Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Criollo

    3.8 (13 reviews)
    Closed 8:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Criollo Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Criollo

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Peruvian chicken to go
    Frank R.

    Pretty mediocre experience. I ordered to-go, but they prepped it as dine-in and acted like it was my mistake. Then they just threw everything into a styrofoam container without care. The kitchen looked sloppy and chaotic. I went during the day and they were out of most items--only had the Peruvian chicken. The chicken was fine, but lacked seasoning and wasn't anything memorable. Unfortunately, it also made me sick the next day (the only thing I ate that day). There's potential here, but the service, kitchen standards, and overall experience really missed the mark. Probably won't be back.

    Peruvian Half Chicken
    Helen H.

    The place is located within 3rd St. Market Hall. We decided for get the Peruvian rotisserie chicken. The half chicken was smaller than expected, but it did come with two sides. We also ordered a Peruvian salad. I don't know what makes it Peruvian, as it was just a simple salad. Maybe it's the dressing?

    Ed F.

    it was a difficult choice once when you come here. there are so many cuisine options. Why did I decide to try Criollo? simple- Peruvian food. No guinea pigs on the menu, but they do offer a combo that consist of a half chicken w/two sides for under $20. But when i opened it, there was only a 1/4 chicken. I brought my dish back to them. They immediately saw i had the wrong order and corrected it by giving me a whole Peruvian chicken along with the original wrong 1/4 chicken order. An extra star just for that! So how was the combo: I gotta be honest. the flavor was very subtle but good. It would have been better if it were not so dry. Perhaps if this dish was served immediately after it was cooked, the bird would have been moist and not so dry. But ordering this dish for dinner...it was probably sitting for many hours in their pre-cooked container from being prepared earlier for their lunch crowd. But an extra star for their flavorful black beans and peruvian rice. very good. So 3 stars for the food and an extra star for customer service. But i will definitely return, but for lunch only to truly taste the potential of this location .

    Yuca

    Don't pay the extra 3 dollars for the side of yuca. They give you 5 pieces of yuca. So 60 cents per yuca. Unbelievable!

    Big Portion Big Price

    See all

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Betsy S.
    76
    92
    11

    9 months ago

    The Peruvian chicken is delicious! And we loved the black beans and Puerto Rican rice too! Food came out quickly and was reasonable priced

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ed F.
    0
    305
    976

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Criollo

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Puerto Rican 454 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Sabor Tropical Restaurant and Lounge

    Sabor Tropical Restaurant and Lounge

    3.9
    (130 reviews)
    2.4 mi
    $$

    Visited Sabor Tropical Restaurant recently for dinner on a Sunday evening…read more We were immediately greeted and seated. The restaurant itself was impeccably clean and welcoming. I started out my experience with their Pisco Sour. I prefer the Peruvian style Pisco Sour (with egg whites and bitters), they serve it in the Chilean fashion (sans egg whites and bitters). It was aok if that's the style you prefer! For our starter, we got the tostones rellenos, which were the star of the evening for me. So flavorful with just the right amount of heat. Perfection! For my main dish, I got their salmon tropical, which is grilled salmon over whipped potatoes with cilantro, mango, onion, and avocado on top. It's also served with asparagus, which was pitch perfect. All in all--it was a fresh and tasty dish! For dessert, my dining companion and I opted to share their nutella flan. I found it to be overly, cloyingly sweet and wouldn't likely order dessert here again. The service was attentive and the prices were reasonable. Get to it!

    This was restaurant of the week and a good choice. Street parking is as good as it gets but after…read moredriving around the block a couple times a spot opened up. The place has outdoor seating in front and the inside has a nice bar with big front windows and tables/chairs. The bar menu for a tropical restaurant had a small tropical drink menu I thought but the strawberry mojito sounded good. The strawberry mojito was good but for all I know it was a kiddie cocktail because it didn't taste like an adult beverage because it didn't taste like an alcohol beverage. The blond woman with the hypnotic/beautiful accent working the whole room by herself did a great job. The menu has so much good stuff on it that it's hard to pick a dish so I opted for the Latin inspired signature sampler which is empanada choice of meat, steak quesadilla, tostone ralleno pork, three mango bbq wings and tostones. The food took a bit to hit the table but it looked good when it did. Everything was delicious/flavorful and seasoned nicely. I enjoyed everything on the plate so it's hard to pick one over the other except the wing's because wings are everywhere. The pork was moist and seasoned nicely as well as the tender steak quesadilla, it's all very good. Overall I really like my lunch and I'm so glad that I stopped for something different and they did a great job.

