Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Crosby's

    3.0 (1 review)
    Open 5:00 am - 11:00 pm

    Crosby's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Crosby's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Lexy M.
    1182
    984
    9228

    5 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Kelly M.

    Kelly M.

    Helpful 79
    Thanks 0
    Love this 63
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Crosby's

    The Perfect Pizza

    The Perfect Pizza

    3.6
    (31 reviews)
    2.3 mi
    $$

    Drove by The Perfect Pizza many times in my lifetime but never stopped in until tonight!…read more Was pleasantly surprised by how good their pizza and wings were and will be defiantly be stopping in again! Our waitress was patient and pleasant and the owner was very friendly as well. Made sure we had everything we needed. Got a large pizza for our group with the works on it as well as a medium cheese and pepperoni. Also tried their lemon pepper wings and medium wings which were cooked crisp and delicious! The restaurant is fairly small but kept clean. There was a steady stream of customers picking up pizza as well as eating in. Give them try! A local establishment who has been in the area for 30+ years and hopefully many more years!

    Late on posting this as it has been about a month since I was here, but better late than never!…read moreMy family and I were in Jamestown for a weekend and when it was time for dinner my 5-year old daughter wanted pizza. I always turn to Yelp when we're away from home and found The Perfect Pizza less than 2 miles away. My daughter loved it at first sight. A Michaelangelo (the world famous TMNT, not the world famous artist) figure as big as her greeted us and she was thrilled. As we sat down the waitress showed us where we could find coloring books and crayons for my daughter. It is a small place. Clean, casual, a bit eclectic in decoration, and feels very homey. Like your local pizza place you know and love. The waitress was very friendly, attentive, and helpful. We got a simple white pizza and a couple subs. My chicken tender sub was great; simple, crispy chicken, nothing fancy, but solid. I don't remember what sub my husband got, but I remember he got a large and liked it, but couldn't finish it. The pizza was a hit with my daughter. It felt a bit greasy, but I think only because it looked like there was a little oil on the pan to keep the pizza from sticking. It seems like a popular place as there was a steady stream of to-go orders picked up. I would definitely go back if we're in the area again.

    Photos
    Italian ranch parm wings were amazing!
    Italian ranch parm wings were amazing!
    P Amazing pizza and wings
    P Amazing pizza and wings
    Cauliflower crust

    See all

    Cauliflower crust
    PizzaExpress

    PizzaExpress

    3.1
    (12 reviews)
    0.9 mi

    I love both locations, but the lakewood one is my favorite…read more All the staff especially Travis are wonderful. Very welcoming and friendly. Nice little dine in section with great AC. They keep it very clean. Amazing wings with multiple varieties. Amazing grandwhiches. Great pizza. Amazing cheesey garlic bread sticks. Ice cold soda bottles. Kens ranch packets. Kens blue cheese cups. Fast drivers so please tip them well especially in winter. Perfect location right on Fairmount between the movie theater and mini golf/driving range. They're so good our friend drove all the way from little valley to lakewood just to eat their wings with us tonight.

    I'm not from the area, a friend recommended I try this place saying the food was delicious…read more My review is strictly based on service. There was NONE No friendly service . Went there 30 minutes before opening , was willing to wait. Worker came outside right before I even got close to the door and goes "can I help you" in the absolute rudest manner. I was kinda taken back and shocked a bit by his tone. So I just asked if this was pizza express and his response was again off putting "yes but we don't open til 11" Okay yeah I get that no big deal! The way he spoke to me was uncalled for so I just walked away. I still want pizza but not with a side of disrespect for your paying customers

    Photos
    Amazing wings! Amazing Grandwich bacon cheeseburger!
    Amazing wings! Amazing Grandwich bacon cheeseburger!
    Birthday boy wanted wings and pizza logs! They were amazing!
    Birthday boy wanted wings and pizza logs! They were amazing!
    Amazing wings!  20 crispy hot butter garlic  20 medium butter garlic. Garlic cheesey bread is to die for

    See all

    Amazing wings! 20 crispy hot butter garlic 20 medium butter garlic. Garlic cheesey bread is to die for
    Domino's Pizza

    Domino's Pizza

    2.8
    (9 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    $

    Domino's is usually average pizza to me and last night I ordered delivery. I got two pizzas and on…read morethe app it said that Roger was preparing my order. Roger knows how to make some pizzas! The delivery was within the time specified, if not earlier. The pizzas were hot and fresh and they might have been the best Domino's pizzas I've ever had. They really tasted good. I forgot to check the well done box on how I wanted to have the pizzas cooked and they still were cooked well done and had that extra bit of crisp to them especially on the crust without being burnt. Decent for their thicker hand tossed crust pizza. I didn't take a picture as I didn't intend on writing a review, but it hit the spot and actually impressed me.

