Order Criscito Pizza Takeout or Delivery
CRISCITO PIZZA · YELP ASSISTANT
Ask Yelp Assistant
Criscito Pizza Photos
Business Info
Criscito Pizza Popular Dishes
CRISCITO PIZZA ATMOSPHERE
More like Criscito Pizza
Recommended Reviews - Criscito Pizza
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Worth Every Penny! Our Guests Are Still Talking About Criscito Pizza! We hired Criscito Pizza to cater our daughter's baby sprinkle. They were hands down one of the highlights of the entire celebration. Our package included all eight signature pizzas and every single one was outstanding. The Honey Basil Garlic was definitely a crowd favorite, with the perfect balance of sweet and savory. Guests also raved about the Lasagna Pizza (my own favorite!), Sweet Heat, Calabrian, Mushroom Truffle (this was devoured immediately), Margherita, the little kiddies favorites...Pepperoni and NYC Cheese. There was truly something for everyone and not a single pizza disappointed. The crust deserves its own review! It is organic! Several of our guests commented that it tasted like fresh artisan bread...light, airy and perfectly chewy with just the right amount of char. Friends and family who drove down from Los Angeles said the pizza alone was worth the trip to San Diego (and of course, spending time with us! :). Others called the flavors "extraordinary" because they were unlike typical pizza. You can tell Criscito uses high-quality ingredients and takes pride in EVERY pizza they make. The fresh spinach salad with feta, dried cranberries, walnuts, olive oil and balsamic glaze was also delicious and paired perfectly with the pizzas. But what truly made the experience exceptional were Desiree and Matthew. They worked tirelessly throughout the event, constantly baking fresh pizzas, replenishing the buffet, and serving our guests with genuine smiles. I started calling them the "Pizza Fairies" because they seemed to sprinkle a little magic on every pizza they made. They made everything look effortless while providing first-class service. Another thing I appreciated was how self-sufficient they were. They brought their own electricity, potable water, plates, napkins, and utensils, so I never had to worry about a thing. They handled everything professionally from start to finish. Criscito Pizza isn't the cheapest caterer you'll find, but this is one of those times when you truly get what you pay for. The quality of the ingredients, the artisan craftsmanship, the incredible flavors, and the outstanding service made every dollar worthwhile. If you want your guests talking about the food long after your event is over, book Criscito Pizza. I wouldn't hesitate to hire Desiree and Matthew again. They helped make our daughter's baby sprinkle unforgettable and I can't recommend them highly enough!
If I could give 10 stars I would. From filling out the inquiry call to perfect pizza execution, we were so happy we chose Criscito Pizza to cater our end of season volleyball banquet for 142 guests. Phil was wonderful to work with and so responsive. The per person price was reasonable. His team was fantastic on site and very friendly. The pizza was DELICIOUS...everyone loved the variety and the toppings. The spinach salad was so fresh. They set up a little earlier to ensure our 5:30pm dinner service would start on time which was so nice. I highly recommend Criscito Pizza and I cannot wait to work with them again!
WOW! FANTASTIC!!! Currently loving the Calabrian with sausage, peppers, garlic, mozzarella, and I added ricotta. Chose NY over Neapolitan crust since I prefer crispy over soft. Both types of crusts are the same thickness, so I'm told. Fairly empty on a Saturday night, lots of take out, so lots of tables available. Clean and simple pizzeria. Highly recommend! Patient service as I had several questions my first time here. When I say clean, take a peek behind the register, kitchen is also immaculate! And did I say ORGANIC DOUGH?!! Elated
Small quaint shop with a super tasty menu! Tucked away in the middle of Carmel, is a hidden gem crafting personal pizzas and healthy salads. I came here with a friend and had the arugula pizza and chop salad with a green sauce. Pizza was amazing - dough was chewy without being soggy and their red sauce was really good. 9/10 in their simplicity and quality execution.
