Pizza is great, they are always polite, always fast, and almost always make a perfect order (and on the rare occasion they don't, they fix it quickly). Our go-to pizza place. Really glad they are here. read more

I just attempted to order a pizza from you guys. The lady who took my order was so rude on the phone and kept yelling at me to please hold and then would yell at the customers in the restaurant that she would be right with them. She then told me it was going to be 45 minutes and sounded all mad. And then i decided to take my business elsewhere because obviously she should care less. I am disappointed because i wanted to try your pizza but not when you have employees working for you like that. Sincerely a disappointed customer. read more

I was racially profiled and laughed at while ordering and the person after me was talked to very nice and normal, not sure why, it was my first time there and it was very poor customer service and average food read more

Cute little restaurant with great low prices, probably the best pizza for its price. The short guy who makes the pizza took my order and he is so sweet! I think his name was Oliver? Pizza wasn't too greasy, the crust is to die for, and the feel of Crusted is the perfect small establishment experience. I'd give it 6 stars if I could! read more

Pizza was awesome. The guy called me sweetie/honey too but it isn't a big deal to me. I know another reviewer was sketched out by it. I' grew up in the 80's so I have heard this most of my life. Not saying it is right or wrong but I worry about other things. My kids raved about the pizza and every iight asked to go back. If looking for pizza this is the place! read more

For the price, the pizza is pretty good. Not as greasy as Little Caesars but in other ways, it's similar to theirs. The pizza was ready in 15 mins and the staff when I picked up were friendly. Great choice for a quick lunch or dinner on a game night like we had. Worth supporting this local TC business! read more

Crusted Creations - Large pepperoni pizza with Parmesan crust - Pizza Near Me - Traverse City, Michigan

The oldest pizza joint in TC! Maybe Dino's is older? Great owner Craig is a heck of nice guy and makes a great pie! They have a 50% off second a pizza, great deal for families or large parties! Good salads. read more

Great local spot. Pizza was very good. Delivery was promp even though we're hard to find.

We ordered a large pineapple and ham pizza and an antipasto salad with ranch. Both were really really good and it only took about twenty minutes. I took one star away because I'd asked for a garlic butter crust and didn't get it, but other than that it was good and we'll be ordering again. read more

Crusted Creations - Antipasto salad with ranch - Pizza Near Me - Traverse City, Michigan

See all

I worked there in 1988 in the store making pies and as a delivery driver. I remember the busiest night, I made 32 deliveries and worked 5pm to 4am. One delivery, the pizza was $9 and change and the woman gave me a $20 and said keep it. I said, are you sure and she said yeah babe, enjoy. read more

My family has gone to crusted creations for as long as I can remember. I don't want to be a mean person but... the guys working here are.... Not great. They told me 20 mins and I was there in 25. They then "couldn't find my order" and then once they found it they said it wasn't paid for (I paid over the phone). The manager is nice but the guys working kept calling me "sweetie" like I was 5 years old & then once everything was settled with the payment they told me it was 10 min wait. I'm fine with waiting 10 mins but why tell me 20 if it was actually more like 40....? Just a weird interaction. Good pizza tho. read more

On vacation and am so happy with this place. Easy to order, on time delivery, good price and tastes great. Definitely doing this next year read more

See all

Pizza tasted really good and crispy bottom to crust. The bread was also good. Great non chain taste to try something different.

I downloaded this app just to leave this review , I can excuse it taking 45min every time I order and even let slide being rude sometimes , pizza places can be stressful to work at. This time tho, they put me on hold....10 mins pass, chalk it up to forgetting. I wait 10min, call back and they do it again. Usually u can hear them on another call or the counter but they put it on hold and go back to make food. That is a new level of lazy and rude. Horrible service but darn good pizza tho haha. Edit: waited 15mins and they took the phone off the hook on a Monday at 7. Apparently the crew doesn't wanna be contacted at the store tonight. read more

Holy crap. We have ordered pizza from these guys for the last number of years. Ordered today for delivery at about 11:30. They called at 12:15, couldn't find the address. They went back to the store to have someone else deliver it. That person couldn't find it (Google wan't holding their hand enough). That person went back to store. 1:30 I talked to the manager. He says that it's my fault because I didn't give them an "address they can find". I tell him shouldn't have to pay for pizza 2 hours late (for a customer) and he says "then I'll just cancel your order" and he hung up on me. Customer service?? What's that? read more