    To start off we are all human I understand that and I was a manager of the Boca Raton location in…read moreWest palm beach Florida. This place needs to have a whole new retraining course on customers service let alone company policy. I called in to let them know that the food that was ordered was incomplete or just thrown down and I have it on camera footage. I got five out of 10 hot wings then got two orders of lava cake, but the lava cakes are all on top of each other. All messed up a cheesy bread that is never since been up here cooked thoroughly. It always has raw dough in the middle and I have to re-cook it here at my house. and the pizza was just thrown to the ground. It's kind of crazy. I called in to speak to the store manager very politely said that I was sorry for bothering them. I just wanted to make sure they were aware of everything and all he was able to do was tell me how I wasn't the one who had any business calling in because I didn't place the order. My kids Aunt did from Queens, New York and we are inJamestown. Although it's my house, I received the order why am I not allowed to call in about it? It's quite interesting. The manager was absolutely rude I just let him know that this wasn't gonna work out and I have a good rest of the night and sorry for calling.. I don't think he deserves the position of management. Also they never ever send the icing that goes to the lava cake even when you buy two or three of them and don't ask for paper plates or napkins they won't come either

    Photos
    This is their Joke version of Alfredo sauce extra cheese pepperoni banana pepper. They want us to pay for them to fix it.
    This is their Joke version of Alfredo sauce extra cheese pepperoni banana pepper. They want us to pay for them to fix it.
    Thinnest crust in history
    Thinnest crust in history
    Thin crust medium pizza

    See all

    Thin crust medium pizza
    Steener's Pub

    Steener's Pub

    4.0
    (81 reviews)
    2.0 mi
    $$

    BEST Chicken Wings! They are the most consistent. Fresh, meaty, crispy, saucy. They just do it…read moreright here. I get the hot buffalo. My daughter gets brown sugar on medium buffalo. The ranch dressing is so good with the wings and salads. It's not runny and must be made in-house. On a cool night, I'll also order the French onion soup. Service is always friendly and quick. The remodel gives them more space and the patio is great when we bring our dog with us. The bathroom in the expanded space is newer and more spacious. We love supporting this local restaurant. We'll see you soon! Thank you for staying open all year!

    For my drive back to Cleveland from skiing at Holiday Valley I was looking for a place along the…read moreroute to grab some fish and chips for dinner. Steener's Pub popped up and the reviews were good. Located in Bemus Point just a couple of miles from I 86 made for a convenient stop. Steener's is located a bit outside of the Bemus Point main drag, but there are a couple of other businesses nearby. The building looks modern from the outside, inside it looks like the original bar area has been there quite a while, they then added a dining room and later a second dining room. The decor is casual tavern style, lots of wood and mellow colors without much extra. The menu is a nice mix of typical bar food with a good selection of fish and seafood which makes sense for a place so near to Chautauqua Lake. Service was good, the waitress was friendly. I ordered the fish and chips since it was highlighted in the menu. The order came out quickly, a huge batter fried fish fillet on top of a load of fries with side cups of tarter sauce and coleslaw. The fries and coleslaw were just what you expect, good but nothing special. The fish was outstanding, mild flaky white fish in a perfectly crunchy coating; delicious and very satisfying. My only complaint was that while it was nicely presented on a square plate, having the huge fish fillet on top of the fries made it difficult to eat since I had to move the fish around to get to the fries and cutting the fish with the fries underneath did not work well. I appreciate attractive food presentation is important, but this was too much food for the size of the plate. I really liked my dinner at Steener's, if they could raise the level of the side dishes to match the fried fish this would be truly exceptional. Keep making great fish, just upgrade the rest of food to match.

    Photos
    2nd room
    2nd room
    Steener's Pub
    Front

    See all

    Front

    Crosby's - convenience - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...