like a lot of different styles I know great pizza when I eat it…read more Brooklyn Brothers is great pizza. The mozzarella sticks were on point and hot, the wings were meaty, tender and saucy drinks were refilled frequently! The pizza, advertised as New York style had zero flop, folded just right and the cheese to sauce ratio was perfect. The crust could have had more of a crunch but I'll just have em add more time to the bake as that's more my personal preference! WE FOUND OUR KENTUCKY PIZZA PLACE!!

Oh my goodness they forgot the kitchen sink when making my Italian Sub !…read more Absolutely shockingly delicious but of course so are their pizzas ! Must try the sub , no really ,RUN !

Stellar service and delicious pizza! I believe it was Karen behind the counter and she was warm and…read morewelcoming. They have a few TVs in the dining area and they put on the Disney Channel for my daughters to watch while we waited for our food, which she brought out to our table. There were extra wings that they had made, and she offered them to us free of charge - to which we graciously accepted. Being from CT originally, I haven't found great pizza until now. The crust was crispy on the outside and airy with just the right amount of chew. The sauce was robust and the cheese wasn't overly greasy - just right! This is our new favorite in the area and we will be back! Thank you Midtown Pizza!