Saturday, 9/16/2023, stopped in for a gyro in the afternoon. The only woman working had a grimace and didn't use any words while I ordered but instead just shoved her hand on my face when I was looking for the credit card scanner. I wish I could say that being rude and filthy was the worst of the service, but nope. So with her bare hands she entered my order, ran my card, handled the bun, retrieved and heated the meat, answered the phone, stuck dirty dishes in the dirty dish water, typed on the order screen, filled the bun with meat, scratched her scalp, then grabbed all the toppings to place in the gyro. Again, no hand washing, no gloves. Bare-handed placed feta, onion, lettuce, and tomato I assume on the sandwich and then audibly shooed a fly away. I used that pause to finally collect myself enough to say "I changed my mind, please give me a refund.". I can't even deal with what I witnessed in those 10 minutes. After YEARS of eating their pizzas I'm just disgusted thinking about how unsanitary it is now and wonder how long has this been going on. I wonder if we could carbon date the stains on her work clothes to get a ballpark, as they appear to have never been washed. read more

So good! Absolutely love their $8 take out special and will go there as long as they have it!

Must be under new ownership because the menu changed and when we ordered what we have been ordering for the last 10 years the person didn't know what we were talking about. read more

Really good pizza, good crisp crust and a great value. They also have delicious homemade chocolate chip cookies. Would give 5 Stars but the guy answering the phone is consistently RUDE. Won't recommend as a result. Owner - fire that dude, or keep him off the phone. He is ruining your profit! read more

Pizza tastes like cardboard, management might be the most inept human in existence. called three consecutive fridays for pickup order only to discover upon arrival my pizza hadn't been made! On the second occasion he gave me a pepperoni pizza instead of pineapple, when I mentioned this they put raw pineapple on a already cooked pizza and said there you go. Awesome, as he gave away a free salad to the guy in front of me for no reason. If you are a tourist I highly recommend you avoid this pizza at all costs. Flies all over the kitchen, shitty pizza and horrible customer service. i suggest trying Dino's, Domino's, Pizza Hut etc...Usually I recommend local but in this instance avoid them like the plague, I know I will. read more

The pizza's fair, it's not the best I've ever had but it's not the worst. And don't let people lie to you: You can absolutely get bad pizza, and it's NOT still good. What I DO like however, are the calzones. I mean even they are nothing to write home about, but they're filling and tasty and sit at a good price. I can't complain about that. read more

This is one of our favorite pizza places in town. Might be the best. Very reasonable I.e. large w/ double cheese, pepperoni and mushroom with a side of extra sauce $14.95. And I'm a sauce guy and their sauce is very good might be why I think it's one of the best in town. read more

Crusted Creations has been around for quite a while (I can't remember it not being there). Its just a pizza place. No where to sit, no fancy tvs, no atmosphere. However they do offer some tasty pizza. They have an average thickness crust that is pretty tasty. They are pretty cheap, and its not anything to write home about. However they consistently put out a tastier pizza in comparison to other joints around town. read more

The guy answering the phone was extremely rude. He hung up on me 3 times for no reason-I wasn't rude, even when I had to call back because I was "disconnected". Canceled our order and bought elsewhere. read more

Best pizza in traverse city! Always good and crunchy never had a bad order, and def a good value

Everyone is extremely rude. The phone guy is short, cuts you off, and just sounds miserable. They are not much better in person. When arriving to pick up my order, I was asked my name, and I said they never asked me my name, to which the guy replied do you have a name? I said my name and what I ordered and he finally asked my phone number after explaining to me that he has sooo many orders and there is no way to pull up what I ordered. I didn't say anything but how am I supposed to know how your POS system works? Especially when their super helpful phone guy doesn't ask the correct info? The pizza has been progressively worse each time. We will not go back. So many other places to get good food and friendly environment in TC. Skip this place. read more

This is one of if not the oldest pizza place in TC. They make my favorite pizza in the world, but I fully admit I am completely biased. This is not a greasy thick overly filling pizza. It isn't a thin crust either. The crust is soft but firm and bubbles up nicely in the oven. Very standard toppings. It doesn't seem like anything special, but their ground beef and mushroom pizza with extra sauce is phenomenal. read more

I have never in my life experienced such terrible service. The people here were rude, condescending, and mean. You couldn't pay me to go back here. In the past month I've found myself ordering pizza from here often. You can buy a single slice and they're pretty close to where I live. It became a routine for me to buy a small pizza or a couple slices on my way home after running errands (i.e. bank, grocery shopping, etc.) Their pizza's not the best but also not the worst and for the money I was okay with that; Until today. Today I was refused service after the woman at the register would not accept my debit card. She claimed that my faded signature actually read see id and demanded I show her my license. I did not have my id on me, as my house is only a few blocks away and who in their right mind thinks they'll need a photo id to buy a slice of pizza. She was rude and condescending and was essentially insinuating the debit card was not mine. I thought about writing a review then and there but decided to go back with my id and try to reconcile what had just happened. I walked in calm and attempted to have a reasonable conversation with this woman when she began cutting me off saying do you want a slice a pizza. Every sentence I began she interrupted immediately to the point where I was speechless. After being yelled at and interrupted countless times by her I asked to speak to her manager. Eventually, she did, but I watched as they walked out together her whisper to him while he shook his head. He began the conversation already decided. He claimed I was arguing with him and that the back of my id could easily be mistaken to have read see id. The mistreatment I experienced left me dumbfounded to the point where I just walked out. I have worked behind a register at a food establishment for years and never once have I even checked for a signature let alone think I need to on a three dollar order. The entire experience was ridiculous and I will never go back again. read more

