Food: Breadsticks are a MUST! So delicious. The pizza was great too... the large was only $1-2 more…read morethan the medium. Very reasonable cost for what you get! Plenty of options. Fountain drinks are self serve. Service: there were only 2 other tables dining inside and our 2 large pizzas and breadsticks were delivered within 20 min. You order at the counter, so you don't really have a server. They offer the plates, plasticware, and napkins by the drink fountain. All self serve. Employees were very friendly and accommodating to requests. Ambiance - the place was bigger on the inside than i thought. There were plenty of booths for dining. I would guess that maybe around 50 people could eat in there. Restaurant was well designed and clean. Saw the employees cleaning the tables regularly while i was there.

This was my first time trying their pizza. My boyfriend has had it before and really likes it. It…read morewas so good! We got a sausage pizza, breadsticks, and taco pizza. We highly recommend the taco pizza. It's amazing!

Great service, great food! Nice atmosphere also. Friendly staff. My hubby and myself both give it…read more5 stars, will definitely return and recommend!

Food was great however the atmosphere was not great... a gentleman with a mancino's shirt was…read moresitting with 2 other guys and talking so loudly that we couldn't hear each other.

I have previously left a great review a couple of years ago. Hadn't ordered from them for a while…read moredue to the very long wait times. Today, I decided that I wanted something different and had a drive until I was back in town, so it would be fine to have a longer wait time for pick up. I don't see why it takes 45 minutes to make a regular crust pizza with one topping, but at least they let you know ahead of time. My issue today was that I also ordered a sandwich. I picked up my food as the pizza was coming out of the oven, in which I had to wait on.. and the whole time my sandwich was setting there boxed up. It had been boxed up for quite some time. The sandwich was cold, and the pizza was bland and didn't have the extra sauce that I paid for. It's just very bland pizza. The crust is flavorless, and it seems like the cheese is too. The sandwich would have been good if it was hot and the oil hadn't soaked into the bread by the time my pizza was ready. Let me also add, that it's a pretty pricey pizza. So... high cost, long wait times, and meh flavor.

We have never been here before but when visiting Plymouth we stopped in to try the pizza…read more First the good, it was quick and the pie had plenty of cheese. The toppings were covered with cheese so I couldn't see the quality or quantity. The pie crust was too thick and chewy for our taste. The price for a 14 inch, 2 topping pizza was twenty dollars. Not exactly a bargain. We were expecting more.

I am honored to be the first to review this restaurant. The pizza is phenomenal! And I truly mean…read moreit. There are pizza joints all over the place, but this place stands out. You can tell that the ingredients are of a very high quality and the dough recipe is perfect. What really stands out to me is the crust. It has a really nice char and doesn't do that greasy flop thing that most run of the mil pizzerias are putting out. If you have ever had a coal fired pizza that's what it tasted like to me. They have a great oven and the timing is dialed in perfectly. Prior to reviewing the restaurant, I made sure to try it a few times. And I'm happy to say that it is consistently good. My only complaint is that their hours are limited and open at 4pm on most days. I think they do lunch hours on Thursday and Friday. They also offer a Chicago style deep dish; however, I haven't tried it yet. Give this place a try. I think you'll enjoy it as much I do. Chief

The ambience is typical of a pizza parlor. I ordered the New…read moreYork style pizza and it was cut in so small of slices you couldn't fold it. The person who was behind the counter was absolutely no help. I would like to write this place at a negative one however that is not an option so I gave it a one star.

I had ordered a pizza from there and waited patiently in my car. The representative was kind enough…read moreto bring it out to my car!! HOW AMAZING IS THAT!? I came in late at night and everything was so clean I felt terrible. They still did my order. Props to everyone working!!

The food has been consistent since the 90s, which isn't a bad thing at all! Sadly since Covid the…read moredining room has stayed closed. Honestly I'd probably give them 5 starts if they'd just open that back up.

Best pizza in town... Nothing else to say. Try it you don't be disappointed. Love this place.read more

Came here on a nice Sunday afternoon. Our servers were okay, and the ambiance was nostalgic and…read morewarm. They had a salad bar setup so we started with that. They have some good options - just standard iceberg lettuce and really good ranch I thought. For the pizza I ordered the pan vegetarian and we also got a thong crust pepperoni crust mushroom pepperoni and banana pepper. This one tasted like cardboard. Honestly the veggies on the pizza were fresh, but there was just no flavor to anything. Still cost me $70 too which I thought was steep.

Went in and got small salad bar to go. Asked about just a cup of ice to go as well. Said would…read morehave to charge me $2.00 for a cup of ice. REALLY. A small bag of ice is a little over $2.00. I mean come on....

Their pizza is pretty good. The food really in general is good. I love the sausage breakfast pizza…read more Their drinks are also pretty good I would like a root beer on the pop machine.

Horrible service. Clerk or manager running store is stealing from either customers or the store…read more Ordered 2 large pizzas online and recieved 2 medium pizzas at barely over 12in in diameter. Receipt and online order both show large. I paid for large pizzas that should have been atleast 14in in diameter according to there app and website. Called walkerton location and they confirmed the size of the pizza i receieved was indeed medium sized pizza. When asking staff at plymouth location about there sizes they get extremely short with you dont see how this is good customer service. Asked for a refund and was gave the help desk number that is for caseys employees. Will be calling corporate office thanks to a quick google search. Never ordered from this caseys before and never going to again. It is a simple problem to remedy i simple asked for a refund in exchange they can keep the pizza and absolutly refused to give a refund.

The employees stand in the back yelling, cussing and play on their phones. This evening could have…read morebeen better but the employees simply just were there to make a check and go home. Very disappointing customer service.

Been here before many many times not once have I had an experience like this. Walked in 15 minutes…read morebefore closing and ordered a cheese and pepperoni pizza. Only thing that we wanted, the manager working there walks to the back as I pay and yells to the workers "I'm going to be here till fucking ten at night because these assholes come in 5 minutes before closing and keep ordering." We ignored her because she wouldn't stop calling us assholes for ordering 15 minutes before closing and ordering something that takes 6 minutes to make. As we got out pizza she says "Fucking assholes" and points at us as we got into our vehicle yelling more things. extremely disappointed in the service that we got, she wasn't even the one making the pizza or preparing it she was sitting and staring at us from behind the wall that enters into the cooking area. She doesn't deserve to be working in any restaurant because who wants to be hearing that while waiting for their pizza?

been going here since i was a little kid! the food is always great, as well as the service. way…read moreback when we used to go inside and eat, not sure if they still do that? anyway i just order at the drive thru! gyro plate is the best!

This is takeout place. Yes, the building has some tables and chairs in it, but they are alongside…read moreboxes and crates of supplies! The line of cars waiting to pickup their called-in orders wraps around the building, as other reviewers have stated. And the food is truly tasty. But don't plan on taking your family there for a sit down! Staff are friendly and efficient.