Cancel

Open app

Search

Dagostaro's Pizzeria

4.0 (1 review)

Dagostaro's Pizzeria Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Dagostaro's Pizzeria

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 50,657 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Michael Angelo's Pizzaria

Michael Angelo's Pizzaria

4.2(327 reviews)
6.8 mi
$$

The fried chicken is amazing. The juicy inside and crispy outside is makes my heart happy. Did I…read moremention there was a side of fries that were well seasoned? Well there was and definitely worth the money. The fried chicken takes 20 min. They make them fresh. You can definitely tell. Service was friendly and the pizza shop was clean. Definitely gives you the 90s vibe.

Your middle of the road pizza place where nearby families go and local little league teams host…read moretheir team parties. I tried some cheese pizza that was ordered by someone else. We were here with friends and didn't really feel like pizza. I ordered zucchini, calamari, and a large salad for my own family. The calamari and zucchini were pretty good and came quickly, piping hot. Cocktail sauce and ranch were pretty good. Definitely a passing grade for a small mom and pop pizza spot. Pizza was good enough when it came out hot. As it got cold, as most average pizzas do, taste really fell off. The large salad was also a good size. Ingredients like pepperoncinis and olives were generous... decent amount of protein (chicken) though it was like some precooked possibly prepackaged grilled chicken with no color on it. Freshly cooked chicken would be a massive and simple upgrade. Size/quality value was pretty good though, and again, I liked the ranch. Games kept the kids occupied for a bit. Lots of screens around the perimeter for watching the game. Pretty clean, just a little dated and dark inside. If you compare to a locally beloved place like Graziano's I'd say this place is comparable. Pizza I couldn't tell you which is better. Sides like the salad and calamari are a better value here, but Grazi's has some better options in the potatoes and their calzones. I think the ceiling on a place like this is 4 stars. They get a 3.5. Better protein in the salads? Cheese that doesn't turn into bland plastic when it isn't piping hot out of the oven? Brighten up the interior a little? If you're wanting that little league pizza party nostalgia when it comes to food and vibe, this place doesn't disappoint.

Photos
Michael Angelo's Pizzaria
Michael Angelo's Pizzaria - Michaelangelo's Special Edition the best

Michaelangelo's Special Edition the best

Michael Angelo's Pizzaria

See all

Petrilli's Pizza

Petrilli's Pizza

4.4(905 reviews)
3.7 mi
$$

Best pizza I am not a pepperoni person. I love the pepperoni, highly recommended. Excellent is…read moreexcellent and that's what these guys are.

LOCATION: right off the 10 on Mountain in a shopping plaza, good amount of parking, but small…read moreplaza. Very convenient to find. SERVICE: The man at the front helping with taking orders and giving customer the orders is friendly and accommodating. Gave us a free ranch and the complimentary cheeses and chili flakes. Orders could taken a bit longer around dinner time as they are very popular in town! DoorDash pick up is a little pricier than ordering with them over the phone by a couple of bucks, not too bad. We've also ordered large orders ahead of time and they've been accommodating. FOOD: We always love the Bianco and the Speciality, mainly the speciality! Delicious! The crust is thick and bottom is a little hard, but the toppings are generous. The bottom of our pizza was a little soggy I think due to time and amount of toppings, but we still love it. The sausage they have is great and the cheese pulls long! I love their square slices when you order Large or XL for parties. Keep in mind they are pricer around 48-54$ and small for two is $25. They have a personal pizza for around $19.

Photos
Petrilli's Pizza - There's 2 bare bones dining tables and chairs if you have no time to go home to enjoy your absolutely delicious freshly made pizza.

There's 2 bare bones dining tables and chairs if you have no time to go home to enjoy your absolutely delicious freshly made pizza.

Petrilli's Pizza - Mushrooms/olives/tomatoes,/peppers/pineapple/onions. Nice & loaded. A "Small" (12")

Mushrooms/olives/tomatoes,/peppers/pineapple/onions. Nice & loaded. A "Small" (12")

Petrilli's Pizza - Pepperoni, salami, jalapeño, olives

See all

Pepperoni, salami, jalapeño, olives

Pizza Pirates - Lg. "The ultimate", well done. Very nice.

Pizza Pirates

4.2(232 reviews)
6.2 mi
$$

Arrr, ye scurvy landlubbers! Gather 'round while Captain Blacktooth spills the grog about this fine…read moregrub tavern! By the powers, the grub here be legendary! The pizza -- arr, she be a crispy, saucy beauty that'd make even the saltiest sea dog weep with joy. The cheese sticks? Golden, gooey treasures straight from Davy Jones' own pantry! And don't ye dare set sail without tryin' them raspberry dessert sticks -- sweet as stolen Spanish gold and twice as temptin'! The housemade ranch dressin'? By Poseidon's soggy beard, 'tis the finest white elixir to ever grace a pirate's tongue! Creamy, garlicky, and fit for a king... or at least a very well-fed buccaneer. The prices? Ha! So fair they'd make a merchant captain blush and hand over his purse without a fight! One last thing, ye swabs -- sign yer name to an account, ye will! Pile up them points like pieces of eight fer yer next plunderin' feast. Every bite earns ye more bounty! Five skulls and crossed cutlasses out o' five! This be the best port o' call for a hungry pirate in these waters! Yarrrr! ‍

Always the best price for amazing pizza! I'm telling you these guys know how to make a great pizza,…read morefrom extra mozzarella cheese to your very own personalized pizza! You can tell their customer service is always very professional and helpful. They have coupons available so make sure to double check what fits your needs and save some extra cash! Very clean establishment, some seating for if you want to enjoy your pizza or hangout to wait for your pizza to be done. Kyle was very friendly and helped with an issue I had when ordering online. He was very cheerful and delivered customer service with a smile! That brightened my day to pick up my pizza! Check this place out and enjoy!

Photos
Pizza Pirates
Pizza Pirates - This is how the Pepperoni Deluxe is supposed to look.

This is how the Pepperoni Deluxe is supposed to look.

Pizza Pirates

See all

Dagostaro's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...