It was really good ice cream for my first ever visit here. I got a two scoop sundae and with tip,…read more20%, it came to over $11. In my opinion, that's outrageous so I probably won't be back. That being said, the service was very good, but it's just too expensive for ice cream

I love this place! I went in once and tried the beantown ice cream flavor, and that's basically all…read moreI had for the next couple of visits... and I don't think I will change my choice for a long time. It is one of the best coffee flavored ice creams I've ever had. The owners are also very friendly and accommodating, and there are even seats outside on the busy Peoria heights road. Definitely stop by and try it out, you won't regret it... unless you're counting calories, then maybe.

Review Visit: September 29th, 2013…read more "Do you want to go to The Ice Cream Shack?" "Sure! Which one?" "THE Ice Cream Shack." "Right, but which one? Peoria has a ton of them." "It's a place called THE ICE CREAM SHACK." "Ohhhhhh..." I imagine that is a common conversation among people when they are talking about coming here. I know there was some slight confusion between my cousin and I when we made plans to check this place out. After spending the afternoon hiking at Forest Park Nature Center with my friend Tim and my cousin's family, we needed some sugary treats to recharge our batteries. The kids were vocally loud in their agreement on getting ice cream. So, we hopped in our cars and headed over. I had been by this area quite a few times and never realized there was an ice cream place. The building itself is a bit recessed from the road and doesn't really have an outlandish look that some ice cream shacks have. So, you can end up driving by without noticing it (as I have). It was a slow when we pulled up so there was plenty of parking for our two vehicles. We hopped out and walked on up to the window to figure out what we wanted. Luckily this place doesn't have a million different options to pick from like a lot of places. Their menu is simplistic and focused on ice cream with a small selection of non-frozen desserts to pick from. On this day, I snagged a Peanut Butter Cup-flavored wizard. As we waited for our snacks, I eagerly anticipated getting a peanut butter cup-themed wizard staff and hat to go with my delectable. When they called my name, I sprinted up to the window to get my goodies. What they gave me was just the wizard that I ordered and no garments or anything else. Dream crushed. I'm kidding. We all got our orders in a fairly quick time as there weren't many people there. I don't recall what everyone else got but we took some funny photos while scarfing down our sugary dairy products. Everyone seemed to enjoy what they ordered and after goofing around a bit more, we parted ways. Not only did the kids get to be kids jacked up on ice cream and hiking, us adults got to be kids at heart while being goof balls loaded up on sugar.

I don't understand for the life of me why a business can't accept credit cards. It's 2025 not 1910,…read moreare the owners that cheap? It's not like their prices are low enough to justify it. They actually cost more than Dairy Queen. Once I saw that and there prices I just turned around. I just can't support a business that can't support itself

Love this place. Every time I go back to visit Peoria, we must stop and we try to take friends. Our…read moremost recent visit, we were served by Yeni herself and she was really kind about having us try several flavors before we made our final selections. This shop has so many things! Regular ice cream, dairy-free sorbet flavors, horchata, aqua fresca and boozy flavors. So much, all home made. My plan was to have a scoop of the no sugar added avocado ice cream as I did my previous visit. It was so refreshing on a hot night. Sadly, this flavor was not available, but there were OH SO many. The lavender was wonderful. The pine nut was unexpectedly sweet and smooth. My husband ended up choosing starry night, which was a mix of berries topped with gold star shaped sprinkles and it was a beautiful presentation. My choice ended up being something she suggested that I try. I honestly can't remember the name but the 90s was in the title so of course it was something I was interested in ha ha. So let me tell you, this flavor tasted like Saturday mornings as a kid, when you're watching cartoons, eating cereal and then you drink the last bit of your sweetened milk from the bottom of the bowl. Oh my gosh, it took me back! Yeni explained that it was a mix of her homemade Mexican vanilla and she added grape nuts. Yes, you heard that right - grape nuts, cereal! I am so excited that this shop is in Peoria Heights, and I hope that it stays for a long time. We will plan to be back regularly. Thank you for the wonderful hospitality. Yeni!

I had the Mexican corn and an ice cream I forgot the name but it was purple and had stars on it…read more Very good place with unique flavors. Definitely Give this place a a try!

Wow! Just wow! This ice cream & yo-cream shoppe has it all. When you first walk in you get to…read morechoose between cups that are flat rate pay or per oz. pay. We chose the oz. Now, I don't like to brag, but we bought $37 worth of ice cream and yo-cream in there today and there are only two of use. We ate all of it, every little sprinkle, m&m, nut, brownie chunk, chocolate rock, Andes' mint and gummy worm, cherry, chocolate, pineapple, vanilla swirl! We like to have died happily ever after today. It looked like a pink piglet silo inside, which I appreciated, because I felt like a little pink pig eating all that. Afterwards, we rolled out the door and barely made it into our vehicle without using a crane. Best birthday ice-cream I ever had and I'm turning 47 this year. . . See you all summer long! Oink oink

a very cute shop with lovely outdoor seating. the froyo was really yummy and they had so many…read moreoptions for toppings!