We had Criscito cater my family reunion. They have a pizza oven that they bring on site. Communication with Phil, the owner, was easy before the event. Day of the event they arrive a few hours before the serving time in order to fire up the wood-fired oven. The catering menu has 8 flavors of pizza & 2 types of salad (Caesar & spinach). They also offer gluten free & vegan if desired. Our guests raved about pizzas & salads. Max & Des who ran the catering were friendly & accommodating. They cleaned up the area where we served which was appreciated. Highly recommend Criscito for catering.
The service was great and the pizza was even better. Noah was so nice and let us sample the gelato while we waited for our pizza. Pizza was done in no time and it was so much better than we expected. The crust, the sauce the toppings... all great quality and so delicious. Also, the restaurant was very clean with a spread of cheese and pepper shakers by the water dispenser. We can't wait to have them cater our wedding.
This place is amazing! High quality ingredients, delicious, fresh, made to order pizzas that are authentic Italian style. The staff is friendly and the wait times were quick. I Also absolutely loved the area and the ambiance sitting outside eating near the fountain and beautiful scenery.
I really enjoyed this place, it's a little hard to find since it's between apartments but worth it. Pizza is fresh, the place is very cute plenty of seating inside and the staff were nice. I would return and try other stuff on the menu,
Ordered margaritas pizza neopolitan taste 3.5/5 quality and Ny style pepperoni 3.5/5 taste. The dough was really good but Pretty expensive for the size of the pizza. Also NY style pepperoni pizza was the same as neopolitan. In dining experience was whatever, you dont get anyserice lol. So just order to go save money on Tip. Near by pizza shop such as Regent pizza had better pizza and size/price and customer service but I guess because they do have more ppl working. Their salad was 3.8/5
10/10 -- A Love Story with Criscito Pizza Criscito Pizza will forever hold a special place in our hearts -- they catered our wedding in June 2019, and guests STILL rave about that pizza to this day. Nearly six years later, we finally made it back to their Torrey Hills spot... and let me tell you -- it's just as magical as it was on our big day. Every bite took us right back to those joyful wedding vibes. The Honey Garlic Basil Pizza is pure perfection -- a sweet, savory, herby masterpiece. The Carbonara Pizza? Silky, rich, and utterly crave-worthy. And the Calabria Pizza brings the perfect kick to round out your pizza pilgrimage. But wait... whatever you do, DO NOT sleep on the gelato. Their banana gelato might just be the best thing I've ever had in a cup. It's a flavor explosion -- creamy, dreamy, and the ideal finish after devouring a few pies. The team here is wonderful, the quality is top-notch, and the food is clearly crafted with love and care. Whether you're getting married, celebrating life, or just craving the best pizza in town -- Criscito delivers in every way. We will be back -- again and again and again. Thank you, Criscito, for being part of our forever story!
I was visiting Scripps and was dying for a pizza. I found Criscito Pizza and hit it on the way home. I love figs so the fig and feta pizza was the obvious choice. I like that it had mozzarella too. At pickup I realized they had gelato, it was awesome too. It is in a small retail area next to a large apartment/condo complex so a little tricky, but so worth it. I shared it was a friend and she agreed it was the best!! Great job guys. Wonderful variety and supreme taste! I will be back for more fig/feta pizza!!
We had an amazing experience with Criscito Pizza! They were easy to work with, very professional, and even showed up early to get everything set up and ready to go. Our guests absolutely loved the pizza, especially watching it being wood-fired right in the parking lot -- it was such a fun and unique touch to the evening. We kept getting so many compliments about the food throughout the night! Highly recommend Criscito Pizza for any event. Delicious pizza, great team, and top-notch service!
We had Criscito Pizza cater our wedding, and I think it was everyone's favorite wedding dinner they have ever had. Phil had amazing communication with myself and my wedding planner, asking the right questions and even taking the time to walk and understanding the challenging guidelines at our venue. He clearly made his services clear and managed everything effortlessly. He brought the pizza oven, and a team of serves and dishwashers that made the entire dinner a breeze. With a table of 10 different pizza options, our guests were happy, and full. It was a joy to try so many different kinds, and served as the perfect late snack as the night went on. I am so thankful we found Criscito Pizza and were able to work with Phil.
18 days ago
1 month ago
Business owner information
Phil B.
