Husband and I ordered online takeout from Little Italy. Large Napoli and breadsticks. I almost…read moredidn't because of the reviews but I'm SO glad I did. We ordered online and was given a 25 minute time window. No problem we were in Springfield. We pulled up 5 minutes early. This is not a restaurant but just a pickup and delivery joint. I walked in and was handed my pizza-warm and fresh. The owner was very nice and told me to eat it hot! We dug in 10 minutes later and it was still hot and delicious! Large quantity of toppings and they subbed olives for green peppers no charge. Wonderful! We were very impressed-sauce delicious, cheese yummy and toppings perfect! Please give them a try they are honestly good! The breadsticks were hot and yeasty with the pizza sauce for a dip. They were good but needed a little cheese. That's why the 4 star. Otherwise YUMMY!!!

They made our pizzas wrong. When I called to inform them of the error I was told to just keep the…read morepizzas and that new ones would be brought out. So I fed my children the wrong pizzas so that they could eat. I then received a phone call telling me that they wanted the pizzas back as a swap for the new ones. I informed them that I had already given my kids some of the pizzas. When the guy showed up with the correct pizzas he was very rude about it and accused me of giving him empty pizza boxes. I told him that I had already fed my kids some of the wrong pizza and that I had told them on the phone. He proceeded to raise his voice demanding me to open the boxes. After he left my I called to complain about the rudeness and was informed that the rude person was the owner. I'm sorry, but an owner should never act like that towards a customer when it wasn't their error. We will never be ordering from here again.

I have been coming here since I was...14??? I dont know, time flies. We used to come here after…read moreFriday night football games for pizza. Fast forward two decades later and I'm still a sucker for the pizza AND the onion tanglers. I have to live the gluten free life now(boooo) but let me tell you, don't sleep on the gluten free crust. I tasted ZERO difference. So good.

Service was great, and I have absolutely no complaints about that. The chips were great, but I…read morebelieve the queso could use some refining. My BLT was extremely good and the fries were a great pairing. As far as looks, from the outside looking in, it's nothing to brag about. But once inside, you are teleported into a great establishment. Although I didn't go into the arcade, it is a great added area for the kids. 4.5/5 for sure!

gross..........gross..........disgustingly gross. I use to think that Casey's served at least an…read moreedible pizza. then I started ordering pizza from Bateman's bad dad's pizza in Springfield. their pizza is amazing. however, they have been closed for the past three days. so out of a desperate pizza craving, I ordered a medium supreme pizza from Casey's. omg, what a big mistake. first off the crust (if you can call it that) is so thick and doughy it makes you feel like you are biting into an entire loaf of bread, it is just disgusting. casey's uses such low-quality ingredients on their pizza. the sausage is not even real Italian sausage, it is some fake mystery meat. the pepperoni is definitely not real pepperoni. the mushrooms are vile canned mushrooms. you can tell that the mozzarella cheese they use contains fillers because it barely melts all the way through. it is just a cheap, horrendous, disgusting mess. a barely consumable product. I choked down one slice and threw the rest in the trash where it belongs. i am tired of the majority of restaurants in Chatham serving shitty barely edible food and thinking it is perfectly fine to do so. this is my last Casey's pizza. you suck casey's and so does your pizza.

Just had a very disappointing experience with my curbside pickup of my order. First after several…read moreminutes past our pick up time, our food was given to a different car (a car instead of a SUV). Then even after the other driver told them it wasn't theirs. The employee walked back inside without acknowledging me (we were parked by each other). Obviously a new pizza would need to be cooked, so I wanted patiently. After 30 minutes from our original, I went into the store where I was ignored by the same employee. Until it finally dawned on her that there was a curbside pickup ready. At which point she grabbed our pizza from on top of the oven (who knows how long it has been sitting there) and hands it to another employee to bring outside. I let him know that it was mine and how the other employee had given our original order to someone. At no point was there any acknowledgment of the mistake or an apology or another attempt to correct the situation. This is very disappointing given the usual good customer service.]

OK...we tried it again. We eat out often and wanted to give the place a chance. After all,…read moremistakes happen. We didn't have the 2 hour wait (it was hot when we picked up). However, there was excessive sauce and the toppings were wrong (sausage but no pepperoni)! We are trying the new Pizza Hut tonight! Check out that review soon...

I can't describe this restaurant. I feel like sometimes it's great and sometimes it's not. What I…read moremean is that only three out of ten times in the past two months it was FANTASTIC. The other seven times there was a TON of sauce or a lack of it. But on special occasions do I order a cinnamon wheel which can be a bit crummy, but it's still GREAT! Their service isn't the best, but it's okay....

I get pizza here once a week and they never disappoint! The place is clean and the employees are…read moreamazing. This is the #1 pizza place in my family and will continue to be!

By far the best pizza in town you get the most toppings the crust is always perfect the chicken…read morewings at what else do you need to say

I live in a retirement community and on occasion someone will buy a pizza from Casey's and I was…read moresurprised how good it tasted. It changed my mind about Casey's Pizza. Now I try not to judge anything unless I have tried it myself.

Never be here again, the old lady at the reception was so rude. Idk anyone in there like that or…read morenot but that's the worst feeling that I ever feel in Casey ever

Just stood first in line waiting for 15 minutes just to be told they don't have the ingredients to…read moremake what I wanted (a cold cut combo). Could've asked me what I was getting before I stood there waiting for 15 mins so I didn't stand there for nothing. Waste of time. Never have what is needed either.

it was very good. SUPER SUPER GREAT I got a very good experience from a nice woman named Marsy…read moreShe's very kind and she DEFINITELY deserves a raise so she can go to college for cosmetics.