Top shelf pizza and wonderfully friendly proprietor and staff. Fantastic authentic pizza, perfectly…read moreseasoned and inventive varieties. Best pizza in Gettysburg to be sure, and a competitor that would hold its own anywhere.

Food was delicious- we ordered "to go" and the staff were very personable and friendly!! We ordered…read moremozzarella sticks, white pizza, and cheese pizza. Ingredients super fresh on the white pizza. Loved the crust. Can't wait to go back and try more items!!! A Must Stop when you are in Gettysburg!

Ordered hamburger bacon and Jalapeno. Got home it was pepperoni and jalapeño. Charged me at the…read moreregister for the pizza I ordered, so the knew what I ordered. Not happy

Food and service excellent. Hunting season starts getting cheese stk with gravy fries twice a week .read more

Celiac friendly, gluten free . This place is a wonder. My wife is a full blown go to the hospital…read moreif I breathe gluten and this was a wonderful find. They knew all the precautions and knew exactly what was up. Gf homemade garlic bread and pizza. My wife the western pizza, very delicious. Thank you

The food was great...pizza, chicken parm sub and stromboli. Portions were large...everything was…read morehot and tasty.

Stopped here for lunch on Thursday, December 11…read more Ordered a medium pizza with pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, and green peppers and one diet Coke fountain drink. Pizza was delicious as usual and served within about 10 minutes after we arrived. The wait staff was very attentive and friendly. The charge for the meal was $30 plus a cash tip. I think this is a little expensive for a medium pizza and one drink however we can only eat half the pizza at one time, so we took the other half home with us and had it for lunch today and it was still excellent. This of course cuts the cost to about $15 per lunch which makes it very reasonable. Men's bathroom was very clean and neat. Try it you'll like it.

My daughter and I stopped here on the way home from practice yesterday. We've driven by there so…read moremany times before but never stopped. We are glad that we finally did. We were greeted by the friendly cashier. We noticed the wonderful aromas coming from the kitchen. I ordered the Italian sub which was "a good choice" and my daughter got the baked ziti. We sat down to wait and my daughter needed a pencil to work on her homework so I asked the gentleman at the cash register. He went out of his way to scrounge one up for my daughter so she could work on her homework while we waited for our food. Shortly thereafter the food came out and we were able to indulge in a wonderful Italian sub and my daughter munched on the lettuce in the salad in the car. She commented how fresh the lettuce was and then when she got home, she devoured the baked ziti which she said was fantastic. We are so glad that we stopped and hopefully we will try and make a tradition of stopping by weekly if possible so glad. Unfortunately, I didn't get any pictures but the next time we stop by I'm sure I will try.

We tried this place for lunch on a Saturday in a cool little renovated shopping center in downtown…read more The panini and shrimp salad sandwiches were very fresh and well prepared. Onion rings were really good too. Service was very good and fast and it was around 1:30 pm. Portions were a fairly good size. The dining area is very small and just average. Nothing fancy. There is also much outdoor seating but it would be too hot in the summer to sit out there with the bright sun facing south. Like most restaurants since the pandemic, everything is costly these days. This restaurant was fairly reasonable compared to most.

Everything I've ever eaten from them is very good. Just recently had their pizza. Another winner.read more

PIZZA IS FIRE, BUT dont even think about expecting it a second sooner than the time you are told, &…read morebest be vigilant about reading that menu slowly, carefully and fully (author suggests preparing flash cards until you can PRECISELY recite the phone number and operating hours by memory, and are familar enough with the flow of the menu, it's diff sections, and at a minimum, the ingredient lists of your favorite, go to items. Basically, once you feel comfortable enough to be vocal about EXACTLY how you want your order prep'd, THEN you are ready. Until then, continue to recite directly from the menu, &/or rely on those flash cards when ordering. If you are wondering why such caution is given, please read each of the following DISCLAIMERS/WARNINGS that are directly copied and pasted from the menu. there are no less than FIVE, as you may confirm yourself by simply clicking on the link or going to the website provided on yelp,, or simply see below: DISCLAIMER: Please carefully read the ingredients of the item you want to order. If you have any preferences ask your server PRIOR to ordering (EXAMPLE: If ordering a calzone that comes with ham, mozzarella, ricotta & pizza sauce, you cannot complain if it contains 'pizza sauce' unless you specified for 'no pizza sauce'.) The crust of our pizzas are brown. Ask for light baked if you prefer it to be more white. Prices are shown for menu items only, every customization might occur in a price change. We make fresh food and some items may take different cook/preparation times, therefore they may be served at different times. Mistakes are possible, so if the food you have been served is incorrect in any way, please let us know right away and we will replace it -- to replace the food, we will need you to return the incorrect order back. Since we make fresh food to be consumed immediately, we cannot consider complaints the next day or any day after. All times of food preparation is estimated, not guaranteed. Grill and kitchen might close earlier than closing time (pizzas and cold subs available) NOTE: All food is prepared upon ordering... please allow 20-30 minutes (minimum) for our chef to create your meal. --(AUTHOR'S NOTE: beginning to see a pattern here...)-- MENU HEADER: (literally, like its their motto) we are not a fast food restaurant If you are in a hurry please consider that... --(AUTHOR'S NOTE: ok, these people must have been SERIOUSLY wronged in the past by some cranky customers... This town has like 600-700 population, who generally have quiet/polite dispositions , and "tourists" are def not culprits...what the heck happened here??!!)-- 4th & FINAL WARNING: (note how this includes yet another disclaimer regarding time of preparation etc. Directly following the food allergy warning. same paragraph, as if to say "yo, im including this here, right under the "possible death by peanut oil" disclaimer, just to emphasize how frickin' serious we are, about you understanding that WE ARE NOT A FAST FOOD RESTAURANT!" : - Rocky's New York Pizza Cannot Ensure That Items Do Not Contain Ingredients That May Cause an Allergic Reaction Please Consider This When Ordering. All food is prepared upon ordering...Please allow at least 20-30 Minutes (MINIMUM) for our chef to create your meal. Items may take longer than the estimated time given when you are placing your ordeR.