Thanks Christina! We appreciate you guys coming in
I came here to try their pizza a couple of years ago and ran into a friend! I ordered the NY Style Calabrian with artisan pepperoni, a Neopolitan style San Diegan with hot honey, and a cranberry salad with marinated chicken breast. Everything was ready in about 20 minutes. I liked that the dressing was on the side. The dressing was great and they give you lots of chicken! I liked both of my pizzas! The dough was good! I ended up getting some gelato after. They only have a few flavor, but I'm glad I saved some room because it was very refreshing! read more
3 months ago
Worth Every Penny! Our Guests Are Still Talking About Criscito Pizza! We hired Criscito Pizza to cater our daughter's baby sprinkle. They were hands down one of the highlights of the entire celebration. Our package included all eight signature pizzas and every single one was outstanding. The Honey Basil Garlic was definitely a crowd favorite, with the perfect balance of sweet and savory. Guests also raved about the Lasagna Pizza (my own favorite!), Sweet Heat, Calabrian, Mushroom Truffle (this was devoured immediately), Margherita, the little kiddies favorites...Pepperoni and NYC Cheese. There was truly something for everyone and not a single pizza disappointed. The crust deserves its own review! It is organic! Several of our guests commented that it tasted like fresh artisan bread...light, airy and perfectly chewy with just the right amount of char. Friends and family who drove down from Los Angeles said the pizza alone was worth the trip to San Diego (and of course, spending time with us! :). Others called the flavors "extraordinary" because they were unlike typical pizza. You can tell Criscito uses high-quality ingredients and takes pride in EVERY pizza they make. The fresh spinach salad with feta, dried cranberries, walnuts, olive oil and balsamic glaze was also delicious and paired perfectly with the pizzas. But what truly made the experience exceptional were Desiree and Matthew. They worked tirelessly throughout the event, constantly baking fresh pizzas, replenishing the buffet, and serving our guests with genuine smiles. I started calling them the "Pizza Fairies" because they seemed to sprinkle a little magic on every pizza they made. They made everything look effortless while providing first-class service. Another thing I appreciated was how self-sufficient they were. They brought their own electricity, potable water, plates, napkins, and utensils, so I never had to worry about a thing. They handled everything professionally from start to finish. Criscito Pizza isn't the cheapest caterer you'll find, but this is one of those times when you truly get what you pay for. The quality of the ingredients, the artisan craftsmanship, the incredible flavors, and the outstanding service made every dollar worthwhile. If you want your guests talking about the food long after your event is over, book Criscito Pizza. I wouldn't hesitate to hire Desiree and Matthew again. They helped make our daughter's baby sprinkle unforgettable and I can't recommend them highly enough! read more
If I could give 10 stars I would. From filling out the inquiry call to perfect pizza execution, we were so happy we chose Criscito Pizza to cater our end of season volleyball banquet for 142 guests. Phil was wonderful to work with and so responsive. The per person price was reasonable. His team was fantastic on site and very friendly. The pizza was DELICIOUS...everyone loved the variety and the toppings. The spinach salad was so fresh. They set up a little earlier to ensure our 5:30pm dinner service would start on time which was so nice. I highly recommend Criscito Pizza and I cannot wait to work with them again! read more
WOW! FANTASTIC!!! Currently loving the Calabrian with sausage, peppers, garlic, mozzarella, and I added ricotta. Chose NY over Neapolitan crust since I prefer crispy over soft. Both types of crusts are the same thickness, so I'm told. Fairly empty on a Saturday night, lots of take out, so lots of tables available. Clean and simple pizzeria. Highly recommend! Patient service as I had several questions my first time here. When I say clean, take a peek behind the register, kitchen is also immaculate! And did I say ORGANIC DOUGH?!! Elated read more
Small quaint shop with a super tasty menu! Tucked away in the middle of Carmel, is a hidden gem crafting personal pizzas and healthy salads. I came here with a friend and had the arugula pizza and chop salad with a green sauce. Pizza was amazing - dough was chewy without being soggy and their red sauce was really good. 9/10 in their simplicity and quality execution. read more
We had Criscito cater my family reunion. They have a pizza oven that they bring on site. Communication with Phil, the owner, was easy before the event. Day of the event they arrive a few hours before the serving time in order to fire up the wood-fired oven. The catering menu has 8 flavors of pizza & 2 types of salad (Caesar & spinach). They also offer gluten free & vegan if desired. Our guests raved about pizzas & salads. Max & Des who ran the catering were friendly & accommodating. They cleaned up the area where we served which was appreciated. Highly recommend Criscito for catering. read more
28 days ago
The service was great and the pizza was even better. Noah was so nice and let us sample the gelato while we waited for our pizza. Pizza was done in no time and it was so much better than we expected. The crust, the sauce the toppings... all great quality and so delicious. Also, the restaurant was very clean with a spread of cheese and pepper shakers by the water dispenser. We can't wait to have them cater our wedding. read more
3 months ago
4 months ago
Business owner information
Phil B.