    Photos
    Sabor Tropical Restaurant and Lounge
    Sabor Tropical Restaurant and Lounge
    Sabor Tropical Restaurant and Lounge

    See all

    Noche Restaurant & Bar

    Noche Restaurant & Bar

    4.0
    (88 reviews)
    7.9 mi

    Finally made it in here in a warmer month. Restaurant is cute, but we sat outside on the spacious…read morepatio. Service was ok, but food was a bit of a failure. I ordered the La Bandera and it was overly salty. Now, I don't know if this is the norm for this dish, or if the chef that night was heavy handed. The first bite seemed ok, but the more I ate, the saltier it became, it seemed. Hubs had the short rib sandwich and was not impressed. We also had the queso dip, which I liked very much, and a pitcher of margaritas, which we both enjoyed. I would try this place again, because you never know if someone is having an off night and deserves a second chance. I'd also like to come here during the day (the Dia part) to try that menu as well. 88/2025

    Stopped here for brunch on a whim and were generally impressed with the great atmosphere and staff…read more We arrived right around 10a and were promptly seated. The dining room was colorful collection of pictures, garlands and banners which added to the cheery atmosphere. I had the fiesta burrito with chorizo. As stated, it comes smothered with their house made sauces, one green, maybe cilantro or avocado, the either a red sauce. Not listed in the description was also corn, carrot and peas. Don't be surprised when you cut into it and you see that. On the side was a coleslaw that brought some nice heat and brightness to the plate as well. Maybe the biggest surprise of the entire meal was the house coffee they served up. Today I believe it was their sauvecito. While I was surprised that they would serve such a strongly flavored house coffee, it packed a nice cocoa flavor that rounded out the meal nicely.

    Photos
    Noche Restaurant & Bar
    Jerk chicken with plantains, rice and salad. Very flavorful.
    Jerk chicken with plantains, rice and salad. Very flavorful.
    Coquito was light tasty with a kick

    See all

    Coquito was light tasty with a kick
    Travieso

    Travieso

    4.0
    (40 reviews)
    16.2 mi

    What happened to Travieso Latin Fusion? We came expecting a nice dinner and instead got front-row…read moreseats to what felt like an unsupervised teen nightclub -- just with higher drink prices. Service was almost nonexistent unless you count servers yelling across the restaurant, and ignoring us. We had empty water pitchers, food that was slung on to a plate and looking at filthy tables. Professionalism was nowhere to be found. We kept wondering if a manager was going to appear... or if the entire place was being run by teenagers. It's honestly shocking because this used to be a well-managed spot with great food and a welcoming atmosphere. Now it feels chaotic, immature, and uncomfortable for anyone expecting an actual dining experience. If you're looking for dinner, you may want to keep driving. If you're looking for a loud, awkward social experiment with margaritas, you've found your place.

    I helped in planning our work holiday party and we hosted this year at Travieso. We had roughly 70…read moreattendees with use of the full restaurant space. We choose to set up more formal dining in the dining room with buffet set up and a passed app. We had a speciality cocktail and mocktail option created for the event that guests could order at the bar - the pineapple gimlet was delicious! Their team worked with us on layout beforehand and even played our selected playlist on the sound system, they also helped me with some final set up with signs and some Christmas crackers I wanted to place at the tables. Everything ran smooth with food moving along at the times we discussed. Everyone enjoyed themselves and is still talking about it almost a whole week later!

    Photos
    Beef Birria Masa Dumplings
    Beef Birria Masa Dumplings
    Travieso
    Empanadas (2 black bean and corn, 2 pork)

    See all

    Empanadas (2 black bean and corn, 2 pork)
    Delicia Tropical Cafe

    Delicia Tropical Cafe

    3.8
    (229 reviews)
    72.0 mi
    $

    $50 for fake Puerto Rican food the community deserves better"…read moreI need to write this review because people in Elgin deserve to know the truth, especially those who may not be familiar with authentic Puerto Rican cuisine. Let me start with the Papas Rellenas potato balls that are supposed to be made with real mashed potatoes, seasoned properly, and filled with well-seasoned meat. What I got was clearly made with INSTANT mashed potatoes. You can taste the difference immediately. It was bland, gummy, and honestly embarrassing to call Puerto Rican food. Then the Alcapurrias which should be packed with flavorful, well-seasoned meat filling. Instead, mine were stuffed almost entirely with green banana (guineo) and barely any meat at all. The only thing that had any flavor WAS the little bit of meat in there, which tells you the issue the base itself had zero seasoning. Eating an alcapurria that tastes like a plain pound of banana is not it. I spent $50 on this meal. FIFTY DOLLARS. As a Puerto Rican, this is a disgrace. This is one of only two Puerto Rican restaurants in Elgin, which means people are counting on places like this to represent our food and culture and this is what they're getting? Authentic Puerto Rican food is rich, flavorful, and made with love and the RIGHT ingredients. This was none of that. Do better. The community deserves authentic food, not a watered-down imitation at premium prices. Not recommended.

