Dr Hershman has been caring for my problem ridden feet for years. His attentive care has kept me walking and avoiding surgery with no pain.

My 1st visit to Dr. Hershman and he explained the problem and resolved it as well. He's amazing in his field and the warm welcome at the front desk as a new patient was very appreciated. read more

Been going here for years, despite frequent errors with respect to my yearly orthotics -- something always goes wrong bc of errant orders. And then they put me in collections for nearly $800 without so much as a call for orthotics that my insurance covered entirely. I'm livid. read more

I have been seeing Dr. Hershman on Sutter St. for many years now. I find him to be an excellent Dr. He's done alot of good with , my feet and he keeps them in shape. I think he's a nice guy, concerned, easy to talk to. AAA read more

I'm very surprised to read the negative reviews for Dr Hershman here. I've been seeing him since 2013 for a variety of foot-related issues, including plantar fasciitis, ingrown toenails, a stress fracture, and other fractures related to a fall. He also performed the surgery for a big toe joint replacement. I've been extremely happy with his care and treatments. The staff has always been friendly and professional, and I have been able to see him on short notice more than once. The orthotics he prescribed have been most helpful in easing the discomfort of hallux rigidus. I do not hesitate to recommend Dr Hershman. read more

Didn't take the time to do the simplest thing and immobilize my foot that would have saved it from permanent damage and when I came back with pain, he just didn't bother to accurately image my poor foot would have shown a painful torn toe capsule. Instead I got a dismissive lecture and was sent home. And now what???? Pain or a painful surgery? This is awful, very poor, dismissive care. read more

Absolutely the worst podiatrist I have encountered. I have problem feet, so have searched for the best. Fortunately, I have found what I consider the best: one who listens, analyzes, then executes a plan, which has worked over the past year. No unnecessary orthotics, no nonsense. All I ever got from Dr. Hershman was a running litany of how many celebrities he knows and how many adoring "fans" he has. I don't get it because he has the demeanor of a bored orderly and didn't even find the cause of severe pain in my left big toe: a huge ingrown nail. It took a doctor in New York who prescribed a CT Scan of my foot and found the offending nail deep inside my toe. He surgically removed it and I have been pain free ever since. RUN AWAY from this office if you have serious concerns that need more than just an expensive orthotic or bragging about celebrities. read more

Dr. Donald Hersham has been my doctor for almost 4 years now. He has operated on my feet for 2 different procedures. I'm going to have another surgery with him in May and I absolutely trust him. He's the BEST Doctor of Podiatry. He LISTENS to his patients sincerely and makes sure you are happy on every visit. His entire STAFF is FABULOUS and they are always on top of things. I don't understand how some other reviewers are unhappy with him. It's quite a shocker to me. He's an excellent doctor and he CARES about every patient he sees. Please consider seeing Dr. Hershman, he's a true professional that cares for your well being. read more

3 words: FRAUD, NIGHTMARE, AND INCOMPETENT. Pretty much the roughest absolutely rude bed side addtemdlamce, which seems to have a direct correlation on last night and how much partying the doctor had done the night prior. Unfortunately for me, I just learned my account has been placed into collections even thought I was never notified of an outstanding bill, yet they have all my contact information. UPDATE: This office has gotten even worse. Beside the no billing and immediate collections, and has financially affected my credit score (for $29) their more-than-rude response was CALL IRIN (some unnamed woman), which she could do nothing. Damage was done. As previos posts have mentioned THIS OFFICE IS A NIGHTMARE! I am not submitting any all fraudulent business applications as I can to get this fraud out of SF so he can go paint his paint his painting in Palm Springs, Ft Lauderdale. This office is a FRAUD. Stay away. read more

Not a fan of this doc. I had minor foot surgery he performed. When he put the needle in between my toes I expressed pain and he abruptly stopped, looked at me, and rudley said "do you want me to continue or not"?.. The look on his face was like he sucked a barrel of lemons and he seemed annoyed that i was in pain. So I sat there and sucked up the pain like i was in the 1700`s.. I did`nt like the job he did because my issue came back which i ended up treating myself and since it`s been fine. This surgery was awhile ago but it looks like the reviews here nothing has changed. Maybe he should look into another line of work because this one seems to piss him off. I will never go back here!!! read more