I never post reviews but this place got me so angry. I arrived 5 minutes before my order was supposed to be done. I ask the guy behind the counter how long and he tells me 10 minutes. Cool 5 minutes behind isnt a big deal. Not super busy but hey everyone falls behind. After 11 minutes he tells me 'Almost done'. Alright must be boxing it up now. Again a little past when I was told but no biggie. After 25 minutes of my arrival (20 minutes after it was supposed to be done) he has it ready. This is Pizza, not filet mignon. It takes 18 to 20 minutes to make a pizza. What were you doing the 20 minutes before I arrived? Again it wasn't busy one other person came in. And honestly I would have been fine if the guy behind the counter simply said 'sorry for the wait' or 'My bad I thought it was going to be done earlier' Or anything. The lackadaisical attitude infuriated me. I get it you're not being paid any more to help out the customer but a little urgency or care would be nice. Pizza was good but overpriced. Service was abysmal. Won't go back and you shouldn't either. read more

Called for a carryout the idiot who answered the phone was extremely rude and short with me when trying to use a coupon. When I ask to place an order the guy said in a really snotty condescending tone "WHAT DO YOU WANT" then proceeded to be even ruder when I requested extra sauce. Go ahead and throw that food in the trash I'll pay a pizza restaurant that knows how to talk to people. read more

This pizza joint is absolutely delicious! I love their calzones, as they never skimp on the cheese and their crust is to die for! I highly recommend this place. The staff is always so kind and funny! It's hard to find a place that has consistently amazing food and great people that work there. 5 stars! read more

GET RID OF THE GUY THAT WORKS THE PHONE!!! It's the same guys for years. He's just a jerk for no reason. It's crazy to me he is still working there. Looks like I'm not the only one complaining. Won't be ordering pizza from there anymore. read more

These guys are my favorite pizza place Can I order pizza about 3 weeks ago and I went down to pick it up holy expecting that they were at hearing to covert 19 Food preparation Precautions.I walked into fill my pizza and to my dismay Neither of the 2 people that were working we're wearing facemask or Gloves. I inquired as to why they were not.They became verbally violent with me.This is not what I expected.Prior to covert 19 they have been a great place to purchase Awesome pizza. I am deeply saddened that I will No longer be able to patronize Crusted creations . During these trouble times, I will be forced not to patronize crusted creations until They have changed. And Put the safety of their customers 1st read more

Pizza is great! My second favorite place in TC. But their service sucks! Absolutely sucks! Just got off the phone with a rude employee, who wouldn't take my order, and hung up on me. Well, i guess it's Jets from now on! read more

This was an excellent pizza option while we were staying at the Great Wolf Lodge. A well made pie with interesting crust options. It was great to get a satisfying meal for a reasonable price while supporting a local business. read more

Crusted Creations is by far the best pizza I have ever had. I used to like all the chain pizza places but they are so much better because they'll make the pizza exactly how you want it. The salads are great as well. I love the chefs salad the most and they even take out all the stuff that I don't like in there for me. They have fast delivery, and all the guys that work there are down to earth and nice :-) read more

Crusted creations is where it is happening. Good price and would definitely choose them over any of the other Pizza joints around town. Their crust is thinner than most and doesn't end up being like cardboard and their sauce is incredibly tasty. I usually get Xtra sauce. And to top it all off they have several flavors of crust. Poppy seed, sesame seeds, butter, garlic, Cajun, and ranch for free. I haven't done it in awhile but they use to have the "badonkadonk" crust, which is all the flavors of crust listed above and it was delicious. I can't recommend them enough. read more

Never Again. These guys are the worst. 40 min plus for a small pizza and bread sticks. Twice I've called ahead, ordered and picked up food from another restaurant, driven to Crusted Creations and waited while my other food gets cold. Not sure why I tried this a second time, but there won't be a third. read more

By far, the best BBQ chicken pizza I've had. I've had them all over & nothing compares. I used to get their pizzas when I was back in HS, but for whatever reason have overlooked them the last 30 years. They're back on top of my list! read more

Pretty good pizza at an incredible price. Only $7.99 for a 14" cheese pizza all the time, and it is above-average pizza by Upper Midwest or generally by non-Northeast standards for pizza ;) A reliable option. read more