Small spot for ice cream. Very old business that does soft serve. Cash only too. Wasn't impressed…read morewith their take on the Reese's blizzard mainly because about halfway through it was water. Not sure if it was a problem with the machine or not but it wasn't it for me.

A Peoria institution for decades. In the more than half-century that I've been coming here, have…read morenever, ever, had a bad experience. If you have visitors coming to town, take them here on a balmy summer evening and enjoy the cold, sweet treats along with the broad cross-section of Peorians from all walks of life.

Review Visit: November 4th, 2012…read more Cold Stone Steve Austin approves. If you aren't a 1990's wrestling fan, you might not get the reference above. But if you are, I am sad to say that Stone Cold Steve Austin and this place have nothing in common. That said, you can wrestle the inner guilt as you treat yourself to some delicious ice cream. Erin, Matt and I wandered in at the tail end of our travels. We needed something sweet to wrap up a day of traveling. As we walked in, our eyes lit up at the amount of delicious ice creams they had. We approached the counter and ended up sampling a few things before we settled on what sounded good. Our scoops of ice cream were served in little bowls with little plastic spoons. Skipping the cone let us sit down and eat the ice cream at a casual pace instead of fighting the melt. As we sat there, we all remarked at the same time on how good the ice cream was. The flavors ordered are long forgotten but the memory of the visit and the smiles on our faces are forever etched in my mind. The ice cream was really good, I will say that. Not homemade good but close. It was especially delicious after a long day of traveling and exploring. If you haven't explored and/or traveled much, it will unexpectedly wear you out. Luckily, you don't have to come to Peoria for Cold Stone. They have locations scattered throughout the United States. Check the website below to see if there is a location near you.

What could improve? Let's start with the fact that we walked into the store all happy, after…read morewatching a movie. While we were laughing and having a good time, and NOT disturbing anyone, these so called "employees" gave us so much attitude and sass. That is the worse thing a customer can experience. They asked us what we wanted with so much attitude and then as we walked away, they called my boyfriend and his other friend gay. What kind of customer SERVICE is that? We were so respectful to them. So if you want more customers to come over, don't hire those types of people. That's what causes corporation to go in the dust. We will NOT be coming again. ps. we all got called bitches

Very friendly, fast, and good food and ice cream reminds me of my childhood going here.read more

As we approached to order from the outside walk up windows we were told you had to order inside. We…read morewalked in and it was so hot inside...no air, it was not at all bright & inviting like every other ice cream shop. We proceeded to order & my husband stepped back outdoors to wait since it was so hot inside. I ordered a small choc/van twist cone & he ordered a small cherry slush glacier. It took about 10 mins, which was not bad but when she placed the cone and glacier on the counter I was sadly disappointed. The cone was very lopsided and the color of the ice cream was off. The vanilla was a weird rusty white color and the chocolate was pale grayish brown. You could tell by looking at it the texture of the ice cream was not smooth & creamy at all and very grainy & icy. My husband's cherry glacier had ice cream dripping down the side of the cup and a lid smashed on top & no straw or spoon.When she called my order I couldn't believe it was ours because every other place we order this, it looks tempting to eat. This looked so unappetizing! She had also placed my cone on the dirty counter where all customers are placing their hands and money on. I knew by the looks of my cone and after placing it on the counter that I was not going to eat it, it was all just off. I picked them up proceeded outside where my husband looked at my cone and & said that color is all off. He opened his treat and said this ice cream is off. I took one lick off my cone and it was gritty and the flavor was not good. Mine went immediately to the garbage, he tried to eat his but ended up throwing it away as well. A waste of $8 and sorry that we left a very generous tip. It has definitely changed from last summer. The ice cream, the cleanliness, the atmosphere have all gone down hill. We won't be back.

Moved to town not to long ago and a new ice cream place opened up over the summer! It's in place of…read morethe Old Dairy Queen in case you didn't know! I've visited a couple times and I took a few pictures every time I went. The people that work here are super friendly, helpful and quick! I have discovered that the blueberry cheesecake creamer is my absolute favorite! The ice cream tastes so fresh and Light! They have a ton of seating surrounding the building and when I go I also see a lot of people hanging around, happy, and having fun! They usually get through the lines pretty quickly though. If you see a big crowd of people don't hesitate to stop, the wait won't be very long! Get over there and try a blueberry cheesecake creamer, you won't regret it!

Carius Creamery in Morton is a hometown gem--still under the same ownership as when it was Dairy…read moreQueen downtown for so many years. They've kept all the charm and quality you'd expect, with a fantastic ice cream selection that feels very familiar if you loved the classic DQ menu. The service is always quick and incredibly friendly--it's the kind of place where you feel welcome the moment you walk up. There's plenty of parking and outdoor seating, which makes it perfect for families or a relaxing treat. And with a park just across the street, it's a great stop when you're out with little ones. Delicious ice cream, great people, and a perfect location.