I really think this doctor is dishonest and unprofessional. I've visited him at least twice, very disoriented and took and xray of my foot the first time. When I went back to follow up, he "forgot" to review them, so took a second xray. still never heard/saw/explained anything from those xrays. I'm sure he billed my insurance company each time. They do leave the doors open to the exam room while he is meeting with you which is weird and unprofessional. The front desk ladies are pretty gruff and don't take people in the order in which they came (or their appointments are). When they called someone in before me by mistake (and realized it) one woman was like "oh well" out loud, and didn't apologize and didn't do anything. What I find most concerning is his orthotics scam. i was prescribed orthotics for my shoes without any explanation of cost or anything. Lo and behold when they came in they were $450. they do not work, they cannot be worn and when I went in there were racks of them waiting to be picked up by what I would assume were unsuspecting patients. I find this practice dishonest and a bit of a scam since I do not think they were necessary for my BUNION (issue why I was seeing him). I would HIGHLY recommend finding someone more professional, more organized and more HONEST. read more

My recommendation would be to find a different doctor if you have questions. In my two visits to him, both of my appointments were delayed by about 20 minutes and the doctor seemed rushed and didn't give me a chance to ask questions. Also, he doesn't really give a good job of explaining things to you or really give you a chance to ask questions. He wrapped up both visits with a quick "OK?" and then walked out of the room. It was hard to tell whether my examination was over or not because they both ended so abruptly. I even had to ask the receptionist out front of the doctor was coming back. im glad i dont have to see this guy anymore read more

If you can still run, run away. Do NOT let this man conduct surgery on you. Do NOT let him sell you on unnecessary procedures. DO get a second/third opinion. DO conduct your own research. DO ask many, many questions. Yes, he was charming -- but, I made the critical mistake of believing in him when he told me that while he was fixing one problem, why not take care of other issues? For the rest of my life I'll most likely never be able to walk normally again nor be able to walk for more than 5 minutes without severe pain. I am in pain every day. His parting comment to me - "I'll light a candle for you." No legal recourse because that's one thing he's very, very good at. read more

Getting ready to take a trip with my Father that we've been planning for weeks and every day my ingrown toenail is getting worse. I tried soaking it and it would start getting better, then a little bump against the toe would bring it right back to it's apinful state. I went on Yelp and called a number of podiatrists and Corrina from Dr. Hershman's office called me back and said I could be seen in a few hours. Upon arriving Corrina and Jorge made sure I was comfortable and well informed. I've had ingrown toenail surgery before and this experience was head and shoulder's above the previous. It was ABSOLUTELY PAINLESS!!! It was over before I knew it began. I found Dr. Hershman as down to earth and quite a humanitarian. I also saved a lot of money coming here and when you don't have any health insurance, like myself, it makes a big difference. By the end of the today's appointment I left with smile on my face. Why can't more doctors be like this? Thanks again, Dr. Hershman, Corrina and Jorge! read more

I just phoned Dr.'s office to schedule a "new patient" appointment--and I do hope Dr. Hershman is not a reflection of the lackluster reception I just received from the person who took the appointment. She spoke in a short, quick monotone way--giving me the impression that she was far too busy and important to be on the phone with me at that particular time. Not at all giving me the warm and fuzzy feeling that she was thrilled that I chose HER doctor and office to take care of one of my most important body parts: my feet! I made the appointment, but will be keenly aware of how the entire experience goes before I commit to having Dr. Hershman become my regular DPM. Wish me luck! read more

I have never seen Dr Hershman but he was recommended by a colleague of his. Problem is I can't get anyone at the practice to call me back!! If I can ever arrange an appt, I'll gladly revise this review! read more

I do agree that the people who answer the phone in his office are less than professional and don't have good skills on the phone. I used to go to the office to see the other podiatrist who unfortunately passed away. He was a total sweetheart. What really got to me with this doctor is that the two times I saw him, once I was invited to the room and seated, I had to wait 45 minutes before he walked in. I am not exaggerating. And it didn't occur to him to apologize. Once I would understand but twice?!! When I was leaving the receptionist said "Sorry about the wait" but that's all I got. I promised myself not to go back :( read more

