Fresh, wild seafood market AND Hot or Cold lobster rolls- only. Love the concept! Dobbs Ferry Lobster Guys had popped up on Yelp and came across a Westchester Magazine article back in '21. Since I'm catching up on more errands in the area these days, I made time for an early Friday lunch pickup.
Seafood prices have undoubtedly gone up but Lobster Guys' prices are almost comparable to a fish market in Elmsford I visit at times and a top-tier supermarket in Harrison with very good quality seafood. So what makes Dobbs Ferry LG stand out even more so? Well, Dobbs Ferry LG's owner, Anthony is out on the water getting his catch.
I initially came for Buttered Lobster Rolls but their fresh seafood also caught my attention. I gave Anthony at least 10-15 mins to prep my lobster rolls order and quite honestly, they were worth it. For me, buttered- not mayo Lobster rolls are one of life's greatest sandwiches. The meat is buttery, has a very subtle crunch (but not a 'crunch' in that sense) and packed real nice. I had also gotten a lb of Halibut at $29- which I can't complain.
Hubs and I'd driven from home to BK just for Red Hook Lobster Pound's rolls in the past and other spots like them throughout the city- but swore them off completely for their processed taste and mealy lobster texture. Including a lobster roll spot in Greenwich, CT. I got no time for fakes. $24.95 for a well-packed buttered lobster roll here. The meat is tender, juicy and buttery. The price is brilliant. Best lobster roll in the vicinity. Fact. read more