I'm not sure how this is rated so high, but ok. The pizza is bad. It's soggy and falls apart. It…read moreborders on watery. It takes a VERY long time to get the pizza. The place itself is cluttered and full of signs about how you should expect everything to take a long time and be bad. No Joke, that is a decorating motif. So, if you are in the market for a bad pizza that takes all day to arrive in a place that looks like tables squeezed into a supply closet this is the place to go. If you want to do better, go 20 minutes in any direction and have a better experience. Is what it is.

Dear Cheesesteak Gods, please forgive me for never trying their food here as this was my first time…read moreafter several years of Johnny's bring opened. I decided to jump online and place an online order and run over and pick it up because we live just a few minutes away and my selection was the crinkle cut french fries and a large cheesesteak with lettuce, tomato, mayo, and fried onions along with extra provolone. Just got home and just finished half of the sub and it is an absolute beast. The sub roll was so soft and so fresh which really put the icing on a cake or shall I say the icing on a cheesesteak as you can see in a pictures they definitely load you up with freshly chopped up steak and it was seasoned perfectly along with fresh tomatoes, lettuce, and perfectly grilled onion mixed in with the meat. I have to be honest and say this is one of the better cheesesteaks I've had in my lifetime and trust me I've eaten a lot of cheesesteaks all over the United States. The crinkle cut fries were fresh very hot when I got them home and absolutely have that little crunch in the inside was perfect. I know it's french fries but places do screw up but not Johnny's. This was really good french fries. They were fairly busy with phone orders coming in and people coming in to pick up pizza and they were busy and I can see why and I think out of all honesty you've earned our future business as a go to place and on our next visit we are going to try one of your pizzas. The inside has a few tables and counter seating and it's really tastefully decorated, I really enjoyed the decor. Service was on the money, friendly gentleman cashed me out and brought my food whenever it was ready no complaints there either. So the bottom line is I do highly recommend giving Johnny's a try. They do have a very nice menu of all different food selections and I don't really don't think you can go wrong and the prices are very reasonable.

On our way back from an event in Abbotstown and we wanted something for a late lunch. Johnny's got…read moregood reviews and was on the way. It is a small shop with maybe half a dozen tables and a counter. Decorated with various license plates, automotive items and some 50s memorabilia. The woman at the counter was very nice as was the staff who we encountered as the food was delivered and as we were leaving. My friends ordered cheese steaks, I ordered a lunch special, sausage and pepper sub with fries. When the first cheese steak came out we all went wow, they were huge! Not expected. My 1/2 sub was as big as a normal one and it was accompanied by a nice portion of old school krinkle cut fries. The sub was to hot to pick up, baked in the over so I started on the fries. Crisp, perfectly cooked and delicious. Didn't need catchup they were so good. The sandwich roll cooled down enough to eat and it was excellent. Plenty of nice sausage, peppers and onions. It was great, very tasty. This was a nice find for us. The experience was great, food was great and pricing was very reasonable. I suggest visiting Johnny's if you are in New Oxford.

Very good pizza! We were in the mood for good pizza and stumbled into this little place next to…read moreSheetz.

Got a large 1/2 meat lovers (my husband) and 1/2 vegetarian (me). Delicious! We agreed that if we…read moremade a pizza at home, that's what we hoped it would look and taste like. Fresh ingredients, beautiful crust and the cheese...oh my! My husband says it is the best pizza he's ever eaten. He's 78 and that's saying a lot!! The dog gives it 2 paws up, too!

First time here as I met a local For lunch. Clean , friendly…read morewaitress , nice menu , and good food .

Nice little Italian joint nestled in the rolling hills of York County…read more We decided to order three pies. One 16-inch pep, one 16-inch bbq chicken and a sicilian pie with sausage. I called the order in and was told 20 minutes. Turned out closer to 30. The sicilian met expectations. Nice thick crust and a healthy amount of sausage (sliced, nit crumbled). The bbq chicken was a bit on the sweet side. There is no sauce under the cheese, just drizzled on top. I can't speak for the pep. I'd order from here again!