Always good. Chicken finger and steak subs are our staple order. Worth the drive from EAread more

This is your exact prototypical neighborhood pizza. You know what you're getting every time and…read morewhile it isn't the greatest, it'll never let you down. $22 for a large cheese pepperoni pie is a good price these days. Sauce was sweeter, I enjoyed it. A little too doughy, wish it were crispier underneath so it held its form and not flopped while eating it. We also ordered the spicy sausage rolls, thinking they were similar to a pepperoni roll, with a pillowy bun stuffed with sausage and peppers, instead it was an egg roll type appetizer. Not bad, but it could be refined better. $9 for 3 smaller egg rolls cut in half. Atmosphere itself seems to be strictly a takeout joint. There are tables but it's not a particularly sit down place. Staff was friendly both on the phone and in person. Always prefer to support local food, will try other items in the future.

Great staff. Very friendly. Consistently great pizza…read more Would highly recommend. Been there 100's of times and drive 15 minutes & pass at least 10 pizzerias on my way.

Ordered a turkey sub. Awful. Roll was stale. Lettuce was bad. I asked for oil. No oil on it. I've…read moreordered from there a few times in the past and the food has been mediocre at best, but I wanted to give it another chance today. Big mistake. Will not return.

Very good food service. Delivery is good too. Highly recommend this restaurant…read more Staff are amazing

How can you mess up an order of 2 steak hoagies and an assorted sub. well they did. Received 1…read moresteak hoagie and 1 assorted and 1 some kind of plain chicken dry with nothing sub. WTF no more John and marys for us

They have entire vegan menu, upon request…read more The pizza was phenomenal. The ricotta on top was so good. We are are good eaters and one pizza is enough for two people. We got two because we wanted to try more than one, and we took half of each one home. It was great leftover, too. Best vegan pizza I've ever had.

This place is busy and when I say busy, I'm talking about a good 45min wait type of busy. But you…read moreknow what, it's totally worth the wait. You order at the counter and they will bring your food/drinks to you. I love the open kitchen concept, and it's always a joy to watch fresh pizza being made. Would definitely come back Chopped salad- easily can serve 3 people. If I didn't want pizza, I would definitely just come here for the salad and wine itself. Mushroom pizza- nice thin crust and delicious flavor profile. Cacio e Pepe- a ricotta top pizza that tastes really amazing.

Had a special with two 2 litters of pop on FB and their website but when I went to pick the order…read moreup and already paid for it they refused to give me the two bottles of pop that was part of the deal. I showed them their facebook page and they said they had the right to change at anytime!!! So they changed the deal after I paid!!!!! Would never go back plus the pizza tasted like a frozen Toney's pizza... nasty

Pizza pantry is the OG of the community for a great reason. Food is always consistent. We have…read morenever had a bad meal there. We really enjoy the sub sandwiches , and their wing orders are a dozen, rather than the 10 standard at most places now. Service is always good and ready at the time promised. Strictly a takeout place, great for bringing home food to enjoy

As far as pizza shops go, I'm not sure what else you could want out of one. Pizza is always solid,…read moreand the subs are always excellent. Staff is friendly and prompt whenever we call ahead. And arguably the most important, the prices for all their menu items is well within reason, no price gouging here and I respect that. Our family loves town line and they deserve all their flowers for a well run pizza parlor.

Used to be a great place to grab pizza and wings with a few extras. Not sure what happened lately…read morebut the last few visits have been less than impressive. Pizza is either undercooked or burned, the extras are underwhelming and the service is downright rude. Sorry to see a great place go down like this.

Geez, did this pizza hit the spot or what?!?! Walked over…read moreafter a long day of skiing and was greeted by the owner himself. Sit at the bar and had a beer as I watched them hand toss my pizza, along with it cooking in a brick pizza oven right in front of my eyes. Have to say they are some of the friendliest staff I've met. And that pizza was to die for!!!! Literally had to unbutton my ski pants the next day. lol Soooo worth it though. Thanks guys, your Columbus, Ohio friend. See you next year.

Love the thin crust on the pizza. For 3 pizzas, 3 orders of wings and a salad, the wait time was an…read morehour and half. The pizza was good but it took awhile until we can pick it up. There aren't too many choices on pizza in this town.

This is my favorite pizza in Batavia. After living here for a few years, this was my go-to spot. We…read morewere back in town for the day hanging out and decided we needed to get some pizza before we went home. We ended up getting a few things which were all delicious. We got a large cheese and pep pizza, some wings, fried mozzarella, and some fried dough bites for dessert. The pizza here has been great and the service is always pretty quick. They have two sides of the restaurant with takeout on one, and dining on the other. The dining room is gorgeous and has such a great vibe to it. It feels upscale, yet cozy. If you're in Batavia and need a pizza, Main Street is the place to go.

They have daily deals and this was half a sheet plus wings. The wings were all good but our…read morefavorite was the bourbon and berry hot. The other flavors we got was also good. The pizza dough was my favorite since it is soft and fluffy. Flavor wise really nice and portion are huge. Service was great and definitely would come back!

We've been eating here since they opened and we love it! Their pizza and wings are so consistently…read moregood. The service is friendly! The garlic parm wings with the homemade blue cheese is my go to!

This is St. Patrick's Day and Eric has a Rueben Calzone today as one of his Monday specials. I…read moreordered ahead and arrived about 5:15. My order was just coming out of the oven so perfect timing. They included a delicious "thousand island" homemade sauce whose flavor absolutely complemented the tasty sandwich. Normally, Eric features either a meatball sub or a beef on wick. Having now tried both you better order ahead of time as he sells out every Monday.

Ordered 1/2 sheet pizzas for an event. Crust is the thicker" Buffalo style" and very flavorful. We…read morehad plain cheese, char cup and their stinger pizza. All very good. It's a little off the beaten path but if you're at Darien Lake, Corfu or Lancaster it's only a 15-20 drive. Would highly recommend as it's one of the better places by the Genesee Co, Erie Co boarder.

The food is as delicious as the website pictures. Class food and an entertaining staff. I highly…read morerecommend