Hi Dany - we tried to contact you regarding this incident but we…
This place is amazing! High quality ingredients, delicious, fresh, made to order pizzas that are authentic Italian style. The staff is friendly and the wait times were quick. I Also absolutely loved the area and the ambiance sitting outside eating near the fountain and beautiful scenery. read more
9 months ago
I really enjoyed this place, it's a little hard to find since it's between apartments but worth it. Pizza is fresh, the place is very cute plenty of seating inside and the staff were nice. I would return and try other stuff on the menu, read more
Ordered margaritas pizza neopolitan taste 3.5/5 quality and Ny style pepperoni 3.5/5 taste. The dough was really good but Pretty expensive for the size of the pizza. Also NY style pepperoni pizza was the same as neopolitan. In dining experience was whatever, you dont get anyserice lol. So just order to go save money on Tip. Near by pizza shop such as Regent pizza had better pizza and size/price and customer service but I guess because they do have more ppl working. Their salad was 3.8/5 read more
2 months ago
1 year ago
10/10 -- A Love Story with Criscito Pizza Criscito Pizza will forever hold a special place in our hearts -- they catered our wedding in June 2019, and guests STILL rave about that pizza to this day. Nearly six years later, we finally made it back to their Torrey Hills spot... and let me tell you -- it's just as magical as it was on our big day. Every bite took us right back to those joyful wedding vibes. The Honey Garlic Basil Pizza is pure perfection -- a sweet, savory, herby masterpiece. The Carbonara Pizza? Silky, rich, and utterly crave-worthy. And the Calabria Pizza brings the perfect kick to round out your pizza pilgrimage. But wait... whatever you do, DO NOT sleep on the gelato. Their banana gelato might just be the best thing I've ever had in a cup. It's a flavor explosion -- creamy, dreamy, and the ideal finish after devouring a few pies. The team here is wonderful, the quality is top-notch, and the food is clearly crafted with love and care. Whether you're getting married, celebrating life, or just craving the best pizza in town -- Criscito delivers in every way. We will be back -- again and again and again. Thank you, Criscito, for being part of our forever story! read more
Business owner information
Phil B.
Thank you brandon. This is special and you guys are also a part of…
6 months ago
I was visiting Scripps and was dying for a pizza. I found Criscito Pizza and hit it on the way home. I love figs so the fig and feta pizza was the obvious choice. I like that it had mozzarella too. At pickup I realized they had gelato, it was awesome too. It is in a small retail area next to a large apartment/condo complex so a little tricky, but so worth it. I shared it was a friend and she agreed it was the best!! Great job guys. Wonderful variety and supreme taste! I will be back for more fig/feta pizza!! read more
2 months ago
Business owner information
Phil B.
Thanks so much Nina. We really appreciate you and your family.
6 months ago
Business owner information
Phil B.
Thanks Sanford we really appreciate your continued support!
