This is my favorite pizza in Batavia. After living here for a few years, this was my go-to spot. We…read morewere back in town for the day hanging out and decided we needed to get some pizza before we went home. We ended up getting a few things which were all delicious. We got a large cheese and pep pizza, some wings, fried mozzarella, and some fried dough bites for dessert. The pizza here has been great and the service is always pretty quick. They have two sides of the restaurant with takeout on one, and dining on the other. The dining room is gorgeous and has such a great vibe to it. It feels upscale, yet cozy. If you're in Batavia and need a pizza, Main Street is the place to go.

Once again, I'm back in Batavia and MUST stop in here as I " eat my way " through western New York!…read moreLucky for me it was a Tuesday so I could take advantage of the Pasta Special, 2 pasta dinners and a bottle of wine for $30. As always a delicious meal

I have ordered from them for years. I started getting cold or burnt crust with no replacement. They…read moreno longer allow me to order, because I complained about their service. So much for loyalty!

Staying in Batavia at a hotel with a late check in pizza was the fastest option. The front desk…read morerecommended Ficarella's. I was pleased to see they offered gluten free and cauliflower crust options. I only wished they offered dairy free cheese. Delivery was pretty fast and our pizza was delicious and the calzone was huge! I liked the many different and unique sauces offered for the wings ( blueberry bbq, cattleman s.gold,etc) I would definitely go back

We came here to celebrate my sister's birthday (her choice) and had such a great time. I started…read moreoff the night with an aperol spritz, which paired beautifully with one of their wood fired pizzas. My fiancé and I split the chicken bacon ranch which I highly recommend. The pizza plus an app is plenty of food for two people. Our server was friendly and efficient too. I would definitely come back here for a drink and pizza again.

I made reservations for 9 people on a Tuesday night... which they never wrote down in their…read morebooks...so I was glad it was a slow night. Our server was very sweet and knowledgeable! If you have a large party- beware they can apparently only cook 2 pizzas at a time in their oven so we did have quite a few people in our party wait awhile for their pizza while others got their food. The food was good. I had the bucatini carbonara with shrimp, which was cooked to perfection. The meal was extremely rich in flavor, which was awesome but couldn't eat too much of it! The pizzas were all really good. They have a lot of crust on each pizza (the ingredients weren't really spread too far along the dough) One more thing I must add- there was no music! No nothing. Just voices echoing from our party and the bar... please add music!

Amazing amazing pizza on a regular day and I gotta say taco pizza awesome you got it down girl…read moreamazing. Keep making that magic God bless.

We got some pepperoncini pizza and 12 each of BBQ and medium wings to take out. All the food was…read moregood, but their buffalo wing sauce was a little thin. The BBQ wings were fine. The round pizza was cut into squares, so be aware if you don't like that. The crust is also quite thick around the edges, but it was properly baked and not burned. There was a special which included a 2 liter of pop. The service at the counter was prompt and friendly. In addition they opened at 11am on Sunday, which is not always the case.

delivery was very fast pizza was fresh and hot .Sauce is…read moresweeter so kids will like it . breadsticks are more like cheese bread ( large pizza cut into sticks) see photo greta food for hotel room

Excellent pizza. Dough is tasty and toppings are plentiful. They are flexible with the Specialty…read morepizzas. Also, the sheet pizza is delicious

This place was great in the 90's. After my last experience here, I would not recommend it. Owner…read morewas not concerned, even dismissive about a problem with our order. I'll take my business & my money to businesses where I feel like an appreciated customer.

Great pizza, never burnt and ive been going there for 30 plus years. I do miss thier char grilled…read morebbq wings they had years ago, omg they were soooooo good.

First time here and Buffalo in general. Saw boxes of their pizza in our place of work that's why we…read morecame here. If locals order from thsi place and see them enjoy the food, we thought it might be good. Plenty of parking and on a Wednesday, very busy compared to other restaurants we have seen in the area. The server was bubbly and kept on checking on us. I enjoyed the pizza

This place truly never disappoints…read more Seriously... The biggest issue you will have is tackling the HUGE portions

I drive by this place once every couple weeks, and never even noticed it until a few weeks ago,…read moresince it's a small place, unassuming place, kind of off to the side and in the cut. Figured I'd stop in quick and grab a slice. Welp...they don't have slices! So instead I opted for a small meatball sub. Since Andy's doesn't have medium subs, only small and large, the "small" is actually more like a medium. It was fairly tasty and hit the spot. Pricing for their pizzas and subs is essentially on par with most local places that you'd find in Rochester or Buffalo. Hopefully I can stop in again to try more of their menu, although be aware that they are only open on evenings and not for lunch!

Great pizza and fast delivery! Sauce is not too sweet or too spicy. Prices are reasonable.read more