    I recently tried a Puerto Rican spot out in Elgin and had really high hopes going in…read more I ordered a jibarito with a side of rice, plus an alcapurria and a pastel to try a little bit of everything. Starting with the jibarito, it was honestly a bit of a letdown. The meat was a little chewy and the overall sandwich felt dry, which took away from what should've been a really flavorful dish. The rice also missed the mark for me. It lacked flavor and had a bit of an odd aftertaste, which made it hard to enjoy. For the pricing, I was a little surprised $15 for a small jibarito and $5 for a small side of rice didn't quite match the quality or portion size. That said, not everything was a miss. The alcapurria was definitely the highlight fresh, well-made, and full of flavor. I'd absolutely order that again. The pastel was just okay in my opinion there were a lot of potatoes and not as much meat as I would've liked, so the balance felt a bit off. Overall, it was a mixed experience. There are some strong items on the menu, but between the inconsistency and the pricing, I'm not sure I'd rush back.

    Photos
    Jibarito Delicia (steak, chicken, veggie or pork) Alcapurrias De Guineo
    Jibarito Delicia (steak, chicken, veggie or pork) Alcapurrias De Guineo
    The relleno de papa instant potato ball
    The relleno de papa instant potato ball
    Delicia Tropical Cafe

    See all

    LimaMar Restaurant

    LimaMar Restaurant

    4.5
    (55 reviews)
    80.0 mi

    Very nice place for some modern Peruvian food. The service was outstanding. The waiter even made a…read morecocktail that wasn't even on the menu. Loved the feeling and ambiance of the place.

    Truly a must-go in Rockford for anyone wanting to break away from the reruns of meat and potatoes…read moreof typical Midwestern cuisine. Honestly, this spot seems out of place in Rockford and seems like something you would find in a bigger city. The decor is colorful and bright, the drink selection is very impressive and creative and the menu is broad yet impeccably put together. I've been here a few times and had some excellent meals, though I'd like to mention the recent restaurant week menu. I brought my fiancé and parents here for a weekend dinner and they were a little skeptical about the empty restaurant. For the weekend, there were a lot of people waking right past, but perhaps the sub-zero temperatures were keeping their eyes focused on getting to their cars only. We were greeted warmly by the server/hostess/bartender (she wore many hats that night!) and ushered to a tablescape that seemed almost too nice to be in the Forest City. We ordered drinks per our server's recommendations and were not disappointed. Full of tropical fruits, peruvian liquors, and a little kick (not all are spicy, just ones we chose)...they were a delight. All were served in fantastical glassware ranging from a mirrored martini glass, a stemmed glass with dangling chili peppers, and a gorilla head. Yep, you read that correctly. My drink was served in a painted gorilla head with star fruit on top. Absolutely delicious. We ordered an appetizer with mussels, ceviche, and a potato dish, as well as fried cassava. To my delight all the seafood tasted nearly as fresh as a coastal city where the fish is likely just out of the water. Everything was perfectly seasoned and not too chewy. The mains were another home run-- the guys got a VERY hearty pork stew and a beef and potato dish (so even those who still want meat and potatoes can feel at home here!) and the ladies a fish dish with a red sauce and a squid ink orzo with seafood. Nothing left us wanting more, but for me the orzo was a complete surprise. It was a gorgeous presentation with exquisite color and the flavor-- so light and yet so... there is no other word for it... buttery. EVERYONE at the table needed more than a bite. We rounded off dessert with a passion fruit mousse (honestly we were stuffed but felt we had to try something else as everything was so scrumptious) and rolled out of there talking about how shocking it was to have SUCH a high-quality and unique place in downtown Rockford. They got more tables as the night continued, but I'd have loved to see more. I would HATE for the people of Rockford not to have this experience. A few tips, the prices are higher than some of the other places in the area (as is the quality!), so be aware. Also they make everything fresh so plan for the evening to be a bit longer than elsewhere. But I cannot stress enough that no matter your tastes you will be very well cared for here, and have an experience you'll remember. And if you're not sure what to order, ask! The owners and servers are knowledgeable and friendly. They will steer you well! Tl;dr: This place is a foodie experience seemingly transported from a bigger city, and we are lucky to have it here in Rockford! Give them a try!

    Photos
    LimaMar Restaurant
    LimaMar Restaurant
    LimaMar Restaurant

    See all

    Criollo - puertorican - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...