1 year ago
We had an amazing experience with Criscito Pizza! They were easy to work with, very professional, and even showed up early to get everything set up and ready to go. Our guests absolutely loved the pizza, especially watching it being wood-fired right in the parking lot -- it was such a fun and unique touch to the evening. We kept getting so many compliments about the food throughout the night! Highly recommend Criscito Pizza for any event. Delicious pizza, great team, and top-notch service! read more
2 months ago
We had Criscito Pizza cater our wedding, and I think it was everyone's favorite wedding dinner they have ever had. Phil had amazing communication with myself and my wedding planner, asking the right questions and even taking the time to walk and understanding the challenging guidelines at our venue. He clearly made his services clear and managed everything effortlessly. He brought the pizza oven, and a team of serves and dishwashers that made the entire dinner a breeze. With a table of 10 different pizza options, our guests were happy, and full. It was a joy to try so many different kinds, and served as the perfect late snack as the night went on. I am so thankful we found Criscito Pizza and were able to work with Phil. read more
6 months ago
If you want the best wood fired pizza, here is your spot. My husband discovered them from their food truck and has talked about it for literally years. Customer service Is great. . Try them out. You will love it. read more
3 months ago
Criscito pizza is right next to Torrey Pines State Natural Reserve This pizza spot is so close to the beach I recommend picking this up and having a picnic at the beach. This pizza is so good I cannot recommend enough. The salad was so delicious and it was so simple! Service was amazing the manager let us try the gelato flavors all of them!!! In order for us to choose what we preferred best Interior was nice, this spot is kind of new so check them out if you're in San Diego, CA! What we ordered : - 2 Calabrian Pizza's one Neapolitan and one NY style - Chop salad read more
Business owner information
Phil B.
Thanks daisy! So glad you enjoyed. We really appreciate you!
3 months ago
2 years ago
Yum! I came in without any expectations because i'm thinking, a lot of pizza around san diego tends to taste the same. Not this place! We ordered a classic pepperoni NY style pizza and the Carbonara. Almost ordered a salad too but wanted to really focus on the pizza. It was actually challenging picking which pies we wanted because they all look so good! We had our pizzas out fairly quickly. P.S. The pizza is really good cold too read more
3 months ago
2 months ago
Business owner information
Phil B.
Thanks Neil we appreciate you!
Visiting San Diego and was done for the day. Didn't want to go out so I looked on DoorDash and found Criscito. After referencing on Yelp, I made the decision to order the Calabrian Neapolitan. I was super impressed by how quickly we received the pizza, and more importantly, how GOOD this pizza was. Yes, we wolfed it! We took into consideration, the time traveled, and loved it even more. The dough was super chewy and what I really appreciated was that it wasn't overly salty (which sausage pizzas often can be). It was wet in the center, but then again, it's a Neapolitan pizza, so I would be more surprised if it wasn't! Definitely recommend!! *Sorry I forgot to take a photo until we had already dug into it read more
Business owner information
Phil B.
Thanks Anita we really appreciate it!
4 months ago
1 month ago
The pizza dough, sauce, and cheese were very good. I really liked the wood fired and the crust had a good taste. I think it was really just the toppings didn't do it for me, the Calabrian and the Pepperoni were pretty basic. Usually the more expensive pizzas like this have more protein to justify it. There weren't many options for additional toppings but I guess they were trying to be more traditional. The gelato selection was limited and it was just average. The staff were fantastic and there is plenty of seating with comfortable chairs. But... Being so close to Mom's pizza makes it tough to recommend on its own. read more
6 months ago
5 months ago
5 months ago
5 months ago
7 months ago
2 months ago
Page 1 of 6
More info about Criscito Pizza
10675 Calle Mar de Mariposa
San Diego, CA 92130
Torrey Hills
Directions
(858) 261-0179
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.criscitopizza.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
More Info
Health Score
Criscito Pizza Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Criscito Pizza
Do you have sourdough crusts?
Yes ma’am. Our normal dough is sourdough. We do throw a pinch of fresh yeast in there for lightness, but sourdough starter is doing almost all of the leavening.…
Does the vegan pizza have vegan cheese on it or is it just veggies?
Just veggies but we can add vegan cheese :)
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
15 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
2 years ago
3 years ago
2 years ago
10 months ago
2 years ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
2 years ago
3 years ago
3 years ago
11 months ago
1 year ago
6 months ago
11 months ago
2 years ago
