Wow! What a menu, and what quality! Went for the first time last week. The place was packed, but…read morethey had a good number of staff, and the line moved along pretty quickly. A menu board was placed just inside the door so we could have see the flavors easily (always a challenge at ice cream places). The variety of flavors was amazing! Service size and prices were quite reasonable. We loved our ice cream and Italian ice! It was fresh, and a good quality. The place was very very clean, and lots of seating available. I will be back as soon as I can!

This ice cream is fantastic!! And to top it off, the prices…read moreand portion sizes are also fantastic!! Finally, some real ice cream in Columbus!

We love having coffee here in the morning. Their scones are delicious!…read moreCoffee is delicious too!

I think you're twice so far, just to get coffee, but will definitely come in for their brunch…read moresomeday! The menu looks great, with a lot more variety than I expected. Each time I've come in I've gotten a hot coffee with sugar-free syrup, and I really appreciate how they have eight or nine flavors that come sugar-free! I usually order some type of hot latte with oat milk, and it taste amazing! Served at the perfect temperature, and only takes a few minutes to come out. The staff is always friendly, and there is always plenty of seating here. I definitely plan to come back for brunch, or even a place to work during the day!

I finally got to try a burger and not just the ice cream. The burger was a thin smash burger with…read morecheese onion and mustard. The burger was pretty tasty but I especially liked the tater tots! They were so flavorful! The ice cream is also great!!

Wife and I staying hotel next door. Walked over and made an order to go. They got my wife's order…read moreright. My order was WRONG. Both of our burgers were so salty you could hardly eat them. You would think after spending almost $30.00 you would get a Thank You....but NO!

Would rate this a 0 if I could but unfortunately I can't so here is the one star that you don't…read moredeserve. Don't recommend coming here. The service is terrible. 2 hotdogs should not take half an hour to make. Do not recommend going there at 9:30 P.M. or later. Even with a full staff they will make you sit the rest of the time while they make food for themselves until they finally get to your order. Have had this happen multiple times. Could use better staff of shut the place down and put something there actually worth everybody's time.

Sonic has only been in Columbus for a few months, but it is already becoming a favorite! Please…read moredon't let one poor review stop you from trying this location. All of their employees are new as the location is new. The managers are doing a great job and they want to serve you. The poor employees will be weeded out in time.

Going into Casey's I saw this atrocity. One of the workers had I guess what you could call a mask…read moreon. It was copper in the shape of a mask with no barrier. When asked about it the manager said that copper kills germs and that would suffice as a protection against Covid. Seriously? Really? It's a shame that they don't care about spreading a deadly disease.

I used to love going to this Casey's, 1. Because it's conveniently located 2. The staff was always…read moreso nice 3. The pizza and breakfast options were always satisfying. Recently, however, due to management changes or employee changes I've come to regret supporting this business. One employee in particular with short brown hair always has to scan my ID even though I've been a customer here for over 20' years. Then when I do get my product I have to reach over the counter in to her side to retrieve my paid for belongings. She never slides what I have purchased into my side of the counter. Whenever I question or have a question for her she always replies with such a snarky and cunty attitude. She treats everyone like this, so I've heard. I've actually gone out of my way to not go here while she's working. Stay away folks if you see this one behind the counter! What ever happened to customer service? Not at this place where the one behind the counter rules her court. The only dude that works behind the counter, however is the best and is why I would give 1.5 stars. I'd actually give him 10 stars but the brown headed lately just brings this down. Maybe they should give the guy more shifts as she seems to be the only one I encounter or encountered recently as I no longer even go here due to her anymore. Good luck folks! Best keep your questions and remarks to yourself.

Food was delicious but when I got up out of the booth, a spring poked into the crash of my pants,…read moreripping a hole. When I let the lady at the front know when I paid, she said sorry and that was it. So when I explain to the owner that it ripped a hole in my jeans, he said sorry I'll go fix it. No offer to take care of the $80 pair of buckle jeans I was wearing for work that are now ruined. The food was great, but I thought at least an offer to cover my meal or pay for my pants.

Had lunch on August 11 2024 food was not up to par broasted chicken was cold , salad bar was not…read morefresh, cheese on pizza tasted different like they cha get brand it didn't brown, but crust was overcooked. Very disappointed. Also waitress never came had to go find my own plates.

After having multiple issues ordering pizza in town, we ordered pizza from this Casey's which was…read morethe better of the ones we had tried. For what its worth the Pizza was good. The employee behind the counter told my wife that he didn't know how to ring up the pizzas, and that she could just "Fucking leave". After I went back in to get his name he tried to argue with me and refused to give me his name. He also had his mask on his chin. Either wear it right or not at all. Could care less which one you choose.

This was my first time stopping in and it is just like other locations I've been to. We came during…read morea busy evening rush but were sat quickly and had fresh food available throughout our stay. We were asked if we had any pizza flavor requests when we entered which was nice! I didn't know they took requests so I didn't have any, but there were plenty of standard and novel flavors to choose from while we were there including taco, Mac n cheese, buffalo chicken, etc. There was much more than pizza including fried chicken, mashed potatoes, fried fish, vegetables, pasta, and several other common dinner items. The dessert pizza was our favorite part of the visit! I loved the cinnamon pizza, and the fresh cookie pizza was absolutely perfect paired with their soft serve ice cream machine. I don't know of any other buffets in town, although this is more geared towards kids I'm glad to have found a place like this with a variety of food options in a buffet set up! The quality of the food was about what I would expect for a spot like this, and a meal under $20 on the weekend.

Price was way too high for me. Senior/Veteran discount…read moredoesn't help. I don't eat like I used to so a buffet like this doesn't make sense for this high price.

Perfect breakfast café to visit in Columbus Nebraska. We were visiting our cousins in the Schuyler…read morearea, and was able to meet up with a cousin at the Picket Fence Café. Our server was extremely friendly, and she also stated she was from Schuyler. My wife had the Oatmeal which she loved. Our daughter and our cousin had perfectly prepared Omelets. I had the Chicken Fried Steak and it was excellent as it came with toast, eggs and hash browns. This was our second visit to the Picket Fence, but not our last. We will be back when we revisit the area next summer.

12:30 10 to 15 tables unoccupied, and every one of them was dirty. It's a small restaurant. Most…read moreoccupied tables already had their food and three girls were working the floor. None of them were attempting to clean any tables we left..

This is a hard review for me to write. I am lumping dozens and dozens of experiences together to…read morecome to that 3 star rating. El Tapatio used to be great. Hands down the best Mexican in Columbus. This was years ago when they were in the basement of a building on the square down town. Growing up it was a special treat to go here. Then in college I ate here at least once a week. The food was fantastic and the owner and staff were great people. They got to know me by name I loved it so much. Back then it was a lock for 5 stars. But I am very old that this was back before even yelp existed. We were back in Columbus recently and I insisted we go back to El Taps (what we called it). It is in a new building about a block from the old restaurant location. Sadly it was miles away in quality. The place was almost empty and it still took forever to order and then forever again to get our food. Then when it came... it was not good. I was heartbroken. I'm not sure what happened or if it was an off day but it was bad. By itself it would be a one star but I am holding on to 100 great meals from years past and going to settle on giving it a 3. Here is hoping you have a better time than our last visit. Assuming they have the same owner that they used to, they were good people and deserve all the success they can get.

When with a small group in the evening. We were quickly seated and received our chips and drinks…read morejust as fast. Excellent service and great recommendations. The food was excellent and when I am back in town again, I plan to visit to continue through their vast menu.