I was diagnosed with plantar fasciitis back at the beginning of September by my podiatrist at Kaiser. She gave me some stretching exercises and prescribed me an anti-inflammatory. About a week later I was doing much better and was pretty much pain-free up until yesterday morning when I woke up in a horrible pain coming from the heel of my foot. I called the podiatry department at Kaiser and they weren't able to see me for a week. A friend of mine who uses Dr. Hershman highly recommended him and gave me his number. Not thinking at all that I would be able to get an immediate appointment I called them and the nurse told me to come in as soon as possible! The nursing staff was incredibly kind and professional. I saw Dr. Hershman about five minutes after I arrive. He was incredibly nice and very professional. He took an x-ray of my foot and determine that I have a heel spur. He then gave me a Cortizone injection and also fitted me for custom orthotics. I was hesitant on getting a Cortizone injection because I thought it was gonna be incredibly painful but Dr. Hershman reassured me that it would not be painful at all and it actually wasn't! I highly recommend Dr. Hershman and his office for your podiatry needs. Thank you Dr. Hershman and the wonderful staff for being able to see me at the very last minute. read more

As a surgeon, practitioner, business man and general guy - he's the best. Went to him and after a couple months of consultation I had double bunion surgery. The process was quick and painless (didn't take any pain medication afterwards) and was up and walking in no time, and before you knew it I was back to my 3-5 mile walks. My partner jokes about how I had to visit my neighbors' hours after my surgery and tell them about how successful it was! LOL I would highly recommend Donald Hershman to anyone seeking advice on their feel - the man is a genius/artist. After only a few months post-surgery my feet are beautiful and pain free! :D read more

Dr. Hershmen is a wizard and I would recommend him to anybody. I love my new feet :-) read more

Donald E Hershman, DPM - Not only is he a good doctor he's a great painter - Podiatrists Near Me - San Francisco, California

I've read a few of these complaints about Dr. Hershman, and I find them baffling. I've been going to him for my various foot problems, from nail fungus to surfing accidents to bunions. Each time I was treated quickly, effectively, matter-of-factly, and professionally. I guess since he knows my face from the gym, he understands that I don't require a whole lot of pussy-footing and bullshit. I just want my feet to act right and feel good. Whatever ails my feet, he fixes PERMANENTLY, and I never have to see him about the same problem twice. Well, except for my next appointment. I misplaced my orthotics and gotta get some replacements. FIVE effin' stars! read more

Dr. Hershman has taken firm and gentle care of my feet for at least the past 20 years. Now, with diabetes he is being particularly (and kindly) strict. On three occasions he discovered related or developing problems that my physicians, including specialists, had overlooked or not looked for in the first place. I am most grateful to him. read more

Incompetent. Hershman diagnosed the pain in my foot as a neuroma, gave me a shot a scheduled a followup 6 weeks later. When I went to see a second Podiatrist (Jenny Sanders of the Financial District Foot and Ankle Center) the x-rays and MRI revealed I had torn my planter plate. The two weeks delay from his misdiagnosis to getting a true diagnosis have probably cost me the chance to ride AIDS/LifeCycle. (Yelp requires you give at least one star to post a review, please note that is the only reason I gave one) read more

This is a hard review to write. I really liked Dr Hershman and think he did a good job for what i came in for - a planters' wort that was starting to get painful. But I have to say recovery from that laser surgery was beyond horrible. Unfortunately he gives no tips for care or pain management beyond one day past the surgery and he just told be to get the sheet from the receptionist - wish he spent 2 minutes on that himself. When I came for my follow up visit. He voice a few very small planters warts on my other foot - have been there for years and tiny so I didn't want anything done. He tried to talk me into surgery so when I refused, he used an acid on them. Then a week later, the worts started growing which was likely a coincidence but odd since they were there for so long and stayed small. Then I got billed several hundred dollars for that acid treatment which was painful. So now I am trying to freeze off the worts on my own - afraid to return. read more

Okay, now...I am only 42, and rather active and healthy if I do say so myself...but after schizophrenically wearing balley flats OR platform high heels for 2 years and then having a baby etc. etc., i found myself with constantly aching bunions...and I mean DAILY pain. So not sexy. I decided I was too young to be kvetching about " oy! my aching bunions!" so I got myself to a podiatrist for the first time in my life. Hellllloooo, Dr. Hershman. Very kind exchange with the front desk staff followed by an efficient and knowledgeable assessment of the situation by Dr. Hershman (replete with in house x-rays)....and he prescribes therapeutic shots in my toe knuckles (gulp) and orthotics to nip the situation in the bud. While the shots weren't AWESOME, they sure as shit did the trick...I kinda couldn't believe that i was completely pain free 2 days later. I no longer sound like a Jewish elder whining about my sore feet. I pick up my new orthotics next week to complete the ongoing treatment. Mazel Tov! Thank you Dr. Hershman and staff...I will be back when I need you next, though I don't think that will be for a while :) read more

I've had so many foot related problems in the past 3 years. I feel like my chicken walk has become a kitschy seasonal feature, like the shamrock shake, or pumpkin spice lattes. (Un)fortunately I've had to see Dr. Hershman 3 times in the past 6 months for various foot related injuries. A while ago I shattered a glass on my foot and it wouldn't stop bleeding. Then, due to a bad vacuum, I ended up with some of the aforementioned glass in my other foot a couple weeks later. Late last night I tripped over my bike and managed to double fracture my baby toe. I wasn't sure if i had just stubbed it at first, but when it remained excruciating to walk on, I felt good knowing I would be able to see the Dr. right away because I've always gotten same day appointments. He was quick and thorough, and I'll be seeing him again in eight weeks, hopefully healed and heeled. Highly recommended if you work in the area and need to get taken care of quickly. read more

I was referred to Dr. Hershman a few years ago. He was personable, efficient, knowledgeable, and did a great job with my orthotics. He also essentially gave me a pedicure, and did so very well. I returned to him today for some follow up treatment, and was again highly impressed. read more

I don't know what these folks are talking about. I took my shoe off after WEEKS of being in pain, he said "I see the problem", and 10 minutes later I was walking out pain free. Dr. H is freaking awesome and the front desk staff is composed of a very pleasent and professional ladies. Gong back soon to have Dr. H make it so I'll never have the problems I've been having ever again. He's efficient, knowledgable and has a wondeful bedside manner. I have recommended Jim to several folks looking for a GOOD podiatrist. read more

Dr Herschman ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He literally saved my life by curing the problem I had. He is quick, efficient and is an expert in podiatric medicine. I would recommend him to ANYONE seeking great foot care. Charlie Greene read more

My toes were hurting for the first time EVER, so turns out I had ingrown toe nails. Ouch! Dr. Hershman helped fix them on two separate visits, which was relieving, although I keep getting them of various toes. The receptionists may seem a bit brusque to some, but I find them helpful for the most part. Dr. Hershman was professional and kept the pain down to a minimum, which I appreciated. read more

I was referred to Dr. Hershman for a foot infection. His staff was able to get me in very quickly. I could not have had a better experience. He has an excellent bedside manner, is caring and compassionate. Explained what he was going to do and the reason for it extremely well and put my mind at ease. Both him and his staff are superb. I would go back to see him in the future in a second. I highly recommend him. read more

Some years back, I saw Dr. Hershman because I had a pain in my foot. He scheduled a subsequent appointment to make impressions of my feet for orthotics. While making the casts, he was less than professional, asking me to scoot down on the table, and while I was 'scooting' he grabbed both my ankles and yanked me down. So I got the orthotics, but the pain did not go away. Fortunately for me, my gut feelings about his poor 'bedside manner' and his lame front office staff caused me to go to another doctor. He x-rayed my foot and asked what was being done for the fracture. I said 'what fracture'? Needless to say, a few painful weeks had passed with out me getting the proper treatment for my foot because of what I perceive to be Hershman's negligence in his zeal to sell me costly plastic inserts for my shoes. I would NEVER go back to him for anything. read more

I first met Dr. Hershman eight years ago when he treated me on short notice for a very painful ingrown toenail. My only ingrown ever....I digress....Dr. Hershman did a great job with that problem, but more importantly he talked to me about how flat my feet are and suggested I come back to get fitted for orthotics. THANK YOU DR. HERSHMAN! Before I started wearing orthotics, I used to get lower back pains with regularity. Since I started wearing them, that issue has disappeared. I recently got fitted for a more sports-friendly pair and they are great. Dr. Hershman is friendly, efficient, and highly knowledgeable. I trust him with my feet and confidently recommend him if you have foot problems. read more

I've been an athlete for 4 years now and 2 years back was told that I needed custom made arch supports if I wanted to continue running and biking. My general physician recommended Dr. Hershman and I must say I was quite satisfied with my experience the two times that I went there. PROS: 1. He knows his stuff 2. His office is easily reachable by Muni 3. His office is in a awesome Art Deco building that is in itself worth a visit 4. He does have a packed schedule (think he has two locations that's why) so he was prompt, quick, to the point and yet, friendly 5. I've had my arch supports for 2 years now and no complaints CONS: 1. His staff tend to not rate high on bed side manners but I ignore it all and continue to be polite myself 2. Can be difficult sometimes to get an appointment Other than that, I was glad I went to Dr. Hershman and recommended my then boss to go as well. She was very satisfied and coming from someone who designs footwear for women athletes is proof that Dr. Hershman knows his stuff. read more

revised - maybe his staff was reading the reviews, but I've noticed a significant change in demeanor. they are downright pleasant and friendly. I've been there 4 times in the last 3 weeks (pre- and post-op) and everyone has been very nice. and that's not the vicodin talkin'. I think he's very good - competent, friendly. But I agree with other reviewers, the office staff is the pits. read more

First, I want to say that I was never treated by this Dr. The low rating is for my unfortunately poor experience at his office this morning. I was excited to have found a podiatrist with semi-decent Yelp ratings in my insurance program. I was wary of the yelps re: Staff, but I waved that off as it's the doctor I wanted to check out. Anyhow, I got in at 8:25 as I had an 8:30 appt. As I filled out the new patient paperwork, the doctor walks in the waiting area, looked at my new face and said hello. I said hello back. Then one of his staff took my co-pay and told me to wait in a room. I waited 15 minutes when I heard someone else come into the office and they told her she could wait in the other room. They sounded like old friends so it must've been a loyal patient. Next thing I know, the Dr. is in the other room with the other patient and it sounds like he's in full treatment conversation with the person that walked in after me. It's 9 a.m. Needless to say, I was floored at the incredibly poor communication between his two staff members and this Dr. The only thing positive I can say is that I got my co-pay back quickly. Does anyone else have a good podiatrist to recommend in the FiDi? read more

Dr. Hershman is nice and he gave me great orthodics but... the overall experience of the office is pretty unprofessional. Appointments are delayed and the door of the patient room is always left open which can be kind of embarrassing. He has left the room on several occasions to tend to his computer and make calls on his cell phone. I hate giving bad reviews but I am not impressed. The staff at the front desk can be a hit or miss too. Whatevs. I am kind of over this doctor's office. read more

Dr Hershman knows his stuff. My family goes to see him and I am extremely happy with the orthotics his made for me because he has accommodated orthotics for my regular dress shoes and running shoes. read more

I've seen Dr Hirschman twice and have found him to be very professional, personable and knowledgeable. He ordered Sporthotics for me, and I couldn't be happier with them -- they work well in my work shoes and sneakers. His waiting room can be busy at times so you may have to wait to see him even with an appt (but honestly how many doctors these days maintain an exact schedule). Recommended. read more

I don't want to tell anyone about Dr. Hershman because he is already busy enough, but, I will because he is wonderful. Very knowledgeable, and to the point. Since I did not inherit the perfect feet gene, I plan to have a long ongoing relationship with him. Maybe even need some more surgery. Oh fun. Bunions, what a party. His front desk staff can be a little surly and not client focused, but, they are efficient. Don't let the woman scare you who answers the phone in an apathetic tone, "Doctor's office" throw you. It would be nice if she identified herself or at least id'd what doctor's office you called. read more